Westraint Resources Pty Ltd v BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   WESTRAINT RESOURCES PTY LTD -v- BHP IRON ORE PTY LTD [2001] WASC 111

CORAM:   SCOTT J

HEARD:   20 DECEMBER 2000,  9 & 16 FEBRUARY 2001

DELIVERED          :   8 MAY 2001

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1372 of 1996

BETWEEN:   WESTRAINT RESOURCES PTY LTD (ACN 009 083 783)

Plaintiff

AND

BHP IRON ORE PTY LTD (ACN 008 700 981)
Defendant

Catchwords:

Courts - Practice and procedure - Application to amend statement of claim - Statute of limitations - Equity - Equitable claims analogous to common law claims

Legislation:

Limitation Act 1935-1978, s 38, s 47

Result:

Amendment substantially allowed

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr P R Hayes QC & Mr I D Martindale

Defendant:     Ms C J McLure QC & Mr B Dharmananda

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Skea Hager & Co

Defendant:     Mallesons Stephen Jaques

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Cheers v El Davo Pty Ltd (In liq) [2000] FCA 361

Cia de Seguros Imperio v Heath (REBX) Ltd [2001] 1 WLR 112

Dye v Griffin Coal Mining Co Pty Ltd (1997‑98) 19 WAR 431

Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corporation (1984‑1985) 156 CLR 41

Kitchen v Royal Airforce Association & Ors [1958] 1 WLR 563

Levi v Stirling Brass Founders Pty Ltd (1997) 36 ATR 290

Mayne v The Public Trustee (1945) 70 CLR 395

Morgan v Banning (1999) 20 WAR 475

Overmeire v National Commercial Banking Corporation of Australia, unreported; SCt of WA (Master Seaman QC); Library No 6316; 29 May 1986

Paragon Finance plc v DB Thackerar & Co [1999] 1 All ER 400

Queensland v J L Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146

Sali v SPC Limited (1993) 67 ALR 841

Tony Sadler Pty Ltd v McLeod Nominees (1995) 13 WAR 323

UDC v Brian (1984‑1985) 157 CLR 1

Case(s) also cited:

AG Blake [2000] 3 WLR 625

Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (1995) 57 FCR 360

Associated Leisure Ltd (Phonographic Equipment Co Ltd) v Associated Newspapers Ltd [1970] 2 QB 450

Atkinson v Fitzwalter [1987] 1 WLR 201

Attorney-General v Blake [2000] 3 WLR 625

Baburin v Baburin [1990] 2 Qd R 101

Baburin v Baburin (No 2) [1991] 2 Qd R 240

Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon (1993) 176 CLR 344

Barclays Bank Ltd v W J Simms Ltd [1980] 1 QB 677

Bradford Third Equitable Benefit Building Society v Borders [1941] 2 All ER 205

Brambles Holdings Ltd v Bathurst City Council [2001] NSWCA 61

Breen v Williams (1996) 186 CLR 71

Bride v The Australian Bank Ltd & Ors [2000] WASC 310

Butt v McDonald (1896) 7 QLJ 68

Clay v Clay (1999) 20 WAR 427

Clay v Clay [2001] HCA 9

Commissioner of State Revenue (Victoria) v Royal Insurance Australia Ltd (1994-5) 182 CLR 51

Coulthard v Disco Mix Club Ltd [2000] 1 WLR 707

David Securities Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1992) 175 CLR 353

Dimskal Shipping Co SA v International Transport Workers…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Westraint Resources Pty Ltd v BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] WASC 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Westraint Resources Pty Ltd v BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, Westraint Resources Pty Ltd, sought to amend its statement of claim to include new claims and extend the time frame of the proceedings against the defendant, BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd. The dispute centered around various agreements, including the 6 June 1988 Agreement and the Ore Wagons Sale and Purchase Agreement, which the plaintiff alleged the defendant breached. The plaintiff sought to include claims related to a fiduciary relationship, which allegedly arose from an agreement dated 25 May 1987, and sought to allege that the defendant was unjustly enriched. The defendant opposed the amendments on the grounds that they would introduce new issues that had not been previously pleaded and would extend the time frame of the proceedings, which would cause substantial injustice due to the unavailability of documents and witnesses.

The primary legal issues the court had to decide were whether the plaintiff could amend its statement of claim to include new claims and extend the time frame of the proceedings, and if the proposed amendments were within the bounds of fairness and justice. The court had to balance the plaintiff's right to amend its statement of claim with the defendant's right to be protected from unfair prejudice and the potential for unjust enrichment. The court also had to consider whether the proposed amendments were barred by the statute of limitations and whether the plaintiff had a properly arguable case for the new claims.

The court held that the proposed amendments raised serious matters that should not be raised lightly and that the plaintiff had not satisfied the court that it had a properly arguable case for the new claims. The court found that the proposed amendments would extend the time frame of the proceedings and introduce new issues that had not been previously pleaded, which would cause substantial injustice to the defendant. The court also found that the proposed amendments were barred by the statute of limitations and that the plaintiff had not shown any exceptional circumstances that would warrant an extension of the time frame of the proceedings. Accordingly, the court dismissed the application to amend the statement of claim.

