Wilson and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

[2014] AATA  188

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/1441

Re

Thomas Wilson

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member A K Britton

Date 4 April 2014
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

........................................................................

Senior Member A K Britton

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION — Visa cancelation — Protection of the Australian community — Seriousness of offending behaviour —Whether Tribunal can go behind facts of conviction — Risk of recidivism—Strength, duration and nature of ties to the Australian community—Best interests of minor children—Impact of cancelling visa on immediate family—Decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – s 35;
Crimes (Administration of Sentences) Regulation 2008 (NSW) – reg 22; 24;
Direction No. 55, Migration Act 1958, Direction under section 499, Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501— cl 6.1; 6.2; 6.3; 7(1); 8(1); 8(4); 9.1; 9.1.1; 9.1.2; 9.2; 9.3; 10(1)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – ss 499(2A); 500(6J); 501(2); 501(7)(c);

CASES

Goldie v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1318
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Ali [2000] FCA 1385
R v Wilson (Unreported, Supreme Court  of New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal, Sully, Abadee and Dunford JJ, 18 December 1997)
R v Wilson (unreported, District Court of New South Wales, Coleman DCJ, 28 May 1998)
Re Poto and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] AATA 311
Re Visa Cancellation Applicant and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] AATA 690
Wilson v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 1421

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A K Britton

4 April 2014

  1. New Zealand citizen, Mr Thomas Wilson, seeks review of the decision made in March 2012 by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to cancel his subclass 444 Special Category (temporary) visa. The stated reason for that decision was that Mr Wilson posed an unacceptable risk to the Australian community on account of his criminal history, which included convictions for maliciously inflicting grievous bodily harm and escaping from lawful custody.

  2. It is agreed that the power to cancel Mr Wilson’s visa may be exercised because he does not pass the “character test” on account of having a “substantial criminal record” (ss 501(2), 501(7)(c) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Migration Act)). The central question to be decided is whether that power should be exercised in this case. In making that decision, “Direction No. 55, Migration Act 1958, Direction under section 499, Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501” (the Direction), must be taken into account (s 499(2A)).

  3. Mr Wilson contends that the power to cancel his visa should not be exercised because, among other things, he does not pose a risk to the Australian community and furthermore it is in the best interests of his wife and children that he be permitted to live in Australia. The Minister urges the Tribunal to affirm the decision to cancel Mr Wilson’s visa, and contends that he poses an unacceptable risk to the Australian…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wilson and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 188
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Wilson and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the primary issue before the court was whether the Tribunal could consider evidence that challenges the facts of a conviction when determining if a visa should be cancelled. Mr Wilson, who had a history of serious criminal offences, argued that he did not commit the index offence for which he was convicted. The court examined whether the Tribunal could go behind the facts of the conviction and what weight should be given to Mr Wilson's claims of innocence and his efforts to overturn the conviction. The Minister argued that the Tribunal should not consider such evidence and that Mr Wilson's substantial criminal record justified cancelling his visa.

The court found that while a conviction is strong evidence of the facts upon which it is based, there is no absolute rule preventing the Tribunal from considering material that challenges the grounds of a prior conviction. However, the onus of proof lies heavily on the party seeking to persuade the Tribunal to accept facts other than those on which the convicting court relied. Given Mr Wilson's conviction followed a contested hearing and was upheld on appeal, the Tribunal was not persuaded that he was wrongfully convicted. The Tribunal concluded that Mr Wilson's criminal conduct was serious, and there was a risk he would re-offend, warranting the cancellation of his visa.

