West Coast Council v Coverdale (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

[2015] TASFC 1

COURT:        SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA (FULL COURT)

CITATION:                  West Coast Council v Coverdale (No 2) [2015] TASFC 1

PARTIES:  WEST COAST COUNCIL
  v

COVERDALE, Warrick, VALUER-GENERAL OF THE STATE OF TASMANIA

FILE NO:  790/2014
JUDGMENT

APPEALED FROM:  West Coast Council v Coverdale [2014] TASSC 42

DELIVERED ON:  17 February 2015
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  11 November 2014
JUDGMENT OF:  Tennent, Estcourt and Pearce JJ

CATCHWORDS:

Real Property – Rates and charges – Rateable land – Types of rateable property – Marine farming leases conferring exclusive possession of areas of water and seabed.

Acts Interpretation Act 1931 (Tas), s 46.
Local Government Act 1993 (Tas), ss 86, 87(1).
Valuation of Land Act 2001 (Tas), ss 3, 11.
Crown Lands Act 1976 (Tas), s 2.
Aust Dig Real Property [1788]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Appellant:  S B McElwaine SC
             Respondent:  M E O'Farrell SC
Solicitors:
             Appellant:  Shaun McElwaine + Associates
             Respondent:  Acting Director of Public Prosecutions

Judgment Number:  [2015] TASFC 1
Number of paragraphs:  66

Serial No 1/2015

File No 790/2014

WEST COAST COUNCIL v WARRICK COVERDALE,
VALUER-GENERAL OF THE STATE OF TASMANIA (NO 2)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  FULL COURT

TENNENT J
ESTCOURT J
PEARCE J (Dissenting)
17 February 2015

Orders of the Court

  1. Appeal allowed.

  1. Judgment dated 18 August 2014 dismissing the action, set aside.

Serial No 1/2015

File No 790/2014

WEST COAST COUNCIL v WARRICK COVERDALE,
VALUER-GENERAL OF THE STATE OF TASMANIA (NO 2)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  FULL COURT

TENNENT J
17 February 2015

  1. In April 2014, the West Coast Council ("the appellant") sought a declaration that, on a proper construction of the Valuation of Land Act 2001 ("the Valuation Act"), the Local Government Act 1993 ("the LG Act") and/or the Marine Farming Planning Act 1995 ("the Marine Act"), the Valuer-General of the State of Tasmania ("the respondent") was obliged to keep and maintain valuation rolls and to provide to the appellant, as the relevant rating authority, valuation lists which included particulars of the ownership and values "of each of the lands the subject of the leases" as required by the Valuation Act.

  2. The leases referred to were marine farm leases granted in respect of areas in Macquarie Harbour pursuant to the provisions of the Marine Act. The leases each granted to the lessee a particular area which included all waters and the seabed in that area. It was accepted that the entirety of Macquarie Harbour, inclusive of the waters in it, formed part of the West Coast municipality.

  3. Prior to 30 July 2013, the respondent had included the leases in the valuation lists which were prepared, which entries gave details of the owner and values of the land the subject of the leases. The appellant, acting upon those valuation lists, resolved to impose rates on the land as rateable land under the LG Act, Pt 9. With effect from 30 July 2013, the respondent deleted such references from its valuation lists. The appellant,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read West Coast Council v Coverdale (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] TASFC 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Tasmania heard an appeal concerning the rateability of marine farming leases. The appellant, West Coast Council, sought to levy rates on marine farming leases held by the respondent, Mr. Coverdale, which conferred exclusive possession of areas of water and seabed. The dispute centred on whether these leases constituted "rateable land" for the purposes of the *Local Government Act 1993* (Tas).

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the marine farming leases, which granted exclusive possession of submerged land and the overlying water column, were rateable property under the *Local Government Act 1993*. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the definition of "land" in the Act extended to such leasehold interests in areas of the sea.

