Wzauk v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WZAUK v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2019] FCCA 3246
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Protection (Class XA) Visa – decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal – whether the Tribunal displayed apprehended bias – whether the Tribunal ignored corroborative evidence – corroborative evidence ignored – jurisdictional error established – writs issued.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.48, 499

Cases cited:

BZD17 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 94
Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v MZXPA [2008] FCA 185
Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v MZYZA [2013] FCA572
Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v SZRKT [2013] FCA 317

Re Refugee Review Tribunal; Ex parte H (2001) 179 ALR 425

SZRUI v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs & Citizenship [2013] FCAFC 80

Applicant: WZAUK
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: PEG 197 of 2014
Judgment of: Judge Kendall
Hearing date: 20 August 2019
Date of Last Submission: 20 August 2019
Delivered at: Perth
Delivered on: 13 November 2019

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr MGS Crowley
Solicitors for the Applicant: Estrin Saul Lawyers
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr PR Macliver
Second Respondent: Submitting appearance, save as to costs
Solicitors for the Respondents: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

  1. A writ of certiorari issue directed to the second respondent quashing the decision dated 4 June 2014.

  2. A writ of mandamus issue directed to the second respondent requiring it to reconsider and determine the applicant’s application for review according to law.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT PERTH

PEG 197 of 2014

WZAUK

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. This matter is procedurally unusual and requires some explanation.

  2. The applicant, a Kenyan citizen, filed an application in this Court on 8 July 2014 seeking judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) dated 4 June 2014. He sought review of the Tribunal’s decision to affirm a decision of a delegate of the first respondent (the “Minister”) to not grant him a Protection (Class XA) Visa (the “visa”).

  3. At the time of lodging the judicial review application the applicant was unrepresented.

  4. The applicant lodged an amended application on 22 January 2015. That application contained ten grounds of review. 

  5. On 2 July 2015, Judge Lucev of this Court heard the matter.

  6. Judgment was reserved at the end of that hearing.

  7. Following judgment being reserved by Judge Lucev, the Minister exercised the power under s.48 of the Migration Act 1958 (the “Act”) and the applicant was invited to apply for a further protection visa. He did so on 8 September 2017.

  8. On 27 October 2017, the applicant was again refused a visa and his application was referred to the Immigration Assessment Authority (the “IAA”) for review.

  9. On 24 November 2017, the IAA affirmed the delegate’s decision not to grant the applicant the visa he had applied for on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wzauk v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 3246
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Wzauk v Minister for Immigration, Judge Kendall of the Federal Court of Australia considered an application for judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning a Protection (Class XA) Visa. The applicant sought to challenge the Tribunal's decision, alleging apprehended bias and that the Tribunal had failed to consider crucial corroborative evidence.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the Tribunal had displayed apprehended bias in its consideration of the applicant's claim for protection, and more significantly, whether the Tribunal had failed to consider relevant corroborative evidence, thereby committing a jurisdictional error. The applicant contended that the Tribunal's handling of evidence relating to his sexuality, which was central to his protection claim, amounted to a failure to engage with material that could have supported his case.

Judge Kendall dismissed the ground of apprehended bias, finding that the Tribunal's closing remarks, while perhaps indicating a clear path to decision based on the applicant's sexuality, did not demonstrate that the issue was not still being considered. However, the Court found in favour of the applicant on the ground of failure to consider corroborative evidence. The Tribunal's reasons did not adequately address the evidence of Ms O, a witness who could have provided direct corroboration of the applicant's homosexual identity by testifying to seeing him in a relationship with another man. The Court held that a failure to consider such direct and independent evidence, which was central to the determination of the applicant's claim, constituted a jurisdictional error, drawing analogy to the principles established in *Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v SZRKT*.

Accordingly, the Court found that jurisdictional error had been established and ordered that the writs be issued.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Wzauk v Minister for Immigration revolves around the applicant's application for a Protection (Class XA) Visa. The applicant, a male from Kenya, sought protection in Australia due to his fear of persecution based on his sexual orientation. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was tasked with determining whether the applicant stood a real chance of serious harm if he returned to Kenya due to his sexuality. The Tribunal's decision became the subject of legal scrutiny due to alleged failures in its handling of the case.

Initially, the Tribunal indicated that the primary issue at hand was whether the applicant was homosexual, as this would critically influence their decision on the risk of harm he faced if returned to Kenya. The Tribunal acknowledged that the applicant's claim of being homosexual was central to his application for a protection visa. Despite this, the Tribunal seemed to indicate that they were not convinced by the applicant's other claims, such as those related to his mixed racial background. However, the focus remained on the applicant's sexuality, with the Tribunal stating they would consider all the evidence to make their decision.

