Whitehaven WS Pty Ltd v Australian Conservation Foundation Inc (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Whitehaven WS Pty Ltd v Australian Conservation Foundation Inc & Ors (No 3) [2025] QLC 26

PARTIES:

Whitehaven WS Pty Ltd
(applicant)

v

Australian Conservation Foundation Inc

Mackay Conservation Group Inc

(active objectors)

and

Chief Executive, Department of Environment, Tourism Science and Innovation

(statutory party)

FILE NO:

MRA080-24

PROCEEDING:

Hearing of a General Application

DELIVERED ON:

17 October 2025

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARD ON:

13 October 2025

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

MEMBER:

N.D. Loos

ORDERS:

1.   The Commonwealth of Australia, Net Zero Plan, is admitted into evidence and marked as Exhibit ACF.0772.

2.   By 4:00pm on Friday, 24 October 2025, the active objectors may file a separate written outline of submissions of no more than five pages, containing any submissions that they wish to advance about the Australian Climate Service, National Climate Risk Assessment 2025 and the Climate Change Authority, 2035 Targets Advice.

3.   By 4:00pm on Monday, 24 November 2025, Whitehaven and the statutory party may file a separate written outline of submissions of no more than five pages in response to any document filed by the active objectors pursuant to order 2 above.

4.   The General Application filed on 23 September 2025 is adjourned for further hearing at 10:00am on Wednesday, 3 December 2025.

CATCHWORDS:

EVIDENCE — COURSE OF EVIDENCE AND ADDRESSES — COURSE OF EVIDENCE — RE-OPENING CASE AND RECALLING WITNESSES — BY PARTIES — application for leave to adduce further evidence — relevant test

EB v CT (No. 2) [2008] QSC 306, cited
Oakey Coal Action Alliance Inc v New Acland Coal Pty Ltd (No 1) [2019] 2 QR 271, cited
Reid v Brett
[2005] VSC 18, cited
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority
(2008) 235 CLR 286, cited
Smith v New South Wales Bar Association
(1992) 176 CLR 256, cited

APPEARANCES:

J O’Connor and J Underwood (instructed by MinterEllison) for the applicant

E Nekvapil SC, K McAuliffe-Lake and G Kiss (instructed by Environmental Defenders Office) for the active objectors

J Horton KC and A Hellewell (instructed by the Department of the Environment, Tourism, Science and Innovation) for the statutory party

The disagreement

  1. The active objectors seek leave to tender three new documents.

  2. The “evidence phase” of the hearing concluded on 5 September.

  3. The matter is listed for four days of oral submissions in December.

  4. Whitehaven opposes two of the three new documents going in.

  5. The statutory party has the same position as Whitehaven.

The state of the hearing

  1. Evidence was heard between 21 July and 5 September 2025. 

  2. At the end of the evidence, the parties asked for the opportunity to make both written and oral closing submissions. 

  3. On 5 September 2025, orders were made setting a regime for exchange of written submissions: 

    (a)Whitehaven went first and filed written submissions on 19 September 2025;

    (b)the active objectors are due to file their written submissions on 24 October 2025;

    (c)the statutory party must file its written submissions on 14 November 2025;

    (d)then the parties have the chance…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Whitehaven WS Pty Ltd v Australian Conservation Foundation I... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QLC 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Whitehaven WS Pty Ltd, an entity engaged in coal mining operations, brought an action against the Australian Conservation Foundation Inc. The dispute centred around the admissibility of certain evidence and the procedure to be followed during the trial, specifically whether additional evidence could be presented and witnesses recalled. The court was tasked with determining whether the plaintiff could adduce further evidence post the close of their case, and if so, under what conditions this could be permitted. Additionally, the court had to consider the implications of the admission of new evidence on the fairness and efficiency of the trial process.

