Wet052 v The Republic of Nauru

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GAGELER, KEANE AND EDELMAN JJ

WET052  APPELLANT

AND

THE REPUBLIC OF NAURU  RESPONDENT

WET052 v The Republic of Nauru

[2018] HCA 47

17 October 2018

S267/2017

ORDER

1.Leave to amend the notice of appeal is refused.

2.Appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Nauru

Representation

S A Beckett with M L L Albert for the appellant (instructed by Banki Haddock Fiora)

N M Wood for the respondent (instructed by Republic of Nauru)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GAGELER, KEANE AND EDELMAN JJ.   The appellant was born in Tehran, Iran, in 1990.  His ethnicity is Turkmen and his religion Shi'a Islam.  After graduating from high school and gaining a certificate in industrial electricity, he was employed in various jobs in Iran.  He arrived on Christmas Island in September 2013.  He was transferred to the Republic of Nauru in February 2014. 

  2. On 21 February 2014, the appellant participated in a transfer interview.  In the course of that interview, he stated as follows:

    .He left Iran because his father was an alcoholic who physically abused him.  For instance, his father had burned his hands with cigarettes and cut him with a knife.

    .He had run away from home three times but each time his father found him and brought him home.

    .His father had forced him to go to work and bring money home, when the appellant wanted to study at university.

    .On one occasion, his father had taken a knife, intending to stab the appellant.  His brothers and mother intervened, but his father then threw an ashtray, which struck the appellant on the head. 

    .He was not feeling safe at home.  His mother had urged him to flee Iran, and, with money she gave him, he was able to leave.

    .He feared that if he were returned to Iran he would be subjected to further physical abuse by his father, and might be killed by him. 

    The appellant's application for refugee status

  3. On 26 May 2014, the appellant applied to the Secretary of the Department of Justice and Border Control ("the Secretary") for recognition as a refugee under the Refugees Convention Act 2012 (Nr) ("the Refugees Act"). 

  4. As at the date of the Secretary's decision, the Refugees Act relevantly provided:

    "3        Interpretation

    In this Act, unless the contrary intention appears:

    …

    'complementary protection' means protection for people who are not refugees as defined in this Act, but who also cannot be returned or expelled to the frontiers of territories where this would breach Nauru's international obligations;

    …

    'refugee' means a person who is a refugee under the Refugees Convention as modified by the Refugees Protocol;

    …

    5         Application for refugee status

    (1)A person may apply to the Secretary to be recognised as a refugee.

    …

    6         Determination of refugee status

    (1)Subject to this Part, the Secretary must determine…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wet052 v The Republic of Nauru and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] HCA 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of Nauru, which had affirmed a determination by the Refugee Status Review Tribunal. The appellant, Wet052, had been determined by the Secretary of the Department of Justice and Border Control not to be a refugee and not to be owed complementary protection. The Refugee Status Review Tribunal had affirmed this decision, making an adverse finding as to the appellant's credibility.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the Tribunal's adverse finding as to the appellant's credibility was made without a logical foundation, and whether the Tribunal failed to properly consider the appellant's claims relating to his treatment in Iran as a returned asylum seeker, specifically concerning his alleged political profile and his status as a failed asylum seeker.

The High Court considered the appellant's submissions that he had a political profile that would expose him to a real possibility of harm upon return to Iran as a failed asylum seeker. This argument was primarily based on a statement made during a transfer interview that he had been involved in demonstrations against the outcome of the Iranian election in 2009. The Court found that while the appellant had mentioned his involvement in the 2009 demonstrations, he had not, at any stage, articulated a fear of harm from Iranian authorities as a result of a political profile linked to this participation. The Court also noted that the demonstrations occurred four years before his departure from Iran, and he had apparently suffered no retaliation. The Court accepted the respondent's submission that the appellant did not make this specific claim, and that the Tribunal had considered and determined the general claim regarding the risk faced by failed asylum seekers. The Court also found that the Tribunal was entitled to weigh the significance of the appellant's failure to volunteer information about his father's involvement in drug distribution when explaining his reasons for leaving Iran, despite the transfer interview not being formally part of the refugee status determination process.

The High Court refused leave to amend the notice of appeal and dismissed the appeal with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to amend the notice of appeal is refused.

2. Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GAGELER, KEANE AND EDELMAN JJ
The Secretary accepted that the appellant was a citizen of Iran, that his identity was as he claimed it to be, that his father was an alcoholic and drug addict, and that his cousin was jailed for dealing drugs. On the other hand, the Secretary did not accept that the appellant's father was involved in drug trafficking, that the appellant had been compelled to engage in drug trafficking on his father's behalf, that on each occasion he had attempted to flee home the appellant had been forced to return home, or that his father has close personal connections with the Iranian authorities which he could use to threaten the appellant's safety.The decision of the Tribunal On 2 October 2015, the appellant applied to the Tribunal for review of the Secretary's determination. In that regard, at relevant times s 31 of the Refugees Act relevantly provided:"Application for merits review by Tribunal (1) A person may apply to the Tribunal for merits review of any of the following: (a) a determination that the person is not recognised as a refugee; …(d) a determination that the person is not owed complementary protection." In a supplementary statement signed on 20 November 2015, the appellant made further statements detailing his father's drug addiction and its impact upon him and his family. The appellant also said that he had converted to Christianity in Nauru in about April 2015, and that he had been regularly attending church and Bible classes after being baptised. He said that a number of friends who had learnt of his conversion through friends in Nauru and Australia sent him congratulatory messages over the Internet. The appellant claimed to fear return to Iran, where apostasy is punishable by death, and to believe that he would, at least, be sent to jail. On 1 February 2016, the Tribunal affirmed the Secretary's decision. The Tribunal accepted, "in the absence of any evidence to the contrary", the appellant's claims concerning his citizenship and identity. On the other hand, the Tribunal did not accept that the appellant would be at risk of persecution in Iran on grounds of an adverse political opinion imputed to him through association with his father, or that he would be at risk of persecutory harm because he distributed illicit drugs for his father. The Tribunal expressed concern as to the credibility of several aspects of the appellant's account: .First, in his transfer interview the appellant had made no reference to his father's involvement with the use and supply of illicit drugs when explaining why he left Iran. The Tribunal did not accept that the appellant had satisfactorily explained that omission..Secondly, the Tribunal found implausible the appellant's claim to fear that his father would deliberately implicate him in drug dealing by setting him up with planted drugs, particularly the notion that his father would thereby accept the related danger of disgrace and severe punishment to himself..Thirdly, the Tribunal found it difficult to accept that the appellant's father could have forced him to distribute illicit drugs on an almost full‑time basis over a period of three or four years.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GAGELER, KEANE AND EDELMAN JJ

Finally under this heading, it is simply not to the point to argue that the transfer interview was not part of the refugee status determination process. No‑one suggested that it was – certainly not the Tribunal. While it may be that the appellant did not turn his mind consciously to the pursuit of his claim for refugee status at the time of the transfer interview, the Tribunal was entitled to note, and weigh the significance of, his failure to volunteer that his father had embroiled him in the distribution of illicit drugs in Iran.The Tribunal's consideration of the appellant's claims In this Court the appellant submitted that he had a political profile that meant that he would face a real possibility of harm on return to Iran as a failed asylum seeker from the West. His argument in support of this claim, referred to as "the particular claim", was focused upon the statement in his transfer interview that he had been involved in the 2009 demonstrations against the outcome of the Iranian election. As to "the general claim" that he faced a real risk of harm as a failed asylum seeker per se, there was country information before the Secretary and the Tribunal which indicated that persons returning to Iran were persecuted by Iranian officials because they were failed asylum seekers per se. The appellant argued that neither of these matters was properly considered by the Tribunal, and that the Tribunal erred by failing to consider these integers of his claim for protection. The respondent submitted that the appellant did not make the particular claim, and that the Tribunal considered and determined the general claim. The respondent's submissions must be accepted.The particular claim At the transfer interview the appellant stated that "[i]n 2009 I was involved in demonstrations, mainly in the evening – about the election". This was evidently a reference to the controversial election in Iran in 2009, and the popular demonstrations that ensued. The appellant's involvement in the 2009 demonstrations was not mentioned specifically by the Secretary in his reasons or at all in the Tribunal's reasons. The Secretary found that "the likelihood of a returned asylum seeker coming to harm on return to Iran is proportionate to the political profile that they have". The Secretary observed further that:"in all examples [of failed asylum seekers facing 'difficulties' on return] it related to people who had partaking [sic] in activities either in Iran or outside Iran that were clear illustrations of anti-government sentiment such as well covered demonstrations. A person such as the [appellant], who was not politically active or had a profile [sic], will not be a person of particular interest to the authorities in Iran." The answer given in his transfer interview, that he was involved in the 2009 demonstrations against the election, is the foundation for the appellant's contention that he advanced the particular claim. However, at no stage did the appellant suggest, whether in his transfer interview, his application for refugee status, his refugee status determination interview, or any of his later statements, that he had an actual fear of being harmed by Iranian authorities as a result of a political profile associated with his participation in the 2009 demonstrations. It might be said that it is hardly surprising that he made no such suggestion, given that the demonstrations had occurred four years before he left Iran and he had apparently suffered no retaliation by the authorities. It would also strain too far to suggest that such a fear, if actually entertained, was well‑founded.