Westpac Banking Corporation v Heslop (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Westpac Banking Corporation & Anor v Heslop & Anor (No 2) [2020] QSC 256

PARTIES:

WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION
ACN 007 457 141
(first plaintiff)
JULIE ANN WILLIAMS

(second plaintiff)

v
GRAHAM JOHN HESLOP
(first defendant)
PATRICIA MARGARET HARPER

(second defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 9751 of 2015

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

21 August 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

10 to 14 February and 1 May 2020
Further written submissions received on 8 May 2020

JUDGE:

Bradley J

ORDER:

The Order of the Court is that:

1.   The first defendant pay to the first plaintiff the sum of $329,034.48.

2.   The first defendant pay the first plaintiff’s costs of the claim on the standard basis.

3.   The counterclaim against plaintiffs is dismissed.

4.   The first defendant pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the counterclaim on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

GUARANTEE AND INDEMNITY – CONTRACT OF GUARANTEE – OTHER MATTERS – where the defendants held shares in a company that was indebted to the first plaintiff – where each defendant guaranteed the company’s performance of its obligations to the first plaintiff – where the company was in monetary and non-monetary default under facilities the first plaintiff had extended to it – where the first plaintiff appointed the second plaintiff as receiver and manager of certain property of the company – where the first plaintiff demanded payment from each defendant pursuant to the guarantees they executed – where the first plaintiff obtained default judgment against the second defendant – where the first defendant filed a defence and counterclaim, in which he alleged various breaches of codes of conduct by each plaintiff – where the first defendant denies he is liable to the first plaintiff under the guarantee on which he is sued on account of the alleged breaches – whether either plaintiff committed any of the alleged breaches so that the guarantee on which the first defendant is sued is unenforceable

Equititrust Ltd v Gamp Developments Pty Ltd & Ors [2009] QSC 115, applied
Jones v Dunkel
(1959) 101 CLR 298, applied
National Australia Bank Ltd v Troiani
[2002] QCA 196, applied

COUNSEL:

G Handran for the plaintiffs

The first defendant appeared on his own behalf

SOLICITORS:

Gadens for the plaintiffs

The first defendant appeared on his own behalf

  1. The first plaintiff (Westpac) claims $329,034.48 from the first defendant (Mr Heslop).  Westpac says Mr Heslop is the guarantor of a debt in this amount owed by Lonrae Pty Ltd (Lonrae) pursuant to a written guarantee and indemnity Mr Heslop executed on 24 June 2004 (the Guarantee). 

  2. Lonrae is a company in which Mr Heslop and the second defendant (Ms Harper) held shares as trustees.  Westpac obtained default judgment against Ms Harper on 16 December 2016 pursuant to a separate guarantee of Lonrae’s debt and personal covenants in a mortgage.  These reasons do not deal with her personal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Westpac Banking Corporation v Heslop (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QSC 256
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Westpac Banking Corporation v Heslop, the primary dispute involved a guarantee executed by the defendant in relation to loans provided to a company of which he held shares. The plaintiff, Westpac, sought payment from the defendant under the terms of the guarantee after the company fell into default. The defendant, in turn, filed a defence and counterclaim, alleging various breaches of codes of conduct by both Westpac and the receiver appointed by Westpac, which rendered the guarantee unenforceable. The court had to determine whether the alleged breaches by the plaintiffs were valid and, if so, whether they invalidated the guarantee.

The central legal issues before the court were whether Westpac had breached its obligations under various banking codes of practice and whether the receiver had breached her obligations under receivers' codes of professional practice. The court had to assess these allegations in light of the evidence presented and determine their impact, if any, on the enforceability of the guarantee. The court also had to consider the defendant's failure to give evidence, which could potentially affect the outcome of the case.

The court found that the defendant failed to provide any evidence of the alleged breaches by Westpac or the receiver. Despite the defendant's initial intention to testify, he ultimately chose not to do so, which the court inferred meant that his evidence would not have helped his case. Consequently, the court rejected the defence based on alleged breaches of the codes of conduct. Additionally, the court dismissed the defendant's counterclaim against the plaintiffs. The court held that the defendant's obligation under the guarantee was to ensure the company met its obligations to Westpac, and this obligation remained unaffected by any alleged breaches by the plaintiffs.

