Application by Hercules Group Services Pty Ltd as trustee for The Hercules Group Services Unit Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
[2023] FWC 3107

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.120—Redundancy pay

Application by Hercules Group Services Pty Ltd as trustee for The Hercules Group Services Unit Trust

(C2023/6429)

COMMISSIONER CRAWFORD

SYDNEY, 27 NOVEMBER 2023

Variation of redundancy pay – incapacity to pay – insufficient evidence - application dismissed

Background

  1. Hercules Group Services Pty Ltd as trustee for The Hercules Group Services Unit Trust (Hercules Group Services) has applied pursuant to s.120 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FWAct) to have the Commission reduce the redundancy pay entitlement of Neil Virago (Mr Virago). 

  1. Mr Virago commenced employment with Hercules Group Services on 14 March 2016.[1] Mr Virago was employed by Hercules Group Services as an Operations Manager. Mr Virago’s employment was terminated by Hercules Group Services on 23 October 2023 on the ground of redundancy.[2] Hercules Group Services is part of the Hercules group of companies which is involved in the provision of equipment to car parks such as car lifts, stackers and turn-tables.[3]

  1. It is not in dispute that Mr Virago is entitled to 13 weeks of redundancy pay pursuant to s.119 of the FW Act. Mr Virago has been paid five weeks in lieu of notice for termination in accordance with s.117 of the FW Act. Mr Virago’s annual salary at the time of termination was $110,000. As a result, the value of Mr Virago’s full redundancy pay entitlement is $27,500 gross.

  1. Hercules Group Services has applied to reduce Mr Virago’s redundancy pay entitlement to “4 weeks, or whatever amount is deemed suitable by FairWork”.[4] Four weeks’ pay would equate to $8,461 gross for Mr Virago.  

  1. The basis for Hercules Group Services’ application is:

“Hercules Group Services have (sic) made a $1,019,691 loss for the current quarter with   the entire consolidated group of Hercules companies making a $445,563 loss and our           biggest expense by far is payroll. We are struggling with cash flow and request that the        redundancy pay be reduced to 4 weeks. We only have 21.4 FTE and fall just outside of   the small business provisions.”[5]

  1. I listed the application for Mention/Directions on 2 November 2023. Mr Virago indicated he opposed the application. I then issued directions for the filing of material by both parties and listed the application for hearing via video on 22 November 2023.

  1. Phil Elsley (General Manager) appeared for Hercules Group Services at the hearing on 22 November 2023 and Mr Virago represented himself.

Material filed

  1. Hercules Group Services relied on the following evidence in support of its application:

·   Mr Virago’s notice of redundancy letter dated 23 October 2023. I marked this Exhibit A1.

·   A profit and loss excerpt for the Hercules group of companies Year to Date for the September quarter of the 2023/2024 financial year. I marked this Exhibit A2.

·   An excerpt from bank accounts operated by the Hercules group of companies. Mr Elsley indicated the figures were extracted on 10 November 2023. I marked this Exhibit A3.

·…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Application by Hercules Group Services Pty Ltd as trustee fo... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FWC 3107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hercules Group Services Pty Ltd, as trustee for The Hercules Group Services Unit Trust, has applied to the Fair Work Commission under section 120 of the Fair Work Act 2009 to reduce the redundancy pay of Neil Virago, who was employed as an Operations Manager and was terminated on 23 October 2023. The basis for the application is that Hercules Group Services is experiencing significant financial difficulties, having incurred losses and struggling with cash flow. The applicant seeks to reduce Mr Virago's redundancy pay from 13 weeks to 4 weeks. Mr Virago opposes the application.

The legal issues before the Commission were whether Hercules Group Services could demonstrate it was unable to pay Mr Virago the full redundancy amount, and if so, whether a reduction to four weeks' pay was appropriate. Section 120 of the FW Act allows the Commission to reduce redundancy pay if the employer cannot pay the amount, or if the employer has found other acceptable employment for the employee. Hercules Group Services relies on the inability to pay argument, submitting that it is facing severe financial difficulties and cannot meet its payroll obligations.

Commissioner Crawford considered the evidence provided by both parties. Hercules Group Services provided bank statements and profit and loss excerpts showing losses and financial difficulties, while Mr Virago submitted spreadsheets of active projects and emails about a credit application. The Commissioner found that Hercules Group Services had sufficient funds to pay the redundancy amount, noting that the bank statements showed over $60,000 in various accounts. The Commissioner concluded that Hercules Group Services had not demonstrated an inability to pay the redundancy amount and therefore did not have jurisdiction to reduce the payment.

