West Roofing and Plumbing Pty Ltd v JBBK Construction Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND

ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CITATION: West Roofing and Plumbing Pty Ltd v JBBK Construction
Pty Ltd [2025] QCAT 416
PARTIES: WEST ROOFING AND PLUMBING PTY LTD
(applicant)
v
JBBK CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD
(respondent)
APPLICATION NO/S: BDL058-23
MATTER TYPE: Building matters
DELIVERED ON: 28 January 2025
HEARING DATE: 12 November 2024
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Member Paratz AM
ORDERS: The Application for commercial building disputes is
dismissed.
CATCHWORDS: PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – BUILDERS – where the
builder was claiming for a Variation for works done as a

subcontractor – where a draft Subcontract in writing was exchanged between the parties – where the draft Subcontract in writing was not signed by both parties – whether a

Subcontract that was not in writing and signed by both

parties was void or voidable – whether the terms of the draft Subcontract were enforceable – where there was no Variation in writing signed by both parties – whether the claimed Variation was effective – where the builder had

signed a Deed of Release
Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act
1991 (Qld), s 67D, s 67E, s 67G; Schedule 1B s 3, s 5, s
14(10); Part 4A
Cerda v Jacob [2020] QCATA 57
Clarke v Queensland Building and Construction
Commission [2020] QCAT 88
APPEARANCES & 
REPRESENTATION: 
Applicant: Self-represented by its Director, Tony West
Respondent: Self-represented by its Director, Brett King

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. JBBK Construction Pty Ltd (‘the builder’) engaged West Roofing and Plumbing Pty Ltd (‘the roofer’) to perform work as a Subcontractor on the construction of a service

    station at 68 Albion Street, Warwick in the State of Queensland.

  2. A draft written Subcontract number 21-001-R, dated 28 April 2022, was prepared by the builder. The Subcontract incorporated Australian Standard Subcontract conditions

    AES 4901 – 1998 (incorporating amendment nos. 1 & 2).

  3. The roofer made proposed amendments to the draft Subcontract, and returned it to the builder. The builder alleges that it accepted and signed the amended Subcontract and provided a copy to the roofer, and placed a copy onsite. The roofer says that it did not receive, and did not sign, the amended Subcontract.

  4. The roofer proceeded to conduct work in apparent accordance with the Subcontract, and conducted work that it now argues constituted variations, notwithstanding the absence of a written contract signed by both parties.

  5. This dispute concerns payment for metal flashing of the power truss surrounding the canopy and linkway. It is not disputed that the roofer conducted that metal flashing work, and there is no dispute as to the quality of the work.

  6. The issue in this matter is whether the metal flashing to the power truss is work under the original Subcontract and no amount is due in respect of it; or whether it constitutes a Variation to the original proposed work for which additional payment should be made.

  7. The builder also relies on a Deed of Release dated Tuesday, 26 September 2023 which was signed by Mr West for the roofer.

  8. The roofer claims the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read West Roofing and Plumbing Pty Ltd v JBBK Construction Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QCAT 416
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerns a dispute between West Roofing and Plumbing Pty Ltd and JBBK Construction Pty Ltd. The primary issue is whether an amended draft Subcontract, which was not signed by both parties, can be enforced. The case was heard in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The roofer argued that the amended draft Subcontract could not be relied upon because it was not signed. The builder, on the other hand, relied on oral evidence and the conduct of the parties to support its claim that an enforceable agreement existed. The key legal issues were whether the amended draft Subcontract was enforceable despite not being in writing, and whether it was a regulated contract under the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991.

The Tribunal examined the statutory requirements and concluded that since the work was commercial rather than domestic, Section 14 of the Act did not apply. It also found that Part 4A of the Act, which generally requires building contracts to be in writing, did not expressly provide that a Subcontract for commercial work is void if not in writing. Therefore, the Tribunal determined that the contract could be assessed under general principles of contract law. The Tribunal found that the conduct of the parties and the terms of the amended draft Subcontract indicated an enforceable agreement. This conclusion was supported by the parties' conduct in accordance with the terms of the amended draft Subcontract and the plans and specifications referred to in it. The Tribunal thus upheld the enforceability of the amended draft Subcontract.

The Tribunal's reasoning was grounded in the understanding that the Act's requirements for regulated contracts did not apply to this commercial Subcontract. It relied on the conduct of the parties and the content of the amended draft Subcontract to establish the existence of a legally binding agreement. The Tribunal's decision was also informed by the broader principles of contract law, as outlined in the text Construction Law in Australia. The appeal was dismissed, and the Tribunal upheld the enforceability of the amended draft Subcontract. The orders reflect this decision, dismissing the appeal and upholding the Tribunal's earlier determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Application for commercial building disputes is

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The roofer contended that as there was no written contract signed by both parties, the amended draft Subcontract could not be relied upon. Evidence of the builder The builder filed statements of evidence by two persons, on which it relied: Oral evidence was given at the hearing by Mr King and Mr Braun, and they were cross-examined on their Statements of Evidence. The contractual situation It is undisputed that no written Subcontract was ever signed by both parties. It is also undisputed that the parties conducted the work generally in accordance with the provisions of the amended draft Subcontract, and of the plans and specifications referred in and attached to it. Section 67D of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (‘the Act’) provides that a building contract is a subcontract if both the contracting party and the contracted party for the contract are building contractors, and the contracted party is a subcontractor for the contracting party and the building work the subject of the contract is part of building work the subject of another building contract. Section 67G of the Act (which is in part 4A) requires building contracts to be in writing. Section 67E of the Act provides that unless a provision of Part 4A of the Act expressly provides that a building contract is void, then Part 4A does not have effect to make a building contract void or voidable. The Appeal Tribunal came to a similar conclusion in Cerda v Jacob[3] which also concerned domestic building work. [3] [2020] QCATA 57. Section 14 of the Act applies to a ‘Level 2 regulated contract’. As this was commercial work, and involved ‘a contract between a building contractor and subcontractor’, it is not a ‘domestic building contract’ under Section 3 of Schedule 1B of the Act, and is not a ‘regulated contract’ under Section 5 of Schedule 1B.. As this is not a ‘regulated contract’, Section 14(10) of Schedule 1B of the Act does not apply; and as no provision of Part 4A expressly provides that a Subcontract for commercial work is void if it is not in writing, Part 4A does not make a subcontract for commercial work that is not in writing void or voidable. This matter then is to be determined having regard to basic principles of contract law. The authors of the text Construction Law in Australia[4] discuss those principles as follows: [4] Ian Bailey, Matthew Bell, Catherine Bell, Construction Law in Australia (Lawbook Co, 3rd Edition, 2011) [5.2]. [5.2] In order to be legally enforceable, a ‘simple’ contract (being a bargain between the parties with mutually-supporting promises) must satisfy certain technical legal requirements concerning its formation. For a contract to exist, there must be at least two parties who have achieved sufficiently certain agreement as to the respective rights and obligations, and to contemplate that such agreement will be protected, and if need be, enforced, by the law. To establish the existence of a contract, courts typically look to a number of essential elements of formation. These are categorised in this text, as discussed below, as: