Wood v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Wood v State of Queensland [2024] QSC 32

PARTIES:

IAN ANDREW WOOD

(respondent/plaintiff)

v
STATE OF QUEENSLAND

(applicant/defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 6639 of 2022

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

15 March 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

5 March 2024

JUDGE:

Cooper J

ORDER:

1.   The reference to the following claims are to be struck out of the amended claim and the prayer for relief in the amended statement of claim:

Fraud – $2,500,000.00;

Fabrication of evidence – $250,000,000.00;

Malfeasance in Public Office – $100,000,000.00;

Parasitic damages – $300,000,000.00;

Conspiracy to bring false accusation – $1,000,000,000.00;

Attempting to pervert the course of justice – $500,000,000.00;

Compounding an indictable offence – $1,000,000,000.00;

Official corruption not judicial but relating to offences – $500,000,000.00;

Judicial corruption – $1,000,000,000.00;

Corruption of witnesses (alternatively deceiving witnesses) – $500,000,000.00;

Conspiring to defeat justice – $1,000,000,000.00.

2.    The following parts of the document titled “Better and Further Particulars” filed on 3 November 2022 are to be struck out:

Paragraphs 24 and 30;

The words “and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions” in the second sentence of paragraph 31;

The words “Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions”, “unknown officers of the Indooroopilly Police Station” and “Police Prosecutions” in the first sentence of paragraph 37;

The balance of paragraph 37, from the start of the second sentence to the end of the paragraph;

Paragraph 38;

Paragraph 40;

The unnumbered paragraph appearing immediately after paragraph 40;

The paragraph commencing with the heading “Pure Mental Harm – $30,000,000.00”;

The paragraph commencing with the heading “Fraud – $250,000.00”;

The paragraph commencing with the heading “Destruction of Evidence – $25,000,000.00”;

The three unnumbered paragraphs which appear on the last two pages of the document.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – STRIKING OUT – DISCLOSING NO REASONABLE CAUSE OF ACTION OR DEFENCE – where respondent previously sought leave to amend his statement of claim to claim damages for, inter alia, “conspiring to bring false accusation, fabrication of evidence, attempting to pervert the course of justice, conspiring to compound an indictable offence, official corruption not judicial but relating to offences, perjury, corruption of witnesses (or in the alternative deceiving witnesses), and conspiring to defeat justice” – where leave to amend those causes of action was previously refused – where the respondent filed a further amended claim and further amended statement of claim seeking damages for causes of action in substantially the same terms that were previously disallowed – whether the claims should be struck out on the basis that their inclusion does not comply with the previous decision in which they were struck out, or because the claims do not involve a cause of action for which private rights of action exist

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – STRIKING OUT – PROCEDURAL MATTERS – where respondent previously sought to bring a claim for malfeasance in public office –…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wood v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Wood v State of Queensland, the plaintiff, Mr Wood, brought a civil action against the State of Queensland, alleging various causes of action arising from his arrest, prosecution, and conviction for criminal offences. The primary dispute centred around the validity and particularity of the claims in Mr Wood's amended statement of claim and the accompanying particulars. Specifically, the Court was tasked with determining whether certain claims should be struck out as they did not disclose a reasonable cause of action or defence, or were scandalous, vexatious, or an abuse of the Court's process. Additionally, the Court had to assess whether the particulars provided by Mr Wood were sufficient in detail to support his claims, particularly in light of previous rulings that had struck out similar claims.

The Court identified several legal issues that needed to be resolved, including whether the claims for malfeasance in public office were sufficiently particularised and whether the particulars provided by Mr Wood complied with the Court's orders and procedural rules. The Court also considered whether the amended claims and particulars disclosed causes of action for which private rights of action exist, and whether the relief sought was excessive or scandalous. The central focus was on ensuring that the proceedings were conducted fairly and efficiently, without unnecessary prejudice, delay, or abuse of the Court’s process.

In delivering the decision, the Court found that several claims and particulars were either scandalous, vexatious, or an abuse of the Court's process. The Court struck out specific references to claims such as fraud, fabrication of evidence, malfeasance in public office, and others, as they did not comply with previous decisions or were not supported by adequate particulars. Additionally, the Court struck out certain parts of the particulars that were either scandalous, went beyond the facts pleaded, or lacked a factual foundation. The Court held that these parts did not meet the required standards of particularity and relevance, and their inclusion would cause unnecessary delay and prejudice in the proceedings.

