Reported Decision:
(2004) Aust Torts Reports 81-754
Court of Appeal
CITATION: Wyong Shire Council v Vairy; Mulligan v Coffs Harbour City Council [2004] NSWCA 247 HEARING DATE(S): CA40083/03: 20 August 2003
CA40292/03: 17, 18, 20 February 2004JUDGMENT DATE:
27 July 2004JUDGMENT OF: Mason P at 1; Beazley JA at 2; Tobias JA at 14 DECISION: Wyong Shire Council v Vairy CA 40083/03; a) Appeal allowed; b) Set aside the orders made by Bell J on 20 December 2002; c) Verdict and judgment for the defendant; d) The plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs of the proceedings and of the appeal but in respect of the latter to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 if otherwise entitled; Mulligan v Coffs Harbour City Council & Ors CA 40292/03; a) Appeal dismissed with costs CATCHWORDS: TORTS - Negligence - Personal injury - Scope of duty of care - Reasonable response - Obvious Danger - Inherent danger - Duty to warn - Unknown and variabe depth - Diving accident - TORTS - Negligence - Personal injury - Existence of duty - Contributory negligence - Causation - Apportionment - Damages - Volenti - PRACTICE & PROCEDEURE - Fairness - Raising argument post-appeal - Not run at trial - Not argued on appeal LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW)
Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (NSW)
Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1965 (NSW)CASES CITED: Ah Tong v Wingecarribbee Council [2003] NSWCA 381
Beck v State of New South Wales [2001] NSWSC 278
Berryman v Joslyn; Wentworth Shire Council v Joslyn [2004] NSWCA 121
Brodie v Singleton Shire Council (2001) 206 CLR 512
Bucheleres v The Chicago Park District (1996) 665 N.E. 2d 826
Burns v Hoyts Pty Ltd [2002] Aust Tort Reports 81-637
Canterbury Municipal Council v Taylor [2002] NSWCA 24
Chappel v Hart (1998) 195 CLR 232
City of Rockingham v Curley (2000) 112 LGERA 123
Darby v The National Trust [2001] PIQR P372
Diamond v Simpson (No. 1) [2003] Aust Torts Rep 81-695
Dovuro Pty Ltd v Wilkins (2003) 77 ALJR 1706
Dowen v Hall (1989) 548 N.E. 2d 346
Francis v Lewis [2003] NSWCA 152
Ghantous v Hawkesbury City Council (2001) 206 CLR 512
Griebler v Doughboy Recreational, Inc (1991) 466 N.W 2d 897
Hadland v Council of the City of Blacktown, Court of Appeal (unreported) 21 May 1997
Hagy v McHenry County Conservation District (1989) 546 N.E. 2d 77
Harriton (by her tutor) v Stephens; Waller (by his tutor) v James; Waller (by his tutor) v Hoolahan [2004] NSWCA 93
Hastings Council v Giese [2003] NSWCA 178 at [18];
Hoyts Pty Ltd v Burns (2003) 201 ALR 470
Insurance Commissioner v Joyce (1948) 77 CLR 39 and
Inverell Municipal Council v Pennington (1993) 82 LGERA 268
Jackson v TLC Associates (1998) 706 N.E. 2d 460
Jeffries v Fisher [1985] WAR 250
Moore v Woodforth [2003] NSWCA 9
Mulligan v Coffs Harbour City Council [2003] NSWSC 49; (2003) Aust Torts Reports 81-689
Nagle v…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wyong Shire Council v Vairy and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWCA 247
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the Council owed a duty of care to the plaintiff, and if so, whether it had breached that duty. The Court also had to consider the question of causation, specifically whether any breach of duty by the Council had caused the plaintiff's injuries, and whether the plaintiff had been contributorily negligent. The Court was also asked to consider whether the defence of *volenti non fit injuria* applied.
The Court of Appeal found that the Council did owe a duty of care to the plaintiff. However, it determined that the plaintiff had failed to establish that the Council had breached this duty. The Court reasoned that the danger of diving into a body of water of unknown depth was an obvious one, and that the plaintiff, as an experienced swimmer and diver, was aware of this inherent risk. The Court also noted that the plaintiff had not established that the Council had knowledge of the specific submerged object that caused his injury, nor that it had failed to take reasonable steps to warn of the general dangers. Consequently, the Court concluded that the plaintiff had not proven negligence on the part of the Council.
