Work Health Authority NT v Australian Green Properties Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

CITATION:WORK HEALTH AUTHORITY NT v AUSTRALIAN GREEN PROPERTIES PTY LTD [2019] NTLC 035

PARTIES:WORK HEALTH AUTHORITY NT

v

AUSTRALIAN GREEN PROPERTIES PTY LTD

TITLE OF COURT:  LOCAL COURT

JURISDICTION:  CRIMINAL

FILE NO(s):21815193

DELIVERED ON:  14 OCTOBER 2019

DELIVERED AT:  DARWIN

HEARING DATE(s):  5 – 12 DECEMBER 2018; 20 MAY 2019

JUDGMENT OF:  JUDGE ELISABETH ARMITAGE

CATCHWORDS:

Work Health and Safety - work health and safety duty; exposure to risk of serious injury or death; must ensure; so far as is reasonably practicable; workplace; cattle station; car crash; pastoral permit; judicial notice; strict liability

Criminal Code Act ss 43BA, 43BK, 43BP; Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act s 143; Motor Vehicles Act ss 119, 137B; Work Health and Safety Act (National Uniform Legislation) Act NT 2011 ss 5, 8, 12, 12A, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19, 28, 32, 244

Thiess Pty Ltd and Hochtief AG v Industrial Court of NSW (2010) 78 NSWLR 94; Carrington Slipways Pty Ltd v Callaghan (1985) 11 IR 467; WorkCover Authority of NSW v TRW [2011] NSW IR Comm 52; Riley v Australian Grader Hire Pty Ltd [2011] NSW IR Comm 31; Baida Poultry v The Queen [2012] HCA 14; WorkCover Authority of NSW (Inspector Byer) v Cleary Bros (Bombo) Pty Ltd [2001] NSW IR Comm 278; WorkCover Authority of NSW (Inspector Byer) v Cleary Bros (Bombo) [2001] NSW IR Comm 278

Tooma, M, Tooma’s Annotated Work Health and Safety Act, 2011, Law Book Co., 2017, (2nd Ed)

MVR Information Bulletin R3, Mark Thomas

Defendant:Mr Tom Anderson

Solicitors:

Complainant:             WorkSafe NT

Defendant:Peacokes Solicitors

Judgment category classification:       A

Judgment ID number:  [2019] NTLC 035

Number of paragraphs:  117

IN THE LOCAL COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21815193

BETWEEN

WORK HEALTH AUTHORITY NT

Complainant

AND

AUSTRALIAN GREEN PROPERTIES PTY LTD

Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 14 October 2019)

JUDGE ARMITAGE

  1. The defendant, Australian Green Properties Pty Ltd (AGP), owns and operates Epenarra Station (the Station), a remote cattle station located about 400 km north east of Alice Springs. Mr Daniel Jarmin (aged 26) and his girlfriend, Miss Haley Baker-Covey, both of the United Kingdom, started working at the Station in May 2016. This matter concerns the death of Mr Jarmin on 24 August 2016 who was killed in a single vehicle car crash when he was returning to the Station. It is alleged that AGP did not adequately comply with a work health and safety duty and that its failure to do so exposed Mr Jarmin to a risk of death or serious injury.

The facts

  1. When Mr Jarmin and Ms Baker-Covey first arrived at the Station, Mr Ben McGlynn managed the cattle station and Ms Vicki McGlynn managed the Epenarra Station Store (the Store). Mr Jarmin and Ms Baker-Covey were employed in the Store which stocked food and sundry items, and serviced residents of the Station and a small nearby Aboriginal community. However, in about May 2016 the McGlynns resigned, and in about July 2016 Mr Alan Cunningham commenced…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Work Health Authority NT v Australian Green Properties Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NTLC 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Work Health Authority NT v Australian Green Properties Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the Work Health Authority of the Northern Territory and Australian Green Properties Pty Ltd (AGP) regarding the safety of a vehicle used by one of AGP’s employees, Mr Jarmin, who tragically died during a journey. The dispute came before the Court, which was tasked with determining whether AGP breached its duty to ensure the safety of the vehicle and whether such a breach contributed to the death of Mr Jarmin.