The Court made orders to strike out the specified claims and particulars from Mr Wood's amended statement of claim and the accompanying particulars. This decision was aimed at ensuring that the case proceeded in a fair and efficient manner, without the inclusion of claims or particulars that did not meet the necessary legal standards. The Court's ruling was intended to maintain the integrity of the judicial process and to prevent the proceedings from being unnecessarily prolonged or prejudiced.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The reference to the following claims are to be struck out of the amended claim and the prayer for relief in the amended statement of claim:

Fraud – $2,500,000.00;

Fabrication of evidence – $250,000,000.00;

Malfeasance in Public Office – $100,000,000.00;

Parasitic damages – $300,000,000.00;

Conspiracy to bring false accusation – $1,000,000,000.00;

Attempting to pervert the course of justice – $500,000,000.00;

Compounding an indictable offence – $1,000,000,000.00;

Official corruption not judicial but relating to offences – $500,000,000.00;

Judicial corruption – $1,000,000,000.00;

Corruption of witnesses (alternatively deceiving witnesses) – $500,000,000.00;

Conspiring to defeat justice – $1,000,000,000.00.

2. The following parts of the document titled “Better and Further Particulars” filed on 3 November 2022 are to be struck out:

Paragraphs 24 and 30;

The words “and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions” in the second sentence of paragraph 31;

The words “Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions”, “unknown officers of the Indooroopilly Police Station” and “Police Prosecutions” in the first sentence of paragraph 37;

The balance of paragraph 37, from the start of the second sentence to the end of the paragraph;

Paragraph 38;

Paragraph 40;

The unnumbered paragraph appearing immediately after paragraph 40;

The paragraph commencing with the heading “Pure Mental Harm – $30,000,000.00”;

The paragraph commencing with the heading “Fraud – $250,000.00”;

The paragraph commencing with the heading “Destruction of Evidence – $25,000,000.00”;

The three unnumbered paragraphs which appear on the last two pages of the document.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I was informed during the hearing of the present application that the matter has been listed for hearing before a jury for three days commencing on 29 July 2024.The amendments made by Mr Wood after the decision of Kelly J On 7 December 2023, Mr Wood filed a further amended claim and a further amended statement of claim,[10] purportedly pursuant to the orders made by Kelly J. [10]Court document 27. The relief sought in the amended claim is as follows:“Aggravated Damages – $300,000,000.00Financial Loss – $500,000.00Malicious Prosecution – $600,000,000.00 Assault – $2,500,000.00 Battery - $10,000,000.00Fraud – $2,500,000.00 Fabrication of evidence – $250,000,000.00 False imprisonment – $100,000,000.00 False Arrest – $150,000,000.00Malfeasance in Public Office – $100,000,000.00 Exemplary damages – $250,000,000.00Parasitic damages – $300,000,000.00Conspiracy to bring false accusation – $1,000,000,000.00Attempting to pervert the course of justice – $500,000,000.00Compounding and [sic] indictable offence – $1,000,000,000.00Official corruption not judicial but relating to offences – $500,000,000.00Judicial corruption – $1,000,000,000.00Corruption of witnesses (alternatively deceiving witnesses) – $500,000,000.00Conspiring to defeat justice – $1,000,000,000.00” The statement of claim was amended to:(a)plead in paragraph 5 that Mr Egan was the person who falsified documents;(b)plead in paragraph 6 that Mr Egan and another police officer named Shane Hancock deleted evidence comprising CCTV footage of the incident which founded the charge of wilful damage;(c)claim damages in the prayer for relief in the same amounts and for the same causes of action as identified in the amended claim (see [19] above). Mr Wood also included the following statement at the end of the amended statement of claim:“This pleading was settled by Ian Andrew Wood of Counsel given it is clear that Mr Wood is substantially more qualified than any corrupt and criminal idiot working in the inappropriately named ‘Justice’ system.” Mr Wood did not amend the Particulars when he filed the amended claim and the amended statement of claim.The scope of the strike out application Although the relief claimed on the present application is expressed in broad terms (see [1] above), the State of Queensland did not ultimately press its application to have the amended statement of claim and the Particulars struck out entirely, or to set aside the amended claim. Instead, the strikeout application was pursued by reference to marked up copies of the amended claim, the amended statement of claim and the Particulars which identified those parts of each document the State of Queensland submitted should be struck out.[11] The State of Queensland expressly acknowledged that it did not seek to strike out causes of action which Mr Wood had earlier pleaded as arising from his arrest and the laying of charges by police.[12] I have approached the application on that basis.[11]Affidavit of Timea Havas (Court document 29) at [5] and exhibits TH-3 (marked up copy of the amended claim), TH-4 (marked up copy of the amended statement of claim) and TH-5 (marked up copy of the Particulars).[12]Transcript 1-3:46 to 1-4:1.A preliminary point

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established