The Commissioner dismissed the application on the basis that Hercules Group Services had not satisfied the requirement that it "cannot pay" the redundancy amount. The Commissioner expressed sympathy for the financial difficulties faced by Hercules Group Services but noted that the Commission's role was not to decide on the most appropriate use of an employer's assets or revenue. The application to reduce redundancy pay was dismissed.

The final order was that the application to reduce Neil Virago's redundancy pay was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Neil Virago commenced employment with Hercules Group Services Pty Ltd as trustee for The Hercules Group Services Unit Trust (Hercules Group Services) on 14 March 2016 in the role of Operations Manager. His employment was terminated on 23 October 2023 on the ground of redundancy. Hercules Group Services is part of a group of companies involved in the provision of equipment to car parks. It is undisputed that Mr Virago is entitled to 13 weeks of redundancy pay under section 119 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act). Mr Virago has already been paid five weeks in lieu of notice under section 117 of the FW Act, and his annual salary at the time of termination was $110,000, resulting in a full redundancy pay entitlement of $27,500 gross. Hercules Group Services applied to the Fair Work Commission (FWC) under section 120 of the FW Act to reduce Mr Virago's redundancy pay entitlement, citing financial difficulties and an inability to pay the full amount.

The application by Hercules Group Services to reduce Mr Virago's redundancy pay was listed for Mention/Directions on 2 November 2023. Mr Virago indicated his opposition to the application. Commissioner Crawford then issued directions for the filing of material by both parties and listed the application for hearing via video on 22 November 2023. At the hearing, Phil Elsley, General Manager of Hercules Group Services, appeared on behalf of the applicant, and Mr Virago represented himself. The Commission considered the evidence filed by both parties before dismissing the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Hercules Group Services have sufficient funds to pay Mr Virago his full redundancy pay entitlement of $27,500 gross?
2. If Hercules Group Services cannot pay the full redundancy pay, is there jurisdiction to reduce the amount payable under section 120 of the FW Act?
3. If the answer to issue 2 is yes, what amount, if any, should the redundancy pay be reduced to?

Held
1. The court concluded that Hercules Group Services has sufficient funds to pay Mr Virago his full redundancy pay entitlement of $27,500 gross. As a result, the application to reduce the amount was dismissed.
2. There was no jurisdiction to reduce the amount payable under section 120 of the FW Act as the court was not satisfied that Hercules Group Services cannot pay the amount.
3. Since the court did not find jurisdiction to reduce the redundancy pay, it did not need to determine the amount, if any, to which the redundancy pay should be reduced.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application by Hercules Group Services under section 120 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act) to reduce the redundancy pay entitlement of Mr Virago. The court reviewed the evidence submitted by both parties, including financial statements and business operations details. The Hercules group of companies, of which Hercules Group Services is a part, has faced significant financial difficulties, reporting a net loss of $445,663 from July to September 2023 and holding only $60,451.47 in its bank accounts as of 10 November 2023. However, the court found that this evidence was not sufficient to establish that Hercules Group Services cannot pay Mr Virago’s full redundancy entitlement of $27,500.

The court considered various factors relevant to the determination of whether an employer "cannot pay" the redundancy pay, including the totality of the employer's financial position, the extent of financial difficulty, remaining assets and receivables, efforts to pay other statutory entitlements, prospects of financial improvement, and whether reducing redundancy pay would merely assist the employer without being borne out of an incapacity. Despite the financial difficulties faced by the Hercules group, the court was not convinced that the company was currently unable to pay Mr Virago's full redundancy entitlement. The balance sheet evidence provided by Hercules Group Services did not allow for a proper assessment of the overall financial position of the Hercules group. The court also noted that the Hercules group is still trading and has ongoing projects that will generate future revenue.

The court emphasized its role under section 120 of the FW Act is not to decide the most appropriate use of an employer’s assets or revenue but to determine if there is an incapacity to pay the full redundancy amount. The court found that without sufficient evidence to establish an incapacity to pay, it did not have the jurisdiction to reduce Mr Virago’s redundancy pay. Consequently, the application was dismissed.