[2008] QDC 284
DISTRICT COURT
CIVIL JURISDICTION
JUDGE ROBIN QC
No 507 of 2008
| HENDON HOMES PTY LTD | Plaintiff |
| and | |
| CENTENNIAL GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD | Defendant |
BRISBANE
..DATE 19/11/2008
ORDER
CATCHWORDS: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 374(5)(a),
r 374(8) - judgment in accordance with the claim awarded against defendant failing to make disclosure as ordered by a judge - defence was evasive - defendant did not appear - plaintiff refused indemnity costs of the application - plaintiff refused indemnity costs of the proceeding generally, even assuming that it had made an offer to settle less favourably.
HIS HONOUR: This is a plaintiff's application under rule 374 for judgment under sub-rule 5(a). It is based, as the relevant application conformably with the rule's requirements sets out, on the defendant's failure to comply with an order of Judge Collins of the 25th of September 2008 requiring the defendant to provide disclosure pursuant to rule 211 within 14 days.
That application was dealt with in the absence of the respondent, as was an application by its solicitors on the record for leave to withdraw, which Judge Koppenol determined on the 10th of October 2008. That order made no arrangement for providing the plaintiff with any address for service. What the plaintiff has done, and justifiably in my opinion, is rely on the address of the defendant company indicated in the notice of intention to defend, being an address in New South Wales.
That, according to searches, represents the defendant's principal place of business. It also has a registered office in New South Wales care of a firm of accountants. Very likely it was the advice of Judge Collins's order which led to the solicitors pulling out.
The defence is a lengthy document but one I would assess as conveying little or nothing by way of useful information or allegations. It can fairly be characterised as evasive.
That observation has some relevance. There is a comparison favourable to the plaintiff to be made with its statement of claim. The plaintiff is a builder which, according to the pleaded case, got involved with the defendant - described by Mr Adames from the Bar table as a "marketeer", although that's by the by. Its role appears to have been to locate people who would become clients of the plaintiff which was willing to bear certain costs and make certain payments to the defendant in expectation in getting valuable contracts.
Its claim, which is slightly in excess of $120,000 before interest, is, in essence, for recovery from the defendant of $75,000 paid to it, being three payments of $25,000 which it pleads it made on the completion of land contracts whereby the prospective customers acquired land in Queensland where it was expected houses would be erected for them.
The balance of the claim is for particularised outlays which the plaintiff met by way of payments to local authorities or private building certifiers for the approvals for construction and the like.
In retrospect, it is perhaps unfortunate that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hendon Homes Pty Ltd v. Centennial Group Holdings Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] QDC 284
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to decide whether to grant the plaintiff's application for judgment under rule 374(5)(a) due to the defendant's non-compliance with a disclosure order, and if so, whether to award indemnity costs. The court needed to consider the appropriateness of penalising the defendant for non-compliance with the court's order, and whether the plaintiff was entitled to succeed on the merits without the defendant's evidence. The court also had to determine if the plaintiff was entitled to indemnity costs given the defendant's failure to settle despite an offer that could have potentially reduced the costs.
The court, after considering the relevant factors, decided to grant the plaintiff's application for judgment under rule 374(5)(a). The court was persuaded that the defendant's failure to comply with the disclosure order warranted such a judgment, and that the plaintiff was entitled to succeed on the merits. However, the court refused to award indemnity costs to the plaintiff, reasoning that the plaintiff was obtaining a judgment quickly and at a relatively low cost. The court also noted that the plaintiff had received an offer to settle from the defendant, which was for a lesser amount than the judgment awarded. The court held that these circumstances did not warrant the award of indemnity costs.
The final order of the court was to grant the plaintiff's application for judgment under rule 374(5)(a), awarding the plaintiff the full amount claimed. The court also ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of the application and the proceeding generally, but refused to award indemnity costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
On 25 September 2008, Judge Collins ordered the defendant to provide disclosure under rule 211 within 14 days. Despite this order, the defendant failed to comply, leading the plaintiff to apply for judgment under rule 374(5)(a) due to the defendant's non-compliance. The defendant did not appear in court, and its defence was considered evasive, providing little useful information. The plaintiff refused to accept indemnity costs for the application or the proceeding generally, even assuming an offer to settle had been made. The plaintiff based its address for service on the defendant's principal place of business in New South Wales, as indicated in the notice of intention to defend. The defendant's solicitors withdrew from the case, likely due to the judge's order, leaving the defendant without representation.
