Land and Environment Court
of New South Wales
CITATION: Whitehouse v Remme [1988] NSWLEC 115 PARTIES: APPLICANT
John Frederick WhitehouseRESPONDENT
Klaus RemmeFILE NUMBER(S): 40156 of 1988 CORAM: Stein J KEY ISSUES: :- LEGISLATION CITED: National Parks and Wildlife (Management of Certain Lands) By-laws 1984
National Parks and Wildlife (Land Management) Regulation 1987
National Parks and Wildlife Act, 1974
Land and Environment ActCASES CITED: Adamson v. West Perth Football Club ((1979);
Minister for Natural Resources v. N.S.W. Aboriginal Land Council, Court of Appeal,(1987);
Bathurst City Council v. Saban ((1985);
Fencott v. Muller ((1982-3);
Peek v. N.S.W. Egg Corporation ((1986)DATES OF HEARING: 22/07/1987, 06/10/1987, 7/04/1988 DATE OF JUDGMENT:
04/07/1988LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES: RESPONDENT
Mr Simpkins
JUDGMENT:
JUDGMENT
HIS HONOUR: By a further amended Application filed in Court on 14 March 1988 the applicant John Frederick Whitehouse, the Director of the National Parks and Wildlife Service, seeks a number of declarations and orders against the respondent, Klaus Remme, concerning the construction of a road by the respondent within the Blue Mountains National Park. The relief sought includes declarations that the respondent has committed certain trespasses, breaches of the National Parks and Wildlife (Management of Certain Lands) By-laws 1984 and the National Parks and Wildlife (Land Management) Regulation 1987; injunctions restraining the respondent from roadmaking and driving any vehicle within the Park without the consent of the Director; and orders in the nature of compensation or damages.
The particular area in question within the National Park is some 52km south east of Oberon and adjacent to a road known as Parliament Creek Road. It is part of an area proclaimed as additions to the Blue Mountains National Park in the Government Gazette No. 10 of 16 January 1987. The Proclamation of these additions to the National Park was made by the Governor pursuant to section 33(3) of the National Parks and Wildlife Act, 1974 (the NPW Act) being prescribed lands within the meaning in section 33(l) of the Act. The proclamation added about 17,350 hectares to the National Park by reference to a Plan Ms.4696-3090.
On this Map, (which became Exhibit B at the hearing), the Parliament Creek Road is shown as a public road running from the Werong State Forest in the north to Parliament Creek in the south. Both the State Forest and the Creek form boundaries to the National Park. By a notation on the map all public roads are excluded from the Park. An amended copy of the Plan was published on 22 September 1987 which also showed an unformed and unmade surveyed Public Road 20.115m wide as per Ms.339.OeR. This unformed road is to the east of Parliament Creek Road, entering the Park from the north close to that road and winding south around ridges to cross Parliament Creek to the south in the vicinity of Parliament Creek Road. Apparently this public road had been inadvertently omitted from the Plan Ex. B. It is also excluded from the Park. The amended Plan (Ex. C) also contained…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Whitehouse v Remme and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1988] NSWLEC 115
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court made the following orders: (1) a declaration that the respondent's construction of trails and associated earthworks in the park is a trespass; (2) a declaration that the respondent's actions are contrary to various planning and environmental laws; (3) an order restraining the respondent from further construction or interference within the park without consent; (4) an order for the respondent to remove his chattels from the park; and (5) an order restraining the respondent from driving any vehicle within the park without consent. The application for payment of the costs of restoration and damage was adjourned to a future date.