The court made no orders as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Defendant is and was at all relevant times a company duly incorporated pursuant to the laws of the State of Western Australia and was formerly known as Mt Newman Mining Co Pty Ltd.BACKGROUND TO 6 JUNE 1988 AGREEMENT As a result of the negotiations referred to in paragraph 2B and further negotiations which commenced in March 1988, on 6 June 1988, HML, the Defendant and Pennant Pty Ltd entered into an agreement in writing (“6 June 1988 Agreement”) whereby the parties agreed: By an agreement in writing made between Hancock Mining Ltd ("HML") (now known as BHP (Jimblebar) Pty Ltd), Pennant Pty Ltd and the Defendant, made on or about 6 June 1988 ("Principal Agreement" "6 June 1988 Agreement") the Defendant agreed with HML, inter alia: Pursuant to the 6 June 1988 Agreement Principal Agreement: Pursuant to the terms of the Principal Agreement, EPIOC, with the knowledge and consent of the Defendant, negotiated and agreed with MIMEX a price for Mt Newman iron ore to be delivered by the Defendant on behalf of HML under the Romanian Ore Sales Contract. By a document dated 17 May 1989, HML and the Defendant more fully and formally recorded the terms of their agreement with respect to the sale and purchase of the Ore Wagons (“Ore Wagons Sale and Purchase Agreement”). Further, it was an express term of the Ore Wagons Sale and Purchase Agreement that in the event of default by the Defendant in payment of the purchase price or any part thereof the Defendant was obliged to pay to HML interest on any amount outstanding from time to time at a rate equal to the prime rate charged by the Rural & Industries Bank of Western Australia plus 2% per annum. The Defendant completed the purchase of 75 Ore Wagons pursuant to the terms of the Ore Wagons Sale and Purchase Agreement. In breach of the 6 June 1988 Agreement, Principal Agreement, in or about September on 16 August 1990, the Defendant refused, and at all material times thereafter continued to refuse, to supply any Mt Newman ore on behalf of HML to MimexMIMEX in satisfaction of HML’s obligations to supply iron ore to MimexMIMEX pursuant to the Romanian Ore Sales Contract.PARTICULARSThe refusal was oral and was communicated by Mr G McDonald and Mr G Wedlock of the Defendant to Mr L Hancock and Mr K Dalby, and the substance of the refusal was that the Defendant would not supply any further iron ore to Mimex under the Romanian Ore Sales Contract. It is also to be implied from the fact that the Defendant did not supply any or any further iron ore to Mimex under the Romanian Ore Sales Contract. By reason of and in consequence of its breach of the 6 June 1988 Agreement Principal Agreement the Defendant also breached the Ore Wagons Sale and Purchase Agreement in that it has failed to purchase any of the remaining 275 Ore Wagons for the sum of $20,429,000 remaining to be paid pursuant to the terms of the 6 June 1988 Agreement Principal Agreement and the Ore Wagons Sale and Purchase Agreement Despite demand the Defendant continues to refuse to complete the purchase of the remaining 275 Ore Wagons for the sum of $20,429,000.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I take into account that some of these amendments raise serious matters of a kind that should not be raised lightly - see Overmeire v National Commercial Banking Corporation of Australia, unreported; SCt of WA (Master Seaman QC); Library No 6316; 29 May 1986, at 6. Whilst matters of fraud are not alleged here, as I have indicated the matters arising out of the allegation of breach of fiduciary duty are serious matters and the amendments should only be allowed where the plaintiff has satisfied the court that it has a properly arguable case. The original statement of claim in this matter, filed on 2 May 1996, pleads in par 2 the agreement of 6 June 1988 and the obligations of the parties pursuant to that agreement which have been discussed earlier in these reasons. The original statement of claim also pleads the agreement of 17 May 1989 relating to the ore wagons' sale and purchase. That pleading alleges the breach of each of those agreements and the consequences which the plaintiff alleges followed from the defendant's breach of the agreements. By par 12 of the original statement of claim, the plaintiff pleads a deed dated 1 April 1992, ("the deed of novation") by which the plaintiff acquired the rights formerly vested in Hamersley Mining Ltd. That statement of claim pleads the damage that it is said to flow from breach of those agreements. Nowhere in the statement of claim, until the course of this application, has any mention been made of the Lygren agreement. In addition, until the proposed amendments, the plaintiff has never pleaded the agreement entered into on 25 May 1987. Nor has the plaintiff previously alleged that a fiduciary relationship existed between the plaintiff and the defendant, which it is now said arises in part from the agreement of 25 May 1987. If the amendments are allowed, it is trite to say that the issues between the parties will be extended back to 25 May 1987 and the terms of the Lygren agreement will, for the first time, be put in issue. In addition, as can be seen from the proposed re‑amended statement of claim annexed hereto, issues giving rise to the alleged fiduciary relationship will, for the first time, become relevant to these proceedings. That, in turn, will involve the discovery process being substantially revisited, as the relative financial strengths and weaknesses of the plaintiff and the defendant giving rise to the fiduciary relationship will need to be examined. Counsel for the defendant maintains that these issues will cause a substantial injustice to the defendant in that many of the relevant documents have been destroyed and witnesses who would have been able to give evidence on these issues will no longer be available. In addition, and more centrally to the matter presently under discussion, it is said that these matters are barred by the statute of limitations. It should also be mentioned in passing that the plaintiff, by the amendments in par 16, seeks to allege that the defendant has been unjustly enriched because of the use of the information obtained from the plaintiff's predecessor. Those matters are pleaded in detail in par 16 of the proposed amended statement of claim.