Kelly v Samiri

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Kelly v Samiri & Anor [1989] NSWLEC 222
PARTIES:

APPLICANT
Kelly

RESPONDENT
Samiri & Anor
FILE NUMBER(S): 40130 of 1989
CORAM: Bignold J
KEY ISSUES: :-
LEGISLATION CITED: Land and Environment Court Act
Encroachment of Buildings Act 1972
CASES CITED: Whitehouse v. Remme (1988) 64 LGRA 375;
Bathurst City Council v. Saban (1985) 2 NSWLR 704;
Bryant's Manly Vale Pty. Ltd. v. Francis (1986) 4 NSWLR 635 ;
The Anson Bay Company (Australia) Pty. Ltd. v. Bob Blakemore Pty. Ltd. (Court of Appeal - unreported 18th April, 1989).
DATES OF HEARING:
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
08/11/1989
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


JUDGMENT:

Bignold J.: By its Notice of Motion filed on 4th August, 1989 the 1st Respondent seeks an order that class 4 proceedings pending in this Court and listed for hearing next Friday be struck out or stayed on the grounds of abuse of process.

The class 4 proceedings were commenced on 19th May, 1989 claiming prohibitory and mandatory injunctions against the 1st Respondent in respect of building works carried out on the Applicant's land situate at No. 4 Tobruk Avenue, Balmain. The 1st Respondent is the owner of the adjoining premises No. 6 Tobruk Avenue and it appears has carried out building works on his property which have involved encroachments upon the Applicant's property.

The proceedings have been mentioned before the Registrar on a number of occasions and on 28th July, 1989 they were listed for hearing on 18th August, 1989.

The 1st Respondent's Notice of Motion also claimed by way of alternative relief an order vacating this hearing date. No justification for this relief has been made out and it is refused.

The basis for the 1st Respondent's application to stay the pending proceedings is that the same relief has been sought in separate proceedings commenced by the Applicant in the Supreme Court on the same day that he commenced the proceedings in this Court.

In support of the application for a stay Counsel for the 1st Respondent referred to a number of cases which have established or recognised the following principle stated in Halsbury's Law of England (4th ed.) Volume 37 paragraph 446:-

"Prima facie it is vexatious and oppressive for the plaintiff to sue concurrently in two English Courts or tribunals, and the Court will stay the second proceedings. A defendant will not be called upon to meet, in substance and in reality, the same claim or charge he has already answered in an earlier action. If there are two courts faced with substantially the same question or issue, that question or issue should be determined in only one of those Courts, and the Court will if necessary stay one of the actions. The same principles apply to proceedings other than actions."

Disadvantage to the 1st Respondent of the duplication of the proceedings had been raised at an early stage following the commencement of the proceedings in correspondence passing between the 1st Respondent's Solicitor and the Applicant's Solicitors the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelly v Samiri and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1989] NSWLEC 222
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, Kelly filed a claim against Samiri and another respondent regarding building works that encroached on Kelly's property. The case, Kelly v Samiri, was presided over by Bignold J. The primary issue was whether the proceedings, which had been initiated in both the Supreme Court and the Land and Environment Court, constituted an abuse of process.

The court had to determine whether the concurrent proceedings in two different courts were vexatious and oppressive, as suggested by precedents. The respondent argued that the proceedings were duplicative and oppressive, citing cases that established the principle that a plaintiff should not pursue the same relief in multiple courts. Kelly, however, contended that the causes of action in each court were distinct and based on different legal grounds. Kelly's application in the Land and Environment Court was based on illegal building work and non-compliance with council approvals, while the Supreme Court action was based on trespass.

Bignold J concluded that the separate proceedings did not amount to an abuse of process. The court found that the apparent jurisdictional fragmentation could be addressed by the doctrine of pendent jurisdiction. Additionally, the advanced stage of the Land and Environment Court proceedings, which were scheduled for an imminent hearing, contrasted with the potential two-year delay in the Supreme Court. The court also noted that if Kelly succeeded in the Land and Environment Court, the Supreme Court proceedings might be rendered unnecessary. The court ultimately dismissed the motion to stay the proceedings, finding no significant prejudice to the respondents and deciding that the potential delay and inconvenience to Kelly outweighed any inconvenience to the respondents. The court ordered the motion be dismissed with costs.