White Constructions (ACT) Pty Limited (in Liquidation) v White & 14 Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      White Constructions (ACT) Pty Limited (In Liquidation) v White & 14 Ors [2005]  NSWCA 173

FILE NUMBER(S):
40199/04
40341/04

HEARING DATE(S):               04/04/05, 05/04/05, 06/04/05, 07/04/05, 11/04/05, 12/04/05

JUDGMENT DATE: 17/06/2005

PARTIES:
White Constructions (ACT) Pty Limited (In Liquidation) (Appellant)
Geoffrey Bernard White (First Respondent)
Travers William Duncan (Second Respondent)
John William Spinks (Third Respondent)
Frank Stratton McAlary (Fourth Respondent)
Michael Frank McAlary (Fifth Respondent)
White Constructions Pty Limited (formerly known as White Constructions Limited) (Sixth Respondent)
Exxon Coal Australia Pty Limited (formerly known as White Industries Limited) (Seventh Respondent)
PDC Constructions Pty Ltd (Eighth Respondent)
White Industries (Qld) Pty Limited (Ninth Respondent)
WIL Civil and Mining Engineering Pty Limited (formerly known as Keathson (WA) Pty Ltd and as WIL Plant Hire Pty Limited (Tenth Respondent)
White Constructions (NT) Pty Limited (Eleventh Respondent)
PDC Plant Hire Pty Ltd (Twelfth Respondent)
White Constructions (NSW) Pty Ltd (Thirteenth Respondent)
White Property Developments Pty Limited (Fourteenth Respondent)
White Industries Australia Limited (Fifteenth Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:       Santow JA Ipp JA McColl JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          SC 50144/02

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     McDougall J

COUNSEL:
D E Grieve QC/ S D Epstein SC/ J Horowitz (Appellant)
B W Rayment QC/D T Kell (Respondents)

SOLICITORS:
Deacons (Appellant)
Mallesons Stephen Jaques (Respondents)

CATCHWORDS:
APPEALS - Challenges to factual findings made by trial judge - Principle in Devries v Australian National Railways Commission (1993) 177 CLR 472 applies - Damages - Contended on appeal that loss was suffered - Loss was of a different kind to that argued at trial - Principles relating to finality of litigation prevent damages being awarded on appeal.
EVIDENCE - Discretion to limit use made of evidence that is admitted - s 136 Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) - Failure to call a relevant witness - No explanation given - Rule in Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 applies.
RESTITUTION - Failure to raise it properly at trial such that no evidence there led - Appeal Court unable to determine whether restitution could be practically effected and whether it would be equitable to grant such relief.
CORPORATIONS - Breach of fiduciary duties by directors - Where fraudulent preference afforded to certain creditors - Whether damages recoverable by company itself - Company must prove it sustained financial loss.
EQUITY - Statutes of limitations - Doctrine of analogy is recognised - Breach of fiduciary duties by directors - s 48 of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) applies by analogy.  D

LEGISLATION CITED:
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), Pt 5.7B, ss 565, 598(2)
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s 136
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), s 80E
Limitation Act 1969 (NSW), ss 14(1)(d), 48

DECISION:
(1)  Appeals dismissed (2) Appellant to pay the respondents' costs of the appeals.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40199/04
CA 40341/04
SC 50144/02

SANTOW JA
IPP JA
McCOLL JA

Friday 17 June 2005

WHITE CONSTRUCTIONS (ACT) PTY LIMITED (IN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read White Constructions (ACT) Pty Limited (in Liquidation) v Whi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 173
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned challenges to factual findings made by a trial judge regarding allegations of breach of fiduciary duties and fraud by directors of White Constructions (ACT) Pty Limited (in Liquidation). The appellant, White Constructions (ACT) Pty Limited (in Liquidation), sought to overturn the trial judge's findings, arguing that the directors had acted fraudulently and in breach of their duties, causing loss to the company. The respondents were the directors and other parties involved.

