| [2020] FWC 1912 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.120—Redundancy pay
Worthington Industries Pty Ltd
v
Nael Ablahad
(C2020/1789)
and
Worthington Industries Pty Ltdv
Paul Treloar
(C2020/1790)
and
Worthington Industries Pty Ltdv
Rivas Subair
(C2020/1791)
DEPUTY PRESIDENT CLANCY | MELBOURNE, 9 APRIL 2020 |
Redundancy - applications to vary NES entitlement - applications to reduce redundancy entitlements from 4 weeks to 1 week - whether employer has capacity to pay - applications dismissed.
[1] On 24 March 2020, Worthington Industries Pty Ltd (Worthington Industries) made three applications to the Fair Work Commission under s.120 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) seeking to reduce the amount of redundancy pay to which Mr Nael Ablahad, Mr Paul Treloar and Mr Rivas Subair (the Respondent Employees) are each entitled from four weeks’ pay to one.
Background
[2] Until 3 April 2020, the Respondent Employees were employed by Worthington Industries as follows:
• Mr Ablahad was employed as a full-time employee from 13 June 2018 to 3 April 2020. He was paid $22.50 per hour.
• Mr Treloar was employed as a full-time employee from 9 April 2018 to 3 April 2020. He was paid $22.00 per hour.
• Mr Subair was employed as a full-time employee from 4 April 2018 to 3 April 2020. He was also paid $22.00 per hour.
[3] Worthington Industries say that even though their full-time employment has ceased, they have promised to henceforth offer each of the Respondent Employees as much casual employment as is available, even if they cannot guarantee minimum hours of work. Worthington Industries state that they advised the Respondent Employees that they will offer them full-time positions again as soon as they are able. They proffer that under the current world-wide crisis of COVID-19, this is the best that Worthington Industries can do.
[4] At item 2.3 of their Form F45A, Worthington Industries outlined that they have experienced a reduction in their production output due to both competition and COVID-19 and as a result, have had to end the full-time employment of 5 employees.
[5] The matters were first listed for a Telephone Mention on 27 March 2020. I caused an email to be sent on 26 March 2020 foreshadowing that during the Telephone Mention I would ask each of the Respondent Employees what they had to say about the applications that had been made, and in particular, the request that the amount of their redundancy pay be reduced from four weeks to one week. I also foreshadowed that I intended to ask Worthington Industries to outline the extent to which these applications are based on competition, as opposed to COVID-19. I also requested that Worthington Industries provide, ahead of the Telephone Mention, particulars of the quantum of both a four-week redundancy payment and a one-week redundancy payment for each of the Respondent Employees. Worthington Industries was also invited to provide evidence supporting their assertion that they cannot afford to pay four weeks redundancy pay to each of the Respondent…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Worthington Industries Pty Ltd v Nael Ablahad and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FWC 1912
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the employer had not demonstrated a genuine inability to pay the full redundancy entitlement as required by the Act. The employer's financial position, while strained, did not amount to an inability to pay the full amount due. The employer had not provided sufficient evidence to support its claim of financial hardship, and the court was not satisfied that the employer's financial situation was so dire that it could not meet its legal obligations. The court dismissed the employer's application to reduce the redundancy entitlement, holding that the employer had not met the threshold for reducing the statutory entitlement under section 108(4) of the Act. The court ordered the employer to pay the full redundancy entitlement of four weeks to Mr Ablahad.