In the course of the proceedings, two witnesses were intended to testify regarding the applicant's sexuality. Ms O, a long-term friend of the applicant, was to provide evidence that the applicant had confided in her about being homosexual. Similarly, Ms S was expected to testify that the applicant had shared his sexual orientation with her. This corroborative evidence was critical as it directly supported the applicant's central claim. However, the Tribunal's final decision did not reflect a consideration of Ms O's testimony, which included witnessing the applicant being affectionate with his male partner. The Tribunal's reasons for decision were silent on this point, leading to the inference that this evidence was not adequately considered. This omission was significant, as Ms O's testimony directly contradicted one of the reasons given by the Tribunal for finding that the applicant was not homosexual.

The Tribunal's failure to address and consider this corroborative evidence constituted a jurisdictional error, as it bore directly on the central issue of the applicant's sexual orientation. The Court found that the Tribunal's oversight in not considering this evidence could potentially have altered the outcome of the case, given that it directly supported the applicant's primary claim. This aspect of the Tribunal's decision-making process formed the basis for the legal challenge brought by the applicant.

The matter of Wzauk v Minister for Immigration has a procedural history that involves a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) being challenged in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. The case was brought before the court on the basis that the AAT had made a jurisdictional error in its consideration of the applicant's claim for a Protection (Class XA) Visa. The applicant, a Kenyan national, sought protection on the basis of his sexuality, specifically his fear of persecution if he were to return to Kenya. The AAT's decision was made following a hearing where the central issue was the applicant's sexuality. Despite the applicant's evidence and that of several witnesses, the AAT found that the applicant was not homosexual, a finding that the applicant contested on the basis of alleged bias and failure to consider critical evidence. The applicant appealed the AAT's decision to the Federal Circuit and Family Court, arguing that the Tribunal displayed apprehended bias and ignored corroborative evidence that supported his claim of homosexuality. The applicant's appeal hinged on the AAT's alleged failure to adequately consider evidence provided by two witnesses who could attest to the applicant's sexual orientation. This procedural challenge is grounded on the premise that the Tribunal's failure to consider this evidence constituted a jurisdictional error, as it did not critically engage with material that was central to the determination of the case.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Relevantly, it is noted that the Tribunal closed the hearing with the following statement:MEMBER: Well thank you for your evidence and I thank the witnesses even though they’re not here. I thank Ms Hill. My task now is to make a decision in terms of whether I’m satisfied that you stand a real chance of serious harm if you return to Kenya in terms of your sexuality. Critical in that will be deciding whether in fact you are homosexual as we’ve been talking about most of the morning. I’ll look at all the evidence and I’ll make a decision on that. I think, as I said before, if I find that I’m satisfied that you are, well then, I think it’s a pretty simple decision after that. But if I’m not satisfied that you are, well then, I think that the decision will be relatively simple after that as well. Because you’re not making any other claims really. Certainly, your claim, the race, the mixed racial background and so on. I can tell you now that I don’t, I’m not convinced by that and I know that you’re not really pushing that argument too much as well. I can understand that it would cause you problems, you probably don’t want to experience those sorts of problems but I’m not sure that they are of the scale that I would say invites persecution, serious harm or even significant harm. And so, it really is, turns on the question of your sexuality. I’ll have a look at all the evidence and make a decision based on that, Mr [Applicant].(Emphasis added) It is quite clear from this statement that the issue of whether the applicant was a gay male was still a live issue that the Tribunal was considering when the hearing closed. Accepting that the test is one of possibility, and not probability, it is still the case that an allegation of bias must be “clearly proven”. Here, the Court is not satisfied that that is the case. Grounds 1, accordingly, is dismissed. The applicant’s written submissions in relation to ground 2 can be summarised as follows:a)Ms O, a long-term friend, was to be called to give evidence that she was a ‘close friend of the claimant and that he [the claimant] told her [O] about his sexuality’; b)Ms S was also to be called to give evidence that the claimant likewise told Ms S that he was homosexual; c)because the ‘central claim’ was whether the applicant was in fact homosexual, the evidence of these two independent witnesses would have, at least prospectively, borne heavily on that issue; d)one of the reasons for finding that the applicant was not homosexual was that ‘[o]ne of the witnesses … had never seen him in any relationships with men despite the fact that she claimed he had told her he was gay at the beginning of 2010 and she had known him since 2007’; e)while true, Ms O’s testimony to the Tribunal corroborated the applicant’s central claim. Her evidence was that she had visited the applicant at the home he shared with his then male partner; f)the Tribunal’s decision record does not fully capture this evidence directly, and would itself have been a ground of review, but the reasons do record the applicant’s then representative summarising Ms O’s evidence that she had been present with the applicant and his then boyfriend and had ‘seen the applicant sitting close and being affectionate with another man’; g)the Tribunal did not state that it disbelieved Ms O’s evidence. Ms O’s evidence was direct and independent evidence that, if accepted, falsified the ultimate finding. If the Tribunal had considered that evidence, it might be expected that it would have addressed it in its reasons. The applicant invites the inference that Ms O’s evidence was not considered; h)on the one hand the Tribunal notes Ms O’s evidence that she ‘met’ the applicant’s ‘purported’ partner at their home but is silent on Ms O’s evidence that, while there, the applicant and his ‘purported’ partner were “kissing and cuddling”. On the other hand, the Tribunal does set out in some detail comparatively peripheral matters, like the time spent with the applicant at a gay venue, and the applicant’s admission to Ms O about his sexuality;i)jurisdictional error may be demonstrated by failing to consider critically relevant corroborative material; j)in Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v SZRKT [2013] FCA 317 (“SZRKT”), Robertson J rejected any clear distinction between claims and evidence. The question is rather one of centrality. Hence, in that case a failure to consider an academic transcript was jurisdictional error in that the Tribunal disbelieved the applicant generally because it did not believe he had studied the subject referred to in the transcript; and k)the reasoning in SZRKT is not relevantly distinguishable from this case. The failure to consider the evidence of Ms O was jurisdictional error because her evidence was independent, direct, and corroborative of the central issue for determination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Administrative Appeals Tribunal display apprehended bias in its handling of the hearing and decision-making process?
2. Whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal ignored corroborative evidence provided by Ms O and Ms S regarding the applicant's sexuality?
3. Did the failure of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to consider the corroborative evidence of Ms O amount to jurisdictional error?
4. If jurisdictional error was established, what are the appropriate remedies to be issued by the Court?

