WLT v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

CHILDRENS COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

WLT v Director of Public Prosecutions [2025] QChC 12

PARTIES:

WLT

(applicant)

v

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

(respondent)

FILE NO:

CCJ194/25

DIVISION:

Childrens Court of Queensland

PROCEEDING:

Sentence Review Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Townsville Childrens Court

DELIVERED ON:

19 September 2025

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

9 September 2025

JUDGE:

Dearden DCJ

ORDER:

1.   Application for sentence review granted.

2.   Set aside all sentences imposed at the Townsville Childrens Court on 19 June 2025.

3.   Substitute an order that the applicant be placed on probation for a period of nine months in respect of all offences for which the applicant was sentenced at the Townsville Childrens Court on 19 June 2025.

4.   Convictions are not recorded.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – SENTENCE – SENTENCING JUVENILES – OTHER MATTERS – where the applicant was sentenced to various sentences at the Childrens Court at Townsville including a nine-month detention in respect of the offence of attempt to enter dwelling with intent by break, at night, in company – where the applicant submitted that the sentence was manifestly excessive in all the circumstances – whether the sentencing magistrate fell into error by concluding that an attempted offence, other than those enumerated in s.175A(1) was a significant offence under s.175A of the Youth Justice Act 1992 (Qld)

LEGISLATION:

Criminal Code 1899 (Qld) s 419

Youth Justice Act 1992 (Qld) s118, s122, s 150, s 175A

Making Queensland Safer Act 2024 (Qld) Part 4

Making Queensland Safer (Adult Crime, Adult Time) Amendment Act 2025 (Qld)

CASES:

ERG v Director of Public Prosecutions [2023] QChC 38

R v CDV [2025] QCA 163

HZK v Director of Public Prosecutions [2025] QChC 11

Queensland Police Service v Terare [2014] QCA 260

R v TC [2025] QChC 8

COUNSEL:

L Millar (sol) for the applicant

S De Geest (sol) for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Legal Aid Queensland for the applicant

Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent

Introduction

  1. This is an application for sentence review filed 5 August 2025 in respect of the following offences:-

Date of Offence

Place of Offence

Offence

20/12/2024

Townsville City

Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking.

17/01/2025

Garbutt

Breach of bail condition

16/01/2025

Garbutt

Breach of bail condition

24/02/2025

Garbutt

Breach of bail condition

13/04/2025

Aitkenvale

Unlawful use of motor vehicles, aircraft or vessels - use

13/04/2025

Aitkenvale

Stealing

13/04/2025

Aitkenvale

Driving of motor vehicle without a driver licence, never held a licence

14/04/2025

Aitkenvale

Stealing

14/04/2025

Aitkenvale

Driving of motor vehicle without a driver licence, never held a licence

16/04/2025

Garbutt

Unlawful use of motor vehicles, aircraft or vessel – used on the night

16/04/2025

Garbutt

Stealing

17/04/2025

Wulguru

Attempt to enter dwelling with intent by break at night in company

17/04/2025

Wulguru

Enter premises and commit indictable offence

17/04/2025

Wulguru

Breach of bail condition

16/04/2025

Garbutt

Breach of bail condition

14/04/2025

Garbutt

Breach of bail condition

14/04/2025

West End

Unlawful use of motor vehicles, aircraft or vessels - use

14/04/2025

West End

Attempted stealing

14/04/2025

West…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read WLT v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QChC 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of WLT v Director of Public Prosecutions involved an appeal against a sentence imposed on WLT by the Children's Court at Townsville. WLT was sentenced to a nine-month detention term for the offence of attempting to enter a dwelling with intent by break, at night, in company. WLT challenged the sentence on the grounds that it was manifestly excessive and that the sentencing magistrate erred in treating the attempted offence as a significant offence under the Youth Justice Act 1992 (Qld).

The court had to decide whether the sentencing magistrate correctly interpreted the law concerning the significance of attempted offences and whether the sentence imposed was appropriate given the mitigating factors presented. The applicant argued that the magistrate did not sufficiently consider the mitigating factors, including WLT's age, his Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander background, his prior good conduct on probation, and the impact of his severe traumatic brain injury. The respondent contended that the magistrate appropriately balanced the legislative changes, the increased maximum penalties, and the community's expectations with respect to this type of offending.

The court found that the sentencing magistrate erred in placing excessive weight on the impact on the victims without sufficient evidence and in failing to adequately consider the mitigating factors. The court concluded that the sentence was manifestly excessive and reheard the matter on the merits. The court substituted a sentence of probation for nine months and ordered that the convictions not be recorded.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application for sentence review granted.

2. Set aside all sentences imposed at the Townsville Childrens Court on 19 June 2025.

3. Substitute an order that the applicant be placed on probation for a period of nine months in respect of all offences for which the applicant was sentenced at the Townsville Childrens Court on 19 June 2025.

4. Convictions are not recorded.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondent submitted further that it was open to the learned magistrate to draw an inference in respect of the victim’s harm, although no victim impact statements had been placed before the court, and that in doing so, the sentence was not skewed.[21][21]Exhibit 3 – Outline of Submissions on behalf of the respondent [24]-[25].Conclusion As identified above, although it is not necessary to show error in respect of an application for sentence review, I am satisfied that error has been demonstrated. It is now the task of the court to impose a sentence, proceeding to rehear the matter on the merits in accordance with the approach set out at R v CDV [2025] QCA 163, [42]-[47] and to undertake “a fresh exercise of the sentencing discretion.”[22][22]R v CDV [2025] QCA 163, [48]. The applicant identifies the following mitigating factors as being relevant:“(a)the offences were relatively – lower end of the scale of seriousness for offences of their nature – no person was harmed and no person was physically endangered;(b)WLT was 16 years of age and identified as Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander;(c)WLT was not subject to any supervised orders at the time of the offences;(d)he has performed well on probation in the past;(e)WLT would reside with his mother and two siblings at the family home at 18 Ramsay Street, Garbutt upon his release;(f)he had spent 58 days on remand in pre-sentence custody;(g)WLT had advised that he intended to get support from Queensland Health following his release, in relation to undertaking further testing to determine his functioning level post-injury, relating to his severe traumatic brain injury;(h)the author of the presentence report, noted that WLT’s early exposure to adverse experiences, including domestic and family violence had resulted in WLT being vulnerable to utilising mal adapted behaviours to which he has been consistently exposed to, and aligned to his involvement in criminal behaviour. The author further assessed that WLT’s negative peer associates serve as a contributing factor to the offences before the court;(i)WLT accepted the facts of the offences and was able to identify who would have been harmed in the commission of the offences. He was able to identify emotional impacts on the victim.(j)WLT noted that the offending was dumb and indicated that his actions were wrong;(k)WLT had no plans on re-engaging with his peers [with] whom he committed the offences. The applicant also identifies the period of 58 days of presentence custody (approximately two months), and the applicant’s limited criminal history at the time of the sentence as relevant factors in mitigation. In addition, the applicant points to the lack of weight attributed by the learned magistrate to the pre-sentence custody, and the decision to impose the maximum possible period of a conditional release order (six months), which would mean that for a nine month detention order, of which almost two months had been already served, the applicant was placed on a conditional release order for six of the seven months’ balance of the detention order. It is clear in those circumstances that the learned magistrate has failed to place appropriate weight on the presentence custody and has failed to give appropriate weight to the applicant’s mitigating circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In R v TC [2025] QChC 8, [34] Richards DCJ stated:“The magistrate placed heavy reliance on the principle that detention was no longer a sentence of last resort and therefore adults were in a better position than children under the new laws. That is an incorrect analysis of the Act; the Youth Justice principles still rely heavily on rehabilitation and other factors in mitigation [Youth Justice Act 1992 (Qld) Sch 1]. The new laws require a balancing of those factors against the primary regard of the impact on the victims in arriving at an appropriate sentence for the offending. … although detention is no longer a sentence of last resort, it is not a sentence of first resort. A consideration of the appropriate sentence involves a synthesis of all the factors relevant to the particular child to be sentenced.” [emphasis added]. The applicant submits, correctly, that there is very little evidence of the impact of the applicant’s offending on the victims in this matter, yet the learned magistrate placed significant weight on the impact to the victims and (in the absence of any victim impact statements) drew an inference that the victims would have suffered stress and trauma. The applicant’s submission is that the learned magistrate’s reliance on the impact on the victims has inappropriately skewed the sentence. During the course of the learned magistrate’s sentencing remarks, the following comments were made, in reference to the Making Queensland Safer Act amendments:“Now the court has to have its focus on the impact of these crimes on victims, which – even though I don’t have victim impact statements here – I think the court can act upon the basis that these sorts of offences cause not only damage – people lose their property – but it causes them trauma and stress.”[18] And further:-“I have had primary regard to the impact of the offences on the victims and consider – given the facts – that the only reasonable inference is that they would have suffered stress and trauma.”[19][18]Exhibit 2 – Affidavit of Lana Millar affirmed 8 September 2025, Exhibit LTM2, T1-2, ll 29-32.[19]Exhibit 2 – Affidavit of Lana Millar affirmed 8 September 2025, Exhibit LM2, T1-3, ll 16-18. The respondent, on the other hand, submits that the learned magistrate appropriately placed weight upon the increased maximum penalties available, given the legislative changes, and explicitly took account of Parliament’s intention to change the law through the increased maximum penalty and the expectation placed upon the courts in response to the view of the community with respect to this type of offending.[20][20]Exhibit 3 – Outline of Submissions on behalf of the respondent [23]. The respondent submitted further that it was open to the learned magistrate to draw an inference in respect of the victim’s harm, although no victim impact statements had been placed before the court, and that in doing so, the sentence was not skewed.[21][21]Exhibit 3 – Outline of Submissions on behalf of the respondent [24]-[25].Conclusion