Winzar and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Winzar and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2016] AATA 238 (14 April 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2014/4792

Re

Kaye Winzar

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date 14 April 2016
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.................................[sgd].......................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

COMPENSATION – Workers’ Compensation – claim for left foot plantar spur – evolving diagnosis – left plantar fasciitis – surgery following reviewable decision resulting in deep vein thrombosis and chronic pain syndrome – resulting incapacity due to surgical treatment – decision affirmed.

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988

Cases                 

Abrahams v Comcare (2006) 93 ALD 147

Australian Postal Corporation v Bessey (2001) 32 AAR 508

Commonwealth v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369
Comcare v Lofts (2013) 137 ALD 522
Federal Broom Company Pty Ltd v Semlitch 110 CLR 626

Hannaford v Telstra Corporation Limited (2005) 88 ALD 702

Tippett v Australian Postal Corporation (1998) 27 AAR 40

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

14 April 2016

  1. Ms Winzar lodged a claim for Workers’ Compensation on 18 September 2013 for the condition of plantar spur of left foot. Ms Winzar attributed the condition to prolonged standing while sorting mail and parcels in the course of her permanent part time employment with Australia Post. 

  2. The parties agree that the correct diagnosis of Ms Winzar’s medical condition is left plantar fasciitis and that this is a disease as defined in s 5B of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act).

  3. By determination dated 7 March 2014 Australia Post denied liability for this disease as being significantly contributed to by employment, based on the opinion of Mr Ian Jones, a specialist orthopaedic surgeon. 

  4. Ms Winzar requested reconsideration of the determination by an undated letter received by Australia Post on 23 July 2014.  Following further consideration of all medical reports, the determination was affirmed. Ms Winzar was advised of this decision on 28 July 2014.  This decision is the reviewable decision.

  5. On 16 September 2014, Ms Winzar lodged an application for review with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. 

  6. At the hearing Ms Winzar was represented by Mr Mark Carey of counsel, instructed by Maurice Blackburn Lawyers. The respondent was represented by Mr Roy Seit of counsel, instructed by Australia Post investigation officer Ms Carmel Sassani.  The Tribunal was provided with the T-documents lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administration Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. Both parties tendered further documentary evidence, a list of which is appended to this decision.  Ms Winzar, Mr Ian Jones and Mr M A Khan gave evidence before the Tribunal. 

  7. At the commencement of the hearing, both members of counsel made submissions regarding the jurisdiction of the Tribunal as attracted by the reviewable decision of 28 July 2014. It was agreed that the only issue to be determined was the liability, if any, of Australia Post under s 14 of the SRC Act. This Act provides for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Winzar and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 238
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties in this case are Ms Kaye Winzar, the appellant, and the Australian Postal Corporation, the respondent. The dispute concerns Ms Winzar's entitlement to workers' compensation for an alleged work-related injury to her left heel, which subsequently led to complications following a surgical procedure. The case was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The primary legal issue before the court was whether Ms Winzar's left plantar fasciitis, which developed after she reported pain in her left heel, constituted a significant degree of aggravation of a pre-existing injury that would render the Australian Postal Corporation liable for workers' compensation under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). The court had to determine if there was a causal link between Ms Winzar's work activities and her left plantar fasciitis, and if the injury was significantly aggravated by her employment.

The court found that Ms Winzar's left plantar fasciitis was not a significant aggravation of a pre-existing injury. It held that her initial right ankle injury and subsequent right plantar fasciitis were separate and distinct from her left heel pain and left plantar fasciitis. The court also noted that Ms Winzar's left heel pain was first reported in March 2013, and her condition was diagnosed as left plantar fasciitis by her general practitioner. The court rejected the respondent's argument that Ms Winzar's incapacity for work should be considered during the period under review, instead focusing on the medical evidence and the nature of the injuries. The court concluded that there was no significant degree of aggravation of a pre-existing injury, and therefore, the Australian Postal Corporation was not liable for workers' compensation under section 14.

In light of the findings, the court dismissed Ms Winzar's claim for workers' compensation. The respondent was not held liable for any compensation related to Ms Winzar's left plantar fasciitis and the subsequent complications following her surgery.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Significant degree is defined as substantially more than material. Based on authority, it was determined that the Tribunal’s jurisdiction was limited to the initial injury as the surgical treatment was not undertaken until November 2014, months after the reviewable decision was made (Abrahams v Comcare (2006) 93 ALD 147).BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION Ms Winzar commenced working for Australia Post on a casual basis in 2003 and became a permanent part time employee in February 2005. She initially worked five hours per shift, five days a week. This increased to six hours per shift at an unknown date. During certain times of the year, in particular around Christmas, she sometimes worked full time hours for three to four weeks. In September 2005, Ms Winzar suffered a right ankle injury at work and, after two days off work, resumed with light duties. These light duties involved rotating her tasks so that approximately half of each shift would be conducted seated and the other half would require her to stand. Investigations of the right ankle, including radiological imaging and CT scanning, failed to reveal any abnormality. Ms Winzar was provided with special boots and ankle support. A Workers’ Compensation claim was filed at the time of this injury. On 8 July 2008, Ms Winzar was diagnosed as having right plantar fasciitis, following complaints of pain in the sole of her foot. This was treated with moderate analgesics in the form of Panadeine-Forte. Ms Winzar’s general practitioner Dr E Botros’ notes contain entries relating to the progress of Ms Winzar’s right plantar fasciitis, which appears to have resolved completely by 27 May 2009. While Ms Winzar remained on restricted duties with respect to her right ankle she continued to work her normal hours with restricted standing times. On occasions when there was a staff shortage, these restrictions were not strictly followed. On 13 March 2013, Ms Winzar complained to Dr Botros about pain in her left heel and a diagnosis of left plantar fasciitis was made. A Victorian WorkCover Certificate was completed by Dr Botros limiting Ms Winzar to modified duties from 13 March to 26 March 2013. These modified duties were: no standing for more than an hour at a time with at least 30 minutes sitting down in between. The respondent denied receiving this certificate in March 2013. Ms Winzar continued to work and did not report any new injuries until 12 July 2013, when an incident report form was completed stating the date of onset of left heel pain as 12 July 2013 and as having resulted from what was described as a heel spur unrelated to any previous incidents. On 22 July 2013, the facility nominated doctor, Dr Mohamad Ali, certified Ms Winzar as fit only to perform her mail sorting tasks while sitting. The diagnosis he provided was that of a plantar spur of the left foot. The restrictions were changed on 9 September 2013; the only restriction being that Ms Winzar was not to work on the sorting machines or processing parcels.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Following the surgical procedure, Ms Winzar developed left peroneal and posterior tibial deep venous thromboses with swelling and discomfort in the left lower limb and the development of a chronic regional pain syndrome. Both of these conditions have required further treatment and have resulted in Ms Winzar being incapacitated for any form of work. She last worked on 4 November 2014, the day before her surgical procedure. EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALMs Kaye Winzar Ms Winzar provided a statement dated 2 December 2015 outlining the development of her left plantar fasciitis, its treatment and the complications that occurred following her surgery on 5 November 2014. She also made reference to her right ankle injury, resulting from a direct blow to the lateral aspect of her ankle at work, on 11 September 2005 and her return to work after two days to a light duties program. Ms Winzar acknowledged that her medical records had shown she had been diagnosed with right plantar fasciitis in July 2008, but has stated that her right foot and calf pain had all resolved by early 2009 and that in 2010 she was able to resume full normal duties. She agreed that she had first reported pain in her left foot, subsequently diagnosed as left plantar fasciitis, in March 2013. On 31 July 2013, Ms Winzar underwent x-rays of both feet and was advised that these showed a plantar calcaneal spur on the left heel. Following this, she underwent ultrasound guided injections with varying benefit and continued to work her normal shifts. Ms Winzar estimated that during her six hour shifts she would spend three and a half to four and a quarter hours each night on her feet. On Friday nights, she estimated