The primary legal issues before the appellate court were whether the trial judge's factual findings were demonstrably wrong, specifically concerning the absence of fraud by the directors. The court also considered whether the appellant had properly established a claim for damages arising from breaches of fiduciary duties, and whether the company itself had sustained a financial loss. Further issues included the application of the rule in *Jones v Dunkel* concerning the failure to call relevant witnesses, and the potential for restitutionary relief, which had not been pursued at trial.

The court applied the principle from *Devries v Australian National Railways Commission* (1993) 177 CLR 472, holding that to challenge factual findings on appeal, the appellant must demonstrate that the findings were glaringly improbable, contrary to compelling inferences, or inconsistent with incontrovertible facts. The court found that the appellant had failed to establish this threshold. Regarding the failure to call witnesses, the court applied the rule in *Jones v Dunkel* (1959) 101 CLR 298, noting that the appellant provided no explanation for the omission, entitling the trial judge to draw adverse inferences. The court also noted that the claim for damages was not a claim for recovery of undue preferences or property under the Corporations Act, but rather a claim under general law for breaches of fiduciary duties. Crucially, the court found that the appellant had not proven that the company itself sustained the specific financial loss claimed. Furthermore, the court held that restitutionary relief could not be granted on appeal as it had not been properly raised at trial, and the court was unable to determine its practical effect or equitable basis.

The appeals were dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the respondents' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Appeals dismissed (2) Appellant to pay the respondents' costs of the appeals.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As White ACT gave no explanation for the omission to call potentially important witnesses, his Honour was entitled to take that into account.Conclusion as to the allegations of fraudulent purpose I have dealt with the separate arguments raised on this issue by White ACT on an individual basis. I am conscious of the fact that, although each on its own may not be grounds for interference with the judge’s findings, when taken together they have greater collective force, and regard must be had to that. I have taken account of the additional weight White ACT’s arguments must have when taken as a whole, that is, as an inter-connected assembly of facts and inferences. I am unpersuaded that when seen in this light they establish that his Honour’s findings were in conflict with incontrovertible documentary evidence, or were glaringly improbable or contrary to compelling inferences in the case. In my opinion, individually and when looked at as a whole, the arguments of White ACT do not establish that any of the judge’s relevant factual findings (in particular the finding that there was no fraud on the part of the Directors) were glaringly improbable, or contrary to compelling inferences, or inconsistent with incontrovertible facts established by the evidence. For this reason, too, in my opinion, the appeal should be dismissed. There are other grounds, as well, on which I would dismiss the appeal, and I shall proceed to deal with those.The appellant’s cause of action and the relief sought White ACT’s claim is not a claim by a liquidator for recovery of undue preferences under s 565 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) or a claim by a liquidator for recovery of property or compensation under Pt 5.7B of that Act for the benefit of creditors of insolvent companies. It is also not a claim by “an eligible applicant” under s 598(2) of that Act for an order that the Court “thinks appropriate”. These are proceedings taken by the company itself (albeit that is under winding up) for relief that it has had difficulty in identifying with precision. Mr Grieve said that this is a “case brought under the general law to avoid payments made by the company at the behest of its directors in breach of their duties to it”. He said that White ACT’s case was that, in consequence of those breaches, “the respondent directors were guilty of fraud upon it”. He asserted that the claim was for breach of fiduciary duties (although, I do not think he meant to abandon the claim that there was a breach by the Directors of their statutory duties as alleged in the summons). In its summons White ACT claimed “damages” and, apart from costs and interest, nothing further. On the seventh day of the trial, Mr Grieve handed up short minutes of orders to the judge. In those short minutes the principal relief claimed was a declaration that the loss and damage incurred by White ACT in consequence of the breaches of duty by the Directors was $20,672,029.36. Orders were sought for payment of that sum, interest and related relief. No claim was made for restitutionary relief.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.