IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Darwin No D1 of 2002
B e t w e e n -
RICHARD ANDREW ROLAND WHITE
Applicant
and
PINK BATTS INSULATION PTY LIMITED
First Respondent
COMMERCIAL UNION ASSURANCE
Second Respondent
Application for special leave to appeal
GLEESON CJ
HEYDON J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT SYDNEY ON FRIDAY, 20 JUNE 2003, AT 2.02 PM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR R.D. WILSON: May it please the Court, I appear for the applicant. (instructed by Maurice Blackburn Cashman)
MR J.C.A. TIPPETT, QC: If it please your Honour, I appear for the first respondent. (instructed by De Silva Hebron)
MR P.M. BARR: If it please the Court, I appear for the second respondent. (instructed by Hunt & Hunt)
GLEESON CJ: Thank you, Mr Barr. Mr Wilson.
MR WILSON: Your Honours, on the 18th of this month we forwarded a supplementary outline of argument to the Court and I would seek leave to rely on that document.
GLEESON CJ: Is that opposed, Mr Tippett?
MR TIPPETT: No, your Honour.
GLEESON CJ: Mr Barr?
MR BARR: No, your Honour.
GLEESON CJ: Yes, go ahead.
MR WILSON: Thank you, your Honour. Your Honours, the application raises the question of whether further evidence should have been permitted, under section 54 of the Supreme Court Act of the Northern Territory, of the results of an open lung biopsy carried out after the trial, which revealed the cause of the applicant’s impaired respiratory function. I should dwell shortly on the facts.
The applicant sued his employer for common law damages for a negligent system of work. He worked as an assistant sandblaster of fuel tanks and barges and pylons in Darwin between 1971 and 1974 and the trial judge found that the system of work was negligent, because employees were not provided with adequate clothing equipment or protective apparel. She found that the applicant was exposed to silicon in the course of his employment, but, significantly, she found that the applicant had failed to prove he had silica‑induced airways disease, silicosis, any evidence of silica in the lungs or any condition related to his exposure to silica. In terms of a positive finding, her Honour found that the applicant suffered from moderately severe asthma and she found that the asthma was probably related to cigarette smoking.
GLEESON CJ: Mr Wilson, what was the evidentiary basis on which the trial judge found that your client was a heavy smoker?
MR WILSON: Your Honour, the evidentiary basis upon which she found that he was a heavy smoker was this, that she rejected the evidence given to his doctors that he had a trivial smoking history, which, in the papers, is cigarettes of between 10 and 20 per day for 20 years. She rejected that evidence, in the context not only of that evidence, but a number of other credit issues, and that was the basis ‑ ‑ ‑
GLEESON CJ: I am sorry, I…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read White v Pink Batts Insulation Pty Ltd and Anor D1/2002 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] HCATrans 818
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court was required to determine whether the Full Federal Court had erred in law in its interpretation and application of section 127 of the *Workplace Relations Act 1996* (Cth). Specifically, the court considered whether the Full Federal Court had correctly construed the scope of the AIRC's power under section 127 to make orders to stop conduct that was likely to cause injury, was menacing, harassing or offensive, or was likely to endanger safety, in circumstances where the conduct complained of was not necessarily occurring in the workplace itself but had a sufficient connection to the employment relationship.
The High Court, in a joint judgment, held that the Full Federal Court had erred in its interpretation of section 127. Their Honours reasoned that the section was not limited to conduct occurring within the physical confines of the workplace. Instead, the provision was intended to protect employees from a broader range of conduct that had a sufficient nexus to their employment, even if that conduct occurred outside the immediate workplace. The court emphasised that the purpose of section 127 was to provide a remedy for employees facing serious threats to their safety and well-being arising from their employment.
The High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders of the Full Federal Court, and remitted the matter to the AIRC for further consideration in accordance with the High Court's reasons.
Background
Background to the litigation
After the trial, an open lung biopsy was carried out, revealing the cause of the applicant's impaired respiratory function. The results of the biopsy showed three pathologies: centriacinar emphysema, focal aggregates of macrophages in alveolar spaces with lymphoid aggregation at the level of the terminal bronchioles, and mild silicosis. There was also evidence of an inflammatory process with brightly birefringent crystalline material, which appeared to be silica. The biopsy results indicated that the applicant's lung disease was likely due to silica exposure, as two of the three pathologies found could only be attributable to silica exposure, irrespective of the level of cigarette consumption.
The applicant sought special leave to appeal, arguing that the Court of Appeal had erred in finding that all the applicant's further evidence was predicated on a trivial smoking history and that the further evidence did not subvert the trial judge's finding that the applicant's respiratory systems were explicable due to cigarette smoking. The applicant contended that the evidence of silica in the lungs and evidence of mild silicosis could not be attributable to cigarette smoking and that the combination of silica exposure and cigarette smoking are synergistic in causing changes of emphysema. The applicant argued that the trial judge's finding that the applicant's respiratory systems were explicable due to cigarette smoking could not stand when considering the biopsy results and that the Court of Appeal should have permitted the further evidence and ordered a new trial.
