Hardy v St Vincent's Hospital Toowoomba Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL [1998] QCA 086
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
Appeal No. 7477 of 1997.
Brisbane
[St Vincent’s Hospital Toowoomba Ltd v. Hardy]
BETWEEN:

ST VINCENT’S HOSPITAL TOOWOOMBA LTD
ACN 055 196 533

(Defendant) Appellant

AND:

BETTE HARDY

(Plaintiff) Respondent

___________________________________________________________________________

Pincus J.A. Davies J.A. Ambrose J.

___________________________________________________________________________

Judgment delivered 6 May 1998

Judgment of the Court
___________________________________________________________________________

1.          APPEAL ALLOWED TO THE EXTENT OF REDUCING THE JUDGMENT IN FAVOUR OF THE PLAINTIFF RESPONDENT TO $19,379.79.

2.          THE APPEAL IS OTHERWISE DISMISSED.

3.          THE APPELLANT IS TO PAY THE RESPONDENT’S COSTS, HERE AND BELOW.

___________________________________________________________________________

CATCHWORDS: PERSONAL INJURY - whether breach of s. 9(1) Workplace Health &

Safety Act 1989 - meaning of "practicable" - whether s. 9(1) is to apply only to measures necessary to avert reasonably foreseeable harm to an employee - meaning of "ensure" - damages - reduced to $19,379.79 - whether costs should be allowed only on the Magistrates Court Scale. Workplace Health & Safety Act 1989 s. 9

Counsel: 

Mr D J Campbell for the appellant. Mr G R Mullins for the respondent.

Solicitors:  Hede Byrne and Hall for the appellant.
Shine Roche McGowan for the respondent.
Hearing date:  24 April 1998.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 7477 of 1997.

Brisbane

Before Pincus J.A.
Davies J.A.

Ambrose J.

[St Vincent’s Hospital Toowoomba Ltd v. Hardy]

BETWEEN:

ST VINCENT’S HOSPITAL TOOWOOMBA LTD
ACN 055 196 533

(Defendant) Appellant

AND:

BETTE HARDY

(Plaintiff) Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THE COURT

Judgment delivered 6 May 1998

This is an appeal from a judgment of the District Court in favour of the plaintiff in a personal

injuries case. It relates to both liability and quantum; as to the latter, it is agreed that the amount of

damages awarded must be reduced by a certain sum, as we shall later explain. The case is one which

it could be said that the plaintiff was fortunate to win; but the decision in her favour is challenged only

on a rather narrow basis.

The plaintiff respondent was injured on 8 September 1993 when she fell while ascending stairs

in the course of her duties as an employee of the defendant appellant. She was working as a hospital

cleaner, her hours being from 6.30 a.m. to 3 p.m. The plaintiff suffered her injury almost at the end of

the shift when she was tired; the judge said that the "position was simply that she was 63 and the job was getting beyond her". There was nothing wrong with the stairs; the plaintiff’s case was that she had

to move up and down the stairs quite often in the building, which had four storeys, and that she would

not have fallen if she had used a lift. The judge thought it likely that the practice was that:

". . . ordinarily cleaners would not use lifts unless they were moving equipment from floor to floor,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hardy v St Vincent's Hospital Toowoomba Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] QCA 86
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the appeal of St Vincent's Hospital Toowoomba Ltd v. Hardy, the court considered the appeal of the hospital against a judgment in favour of the plaintiff, Bette Hardy, in a personal injury case. The appeal focused on both liability and quantum, with an agreed reduction in the damages awarded. The plaintiff, a hospital cleaner, was injured while ascending stairs, and her case was that she would not have fallen if she had used a lift. The judge found that the hospital had discouraged the use of lifts by its employees, which led to the plaintiff's injury.

The court examined the interpretation of section 9(1) of the Workplace Health and Safety Act 1989, which requires employers to ensure the health and safety of their employees, except where it is not practicable. The hospital argued that the statutory duty should only apply to measures necessary to avert reasonably foreseeable harm to an employee. However, the court found that the literal construction of the statute, which means that employers must make certain or ensure the health and safety of their employees, was supported by precedent. The court also noted that the word "ensure" did not impose any test of reasonable foreseeability.

The court dismissed the appeal on liability but agreed to reduce the damages awarded to $19,379.79 due to an error in calculating the damages. The hospital also argued that the plaintiff should be limited to costs on the Magistrates Court scale, but the court found that pursuing the claim in the District Court was appropriate given the circumstances. The appeal was allowed to the extent of reducing the judgment in favour of the plaintiff to $19,379.79, and the hospital was ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established