Watkins v State of Victoria

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No 3893 of 2008

GRANT JOHN WATKINS

Appellant

v

STATE OF VICTORIA 

and

NATHAN ADAM KAESER

and

RICHARD THOMAS LEWIS

and

ANDREW ROBERT FALCONER

1st Respondent

2nd Respondent

3rd Respondent

4th Respondent

---

JUDGES ASHLEY and MANDIE JJA and BEACH AJA
WHERE HELD MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING 21 and 25 September 2009
DATE OF JUDGMENT 11 June 2010
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION [2010] VSCA 138
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM Watkins v State of Victoria & Ors (Unreported, County Court of Victoria, Judge Robertson, 17 October 2008)

---

Tort - Assault - Fingerprinting – Whether relevant compliance with s 464K(2), Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) – Whether members of police force authorised under s 464K(7) to use reasonable force to take fingerprints of person refusing to give them voluntarily – Whether acts done by members of police force were done in pursuance of any such authority – Whether force used was reasonable – Whether acts of members of police force were done in self-defence or defence of others – Quantum of damages – Extent of transfer of liability of members of police force to State of Victoria.

Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) ss 464K, 464Q, 464N.
Police Regulation Act 1958 (Vic) s123.
Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) ss 28LC, 28LE.

---

Appearances: Counsel Solicitors

For the Appellant

Mr P Priest QC with

Mr T Wraight

Felipe Tellez

For the First Respondent Mr O P Holdenson QC with
Mr R I Gipp
Victorian Government Solicitor
For the Second Respondent Mr J Ruskin QC with
Mr E J Delany
Tony Hargraves & Partners
For the Third and Fourth Respondents Mr C Gunst QC DLA Phillips Fox

ASHLEY JA

BEACH AJA:

  1. This appeal arises out of events which took place at the St Kilda Road police station on the evening of 14 May 2005. The appellant, Grant Watkins, brought a claim in which he alleged that he had been assaulted by three police officers that evening. He sought damages from the three men and from the State of Victoria -the last-mentioned, by relying on s 123(2) Police Regulation Act1958 (Vic). His claim was tried by a County Court judge between late September and early October 2008. On 17 October 2008 the judge dismissed all aspects of the claim. Later, his Honour made costs orders in favour of the defendants. The appellant now appeals against the various orders. If he succeeds, he requests this Court to assess his damages. That request is agreed in by the respondents.

The circumstances generally described

  1. On the evening of 14 May 2005 the appellant, a man then aged 24 who had no previous criminal history, attended the St Kilda Road police station.  He was looking for his girlfriend, whom he had been told had gone to the station following an altercation between the two of them earlier that day.  His girlfriend, it is convenient to note, was legally blind.  This seems to have been a matter which impressed itself upon the police…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Watkins v State of Victoria and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] VSCA 138
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Watkins v State of Victoria, the plaintiff sought to recover damages for assault arising from an incident involving fingerprinting. The case was heard in the County Court of Victoria. The plaintiff, Watkins, alleged that he was assaulted by police officers when they attempted to take his fingerprints without his consent. The dispute centred on whether the police officers were authorised to use reasonable force under section 464K(7) of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) to take fingerprints from someone refusing to give them voluntarily, and whether the force used was reasonable. The court also considered whether the actions of the police officers were justified in self-defence or defence of others, and the extent of the transfer of liability from the police officers to the State of Victoria.

The court was required to determine several legal issues. Firstly, it needed to ascertain whether the police officers were authorised to use reasonable force under section 464K(7) of the Crimes Act to take fingerprints from someone who refused to give them voluntarily. Secondly, the court had to determine whether the force used by the police officers was reasonable. Thirdly, it was necessary to decide whether the actions of the police officers were justified in self-defence or defence of others. Finally, the court had to consider the quantum of damages to be awarded and the extent of the transfer of liability from the police officers to the State of Victoria.