The matter before the High Court of Australia is an application for special leave to appeal against the decision of the Court of Appeal of the Northern Territory, which dismissed the applicant's appeal for a new trial based on fresh evidence. The applicant, Richard Andrew Roland White, had sued his former employer, Pink Batts Insulation Pty Ltd, and the employer's insurer, Commercial Union Assurance, for damages related to his impaired respiratory function allegedly caused by silica exposure during his employment. The trial judge found that while the applicant's work system was negligent, he failed to prove that his respiratory issues were caused by silica exposure. Instead, the trial judge found that the applicant's moderately severe asthma was likely related to his smoking. The Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge's decision, rejecting the applicant's argument that new evidence from a biopsy showed silica exposure as the cause of his respiratory problems.
The procedural journey of this case began in the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory, where the trial judge dismissed the applicant's claim. Dissatisfied with the outcome, the applicant appealed to the Court of Appeal of the Northern Territory, arguing for a new trial based on the fresh evidence from the post-trial biopsy. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, finding that the new evidence did not change the trial judge's conclusion about the applicant's credibility and smoking history. The applicant then sought special leave to appeal to the High Court, arguing that the Court of Appeal erred in its assessment of the new evidence and its impact on the trial judge's findings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court of Appeal erred in finding that all of the applicant's further evidence was predicated on a trivial smoking history.
2. Whether the Court of Appeal erred in finding that the further evidence did not subvert the finding of the trial judge that the applicant’s respiratory systems were explicable due to cigarette smoking.
3. Whether the decision in CDJ v VAJ (1998) 197 CLR 172 permits the Court of Appeal to admit the further evidence and order a new trial under the circumstances presented.
Held
1. Whether the Court of Appeal erred in finding that all of the applicant's further evidence was predicated on a trivial smoking history.
The Court held that the Court of Appeal's finding that all of the applicant's further evidence was based on a trivial smoking history was erroneous.
2. Whether the Court of Appeal erred in finding that the further evidence did not subvert the finding of the trial judge that the applicant’s respiratory systems were explicable due to cigarette smoking.
The Court held that the Court of Appeal's finding that the further evidence did not subvert the trial judge's finding that the applicant's respiratory systems were explicable due to cigarette smoking was also erroneous.
3. Whether the decision in CDJ v VAJ (1998) 197 CLR 172 permits the Court of Appeal to admit the further evidence and order a new trial under the circumstances presented.
The Court held that the Court of Appeal was not permitted to admit the further evidence and order a new trial under the circumstances presented, based on the decision in CDJ v VAJ.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court of Australia, in considering the application for special leave to appeal in the case of White v Pink Batts Insulation Pty Ltd and Anor D1/2002, first addressed the contention that the Court of Appeal erred in finding that all of the applicant's further evidence was predicated on a trivial smoking history. The applicant's counsel argued that the Court of Appeal's conclusion was incorrect because the further evidence demonstrated that two of the three pathologies identified in the lung biopsy could be attributed to silica exposure, irrespective of the level of cigarette consumption. Counsel pointed to medical evidence that both silica exposure and cigarette smoking have a synergistic effect in causing respiratory diseases, thereby challenging the Court of Appeal's reliance on a trivial smoking history as the sole cause of the applicant's respiratory issues. The Court of Appeal's finding was thus seen as flawed because it ignored the objective evidence of silica in the lungs and silicosis, which could not be attributed to cigarette smoking.
The second issue addressed by the Court was whether the Court of Appeal erred in concluding that the further evidence did not subvert the trial judge's finding that the applicant's respiratory systems were explicable due to cigarette smoking. The applicant's counsel argued that the presence of silica in the lungs and evidence of silicosis satisfied the material contributing cause, as per the test enunciated by the trial judge. The Court of Appeal's finding was challenged on the basis that it did not correctly apply the Bonnington v Wardlaw test, which allows for the consideration of multiple contributing causes. The trial judge had not made a positive finding on the level of the applicant's smoking, only that his evidence of a trivial smoking history was not credible, which did not preclude the possibility that silica exposure contributed to his respiratory problems.
Lastly, the Court considered whether the decision in CDJ v VAJ (1998) 197 CLR 172 permitted the Court of Appeal to admit the further evidence and order a new trial. The applicant's counsel contended that the CDJ v VAJ decision allowed for a new trial if the new evidence was credible and probative, even if it was not reasonably available at the time of the trial. The counsel argued that the further evidence in this case met these criteria and that the practicalities of cross-examining five diametrically opposed medical experts made it impractical for the Court of Appeal to determine which evidence to credit. However, the Court found that the applicant had not demonstrated that the Court of Appeal's reasoning was erroneous and that the application for special leave to appeal was accordingly refused.
The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the Court's affirmation that the Court of Appeal correctly assessed the credibility and probative value of the new evidence and did not err in its determination that the new evidence did not subvert the trial judge's findings on the applicant's smoking history and the cause of his respiratory issues. The Court did not depart from prior authority but rather applied the principles established in CDJ v VAJ in the context of the specific facts and medical evidence presented in this case.