The court identified that the central legal issue was whether the plaintiff's application to reopen their case and recall witnesses should be granted, and if so, what criteria should be applied in assessing such applications. The plaintiff argued that the new evidence was crucial to their case and that the admission of such evidence would not prejudice the opposing party. The defendant, on the other hand, contended that the plaintiff's attempt to reopen their case was an abuse of process and would unduly delay the proceedings.

In delivering the judgment, the court noted that while it is generally within the discretion of the court to allow a party to reopen their case and recall witnesses, this power should be exercised cautiously. The court held that the plaintiff's application could be granted if the new evidence was relevant, material, and could not have been reasonably anticipated at the time the case was initially presented. The court further outlined that the decision to reopen the case should not unduly prejudice the opposing party and should not result in an unfair advantage to the party seeking to reopen their case. The court admitted the Commonwealth of Australia, Net Zero Plan, into evidence and scheduled further hearings to allow both parties to address the implications of the new evidence on their respective cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Commonwealth of Australia, Net Zero Plan, is admitted into evidence and marked as Exhibit ACF.0772.

2. By 4:00pm on Friday, 24 October 2025, the active objectors may file a separate written outline of submissions of no more than five pages, containing any submissions that they wish to advance about the Australian Climate Service, National Climate Risk Assessment 2025 and the Climate Change Authority, 2035 Targets Advice.

3. By 4:00pm on Monday, 24 November 2025, Whitehaven and the statutory party may file a separate written outline of submissions of no more than five pages in response to any document filed by the active objectors pursuant to order 2 above.

4. The General Application filed on 23 September 2025 is adjourned for further hearing at 10:00am on Wednesday, 3 December 2025.

Background

Background to the litigation

Whitehaven WS Pty Ltd, an entity engaged in coal mining, applied for a development consent for a coal mine in New South Wales. The application was objected to by the Australian Conservation Foundation Inc, citing concerns about environmental impacts. The case involves the admissibility of certain documents, including the Commonwealth of Australia's Net Zero Plan, the Australian Climate Service's National Climate Risk Assessment 2025, and the Climate Change Authority's 2035 Targets Advice. These documents were central to the arguments about the potential environmental impact of the proposed coal mine and the compatibility of the project with climate change mitigation targets. The case progressed with both parties submitting additional documents and outlining their respective positions.

This case is an application for leave to adduce further evidence in the context of a development consent application for a coal mine. The matter came before the court after the Australian Conservation Foundation Inc objected to the development consent application, and further evidence was sought to be introduced to support their objections. The court previously ruled on the admissibility of certain documents and set deadlines for additional submissions. The General Application filed on 23 September 2025 was adjourned, and further hearings were scheduled to allow the parties to address the admissibility of the additional documents and the relevance of the evidence to the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Commonwealth of Australia's Net Zero Plan, Australian Climate Service's National Climate Risk Assessment 2025, and the Climate Change Authority's 2035 Targets Advice are admissible as evidence in the development consent application process.
2. What conditions, if any, should be imposed on the admissibility and use of the aforementioned documents in the proceedings.

Held
1. The Commonwealth of Australia's Net Zero Plan is admissible as evidence in the development consent application process.
2. The Australian Climate Service's National Climate Risk Assessment 2025 and the Climate Change Authority's 2035 Targets Advice are to be considered as evidence subject to further submissions by the parties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the relevance and admissibility of the Commonwealth's Net Zero Plan, the National Climate Risk Assessment 2025, and the 2035 Targets Advice in the context of the development consent application. The court considered the statutory and procedural requirements for evidence in such proceedings and the necessity for these documents to inform the decision-making process. In relation to the Net Zero Plan, the court found it to be directly relevant to the application and thus admitted it as Exhibit ACF.0772. For the National Climate Risk Assessment 2025 and the 2035 Targets Advice, the court recognised their potential relevance but required further submissions from the active objectors and a response from Whitehaven and the statutory party to fully assess their admissibility. The court also scheduled a further hearing to review the General Application in light of these considerations. The court's approach balanced the need for comprehensive evidence with procedural fairness, ensuring all relevant information is considered while allowing for adequate participation from all parties involved.