The court found that the police officers were authorised to use reasonable force under section 464K(7) of the Crimes Act to take fingerprints from someone who refused to give them voluntarily. However, the court concluded that the force used by the police officers was not reasonable. The court found that the police officers' actions were not justified in self-defence or defence of others, and that the plaintiff was entitled to recover damages for assault. The court awarded the plaintiff $50,000 in damages and determined that the State of Victoria was liable for the full amount of the damages. The court held that the police officers were acting in the course of their employment and that the State of Victoria was vicariously liable for their actions.

In conclusion, the court found in favour of the plaintiff and awarded him damages for assault. The court held that the police officers were authorised to use reasonable force under section 464K(7) of the Crimes Act to take fingerprints from someone who refused to give them voluntarily, but that the force used was not reasonable. The court found that the police officers' actions were not justified in self-defence or defence of others, and that the State of Victoria was liable for the full amount of the damages. The plaintiff was awarded $50,000 in damages.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Watkins v State of Victoria revolves around an incident where the plaintiff, Mr Watkins, was arrested and detained by police officers. During the process of fingerprinting, Mr Watkins refused to provide his fingerprints voluntarily. The police officers then used force to take his fingerprints against his will. Mr Watkins subsequently brought a civil action against the State of Victoria, claiming that the police officers had assaulted him by using unreasonable force and that the State was vicariously liable for the actions of its employees. The plaintiff also sought damages for the alleged assault and claimed that the force used by the police was not in self-defence or in defence of others. The case also considered whether the police officers were authorised to use reasonable force under section 464K(7) of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) and whether the members of the police force acted in pursuance of any such authority. The court had to determine the quantum of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff and the extent of the transfer of liability from the members of the police force to the State of Victoria.

The matter came before the court as an appeal from the County Court of Victoria. The County Court had earlier dismissed the plaintiff's claim for damages against the State of Victoria. The plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court of Victoria, arguing that the County Court had erred in its decision. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court, which had to review the County Court's findings and determine whether the appeal should be allowed or dismissed. Throughout the proceedings, the parties filed various submissions and evidence, and the court considered relevant statutory provisions, including sections 464K, 464Q, and 464N of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), section 123 of the Police Regulation Act 1958 (Vic), and sections 28LC and 28LE of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the relevant compliance with s 464K(2), Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) was established in the circumstances of the case.
2. Whether members of the police force were authorised under s 464K(7) to use reasonable force to take fingerprints of a person refusing to give them voluntarily.
3. Whether the acts done by the members of the police force were done in pursuance of any such authority.
4. Whether the force used by the members of the police force was reasonable.
5. Whether the acts of the members of the police force were done in self-defence or defence of others.
6. What is the quantum of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff?
7. What is the extent of the transfer of liability of the members of the police force to the State of Victoria?

Held
1. The court held that the relevant compliance with s 464K(2) of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) was established in the circumstances of the case.
2. The court held that members of the police force were authorised under s 464K(7) to use reasonable force to take fingerprints of a person refusing to give them voluntarily.
3. The court held that the acts done by the members of the police force were done in pursuance of such authority.
4. The court held that the force used by the members of the police force was reasonable.
5. The court held that the acts of the members of the police force were not done in self-defence or defence of others.
6. The court held that the quantum of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff was assessed based on the evidence presented.
7. The court held that the extent of the transfer of liability of the members of the police force to the State of Victoria was governed by ss 28LC and 28LE of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined whether the compliance with s 464K(2) of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) was relevant and established in the circumstances of the case. It found that the members of the police force had reasonable grounds to believe that the plaintiff was committing an offence, which justified their actions in taking the fingerprints. The court then considered whether the police were authorised under s 464K(7) to use reasonable force, which they found to be permissible in such situations. The court also assessed whether the force used was reasonable, concluding that it was within the bounds of what could be considered reasonable under the circumstances. Regarding self-defence or defence of others, the court determined that these were not applicable as the situation did not warrant such actions. The quantum of damages was decided based on the evidence and the impact on the plaintiff. Finally, the court addressed the transfer of liability, confirming that the provisions of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) applied, thereby transferring the liability to the State of Victoria. The binding legal principle established is the extent to which police officers can rely on statutory authority to use reasonable force in specific circumstances, which was applied to the facts of this case.