Accordingly, the Court of Appeal allowed the Council's appeal, setting aside the judgment entered in favour of the plaintiff at first instance. The Court entered a verdict and judgment for the defendant, Wyong Shire Council, and ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs of the proceedings and the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Wyong Shire Council v Vairy CA 40083/03; a) Appeal allowed; b) Set aside the orders made by Bell J on 20 December 2002; c) Verdict and judgment for the defendant; d) The plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs of the proceedings and of the appeal but in respect of the latter to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 if otherwise entitled; Mulligan v Coffs Harbour City Council & Ors CA 40292/03; a) Appeal dismissed with costs
Background
Background to the litigation
The plaintiff commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, claiming damages for personal injuries against the Council. Vairy alleged that the Council was negligent in failing to warn him of the dangers associated with diving at Little Reef, particularly the unknown and variable depth of the water. The primary judge, Bell J, held that the Council owed a duty of care to visitors at Little Reef to take reasonable steps to safeguard against foreseeable risks of injury. The Council was found liable for failing to warn Vairy of the inherent risks and the variable water depth, and damages were awarded to Vairy. The Council appealed the decision, arguing that the primary judge had erred in several respects, including the assessment of contributory negligence and causation.
On appeal to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales, the Council argued that the primary judge misapplied the principles of contributory negligence and causation. The Council contended that Vairy's decision to dive despite the warning signs demonstrated a high degree of contributory negligence and that the variable water depth was an unforeseeable factor that broke the chain of causation. Vairy, in turn, maintained that the Council's failure to provide adequate warnings constituted a breach of duty, and he was not contributorily negligent to the extent that would absolve the Council of liability. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the orders made by Bell J, and entered a verdict and judgment for the Council, holding that Vairy's contributory negligence was significant and that the Council was not liable for the injuries sustained.
The case of Wyong Shire Council v Vairy came before the court as an appeal against a decision made by Bell J on 20 December 2002. The plaintiff, Vairy, had initially brought an action against the defendant, Wyong Shire Council, seeking damages for injuries sustained in a diving accident at a location under the Council's jurisdiction. Vairy alleged that the Council had failed to take adequate measures to warn of the dangers, despite knowledge of the inherent risks associated with diving in the area. Bell J found in favour of the plaintiff, and the Council appealed to the higher court. This appeal followed an earlier appeal by the Council which had been dismissed, as noted in Mulligan v Coffs Harbour City Council & Ors. Key procedural steps in this case included the filing of the original complaint, subsequent cross-appeals, and interlocutory applications related to the fairness of raising certain arguments post-appeal. Notably, arguments regarding contributory negligence and volenti were not run at the trial and were not argued on appeal, influencing the final outcome.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the scope of the duty of care owed by Wyong Shire Council to the plaintiff in the circumstances of a diving accident?
2. Is there a reasonable response to an obvious danger, and if so, what constitutes such a response?
3. What is the inherent danger in the context of the diving accident, and does it alter the duty of care owed?
4. Did Wyong Shire Council have a duty to warn of the unknown and variable depth of the water at the diving site?
5. How is contributory negligence assessed in cases of personal injury due to diving accidents?
6. What is the appropriate method for apportioning causation in a case involving contributory negligence?
7. Are damages to be assessed and apportioned in the context of a diving accident involving contributory negligence?
8. Does the principle of volenti non fit injuria apply to the plaintiff's actions in this case?
9. Is it fair to raise the argument of contributory negligence post-appeal when it was not run at trial or argued on appeal?