The court ordered that the defendant pay Westpac the sum of $329,034.48, along with the costs of the claim on the standard basis. The counterclaim against the plaintiffs was dismissed, and the defendant was ordered to pay the plaintiffs' costs of the counterclaim on the standard basis. The court did not find any basis for awarding costs on an indemnity basis, as the contractual agreements between the parties did not provide for such an award.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Order of the Court is that:

1. The first defendant pay to the first plaintiff the sum of $329,034.48.

2. The first defendant pay the first plaintiff’s costs of the claim on the standard basis.

3. The counterclaim against plaintiffs is dismissed.

4. The first defendant pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the counterclaim on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Westpac Banking Corporation and Mr. Heslop, a guarantor of loans extended to Lonrae Property Investments Pty Ltd, a company in which Mr. Heslop held shares. Mr. Heslop guaranteed Lonrae's performance of its obligations under several loan facilities provided by Westpac. Lonrae was in default under these facilities, leading Westpac to appoint a receiver and manager, the second plaintiff, to certain property of Lonrae. Westpac demanded payment from Mr. Heslop pursuant to the guarantees he executed. Westpac obtained a default judgment against the second defendant, who did not file a defence. The first defendant, Mr. Heslop, filed a defence and counterclaim, alleging various breaches of codes of conduct by Westpac and the Receiver. Mr. Heslop denied liability under the guarantee due to the alleged breaches. The case proceeded to trial, where Mr. Heslop chose not to give evidence, although he had previously indicated he would.

The matter came before the court for trial following a default judgment against the second defendant and a defence and counterclaim filed by the first defendant, Mr. Heslop. The case involved several stages of pre-trial directions hearings, where Mr. Heslop indicated he would give evidence. However, on the scheduled day, he did not appear and subsequently advised the court that he would not be calling himself to give evidence. The trial resumed weeks later, and Mr. Heslop did not provide any written evidence or appear. The court considered the evidence presented and the arguments from both sides before delivering its judgment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In his defence, Mr Heslop alleged Westpac had failed to comply with its obligations under various banking codes of practice[4] and that the Receiver had failed to comply with her obligations under receivers codes of professional practice. Mr Heslop denied that he was liable to Westpac under the Guarantee because of this alleged noncompliance. At the outset of the trial, Mr Heslop identified these as the only issues he pursued in the proceeding. His defence included other allegations. These are dealt with, briefly, towards the end of these reasons.[4]There was some confusion on Mr Heslop’s part about which version of the code applied: see [24] below. Mr Heslop’s failure to give evidence Although Mr Heslop appeared at the trial, cross-examined witnesses called by Westpac and called witnesses in his own case, he gave no evidence himself. In the pre-trial reviews and directions hearings, Mr Heslop had said he would give evidence. This remained his position when he opened his case. It persisted when the court adjourned on the afternoon before he was scheduled to do so. On the day, he did not appear. The trial was adjourned, pending further information as to how he wished to proceed. Directions were made to allow him to provide his evidence in chief in writing and a date was fixed for the trial to resume some weeks later. Mr Heslop did not provide written evidence and he did not appear when the trial resumed. On 3 April 2020, he advised the court by email, “Moving forward I will not be calling myself to give evidence in this matter and I now rest my case.” No explanation was offered for his failure to testify at the trial. His decision not to do so may lead rationally to an inference that his evidence would not have helped his case[5] and would not have thrown doubt on the correctness of any inference favourable to Westpac and the Receiver that was open on other evidence.[6] The natural inference is that Mr Heslop was afraid to give evidence, and so be exposed to cross-examination, because it would have exposed facts unfavourable to him.[7][5]Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 (Jones v Dunkel) at 321 (Windeyer J). [6]Ibid at 308 (Kitto J).[7]Ibid at 320 (Windeyer J), quoting with approval John Wigmore, Wigmore on Evidence (Little, Brown & Co, 3rd ed, 1940) vol 2 at 162. Mr Heslop’s earlier dealings with Westpac Mr Heslop’s first relevant dealing with Westpac occurred on 11 October 2001, when he accepted a $110,000 loan offer to fund part of the purchase price for the management letting rights (MLR) for a 36-unit building at Kangaroo Point known as Quinton Cottages. On 5 November 2001, Mr Heslop accepted a separate loan offer of $160,000 to fund part of the purchase price for the manager’s unit at Quinton Cottages. Both purchases settled on 9 January 2002. To secure the loans, Mr Heslop granted Westpac a bill of sale over the MLR business and a mortgage over the manager’s unit. Mr Heslop operated the MLR business at Quinton Cottages together with Ms Harper, who at the time was his spouse. Mr Heslop had previously operated a similar business at a building in Annerley known as Redbrick. Before then, going backwards in time, he had managed a hotel-motel accommodation business, been a licensed real estate agent, worked for the Residential Tenancies Authority and worked as a police officer.The signing of the Guarantee

