WCFT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

WCFT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2019] AATA 4085 (4 October 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:2019/0113           

Re:WCFT  

APPLICANT

Child Support RegistrarAnd  

RESPONDENT

CLFZAnd  

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D Mitchell (Presiding)

Member P Ranson

Date:4 October 2019

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.............................[Sgd]......................................

Member D Mitchell

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – care determination – reasonable action for compliance – interim determination – where no special circumstances – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

Child Support and Family Assistance Legislation Amendment (Budget and Other Measures) Bill 2010 (Cth)

CASES

Confidential and Social Security Appeals Tribunal and Anor [2010] AATA 1

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 46 FLR 409

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No. 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member D Mitchell

Member P Ranson

4 October 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, WCFT (the Father), and the Other Party, CLFZ (the Mother), are the separated parents of two daughters. The issue before the Tribunal relates only to their eldest daughter, born in August 2001 (the Child).

  2. From 1 July 2008, the Father is recorded as having 35% care of the Child and the Mother having 65% care.[1] This was consistent with a Court Order made in February 2009 which provides that the Father has care of the Child for 4 nights every fortnight, half the school holidays and on other special occasions as set out in the Orders.[2]

    [1]    Exhibit 1, T Documents, T27, page 133, CUBA screen captures.

    [2]    Exhibit 1, T Documents, T5, pages 44-51, Federal Magistrates Court Order.

  3. Until 23 September 2017, when the Mother advised the Department of Human Services (the Department) that she had 100% care of the Child from 7 September 2017, the care percentages had remained the same.[3]

    [3]    Exhibit 1, T Documents, T29, page 159, Child support file notes – Other Party.

  4. On 8 December 2017, the Department made a decision that recorded the Mother as having 100% care of the Child from 7 September 2017.[4]

    [4]    Exhibit 1, T Documents, T11, page 64, Letter from Department – change of percentage of care.

  5. The Father objected to this decision on 15 January 2018 on the basis that he agreed that the care had changed to 100% to the Mother, but the change in care was a breach of the 2009 Court Order.[5]

    [5]    Exhibit 1, T Documents, T16, pages 77-94, Objection to a Child Support Decision.

  6. On 22 June 2018, an Objection Officer with the Department made a decision to disallow the objection.[6]

    [6]    Exhibit 1, T Documents, T19,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read WCFT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 4085
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) of a decision regarding child support care arrangements. The parties involved were the Father and the Mother, with the Child Support Registrar also a party to the proceedings. The core dispute revolved around whether the Father had taken reasonable action to ensure compliance with an existing care arrangement, following a significant change in the child's living situation.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the Father's actions met the threshold of "reasonable action" as stipulated by section 51(1) of the relevant legislation. This section provides an exception to actual care percentages for an interim period if a person with reduced care has taken reasonable steps to ensure compliance with the care arrangement. The Tribunal also needed to consider whether any special circumstances existed, although this became moot once the primary question was answered.

The Tribunal considered evidence from both parents, acknowledging their fractured relationship but also their shared love for the child. It noted the Department's policy guidelines for contested shared care cases, which encourage consistent decision-making. The Father contended he had taken reasonable action by attempting to engage with the child via email, seeking psychological and legal advice, and contacting the police. However, the Tribunal found that while the Father had honourable reasons for not initiating court proceedings, he had not sought to negotiate with the Mother or seek her assistance. Crucially, the Tribunal found that the child, due to her age and strong will, had independently decided to cease spending time with the Father. As the requirements of section 51(1) were not met, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, meaning an interim care determination would not be made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is noted that the Tribunal said that it is appropriate to have regard to the Department’s policy in contested cases of shared care in Gillson and Secretary, Department of Families, Housing, Community Services & Indigenous Affairs [2011] AATA 473:“... The respondent has submitted that it is appropriate to have regard to Centrelink's policy guidelines. From the inception of this Tribunal there has been judicial guidance concerning the need of the Tribunal to have regard to policy. Centrelink decisions about shared care are generally made with reference to the Family Assistance Guide 1999 ("the Guide"). In my view it is appropriate to have regard to this policy document in contested cases of shared care; the application of the policy encourages consistent decision-making.”EVIDENCE All of the evidence before the Tribunal has been taken into account including the submissions made by the Father and the Mother. It is clear that the Father and Mother, as is not uncommon in these kinds of matters, have a fractured relationship. Both parents undeniably love the Child and do not want to see harm done to her. Although the parties in this matter have been unidentified there is little doubt that the Child will read these reasons for decision and as such the Tribunal sees no benefit to the parties or the Child to provide a detailed reproduction of the Father or Mother’s submissions in this decision. The Tribunal will instead take a holistic high level approach. The Father provided a number of different written submissions throughout the review process, all of which consistently outlined that he believed he had taken reasonable action to ensure that the care arrangement was complied with. It was clear that the Father takes issue with the Department’s review process and conduct. However, these are not matters before the Tribunal. The Father at Hearing told the Tribunal that he had taken reasonable action to ensure that the care arrangements were complied with by stating that:·He tried to engage with the Child via email on a number of occasions.·Prior to the change in care he had taken her to a psychologist however the Mother refused to engage. He was not allowed to interact with the Child’s psychologist despite attempting to.·He had sought legal advice and was told that he had limited prospects given the age of the Child and that her views were clear. The Father provided a receipt for this advice following the hearing.·He had sought advice from the police and the Federal Magistrates Court and they sent him to get independent legal advice as they could not assist with a recovery order. The Father provided details of his call to the police following the hearing.·He had always been an active father in his daughter’s life. The Father outlined in his written submissions that he also did not instigate legal proceedings to have the court order complied with as he was conscious of the Child’s study and wellbeing. The Father provided full reasons in his written submissions as to why he felt he had met the reasonable action requirement which were consistent with those reasons provided at hearing.[11][11] Exhibit 3 – Applicant’s Submission, including attachments dated 9 May 2019 and Exhibit 5 – Applicant’s reply to Other Party’s Submission.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As the Tribunal has found that the requirements of section 51(1) of the Administration Act have not been met it does not need to consider the interim care period or whether special circumstances exist.CONCLUSION The Tribunal finds that:(a)A change occurred in relation to the care of the Child from 7 September 2018 which resulted in the Mother providing 100% care from that date.(b)An interim care determination should not be made. Accordingly, the decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Both the Father and Mother provided details in relation to the Child which made it clear that it was her decision to no longer spend time with the Father and that she is a child with a strong independent mind. It was agreed that the Father and the Child are both stubborn and this has in part led to the relationship breakdown.CONSIDERATION The question before the Tribunal is whether the Father took reasonable action to have the care arrangement complied with. It is noted that the Explanatory Memorandum to the Child Support and Family Assistance Legislation Amendment (Budget and Other Measures) Bill 2010 that inserted section 51, as it presently is, provided:New section 51 is an exception rule that applies where there is a care arrangement in relation to the child and this care arrangement is no longer being complied with. Provided the person with reduced care has taken reasonable action to ensure the care arrangement is complied with, they will continue to have a care percentage based on the care arrangement rather than actual care, for an interim period. For example, a parent may be negotiating with the other parent to have the care arrangement complied with, or seeking advice and assistance from a family relationship centre, or taking action through other dispute resolution processes. In the matter of Confidential and Social Security Appeals Tribunal and Anor [2010] AATA 1, Deputy President Hack stated:“As it seems to me the issue of whether a child has been made available is not one capable of determination by reference to any overarching principles. It will invariably be a question of fact to be determined by reference to the particular circumstances.” Based on the evidence before the Tribunal and in particular that provided by the Father and Mother at Hearing, the Tribunal finds that while the Father clearly cares for his daughter, his actions do not satisfy the requirements of section 51(1) of the Administration Act. The Tribunal finds that the Father did not take all reasonable steps to ensure that the care arrangement was complied with as, although he had honourable reasons for not instigating court proceedings or making more vigorous contact with the Child in the period after September 2017, he also did not seek to negotiate with or seek the assistance of the Mother. In this matter, given the Child’s age and strong will, it is not a matter that the Mother did not make the Child available to the Father, but rather the Child exercised her own mind in no longer seeing the Father. As the Tribunal has found that the requirements of section 51(1) of the Administration Act have not been met it does not need to consider the interim care period or whether special circumstances exist.CONCLUSION The Tribunal finds that:(a)A change occurred in relation to the care of the Child from 7 September 2018 which resulted in the Mother providing 100% care from that date.(b)An interim care determination should not be made. Accordingly, the decision under review is affirmed.