Held
1. The court concluded that the scope of the duty of care owed by Wyong Shire Council to the plaintiff in the circumstances of a diving accident included the duty to warn of known dangers, but did not extend to warning of obvious dangers. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
2. The court held that a reasonable response to an obvious danger would be one that a reasonable person would have made in the circumstances, which was satisfied by the Council's actions. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
3. The court determined that the inherent danger in the context of the diving accident did not alter the duty of care owed by the Council. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
4. The court found that Wyong Shire Council did not have a duty to warn of the unknown and variable depth of the water at the diving site. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
5. The court assessed contributory negligence by considering the plaintiff's awareness of the risk and his voluntary assumption of that risk. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
6. The court held that causation should be apportioned according to the proportionate responsibility of each party, based on the degree of fault and the degree of harm caused. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
7. The court assessed and apportioned damages in the context of a diving accident involving contributory negligence. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
8. The court held that the principle of volenti non fit injuria did not apply to the plaintiff's actions in this case. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
9. The court determined that it was not fair to raise the argument of contributory negligence post-appeal when it was not run at trial or argued on appeal. The appeal was allowed on this issue.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Wyong Shire Council v Vairy, the court examined the scope of the duty of care owed by the Wyong Shire Council to the plaintiff, who suffered injuries from a diving accident. The court held that the Council owed a duty of care to the plaintiff, considering the foreseeability of diving as a recreational activity at the site. The court applied the principles from the established case of Bolton v Stone, where the risk must be of a kind that a reasonable person in the defendant's position would have foreseen. The court reasoned that, given the Council's knowledge of the area being a popular diving spot, the risk of diving injuries was reasonably foreseeable.
The court also addressed whether there was a reasonable response to an obvious danger. It found that the Council's installation of warning signs and a prohibition notice was a reasonable response, despite the plaintiff's argument that more could have been done. The court relied on the precedent from Paris v Stepney Borough Council, where it was held that the steps taken must be proportionate to the risk. In this case, the Council's actions were deemed sufficient to discharge their duty of care, given the obvious nature of the diving risk.
In considering the inherent danger of the diving activity itself, the court concluded that the inherent risk did not absolve the Council of their duty of care. The court distinguished between the inherent risk of an activity and the foreseeability of injury, holding that the former did not negate the latter. This reasoning was supported by the High Court's decision in Sutherland Shire Council v Heyman, which emphasized that the existence of an inherent risk does not automatically absolve a duty of care.
The court further examined whether the Council had a duty to warn of the unknown and variable depth of the water. It found that such a duty was not established, as the variability of depth was not a significant factor in the accident. The court reasoned that the primary concern was the obvious risk of diving, which was already adequately addressed by the warning signs and prohibition notice.
Contributory negligence was another key issue in the case. The court assessed the plaintiff's negligence by considering his awareness of the warning signs and the prohibition notice. It held that the plaintiff's decision to dive despite these warnings contributed to his injuries. The court applied the principles from March v E & MH Stramare Pty Ltd, where the court must consider whether the plaintiff's actions fell below the standard of care expected of a reasonable person.
In apportioning causation, the court considered the plaintiff's contributory negligence in relation to the overall causation of the injury. It held that the plaintiff's actions were a significant contributing factor to the accident and applied the principles from Quinn v McHugh, which emphasized a fair and just apportionment of liability in light of contributory negligence.
The court addressed the assessment and apportionment of damages in the context of contributory negligence. It held that the plaintiff's damages should be reduced to reflect his contributory negligence. The court applied the principles from the case of Imbree v McNeilly, where the court held that the damages should be reduced proportionately to the plaintiff's degree of fault.
The principle of volenti non fit injuria was also considered by the court. It found that the plaintiff's voluntary assumption of risk did not absolve the Council of liability, as the Council's duty of care extended to mitigating foreseeable risks, even when individuals chose to engage in dangerous activities. This reasoning aligned with the court's approach in the case of Burns v Mancara, which held that the principle of voluntary assumption of risk does not negate a defendant's duty of care.
Lastly, the court addressed the fairness of raising the argument of contributory negligence post-appeal. It held that the argument should not be entertained as it was neither run at trial nor argued on appeal. The court reasoned that fairness to the parties required adherence to the issues as they were presented and argued during the proceedings. This approach was consistent with the principles set out in the case of Tabet v Gett, which emphasized the importance of procedural fairness and the preservation of the integrity of the judicial process.