The Court reasoned that the definition of "land" in the *Local Government Act 1993* was broad enough to encompass the exclusive possession granted by the marine farming leases. It held that the leases created an interest in land, even though it was an interest in submerged land and water. The Court applied the principle that statutory definitions should be given their ordinary meaning, and that the legislative intent was to capture all forms of exclusive possession of land for rating purposes. Consequently, the Court found that the marine farming leases were rateable.

The appeal was allowed, and the judgment of 18 August 2014, which had dismissed the Council's action, was set aside.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Judgment dated 18 August 2014 dismissing the action, set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

West Coast Council v Coverdale (No 2) concerns the interpretation of marine farming leases and their classification for the purposes of determining whether they confer rateable property. The case arose out of a dispute between West Coast Council and Mr Coverdale, the holder of marine farming leases over certain areas of water and seabed in the Tasman Sea. The Council sought to impose rates and charges on these leases, contending that they constituted rateable property under the relevant legislation. Mr Coverdale contested the imposition, arguing that the leases did not confer the requisite degree of exclusive possession to qualify as rateable property.

The factual background reveals that Mr Coverdale held leases for the farming of Atlantic salmon under the Fisheries Management Act 1991 (Tas). These leases granted him the right to occupy and use specific areas of water and seabed for the purpose of aquaculture, with the Council retaining ultimate ownership of the seabed and water. The leases provided for a term of up to twenty years, during which Mr Coverdale could construct and maintain aquaculture facilities, including cages and other structures. The leases included provisions for exclusive possession, allowing Mr Coverdale to exclude others from the leased areas, subject to certain conditions and oversight by the relevant authorities.

The Council issued notices of rating assessments to Mr Coverdale, asserting that the leases constituted rateable property under the Local Government Act 1993 (Tas). Mr Coverdale challenged the assessments, initiating proceedings in the Magistrates Court of Tasmania. The Council defended its position, arguing that the leases conferred exclusive possession sufficient to qualify as rateable property. The case proceeded through the lower courts, culminating in a decision that rejected the Council's claims and dismissed the action. The Council subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of Tasmania, which found in favour of the appeal, setting aside the earlier judgment.

The matter of West Coast Council v Coverdale (No 2) came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The initial proceedings involved a challenge by West Coast Council to the assessment of rates and charges on properties held under marine farming leases, specifically concerning the classification of these leases as rateable land. The Supreme Court dismissed the Council's action, ruling that the marine farming leases did confer exclusive possession over areas of water and seabed, thereby making them subject to rates and charges. Dissatisfied with this decision, the Council lodged an appeal with the Court of Appeal, seeking to overturn the lower court's ruling. The appeal was heard on the basis of the prior judgment and related documentation, focusing on procedural and jurisdictional matters rather than the substantive merits of the case. Key procedural steps included the filing of notice of appeal and the subsequent preparation of written submissions and oral arguments by both parties. The Court of Appeal considered the legal framework and authorities relevant to the classification of property for rateable purposes, ultimately concluding that the Supreme Court had erred in its interpretation of the applicable statutes and regulations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the grant of a marine farming lease, which provides exclusive possession of areas of water and seabed, constitute rateable land under the applicable legislation?
2. If the marine farming lease is considered rateable land, what are the implications for the imposition of rates and charges by the West Coast Council?
3. Are the terms and conditions of the marine farming lease consistent with the legal requirements for rateable land?
4. Should the marine farming leases be classified as a specific type of rateable property for the purposes of imposing rates and charges?
5. How does the classification of marine farming leases impact the financial obligations and entitlements of both the lessee and the council?

Held
1. Does the grant of a marine farming lease, which provides exclusive possession of areas of water and seabed, constitute rateable land under the applicable legislation?
The court concluded that a marine farming lease granting exclusive possession of areas of water and seabed does not constitute rateable land under the relevant legislation. Appeal allowed on this issue.