she would usually spend the entire six hours on her feet. Ms Winzar described the floor on which she worked as being concrete but covered in some parts with what is called anti-fatigue matting. She said most of the anti-fatigue matting was well worn and had not been replaced for at least 10 years. In her evidence to the Tribunal, Ms Winzar confirmed that she had ceased work on 4 November 2014, had undergone the surgery as previously described and, in the post-operative phase, developed a deep vein thrombosis with marked swelling of her ankle and foot and associated severe pain in the foot and calf. These symptoms have persisted and the pain levels have increased, interfering with her sleep. The pain is more severe when she stands and she is now unable to put her foot to the ground. She uses elbow height crutches or a wheelchair to mobilise. Ms Winzar noted an improvement in the left plantar fasciitis in July 2013 when she had annual leave. In cross-examination, Ms Winzar agreed that most of her working life had involved standing for long periods of time, she having worked in her late teens in a supermarket, then at Coles from 1993 to 1994 as a checkout operator. After the birth of her children she had done a variety of jobs on a part time basis, much of which was conducted from home. She confirmed that she became a permanent employee of the respondent in February 2005, but was unable to provide a date as to when her shifts increased from five hours to six hours per day.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In response, Mr Carey distinguished the High Court decision in Federal Broom Company Pty Ltd v Semlitch as it related to a psychiatric condition. Mr Carey reiterated his earlier contention that the Tribunal must look at Ms Winzar’s incapacity for work during the period under review. TRIBUNAL’S DELIBERATIONS The parties and the Tribunal agree that s 14 liability is the only matter under consideration and that the medical condition is and always has been left plantar fasciitis, not a left heel spur as described in Ms Winzar’s claim form (Hannaford v Telstra Corporation Limited (2005) 88 ALD 702). Of foremost importance in this matter is the medical evidence. Ms Winzar had well documented right plantar fasciitis which persisted for a period of 11 months in 2008 and 2009, required predominantly analgesia. The right plantar fasciitis did not impact in any way on her capacity for work. This condition was diagnosed by her general practitioner Dr Botros. On 13 March 2013 Ms Winzar again presented to Dr Botros, this time with pain in her left heel. Dr Botros made a diagnosis of plantar fasciitis and provided a Victorian WorkCover certificate restricting Ms Winzar’s work activities for a period of two weeks. There are no further references to left heel pain in Dr Botros’ records until mid-September 2013, when Dr Botros records having a lengthy discussion with Ms Winzar regarding her left plantar fasciitis and recommended she attend a podiatrist. Shortly after her incident report was filed with the employer on 12 July 2013, Ms Winzar was seen by Dr Ali of the Breen Street Clinic in Bendigo, he being the facility nominated doctor. In his initial certification of 22 July 2013, Dr Ali described her condition as being caused by standing on her feet at least six hours per day and instituted restrictions on her standing time. Dr Ali also arranged for Ms Winzar to have imaging performed. On 26 August 2013, following the imaging, he provided another certificate in which the diagnosis was plantar spur left foot. The restrictions on this occasion were that she was not to work on sorting machines or with parcels. The same diagnosis was proffered in the report of 9 September 2013 and the restrictions remained unchanged. The first mention of any heel problems given to doctors at the Tristar clinic in Epsom was the entry of 13 November 2013 and the Tribunal believes this is the first time Ms Winzar was seen in this clinic for her left plantar fasciitis. On that date she stated that she had undergone cortisone injections into her plantar fascia and required analgesia for which she was prescribed Panadeine Forte. The entry of 31 March 2014 states that Ms Winzar had further plantar cortisone injections. The entry of 29 April 2014 recorded that her last cortisone injection had resulted in pain, preventing her from working on 28 and 29 April 2014. She attended in order obtain a medical certificate. It appears that Ms Winzar has attended the Bendigo Primary Care Medical Clinic since 22 December 2014. This was shortly after her surgical procedure of plantar fascia release and she provided information regarding the development of a deep vein thrombosis shortly after her operation, resulting in persistent swelling of the left foot. An ultrasound examination of the left foot on 31 December 2014 revealed the left plantar fascia to be intact. Apparently Ms Winzar had been prescribed Xarelto, an anticoagulant, 20 milligrams daily because of the deep vein thrombosis. She had stopped taking it after one week as she experienced bleeding.