Wormell Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Wormell Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council & Anor [2021] QPEC 12

PARTIES:

WORMELL PTY LTD
ACN 607 321 157

(appellant)

v

GOLD COAST CITY COUNCIL

(respondent)

and
DANCE HEADQUARTERS PTY LTD

(co-respondent)

FILE NO:

249/2018

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning and Environment Court at Southport

DELIVERED ON:

22 February 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Southport

HEARING DATE:

10 February 2021

JUDGE:

Kent QC DCJ

ORDER:

1. The imposition of a condition on an approval of the proposed development requiring compliance with the revised traffic management plan is not a prohibited development condition for the purposes of s 66(2) of the Planning Act 2016.

2.   Directions will be made for further conduct of the matter.

CATCHWORDS:

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING – DEVELOPMENT CONTROL – CONSENTS, APPROVALS, PERMITS AND AGREEMENTS – MODIFICATIONS – GENERALLY
Where the appeal concerns an approval of an application for a material change of use from warehouse to indoor recreation – whether the plan is inconsistent with an existing development condition – whether the proposed development plan is prohibited by previous development plan – where the appellant submits that an earlier development approval is binding – where the respondents submit that the proposed development is independent of the regulated use under the earlier development approval – where it was found that the proposed development is not prohibited

LEGISLATION:

Planning Act 2016 (Qld) s 66(2), s 73

CASES:

Gladstone Regional Council v Holmes R Us (Australia) Pty Ltd [2015] QCA 175

Liqourland (Aust) Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council & Anor [2002] QCA 248

Pike v Tighe (2018) 262 CLR 648

Steendyk v Brisbane City Council & Ors [2016] QPEC 47

COUNSEL:

Mr R Quirk for the Appellant
Mr J Ware for the Respondent
Mr D Purcell for the Co-Respondent

SOLICITORS:

Hickey Lawyers for the Appellant
McInnes Wilson for the Respondent
Lee Lawyers for the Co-Respondent

Introduction

  1. This application involves the determination of a preliminary point (which arose mid-hearing) in an appeal against the approval by the respondent Council of an application for “material change of use” in relation to the Co-Respondent’s premises at 1 Geary Crescent, Molendinar. 

  2. The substantive hearing of the appeal took place between 16 and 19 November 2020, with evidence being given on the relevant issues.  Towards the end of the scheduled time for hearing, the present issue emerged and by agreement the parties exchanged written outlines of submissions dealing with the preliminary point and the hearing thereof was listed for 10 February 2021. 

  3. The point which has emerged is in relation to the application of s 66(2) of the Planning Act 2016 (Qld) (“the Planning Act”) to the proposed development, including the proposed traffic solution; whether s 66(2) renders part of the solution a prohibited development condition.

    Background

  4. The relevant premises are part of an industrial estate at Molendinar.  The original development approval was granted under a previous legislative scheme, the Integrated Planning Act 1997 (“the Integrated Planning Act

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wormell Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QPEC 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Wormell Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council involves a dispute over the approval of a material change of use from warehouse to indoor recreation at a property in Molendinar. The appellant, Wormell Pty Ltd, challenges the council's approval of the change of use for a lot occupied by the co-respondent, which is part of a two-lot scheme. The original development approval, granted under the Integrated Planning Act 1997, permitted the use of the premises as a warehouse and included a landscaping plan. The proposed change of use involves a revised traffic management plan, which includes a concrete pathway through the landscaped garden area. The key issue is whether the revised traffic management plan is inconsistent with the conditions of the earlier development approval under s 66(2) of the Planning Act 2016, and if so, whether this inconsistency renders the proposed development a prohibited condition.

The court had to determine whether the proposed development is prohibited by the previous development plan under s 66(2) of the Planning Act. This section stipulates that a development condition must not be inconsistent with an earlier development approval unless specific exceptions apply, which they do not in this case. The appellant argues that the earlier development approval is binding and that the proposed traffic management plan is inconsistent with it. The respondents counter that the proposed development is independent of the regulated use under the earlier approval and does not rely on the warehouse use. The court was required to interpret s 66(2) and decide if the proposed development, despite being inconsistent with the earlier approval, could still be allowed as it represents a materially different use.

The court found that the proposed development is not prohibited by s 66(2) of the Planning Act. It accepted the respondents' argument that the proposed development is independent of the earlier approval and constitutes a different use. The court held that the statutory regime allows for different approvals to coexist for the same land and provides recourse for changing or removing conditions from earlier approvals. Consequently, the earlier development approval and its conditions are not in effect for the proposed development, which is a materially different use. Therefore, the imposition of a condition on the approval of the proposed development requiring compliance with the revised traffic management plan is not a prohibited development condition under s 66(2).

