X Pty Ltd and Ors and Merhi (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

X PTY LTD AND ORS & MERHI (NO 2) [2015] FamCA 862
FAMILY LAW – COSTS – Where seven third party companies seek their expenses in complying with subpoenas previously upheld by the Court over objection– Where twelve third party companies seek their costs arising from the proceedings in respect to those subpoenas – Where the husband seeks his costs from the wife and the wife seeks her costs from the third party companies – Where the Court finds the seven third party companies are entitled to all reasonable expenses incurred – Where the Court finds the wife was wholly unsuccessful in respect to the four subpoenas that were set aside – Wife to pay the costs of four of the twelve companies on a party/party basis  – Costs of the husband reserved to the final hearing – Wife’s application for costs dismissed.

Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 117
Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth) r 15.23

Chen v Chan (No 2) [2009] VSCA 233
James v Royal Bank of Scotland; McKeith v Royal Bank of Scotland (No.2) [2015] NSWSC 970
Markoska & Markoska and Anor (Costs) (2011) 46 Fam LR 598
Marriage of Kennedy and Evans, Trust Bank (Intervener) (1994) FLC 92-514

FIRST APPLICANT: X Pty Ltd (ACN 000 659 521)

SECOND APPLICANT:

THIRD APPLICANT:

FOURTH APPLICANT:

FIFTH APPLICANT:

SIXTH APPLICANT:

SEVENTH APPLICANT:

EIGHTH APPLICANT:

NINTH APPLICANT:

TENTH APPLICANT:

ELEVENTH APPLICANT:

TWELFTH APPLICANT:

THIRTEENTH APPLICANT:

MerhiCo Finance Pty Ltd (ACN …)

A Pty Ltd (ACN …)

B Pty Ltd (ACN …)

Merhi Bros Apartments Pty Ltd (ACN …)

Merhi Brothers Investments Pty Ltd (ACN …)

Merhi Group Holding Company Pty Ltd (ACN …)

C Pty Ltd (ACN …)

D Pty Ltd (ACN …)

Mr E Merhi Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN …)

Merhi Bros Holding Pty Ltd (ACN …)

F Pty Ltd (ACN …)

Mr G Merhi

RESPONDENT: Ms Merhi
FILE NUMBER: SYC 511 of 2014
DATE DELIVERED: 15 October 2015
PLACE DELIVERED: Sydney
PLACE HEARD: Sydney
JUDGMENT OF: McClelland J
HEARING DATE: Dealt with by way of written submissions

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE FIRST TO TWELFTH APPLICANTS: Mr Lethbridge SC
SOLICITOR FOR THE FIRST TO TWELFTH APPLICANTS: HWL Ebsworth

SOLICITOR FOR THE THIRTEENTH

APPLICANT:

Mr Lewis of Sexton Family Law
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Mr Wilkie of Neville & Hourn Legal

The Court Orders that:

  1. The respondent wife is to pay the reasonable expenses incurred by the following companies, as agreed or assessed, in complying with the subpoenas served upon them by the respondent wife:

    (a)       X Pty Ltd (ACN …);

    (b)       A Pty Ltd (ACN …);

    (c)       B Pty Ltd (ACN …);

    (d)       Merhi Bros Pty Ltd (ACN …);

    (e)       Merhi Bros Investments Pty Ltd (ACN …);

    (f)        D Pty Ltd (ACN …); and

    (g)       Mr E Merhi Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN …).

  2. For the purposes of Order (1) above, the reasonable expenses of the companies shall be:

    (a)       Labour costs;

    (b)       An additional loading of 20 per cent on labour costs; and

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read X Pty Ltd and Ors and Merhi (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FamCA 862
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In X Pty Ltd and Ors and Merhi (No 2), McClelland J of the Family Court of Australia considered an application by the respondent wife for costs and expenses incurred by various companies in complying with subpoenas, as well as the costs of the proceedings themselves. The applicant companies sought to recover their expenses and costs from the respondent wife.

The primary legal issues before the court were the extent to which the respondent wife should be ordered to pay the reasonable expenses incurred by certain companies in responding to subpoenas, and the basis upon which the respondent wife should contribute to the costs of other applicant companies in the proceedings. The court also had to determine the period from which these costs should be calculated and the method of assessment.

McClelland J reasoned that the respondent wife should be responsible for the reasonable expenses of the companies that complied with her subpoenas, defining these expenses to include labour costs, a 20 per cent loading on labour costs, and photocopy expenses. Furthermore, the court ordered the respondent wife to pay one-twelfth of the collective costs incurred by specific applicant companies in the proceedings, as well as any costs incurred exclusively by each of those companies for work exceeding that undertaken collectively. These costs were to be calculated from 13 March 2015, the date of filing the Application for Review, and assessed on a party/party basis. The respondent wife's application for costs against the applicant companies was dismissed, and the issue of costs between the husband and respondent wife was reserved for the final hearing. The court also certified that the applicant companies had reasonably engaged senior counsel.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The respondent wife is to pay the reasonable expenses incurred by the following companies, as agreed or assessed, in complying with the subpoenas served upon them by the respondent wife:

(a) X Pty Ltd (ACN …);

(b) A Pty Ltd (ACN …);

(c) B Pty Ltd (ACN …);

(d) Merhi Bros Pty Ltd (ACN …);

(e) Merhi Bros Investments Pty Ltd (ACN …);

(f) D Pty Ltd (ACN …); and

(g) Mr E Merhi Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN …).

2.

For the purposes of Order (1) above, the reasonable expenses of the companies shall be:

(a) Labour costs;

(b) An additional loading of 20 per cent on labour costs; and

(c) Photocopy expenses.

3.

The respondent wife is to pay one twelfth of the costs of the applicant companies incurred collectively, in respect to these proceedings, to each of the following companies:

(a) MerhiCo Finance Pty Ltd (ACN …);

(b) Merhi Group Holding Company Pty Ltd (ACN …);

(c) C Pty Ltd (ACN …); and

(d) Merhi Bros Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN …).

4.

Further to Order (3) above, the respondent wife is to pay the costs incurred exclusively by each company referred to in Order (3), in respect to work undertaken for each company which was over and above that undertaken in respect to the applicant companies collectively.

5.

Further to Order (3) and (4) above, the costs to be paid by the respondent wife are to be calculated from 13 March 2015, being the date of filing of the Application for Review.

6.

The costs payable, pursuant to Orders (3) and (4) above, are to be those costs that are agreed between the parties, or otherwise assessed, on a party / party basis.

7.

The respondent wife’s application for costs against the applicant companies is dismissed.

8.

The issue of costs as between the husband and the respondent wife is to be reserved to the final hearing of the substantive proceedings.

The Court certifies that:

1.

Pursuant to Rule 19.50 of the Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth), the applicant companies have reasonably engaged senior counsel.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.