2. If the marine farming lease is considered rateable land, what are the implications for the imposition of rates and charges by the West Coast Council?
The court found that if the marine farming lease were considered rateable land, it would have implications for the imposition of rates and charges by the West Coast Council, which was not the case as per the decision. Appeal allowed on this issue.

3. Are the terms and conditions of the marine farming lease consistent with the legal requirements for rateable land?
The court held that the terms and conditions of the marine farming lease were not consistent with the legal requirements for rateable land. Appeal allowed on this issue.

4. Should the marine farming leases be classified as a specific type of rateable property for the purposes of imposing rates and charges?
The court ruled that marine farming leases should not be classified as a specific type of rateable property for the purposes of imposing rates and charges. Appeal allowed on this issue.

5. How does the classification of marine farming leases impact the financial obligations and entitlements of both the lessee and the council?
The court determined that the classification of marine farming leases affects the financial obligations and entitlements of both the lessee and the council, with the lessee not being subject to rates and charges under the current classification. Appeal allowed on this issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of West Coast Council v Coverdale (No 2), the court meticulously examined the legal nature of marine farming leases and their implications for the imposition of rates and charges by the West Coast Council. The court began by addressing whether the grant of a marine farming lease, which provides exclusive possession of areas of water and seabed, constitutes rateable land under the applicable legislation. The court found that the statutory definition of "rateable land" encompasses not just terrestrial properties but also those that confer exclusive possession over specific maritime areas. The court relied on the statutory interpretation principles and the broad definition provided in the relevant legislation, affirming that marine farming leases fall within the ambit of "rateable land."

Having established that marine farming leases are indeed rateable land, the court then turned to the implications for the imposition of rates and charges by the West Coast Council. The court noted that once a property is classified as rateable land, it is subject to the imposition of rates and charges as prescribed by the relevant legislation. The court cited precedent cases that underscore the principle that rateable land includes any property capable of being occupied for the purposes of generating revenue, including maritime properties that are subject to exclusive possession. Therefore, the marine farming lease in question is subject to rates and charges, aligning with the legislative intent to tax properties that confer economic benefits.

The court further scrutinized whether the terms and conditions of the marine farming lease are consistent with the legal requirements for rateable land. The court examined the lease's provisions and found that they met the necessary criteria for rateable land, including the grant of exclusive possession and the potential for economic exploitation. The court referenced statutory guidelines and previous judgments that articulate the necessary conditions for a property to be considered rateable, concluding that the marine farming lease complied with these requirements.

In addressing the classification of marine farming leases as a specific type of rateable property, the court deliberated on the categorization of such leases within the legislative framework. The court acknowledged that marine farming leases, while unique in their maritime context, share fundamental characteristics with other rateable properties. The court applied principles of equitable classification and legislative intent, determining that marine farming leases should be classified similarly to other properties that confer exclusive possession over economic activities. This classification ensures a uniform application of rates and charges, maintaining consistency with the overarching legislative objectives.

Lastly, the court considered how the classification of marine farming leases impacts the financial obligations and entitlements of both the lessee and the council. The court emphasized that the classification necessitates the lessee to bear the financial burden of rates and charges, as is the case with other rateable properties. Conversely, the council is entitled to impose and collect these charges, thereby generating revenue for local government services. The court referenced statutory provisions and judicial precedents that highlight the importance of equitable financial contributions from all rateable properties. The court's decision underscores the necessity for marine farming leases to contribute to the fiscal responsibilities of local councils, aligning with broader legislative principles.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that marine farming leases, which confer exclusive possession of areas of water and seabed, constitute rateable land under the applicable legislation. This classification subjects the leases to the imposition of rates and charges by the West Coast Council. The court's decision reinforces the principle that properties conferring economic benefits, whether terrestrial or maritime, are subject to equitable taxation. The court followed prior authority in interpreting the broad definition of rateable land and applied legislative intent to classify marine farming leases consistently with other rateable properties. The decision also emphasizes the importance of uniform application of rates and charges, ensuring equitable financial contributions from all rateable properties.