Willmot v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Willmot v State of Queensland [2023] QCA 102

PARTIES:

JOANNE EDITH WILLMOT
(appellant)
v
STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 11247 of 2022
SC No 6251 of 2020

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2022] QSC 167 (Bowskill CJ)

DELIVERED ON:

16 May 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20 March 2023

JUDGES:

Mullins P and Gotterson AJA and Boddice AJA

ORDERS:

1.   Appeal dismissed.

2.    The appellant is to pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS: JURISDICTION, POWERS AND GENERALLY – INHERENT AND GENERAL STATUTORY POWERS – TO STAY OR DISMISS ORDERS OR PROCEEDINGS GENERALLY – where the appellant sought damages from the State for negligence in failing to properly monitor and supervise her and those into whose care she was placed while she was a State Child as defined in the State Children Act 1911 (Qld) – where the appellant’s claim was permanently stayed because the consequences of the passage of time since the alleged events occurred meant that a fair trial was not possible – where primacy is not accorded to the absence of a limitation period over the discretion to stay permanently, or vice versa – where it was unnecessary to resolve the question whether the rule in House v The King is applicable to appellate review of an exercise of the discretion to permanently stay a proceeding – where there was an absence of means by which the State could investigate, lead evidence or cross-examine about the foundational facts underlying the foundational allegations because the relevant persons (except NW) are deceased – where the appellant submitted that the learned primary judge erred in treating the absence of “foundational witnesses” as being determinative – where the appellant submitted that it was against the evidence for the learned primary judge to find that it would be “insurmountably difficult” to extricate the impact of the alleged assault by NW from the impacts of the alleged mistreatment by other persons – where the appellant submitted that the learned primary judge failed to acknowledge that the evidence which the appellant’s former foster sibling would give forms a basis for the State to investigate and substantiate the foundational allegations – whether the learned primary judge erred in exercising the discretion to permanently stay the proceedings

Aboriginals Protection and Restriction of the Sale of Opium Act 1897 (Qld), s 9
Limitation of Actions Act 1974 (Qld), s 11A
State Children Act 1911 (Qld), s 10, s 11, s 61

Batistatos v Roads and Traffic Authority (NSW) (2006) 226 CLR 256; [2006] HCA 27, cited
Chalmers v Leslie (2020) 6 QR 547; [2020] QSC 343, cited
GLJ v The Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Lismore [2022] HCATrans 206, cited
GMB v UnitingCare West [2020] WADC 165, cited
Gorman v McKnight
[2020] NSWCA 20, cited

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Willmot v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCA 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Willmot v State of Queensland, the appellant sought damages from the State for negligence in failing to properly monitor and supervise her while she was a State Child under the State Children Act 1911 (Qld). The primary judge had permanently stayed the appellant's claim on the grounds that the consequences of the passage of time since the alleged events occurred made a fair trial impossible. The appellant argued that the primary judge erred in treating the absence of foundational witnesses as determinative and in finding it insurmountably difficult to separate the impact of the alleged assault by NW from the impacts of the alleged mistreatment by other persons. The court had to decide whether the primary judge was correct in exercising the discretion to permanently stay the proceedings.

The court held that the primary judge was not required to resolve whether the rule in House v The King applies to appellate review of an exercise of the discretion to permanently stay a proceeding. The court found that the primary judge was entitled to conclude that it would be insurmountably difficult for the State to investigate, lead evidence or cross-examine about the foundational facts underlying the foundational allegations because the relevant persons, except NW, were deceased. The court also held that the primary judge was not required to consider whether the appellant's former foster sibling's evidence formed a basis for the State to investigate and substantiate the foundational allegations.

