WHITTLE and COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIVE SERVICES

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   HUMAN RIGHTS

ACT: EQUAL OPPORTUNITY ACT 1984 (WA)

CITATION:   WHITTLE and COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIVE SERVICES [2011] WASAT 68

MEMBER:   JUDGE T SHARP (DEPUTY PRESIDENT)

HEARD:   25 FEBRUARY 2011

DELIVERED          :   21 APRIL 2011

FILE NO/S:   EOA 6 of 2010

BETWEEN:   VALERIE JEAN WHITTLE

Applicant

AND

COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIVE SERVICES
Respondent

Catchwords:

Equal opportunity - Discrimination on grounds of sex - Less favourable treatment - Comparator - Goods and services

Legislation:

Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA), s 4, s 8, s 8(1), s 20, s 90(2)

Result:

The application is dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr R Widerstrom (Agent)

Respondent:     Ms L Eddy

Solicitors:

Applicant:     N/A

Respondent:     State Solicitor's Office

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Boehringer Ingelheim Pty Ltd v Reddrop [1984] 2 NSWLR 13

Edoo and Minister for Health [2010] WASAT 74

Ghockson v Commissioner of Police (1996) EOC 92 ­ 798

Haines v Leves (1987) 8 NSWLR 442

Purvis v State of New South Wales (Department of Education and Training) (2003) 217 CLR 92

Richards and Commissioner of Police [2010] WASAT 11

Zangari and St John Ambulance Service [2010] WASAT 6

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. The applicant, who was at the relevant time a prisoner at Bandyup Women's Prison, brought a claim against the Commissioner of Corrective Services on the basis that the Commissioner had introduced a smoking reduction policy in prisons in Western Australia, but had implemented this policy in Bandyup Womens Prison, and not in Hakea Prison or Casuarina Prison, being men's prisons.  She alleged that the Commissioner provides goods (cigarette lighters) and facilities and/or services (smoking areas, ash trays, fixed cigarette lighters and shelters) on terms less favourable to her than to her male counterpart in another prison.

  2. The Tribunal first considered whether the Commissioner provides goods, services or facilities to prisoners.  It concluded that the Commissioner was engaged in providing goods and facilities in the relevant sense.

  3. The Tribunal then examined the evidence in relation to the allegation.  It concluded that, assuming that allowing a person to smoke can be regarded as treating that person more favourably than not allowing a person to smoke, the Commissioner had treated the applicant less favourably than her counterpart in a male prison.  However, the applicant failed to provide any evidence that this was on the ground of her sex.  The Tribunal found that there was no basis to conclude that the actions of the Commissioner in implementing the smoking reduction policy were influenced in any way by consideration of gender.  Accordingly, the application was dismissed.

The complaint

  1. On 10 September 2009, the Equal Opportunity Commission (EOC) received from the applicant a complaint lodged under the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA) (EO Act).  The applicant was at that time a prisoner at Bandyup Women's Prison (Bandyup Prison).  The applicant's complaint alleges discrimination by the respondent on the ground of her sex in the area of goods, services and facilities.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read WHITTLE and COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIVE SERVICES and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] WASAT 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Whittle, sought review of a decision by the Equal Opportunity Commission (EOC) that dismissed her complaint of sex discrimination against the Commissioner of Corrective Services. The applicant argued that the Commissioner had discriminated against her on the basis of her sex by not fully implementing the Smoking Reduction Project at Bandyup Women's Prison, where she was incarcerated, while the project was fully implemented at other prisons, including those housing male inmates. The EOC found the complaint misconceived, reasoning that the applicant was not being treated less favourably than other prisoners, as the project had been fully implemented at other prisons, both male and mixed.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the applicant had been treated less favourably on the basis of her sex by the partial implementation of the Smoking Reduction Project at Bandyup Women's Prison, as compared to other prisons. This involved determining whether there was a comparator group who were treated more favourably and whether the treatment was due to the applicant's sex. Additionally, the court had to consider the nature of the project, which was intended to provide a health benefit, and whether the partial implementation at certain prisons could be considered discriminatory.

In its decision, the court found in favour of the Commissioner of Corrective Services. The court held that the applicant had not established that she was treated less favourably on the basis of her sex, as the Smoking Reduction Project had been fully implemented at various other prisons, including those housing male inmates. The court further held that the partial implementation at Bandyup Women's Prison and other prisons did not constitute discrimination, as the project was intended to provide a health benefit and its partial implementation did not disadvantage the applicant more than other prisoners. The court concluded that the EOC's dismissal of the complaint was correct and dismissed the applicant's appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Background Reasons for Doing the Project / Benefits Implementation of Smoking Reduction Activities in Prisons Implementation at Bandyup Women's Prison The EOC provided the applicant with a copy of this response and on 11 November 2009 the applicant wrote to the EOC stating that in her view 'it confirms that Bandyup Prison is the only maximum security prison that have these rules imposed'. On 29 December 2009, the EOC wrote to the applicant confirming that all of the material regarding her complaint of sex discrimination had been considered. The EOC informed the applicant that the EOC had decided that her complaint of discrimination is misconceived and was dismissed. The EOC's letter to the applicant contained the following paragraphs (including the emphasis):To establish a complaint of sex discrimination you must show that you have been treated less favourably than other persons in the same or similar circumstances, and that the less favourable treatment is due to your sex. As the Department's Smoking Reduction Project has been introduced to provide support for prisoners and staff to access treatment, education and assistance to quit smoking, which is accepted as a health benefit, I am not able to agree that you are being treated less favourably than other prisoners who are in prisons where the Project has not been fully implemented.I also note from the information provided by the Department that the Project has been fully implemented at a number of male only as well as mixed prisons. So while it is correct that only partial implementation has occurred at Casuarina and Hakea, full implementation has been effected at a range of other male and mixed prisons around the state. In my view, it is misconceived to claim that you are being treated less favourably than other prisoners on the ground of your sex. On 19 January 2010, the applicant gave written notice to the EOC under s 90(2) of the EO Act requiring the Commission to refer her complaint to the Tribunal. The EOC complied with this request on 11 February 2010. Section 20 of the EO Act makes it unlawful to discriminate on the ground of a person's sex either by refusing to provide, or make available, goods, services, or facilities, in the manner in which those goods, services or facilities are made available. Section 20 relevantly provides:20. Goods, services and facilities It is unlawful for a person who, whether for payment or not, provides goods or services, or makes facilities available, to discriminate against another person on the ground of the other person’s sex,… ­ (a)by refusing to provide the other person with those goods or services or to make those facilities available to the other person; or(b)in the terms or conditions on which the first‑mentioned person provides the other person with those goods or services or makes those facilities available to the other person; or(c)in the manner in which the first­mentioned person provides the other person with those goods or services or makes those facilities available to the other person.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.