The court affirmed the Tribunal's decision to cancel Mr Wilson's visa, noting that even though Mr Wilson was no longer in Australia, he was still entitled to seek review of the decision. The court found that Mr Wilson's arguments about his non-risk status and the impact on his family did not outweigh the seriousness of his criminal history and the risk he posed to the community. The outcome affirmed the visa cancellation, and Mr Wilson would need to apply for a new visa if he wished to return to Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In 2001 while in custody Mr Wilson was convicted of the offence “malicious destroy property”. He was given a two-year custodial sentence to be served concurrently. There is little information about that offence in the available material. A report dated 14 September 2007 prepared by Lithgow Correctional Centre manager, Joy Kirby, suggests that the offence was more serious than the description given by Mr Wilson in these proceedings. Ms Kirby wrote that it involved “hinges on a cell door being cut through and a hacksaw blade being found in the cell”. Can the tribunal go behind the facts of the conviction? Mr Wilson submits that in assessing the seriousness of the index offence, it is open to the Tribunal to go behind the facts of his conviction and find, as he claims, that he did not commit the offence. The Minister disagrees. Mr Wilson has maintained his innocence since his arrest for the index offence. He now admits to some involvement in the offence, namely providing information about the victim and her movements, to the people who orchestrated the assault. In these proceedings Mr Wilson testified that those responsible for the assault were part of the criminal underworld and had he disclosed at his trial what he knew about the offence, his family would have been at risk. He claims that it was only on learning of the death of the surviving member of the group that was he was in a position to admit to any knowledge of, or involvement in, the offence. In these proceedings Mr Wilson stated that he has taken steps to have his conviction for the index offence overturned. In a letter to the Tribunal dated 5 September 2013, seeking an adjournment of these proceedings, Mr Wilson’s solicitors advised that Mr Wilson is obtaining legal assistance (through other solicitors) to overturn that conviction and Mr Wilson understands that that action will be taken within the next eight to ten months. In Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Ali [2000] FCA 1385; (2000) 106 FCR 313, Branson J stated at [43] that while proof of a conviction is highly probative of the factual matters upon which a conviction is based there was “no absolute rule that the tribunal may not consider material which challenges the grounds on which a prior conviction was based”. Her Honour stated that a conviction is strong prima facie evidence that the facts found by the court were found correctly. This places a “heavy onus”, as Her Honour put it at [43], on a party seeking to persuade the Tribunal to accept facts other than those upon which the convicting court relied. Her Honour observed at [43] that this heavy onus:[W]ill, as a matter of logic, be more easily satisfied where the criminal conviction and sentence followed a plea of guilty than where the conviction and sentence follow a contested factual hearing. Her Honour observed that people may on occasion plead guilty when a defence may have been available to them. This however is not such an example. Mr Wilson was found guilty by a jury after a contested hearing where he was legally represented. That conviction was upheld on appeal. The new evidence on which he now relies in support of his claim that he was wrongly convicted is: (i) the evidence he gave in these proceedings claiming that the perpetrator(s) of the index offence was part of the criminal underworld and his explanation for not disclosing that information at trial, and (ii) the evidence of steps taken to have the conviction overturned.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Wilson claims he has no intention of re-offending or doing anything that would jeopardise his relationship with his family who mean everything to him and have stood by him over the past two decades: “I won’t even cross the road unless the lights are right”. Ms Wilson shares her husband’s confidence that he will not re-offend.Findings and conclusions The primary consideration — “protection of the Australian community” — requires an evaluation of the nature and seriousness of Mr Wilson’s conduct and the risk to the Australian community should he re-offend. The Direction emphasises the Government’s commitment “to protecting the Australian community from harm as a result of criminal activity … by non-citizens” and states that a non-citizen who has committed a serious offence should generally expect to forfeit the privilege of staying in Australia (para 6.3(3)). While Mr Wilson denies having committed the index offence, he accepts that the role to which he admits was serious in nature. He also concedes that the other offences for which he was convicted were serious in nature. The conduct for which Mr Wilson was convicted — a brutal, premeditated and unprovoked attack on a young woman — was plainly of a serious nature. His other violent offences, in particular those relating to the assault of prison officers, while not as serious were nonetheless serious. The lengthy custodial sentence given to Mr Wilson — a total of 34 years, the longest being for 18 years — points to the objective seriousness of his conduct. While no argument that Mr Wilson’s conduct was serious in nature the parties disagree about the risk