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Heslop’s colourful submissions (at various times oral and written) alleging “unlawful”, “deceitful” and “maleficent” conduct by Westpac are not evidence. They are simply exercises in hyperbole. Conclusion on code allegations Mr Heslop cross-examined a number of witnesses called by Westpac. In the course of doing so, he did not adduce evidence of a breach of the Banking Code by Westpac in relation to the loans made to Lonrae or the Guarantee or any breach by the Receiver of the ARITA Code. Ms Harper gave no evidence of any such breach. Nor did Mr Harper. In the circumstances, Mr Heslop’s defence to Westpac’s claim under the Guarantee fails. His counterclaim also fails. Costs The plaintiffs seek an order that Mr Heslop pay their costs on an indemnity basis. Pursuant to the BBBL, Lonrae agreed to pay Westpac all amounts which it reasonably incurs in relation to the exercise of its rights under any of its securities, including its “legal fees and costs of a full indemnity basis (even if a court does not specifically award costs on that basis)”. The plaintiffs submit this “plainly and unambiguously” provides for the award of costs other than on the standard basis.[30] [30]See Jamieson v Cosigil Pty Ltd [1983] 2 Qd R 117 at 120-121 (Williams J). The additional terms and conditions of the IPL included the following, under the heading “Expenses”:“All reasonable amounts that the Bank spends or incur … in relation to the enforcement or exercise of its powers may be debited by the Bank to the loan account. You will pay interest on each of those amounts at the interest rate that applies to the loan account at the time of debiting … The Bank may debit that interest to the loan account.” These provisions would be sufficient to entitle Westpac to recover its reasonable costs of its claim against Mr Heslop and of defending Mr Heslop’s related counterclaim on an indemnity basis from Lonrae. There is no such contractual basis for an indemnity costs order in favour of the Receiver, but to the extent that those costs are incurred by Westpac, they may fall within the sums Westpac is entitled to recover from Lonrae. Lonrae is not a party to the proceeding. Mr Heslop’s obligation under the Guarantee is to ensure Lonrae discharges its obligation to Westpac, up to the limit of his liability, which was last varied to become $2,772,193, plus 20% on account of expenses and other matters. As noted above, that liability arises on demand by Westpac. In its claim and pleading, Westpac and the Receiver sought to recover “costs” from Mr Heslop. Neither document amounts to a demand that Mr Heslop pay Westpac’s costs on an indemnity basis under the Guarantee. No evidence was adduced of any other such demand. The plaintiffs put an alternative submission that Mr Heslop should pay their costs on an indemnity basis, because he “made serious claims of breach of duty and misconduct which were not borne out by the evidence and lacked any arguable foundation”. The plaintiffs rely on the decision in Colgate Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd.[31] [31](1993) 46 FCR 225 at 233 (Sheppard J).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It follows that Mr Heslop has failed to make out any part of his defence or counterclaim that the Receiver failed to comply with the ARITA Code. Consideration of the other matters pleaded in the defence and counterclaim At the trial, Mr Heslop informed the Court he only wished to pursue his allegations of breaches of the Banking Code by Westpac and of the ARITA Code by the Receiver. For completeness’ sake, these reasons deal briefly with some of the other allegations pleaded by Mr Heslop. National Consumer Credit Protection Act allegations In his defence, Mr Heslop pleaded that Westpac breached ss 128, 129, 130, 131 and 132 of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) (the NCCPA) in respect of the loans made to Lonrae in 2004, 2007, 2008 and 2012. He made no oral or written submissions about these allegations. In short, these provisions prohibit a credit provider from entering into a credit contract with a consumer (or increasing the consumer’s credit limit) unless the credit provider has made an assessment of whether the credit contract will be unsuitable for the consumer if it is entered into or if the credit limit is increased. The assessment must have been made within 90 days of the contract or the increase. The credit provider must make reasonable enquiries and take reasonable and prescribed steps before making the assessment. Mr Heslop’s allegations must be rejected. The operative provisions of the NCCPA, including the National Credit Code, commenced on 1 April 2010. They did not apply in June 2004, when Westpac and Lonrae entered into the Burke BFA, in July 2007, when they entered into the IPL and the Gabba BFA, in November 2008, when they entered into the Parc BFA and varied the IPL, or in March 2010, when Westpac offered the investment property loans for the Boambillee Drive property. The NCCPA was in force in December 2010 when the BBBL was first drawn, in September 2011 when the Hub BFA was signed, and in December 2012 when the BBBL facility was changed. These NCCPA provisions apply to credit contracts where the debtor is a natural person or a strata corporation and where the credit is wholly or predominantly for personal, domestic or household purposes or to purchase, renovate or improve residential property for investment purposes.[28] A debtor is the person liable to pay or repay the credit, but does not include a guarantor like Mr Heslop. In each of these Westpac loans, the debtor was Lonrae. It was not a natural person or a strata corporation. The credit was provided for commercial purposes, to acquire and to provide working capital for MLR businesses, and not wholly or predominantly for purposes that would bring the lending within the scope of these provisions. [28]National Credit Code (Cth), ss 4, 5. Human Rights allegations Mr Heslop pleaded that Westpac and the Receiver: “breached Article 12 of the Human Rights Act by engineering the default and subsequent events which led to assault and unlawful detention of [Mr Heslop] and the sequential loss to both [Mr Heslop] and [Ms Harper] by forcefully and unlawfully taking possession of [the Parc MLR business]. This breach resulted in the loss of dignity by both [Mr Heslop] and [Ms Harper].”