Held
1. Did the Administrative Appeals Tribunal display apprehended bias in its handling of the hearing and decision-making process?
The Court concluded that the Administrative Appeals Tribunal did not display apprehended bias, and dismissed the grounds related to bias.

2. Whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal ignored corroborative evidence provided by Ms O and Ms S regarding the applicant's sexuality?
The Court found that the Administrative Appeals Tribunal did not ignore the corroborative evidence provided by Ms O and Ms S, and dismissed the grounds related to ignored evidence.

3. Did the failure of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to consider the corroborative evidence of Ms O amount to jurisdictional error?
The Court concluded that the failure to consider the corroborative evidence of Ms O amounted to jurisdictional error, as her evidence was central to the determination of the applicant's sexuality.

4. If jurisdictional error was established, what are the appropriate remedies to be issued by the Court?
The Court concluded that appropriate remedies, such as writs, should be issued due to the established jurisdictional error in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's decision-making process.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) displayed apprehended bias in its handling of the hearing and decision-making process. The applicant argued that the Tribunal's statement at the conclusion of the hearing indicated a predisposition to find the applicant was not homosexual. The Tribunal's statement that the decision would turn on whether the applicant was homosexual and the Tribunal's own observations on the matter were scrutinized. However, the court held that the Tribunal's statement did not demonstrate a clear bias as required by the law. The court noted that the test for apprehended bias is whether there is a real likelihood of bias, not merely a possibility. Given the lack of clear evidence of bias, the court dismissed the ground of appeal regarding apprehended bias.

Next, the court addressed whether the AAT ignored corroborative evidence provided by Ms O and Ms S regarding the applicant's sexuality. The applicant submitted that Ms O and Ms S were to testify that the applicant had disclosed his homosexuality to them, which was relevant and supportive of his claim. The court acknowledged that Ms O's evidence included specific instances of observing the applicant with his male partner in an affectionate manner, which corroborated his claim. However, the Tribunal's reasons did not fully capture Ms O's evidence directly, and the court noted that this alone could be a ground of review. Despite this, the court found that the failure to adequately address Ms O's corroborative evidence did not necessarily mean it was ignored. Instead, the court considered whether the omission amounted to jurisdictional error.

The court then examined whether the failure of the AAT to consider the corroborative evidence of Ms O amounted to jurisdictional error. The applicant argued that the Tribunal's failure to consider this independent and direct evidence was a failure to consider material relevant to the central issue of the applicant's sexuality. The court referred to the case of Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v SZRKT, where it was held that failure to consider critically relevant evidence could amount to jurisdictional error. The court found that Ms O's evidence was independent, direct, and highly relevant to the central issue. The Tribunal's failure to address this evidence in its reasons demonstrated a failure to consider material that was critically relevant to the decision, thus constituting jurisdictional error.

Finally, the court considered the appropriate remedies to be issued by the Court in light of the jurisdictional error identified. Given the jurisdictional error, the court found it appropriate to issue writs of certiorari to quash the AAT's decision and remit the matter back to the AAT for reconsideration. This remedy ensures that the Tribunal properly considers all relevant evidence, including the corroborative evidence of Ms O, in making its decision. The court's decision to issue writs was based on the need to rectify the error and ensure a fair and just outcome for the applicant.