The central legal issues revolved around whether AGP had a duty to provide and maintain a safe vehicle, specifically the Toyota LandCruiser used by Mr Jarmin, under section 19(3)(b) of the relevant legislation. AGP conceded that it owed a duty to provide "safe plant," which included the vehicle in question. The court had to decide if AGP failed in this duty by not ensuring that the vehicle was equipped with a fully functional and accessible spare tyre, given the high risk of encountering a flat tyre on the journey. Additionally, the court had to determine if such a failure led to a risk of death or serious injury, which ultimately contributed to Mr Jarmin's death.

The Court found that AGP did indeed owe a duty to ensure the safety of the vehicle given its knowledge of the planned use of the LandCruiser for a work journey. The court was satisfied that the risk of encountering a flat tyre was high, especially considering the vehicle's use on dirt roads and the age of the tyres. It was concluded that the employer had a duty to equip the vehicle with a spare tyre, the means to access it, and the necessary tools to change a tyre. Given that the LandCruiser did not have a functional spare tyre, AGP was found to have failed in its duty, thereby contributing to the risk of death or serious injury to Mr Jarmin.

The Court concluded that AGP's failure to ensure the vehicle was equipped with a fully functional spare tyre breached its duty under section 19(3)(b), and this failure materially contributed to the risk of death or serious injury to Mr Jarmin. The Court ordered AGP to pay compensation to Mr Jarmin's estate for the breach of duty.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In their closing submissions the parties dealt with these allegations by reference to s 19(3)(b) first and I will do likewise.Consideration of particulars pursuant to s 19(3)(b): Did AGP owe a duty to provide and maintain safe plant and structures? Section 19(3)(b) required AGP to provide and maintain “safe plant”. Plant includes machinery: s 4. AGP conceded the LandCruiser was “plant”. AGP accepted that it had a duty to provide “safe plant”.[58] Although the LandCruiser was primarily used on or near the Station, I was satisfied on the evidence that AGP through its employees knew that Mr Jarmin was using the LandCruiser to make trips to the Hotel as he had made two such trips for personal purposes prior to the fatal trip. The use of the LandCruiser for those trips was not a secret and it is apparent that there was acquiescence in this use by AGPs employees. Indeed, Ms Russell received an email and phone calls from Ms Baker-Covey about this use. In addition AGP were advised of and permitted the use of the LandCruiser for the fatal journey, as this was discussed with Ms Russell before Mr Jarmin’s departure. Ms Russell did not prevent the proposal as she was under the mistaken belief that the LandCruiser was fully registered. Even though AGP might not have contemplated or intended that the LandCruiser be used for such a work journey it knew of the precise planned use before Mr Jarmin departed. In those circumstances I was satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that AGP owed a duty to ensure that the vehicle was safe for the trip which it permitted as part of Mr Jarmin’s work. I will now address each of the particularised alleged failings under s 19(3)(b) in turn.(i)Did AGP have a duty to provide fully functional and accessible spare tyre(s) that could be used to replace a punctured tyre? If so, did it fail in that duty? If so, did that failure give rise to a risk of death or serious injury or illness? Spare tyres don’t prevent flat tyres, they simply allow a driver to deal with a flat tyre expeditiously. Spares allow a driver to continue the journey rather than waiting for assistance. In my view, the possibility of a flat tyre is a well-known and understood risk when driving. Indeed the risk was obvious to Mr McGlynn and so he took the precaution of showing Mr Jarmin how to change a tyre. Further, in my view common sense and ordinary life experience points to the risk of getting a flat tyre increasing on dirt roads. In addition, common sense and ordinary life experience points to the risk of getting a flat increasing when tyres have been well used and are getting close to needing to be replaced. I was satisfied that the risk of getting a flat tyre, when driving on dirt, on older tyres, over some distance, is quite high. In those circumstances, when a vehicle is permitted to be used for work in those conditions I was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the employer owes a duty to minimise that risk by ensuring the vehicle is equipped with a spare tyre, the means of accessing the spare tyre and the tools to change a flat tyre.