The court ordered that the imposition of a condition on the approval of the proposed development requiring compliance with the revised traffic management plan is not a prohibited development condition for the purposes of s 66(2) of the Planning Act 2016. Directions were made for the further conduct of the matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The imposition of a condition on an approval of the proposed development requiring compliance with the revised traffic management plan is not a prohibited development condition for the purposes of s 66(2) of the Planning Act 2016.

2. Directions will be made for further conduct of the matter.

Background

Background to the litigation

The point which has emerged is in relation to the application of s 66(2) of the Planning Act 2016 (Qld) (“the Planning Act”) to the proposed development, including the proposed traffic solution; whether s 66(2) renders part of the solution a prohibited development condition.Background The relevant premises are part of an industrial estate at Molendinar. The original development approval was granted under a previous legislative scheme, the Integrated Planning Act 1997 (“the Integrated Planning Act”) and covers the two lot scheme which is situated at 1 Geary Crescent, Molendinar (one lot is occupied by the appellant, the other by the co-respondent, which is largely the genesis of the present dispute). The appeal is against the Council’s approval of a material change of use for the co-respondent’s lot, namely indoor sports and recreation (a dance studio). The original development approval (for use of the premises as a warehouse) which attached to the land continues to do so, and as indicated by document 3, exhibited to the affidavit of Mr Lee sworn 9 February 2021, included a landscaping plan. The issue which has arisen is the interaction of the proposed revised traffic management plan – which has been developed for the purposes of the present appeal – with the previous landscaping plan. As outlined by counsel for the co-respondent, it seems uncontroversial that the revised traffic management plan resolves the traffic issues in the appeal, however a question arose as to whether in the event of the development approval being granted, a condition requiring compliance with the revised traffic management plan would be prohibited because of s 66(2) of the Planning Act. This provides that a development condition must not be inconsistent with a development condition of an earlier development approval in effect for the development, unless the prescribed exception applies (which it does not). The problem is that the revised traffic management plan provides for a 1 metre wide concrete pathway through the edge of the landscaped garden area previously approved, which was to be at least 3 metres in depth.The Legislation Section 66(2) provides as follows:“(2)A development condition must not be inconsistent with a development condition of an earlier development approval in effect for the development, unless – (a)both conditions are imposed by the same person; and(b)the applicant agrees in writing to the latter condition applying; and(c)if the development application for the latter development approval was required to be accompanied by the consent of the owner of the premises – the owner of the premises agrees in writing to the latter condition applying.” (emphasis added) In this case, sub-paragraph 2(c) has not and cannot be met because the agreement of the Body Corporate, as the owner of the subject land, cannot be obtained. The Co-Respondent’s Submissions The co-respondent submits (in arguments adopted by the Respondent) that properly construed, s 66(2) requires two pre-requisites to be met:(a)Firstly, the existence of an earlier development approval being in effect for the development the subject of the present application; and, if so,(b)Secondly, an inconsistency between a proposed condition and a condition of that area development approval.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondents submit that the proposed development does not use or adopt the benefit of the “warehouse” use under the earlier development approval to which the subject conditions attach. Rather it only seeks to use the premises and building thereon. The proposed development is a material change of use of the premises which happens to take a similar physical form in the existing improvements but is independent from the existing use regulated under the earlier development approval. Conclusion In my conclusion the submissions of the respondents must be accepted. Specifically, I accept the central arguments of the respondents that, assuming for present purposes that the proposed condition is inconsistent with the conditions of the earlier development approval, it is of no moment where:(a)the only relevant limitation on the conditions which may be imposed on a development approval is that imposed by s 66(2) of the Planning Act; and(b)the decided authorities and statutory regime contemplate different approvals may co-exist (for different uses) for the same land; and(c)the statutory regime specifically provides recourse for the change or removal of conditions imposed by an earlier development approval, even if acted upon. Thus in my conclusion as to the effect of s 66(2), the earlier development approval and its conditions are not in effect for the present development, which is a materially different use. No question arises as to the conflict between the proposed condition and the earlier development approval within the ambit of s 66(2) of the Planning Act. Thus imposition of a condition on an approval of the proposed development requiring compliance with the revised traffic management plan is not a prohibited development condition. Having resolved the preliminary issue, directions will be made as to the management of the remaining issues in the appeal.