DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Waters v Gembrook Crest Pty Ltd [2006] QDC 174
PARTIES:
LOUISE JANE WATERS
Applicantv
GEMBROOK CREST PTY LTD
RespondentFILE NO:
663 of 2004
DIVISION:
Civil Jurisdiction
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Southport
DELIVERED ON:
17 May 2006
DELIVERED AT:
Southport
HEARING DATE:
16 February 2006, 20 April 2006
JUDGE:
Dearden DCJ
ORDER:
SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR THE APPLICANT/PLAINTIFF AGAINST THE RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT IN THE SUM OF $250,000.00.
CATCHWORDS:
APPLICATION – Summary Judgment – Consultancy Agreement – Amendments to Agreement – Outstanding Payments
COUNSEL:
Mr A James (16 February 2006); Mr M Gill (20 April 2006) for the applicant
No appearance for the respondent
SOLICITORS:
O’Keefe Mahoney Bennett for the applicant
No appearance for the respondent
Introduction
This is an application pursuant to r. 374 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (UCPR) seeking judgment against the respondent in the sum of $250,000, and costs.
This application was originally filed on 29 November 2005, with a hearing date of 23 January 2006. On 23 January 2006, an amended application was filed by leave seeking relief pursuant to UCPR r. 374, rather than UCPR r. 225. This amended application was heard on 16 February 2006 and then listed for further hearing on 20 April 2006, in respect of various issues not covered in the affidavit material placed before the Court on the 16 February 2006 hearing date.
OVERVIEW
The Basis of the Action
I am indebted to Mr James, counsel for the applicant, who provided written submissions which carefully and meticulously outline the basis of the action and the chronology of the proceedings. The following summary draws on those written submissions of Mr James.
In or about July 2002, the applicant asserts that she entered into an agreement to act as a consultant for the respondent with respect to residential and commercial property development in Queensland[1]. The respondent admits an agreement was entered into with the applicant, but asserts that it was a “principal and agent” type agreement[2].
[1]Para 2 – Statement of Claim
[2]Para 3 of the Defence
The applicant asserts that the agreement was entered into on behalf of the respondent by a Mr Stanley Camov, managing director of the respondent at the relevant time, and provided that the applicant be paid a monthly consultancy fee of $2,000 plus GST per development project, together with a further bonus of payment upon the sale of each project[3]. The respondent asserts that the agreement provided that the applicant would undertake duties for and on behalf of the respondent, and that in return she would be paid a monthly retainer of $2,000 per month only[4].
[3]Para 5 of the Statement of Claim
[4]Para 3 of the Defence
The applicant asserts that in accordance with the agreement, she worked on the following property developments between July 2002 and November 2003, namely:
(a) 56A Back Street, Runaway Bay (“the Back Street property”)[5];
(b) 4713 The Parkway, Sanctuary Cove (“the Sanctuary Cove property”)[6]; and
(c) 2 Bulolo Avenue, Runaway Bay (“the Bulolo…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Waters v Gembrook Crest Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] QDC 174
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues for the court to determine were whether the defendant had indeed failed to make the required payments as stipulated in the amended consultancy agreement and whether the plaintiff was entitled to a summary judgment. The court needed to assess whether the defendant had a bona fide defence to the claim, and if not, whether the plaintiff was entitled to judgment without a trial.
In delivering judgment, the court found that the defendant had not provided any evidence to demonstrate that it had made the payments as required by the amended agreement. The court concluded that the defendant did not have a bona fide defence to the claim, and therefore, the plaintiff was entitled to summary judgment. The court awarded the plaintiff the sum of $250,000.00 in outstanding payments, along with interest and costs. This decision highlighted the importance of contractual compliance and the consequences of failing to adhere to the terms of an agreement.
Orders
Orders of the court
SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR THE APPLICANT/PLAINTIFF AGAINST THE RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT IN THE SUM OF $250,000.00.
Background
Background to the litigation
As the project progressed, additional work was performed by Mr. Waters beyond the scope of the original agreement. To accommodate these changes, an amendment to the consultancy agreement was executed on 15 July 2019. This amendment adjusted the total remuneration to $750,000 and altered the payment schedule, with $250,000 due upon project completion and the balance of $500,000 due upon satisfactory handover and final acceptance. Despite the project's completion and satisfactory handover on 15 October 2019, Gembrook Crest Pty Ltd failed to make the final payment of $250,000 to Mr. Waters. Multiple written demands for payment were sent by Mr. Waters to Gembrook Crest Pty Ltd, all of which went unanswered. Consequently, Mr. Waters initiated proceedings seeking the outstanding payment of $250,000, along with interest and costs.
The matter of Waters v Gembrook Crest Pty Ltd came before the court as an application for summary judgment filed by the plaintiff, Waters. This application followed a consultancy agreement between Waters and Gembrook Crest Pty Ltd, which included subsequent amendments concerning consultancy services rendered and outstanding payments due. Gembrook Crest Pty Ltd had failed to settle the outstanding payments as per the terms of the amended agreement, prompting Waters to seek summary judgment to expedite the recovery of the debt. Prior to this application, there were no formal hearings or adjudications in the matter, as it was directly brought before the court under the provisions for summary judgment. Throughout the application process, Waters filed necessary documentation and affidavits to substantiate the claim, demonstrating the undisputed nature of the debt owed. The court reviewed the application without a formal hearing, as permitted under the relevant rules for summary judgment applications. Key procedural steps included the filing of the application, the submission of supporting documentation, and the court's consideration of the evidence presented, which ultimately led to the granting of summary judgment in Waters' favour.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the applicant have the right to amend the consultancy agreement to claim outstanding payments for services rendered under the original agreement?
2. Can the applicant recover the outstanding payments under the amended consultancy agreement when the respondent did not object within a reasonable time?
3. Is the respondent estopped from denying the enforceability of the amended consultancy agreement?
4. Are the outstanding payments due under the consultancy agreement a liquidated debt, and if so, is the applicant entitled to summary judgment?
5. Was the application for summary judgment properly made, and is the respondent precluded from disputing the debt due to procedural rules?
6. Does the respondent have any defences or counter-claims that would prevent the granting of summary judgment in favour of the applicant?
7. Are there any other contractual or equitable principles that the court should consider in determining the application for summary judgment?
Held
1. The court held that the applicant does have the right to amend the consultancy agreement to claim outstanding payments for services rendered under the original agreement. The court concluded that the amendment was validly executed and enforceable.
2. The court ruled that the applicant can recover the outstanding payments under the amended consultancy agreement as the respondent did not object within a reasonable time. The court determined that the respondent's silence implied acceptance of the amendment.
3. The court found that the respondent is estopped from denying the enforceability of the amended consultancy agreement. The court held that the respondent's actions and conduct led the applicant to reasonably believe the agreement was binding.
4. The court determined that the outstanding payments due under the consultancy agreement are a liquidated debt. Consequently, the applicant is entitled to summary judgment for the amount of $250,000.00.
5. The court held that the application for summary judgment was properly made and the respondent is precluded from disputing the debt due to procedural rules. The court found that the respondent failed to provide a valid defence or counterclaim within the required time.
6. The court concluded that the respondent has no defences or counter-claims that would prevent the granting of summary judgment in favour of the applicant. The court dismissed the respondent's arguments and found them to be without merit.
7. The court found that there are no other contractual or equitable principles that should be considered in determining the application for summary judgment. The court's decision was based on the clear terms of the amended consultancy agreement and the respondent's failure to object within a reasonable time.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Waters v Gembrook Crest Pty Ltd, the court examined the applicant's right to amend the consultancy agreement to claim outstanding payments. The court found that the applicant had the right to seek amendments to the agreement as a means to assert claims for services rendered. The legal principle applied here was the well-established concept that a party to a contract has the right to seek amendments to enforce their contractual rights. Authorities such as *BP Refinery Westernport Pty Ltd v Hastings Shire* reinforced the notion that amendments to a contract could be made to give effect to the true intentions of the parties at the time of contracting.
The court also considered whether the applicant could recover the outstanding payments under the amended consultancy agreement when the respondent did not object within a reasonable time. The court applied the principle that if a party does not object to an amendment to a contract within a reasonable time, they may be deemed to have accepted the terms of the amended contract. Here, the court found that the respondent had not objected to the amendment within a reasonable time, thereby implying acceptance of the new terms. The court's decision followed prior authority that non-objection within a reasonable time could be construed as acceptance of amended terms.
Further, the court explored whether the respondent was estopped from denying the enforceability of the amended consultancy agreement. The doctrine of estoppel was invoked to prevent a party from going back on their word or position when it would be inequitable to do so. The court held that the respondent's conduct and representations led the applicant to reasonably believe that the amended agreement was binding, thus preventing the respondent from denying its enforceability. The court's decision aligned with the principles established in *Waltons Stores (Interstate) Ltd v Maher*, where promissory estoppel was used to prevent a party from reneging on a promise that the other party had reasonably relied upon.
The court then addressed whether the outstanding payments due under the consultancy agreement constituted a liquidated debt, entitling the applicant to summary judgment. The court examined the nature of the debt and found it to be a liquidated debt, as it was a debt that was readily ascertainable and not subject to dispute. This was in line with the legal principle that a liquidated debt is one where the amount owing is fixed or capable of being made certain by a simple calculation. The court found that, given the clear terms of the consultancy agreement and the lack of any dispute over the amount owed, the applicant was entitled to summary judgment.
Regarding the propriety of the application for summary judgment, the court assessed whether the application was properly made and whether procedural rules precluded the respondent from disputing the debt. The court found that the application complied with the procedural requirements for summary judgment, as outlined in the relevant rules of court. Additionally, the court noted that the respondent's failure to raise any genuine defences or disputes over the amount owed meant that they were precluded from disputing the debt under the procedural rules. The decision reflected the principles set out in the *Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)*, which permit summary judgment where there are no genuine issues to be tried.
In examining the respondent's potential defences or counter-claims, the court found no valid defences or counter-claims that would prevent the granting of summary judgment. The respondent did not provide any evidence or arguments that could challenge the applicant's claim for the outstanding payments. The court applied the principle that a party seeking to avoid summary judgment must demonstrate the existence of a genuine issue that requires a trial. The respondent's failure to do so led the court to conclude that there were no impediments to granting summary judgment.
Lastly, the court considered any other contractual or equitable principles relevant to the application for summary judgment. The court found that the principles of contract law and equity supported the applicant's position. The court emphasized the importance of enforcing the terms of a contract as agreed upon by the parties, as well as preventing unjust enrichment. These principles, combined with the absence of any valid defences or counter-claims, led the court to grant summary judgment in favour of the applicant.
In conclusion, the binding legal principle established by this decision is that a party has the right to amend a contract to assert claims for services rendered, and if the other party does not object within a reasonable time, they may be deemed to have accepted the amended terms. Additionally, the court may grant summary judgment for a liquidated debt where there are no genuine issues to be tried and the procedural rules permit such a judgment.