he poses to the Australian community. The Direction instructs (at para 9.1.2(1)) that in making that risk assessment, decision-makers must have regard to, cumulatively:(a)The nature of the harm to individuals or the Australian community should the person engage in further criminal or other serious conduct; and(b)The likelihood of the person engaging in further criminal or other serious conduct ... There can be no argument that if Mr Wilson were to engage in criminal conduct of the type previously committed, the harm that would be suffered by any victim would be significant. The injuries sustained by the victim of the index offence and the prison officers assaulted during the 1996 escape, bear this out. The only significant issue in dispute is the likelihood of Mr Wilson re-offending. Mr Wilson submits that he poses no risk; the Minister on the other hand, contends that he poses a moderate to high risk. In support of his submission that he does not pose a risk of re-offending, Mr Wilson points to: the passage of close to two decades since he committed his last violent offence; his remorse for his criminal conduct; the reports that he has matured throughout his long period on incarceration; the rehabilitation treatment he has undertaken, most significantly through the VOTP, and the favourable reports about his participation in those programs; his devotion to his family and his recognition that if he were to re-offend his relationship with them would be jeopardised; his good conduct over the past two and a half years spent in the community in New Zealand.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is agreed that the power to cancel Mr Wilson’s visa may be exercised because he does not pass the “character test” on account of having a “substantial criminal record” (ss 501(2), 501(7)(c) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Migration Act)). The central question to be decided is whether that power should be exercised in this case. In making that decision, “Direction No. 55, Migration Act 1958, Direction under section 499, Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501” (the Direction), must be taken into account (s 499(2A)). Mr Wilson contends that the power to cancel his visa should not be exercised because, among other things, he does not pose a risk to the Australian community and furthermore it is in the best interests of his wife and children that he be permitted to live in Australia. The Minister urges the Tribunal to affirm the decision to cancel Mr Wilson’s visa, and contends that he poses an unacceptable risk to the Australian community. In December 2012 the Tribunal (differently constituted) decided that it was without power to review the decision to cancel Mr Wilson’s visa because his application for review was not lodged within the time period prescribed by the Migration Act. On appeal to the Federal Court, that decision was set aside (Wilson v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 1421). After that decision was handed down, Mr Wilson decided to return to New Zealand, on his account, because he was denied access to appropriate medical treatment for his heart condition in immigration detention and was keen to be reunited with his family. Because Mr Wilson is no longer in Australia, even if his current application were to be successful he will not automatically be entitled to return and must apply for a new visa. While the Minister contends that in these circumstances the current application is of little utility, he does not dispute that Mr Wilson is entitled to seek review of the cancellation decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. Underpinning the Direction is the assumption that if the power conferred by s 501 — to cancel the visa held by a person with a substantial criminal record — is not exercised; the person will remain in Australia. The Direction provides no guidance on the approach to be taken in the circumstances of this case where the visa holder has left Australia and even if the decision to cancel their visa is set aside, will not necessarily be permitted to return. In applying the Direction I have taken the approach of assuming that Mr Wilson would return to Australia. For example in assessing, as required by the Direction, Mr Wilson’s risk of re-offending, I have assumed that he would be present in Australia. Exercising the discretion to cancel the visa The objectives together with other parts of the Direction provide a framework within which the task of deciding whether to exercise the discretion to cancel a person’s visa must be exercised. They state:6.1 Objectives1The objective of the Act is to regulate, in the national interest, the coming into, and presence in, Australia of non-citizens.2Under section 501 of the Act, a person may be refused a visa if the person does not satisfy the decision-maker that they pass the character test. A person may have their visa cancelled if the decision-maker reasonably suspects that the person does not pass the character test, and the person does not satisfy the decision-maker that they pass the character test. Where the discretion to refuse to grant or to cancel a visa is enlivened, the decision-maker must consider whether to exercise the discretion to refuse or cancel the visa given the specific circumstances of the case.3The purpose of this Direction is to guide decision-makers performing functions or exercising powers under section 501 of the Act to refuse to grant a visa to, or to cancel the visa of, a person who does not satisfy the Minister that the person passes the character test. Under section 499(2A) of the Act, such decision-makers must comply with a direction made under section 499.