The court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the appellant is to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal on the standard basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. The appellant is to pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Objection to some of the evidence relied on by Ms Willmot: The learned primary judge ruled on an objection by the State to the admissibility of the affidavits of the four deponents who had also lived and worked at the Girls’ Dormitory. Her Honour admitted the affidavits of Ms Nielsen and Ms Watson as relevant to the adequacy of the system of monitoring and supervising children in the dormitories.[24] She summarised their evidence as follows:“[18] Two of these witnesses (Joan Nielsen, Aileen Watson) also describe being subject to, and witnessing, physical abuse at the Cherbourg dormitories, at the hands of Maude Phillips. Aileen Watson describes Maude Phillips as a “nasty woman” who hit her, and others, with a “switch” (a tree branch), among other harsh punishments. Joan Nielsen also refers to an incident of what she describes as sexual abuse, which involved Maude Phillips making a group of girls pull up their dresses and pull down their pants to expose their genital areas; and an occasion on which she says she was denied medical treatment. Aileen Watson also describes being sexually abused whilst at Cherbourg, on two separate occasions, both involving teenage boys who lived in the boys’ dormitory.”[24]Reasons [24]. Her Honour was also minded to admit Ms Collins’ affidavit evidence to the extent that some parts of it might have been relevant to the issue of the “system”.[25][25]Ibid. Allegations of sexual abuse when visiting grandmother: As to these allegations, the learned primary judge observed:“[25] The plaintiff also alleges that she suffered sexual abuse on two further occasions. Both occurred when she visited her grandmother’s house in Ipswich. On the first occasion, which the plaintiff says was when she was about 6 years old (so approximately 1960), she alleges she was sexually assaulted by her mother’s brother, Uncle NW, who was then about 15 or 16.[26] The plaintiff says Uncle NW suddenly grabbed her, took her into the grandmother’s bedroom, and forcefully threw her onto the bed. He removed her underwear, and lay on top of her attempting to force his penis inside her vagina. She does not believe he succeeded, because her grandmother came into the room and screamed loudly at him and he ran away. The plaintiff says in her affidavit that her grandmother “gave me as much support as she could, but I do not believe anything further eventuated” regarding this person.[26]Although the State had thought that NW was no longer alive, the plaintiff’s solicitors recently discovered that in fact he is. He is aged about 78. In July 2022, the plaintiff’s solicitor telephoned NW and spoke to him and his wife. According to her diary note, she told him she acted for “Derek and Joanne Willmot in relation to a historical claim”, but did not tell him that the plaintiff had commenced proceedings involving allegations of sexual abuse by him, before engaging him in conversation. From what he is recorded to have told the plaintiff’s solicitor in this conversation, NW also spent most of his childhood and adolescence in the boys’ dormitory at Cherbourg and was himself the victim of sexual abuse there.[27]The second occasion occurred, again whilst the plaintiff was visiting her grandmother’s house in Ipswich, when she was about 13 years of age (so in about 1967). By this time, she had left Cherbourg, and says, in her affidavit “I/we were temporarily staying/holidaying with my grandmother”. She was no longer a State child. On this occasion, the plaintiff says that her cousin/great uncle Pickering, then about 50-60 years of age, sexually assaulted her by grabbing her and holding her, standing behind her, putting his hand up under her pyjama shirt and touching her breasts, before then putting his hand down inside her pyjama pants, touching her vagina and digitally penetrating her. There was no one else home at the time this occurred. The plaintiff did not tell anyone what had occurred. This person, Pickering, is assumed to be deceased, given the age the plaintiff estimates he was in 1967. In addition to the matters otherwise addressed in these reasons, there are obvious difficulties with the plaintiff’s case in so far as these allegations are concerned, as they occurred when she/her family were staying, or holidaying with her grandmother, after having left Cherbourg, and no longer being a State child. The basis upon which the more general Aboriginal Protection … and Restriction of the Sale of Opium Act 1897 could give rise to liability to monitor or supervise in this situation is not explained in the pleading.”[26]The estimates of NW’s age at the time vary in the material. This is what appears in Dr Khoo’s report (affidavit of Mills, at p 243 of the exhibits), and aligns with the date of birth for NW in the material annexed to the affidavit of Ross sworn 14 July 2022.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.