The matter of Hendon Homes Pty Ltd v. Centennial Group Holdings Pty Ltd came before the District Court of Queensland in a plaintiff's application under rule 374 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The plaintiff, Hendon Homes Pty Ltd, sought judgment against the defendant, Centennial Group Holdings Pty Ltd, for the defendant's failure to comply with an order from Judge Collins dated 25 September 2008, which required the defendant to provide disclosure within 14 days. This application was made in the absence of the defendant, who did not appear before the court. Furthermore, the defendant's solicitors had applied for and were granted leave to withdraw from the case by Judge Koppenol on 10 October 2008, a decision which did not arrange for the plaintiff to be provided with any address for service. The plaintiff had reasonably relied on the address provided by the defendant in the notice of intention to defend, situated in New South Wales, which was deemed to be the defendant's principal place of business. The defendant's defence was considered evasive and lacking in useful information or allegations. The plaintiff's claim, amounting to slightly over $120,000 before interest, was for the recovery of $75,000 paid to the defendant and additional outlays for construction approvals. Despite the extended time allowed for compliance, the defendant did not make the required disclosure, raising suspicions that defending the proceeding was futile. The court was persuaded to use rule 374 to its fullest extent, entering a judgment against the defendant, though it declined to award indemnity costs as requested by the plaintiff's counsel.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court can enter judgment against a defendant who fails to comply with an order to provide disclosure under rule 211 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.
2. If so, what are the appropriate grounds and circumstances for such a judgment, including potential penalties, notional striking out, or determination on the merits.
3. Whether the defendant's failure to provide disclosure justifies the harsh consequence of a judgment for a large amount of money, and if so, under what conditions.
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to indemnity costs for the application and generally, despite obtaining a judgment quickly and at low cost.
5. Whether the defendant's offer to settle at a later stage affects the plaintiff's entitlement to indemnity costs.
Held
1. The court can enter judgment against a defendant who fails to comply with an order to provide disclosure under rule 211 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The court concluded that it is appropriate to use rule 374 in the harshest way its terms envisaged by a judgment against the defendant.
2. The appropriate grounds and circumstances for such a judgment include effectively penalising the defendant for not complying with the court's order, notional striking out of steps taken by a defendant to protect itself against judgment, and the court reaching the judgment that upon the merits the plaintiff appears entitled to succeed. The court awarded the judgment based on the defendant's failure to provide disclosure as ordered.
3. The defendant's failure to provide disclosure justifies the harsh consequence of a judgment for a large amount of money if it appears the defendant realises defence of the proceeding is pointless or without the means or ability to defend. The court awarded a significant judgment amount to the plaintiff based on the defendant's non-compliance.
4. The plaintiff is not entitled to indemnity costs for the application and generally, despite obtaining a judgment quickly and at low cost. The court refused to entertain an application for indemnity costs in this case.
5. The defendant's offer to settle at a later stage does not affect the plaintiff's entitlement to indemnity costs. The court was not inclined to entertain an application for indemnity costs, despite the defendant's offer to settle for a more modest sum.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court in Hendon Homes Pty Ltd v. Centennial Group Holdings Pty Ltd grappled with the application of rule 374 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, focusing on the consequences of a defendant's failure to comply with a disclosure order. The court first established that it has the authority to enter judgment against a defendant who fails to comply with a disclosure order under rule 211. The court considered three potential bases for such a judgment: penalising the defendant for non-compliance, a notional striking out under rule 371, and determining the case on the merits. The court found that the defendant's evasive and non-compliant conduct justified a judgment against it, though it exercised restraint in not imposing the full amount claimed by the plaintiff, reflecting the need to balance fairness with the procedural misconduct.
In assessing the appropriate grounds and circumstances for such a judgment, the court highlighted the necessity of ensuring justice and maintaining the integrity of the judicial process. While the court acknowledged the principle that harsh consequences should be avoided, it underscored the importance of enforcing compliance with court orders. The court distinguished between penalising non-compliance and determining the merits of the case, opting for the former in this instance due to the defendant's lack of meaningful response. The court also noted that, under sub-rule (8) of rule 374, the defendant retains the option to seek to set aside the judgment if it chooses to defend the claim, thereby providing a safety net against overly punitive measures.
Regarding the harsh consequence of a judgment for a large sum of money, the court determined that it was warranted in this case due to the defendant's blatant disregard for the court's order. The court rejected the notion that such a severe outcome was appropriate unless there were compelling circumstances, which it found present here due to the defendant's evasive and non-responsive behaviour. The court's decision to limit the judgment amount to what it deemed appropriate reflected a nuanced approach, balancing the need for deterrence with the specifics of the case.
The plaintiff's entitlement to indemnity costs for the application and generally was another key issue the court addressed. The court declined to award indemnity costs, noting that the plaintiff had obtained a judgment quickly and at a relatively low cost, which typically would not warrant such an award. Despite the defendant's late offer to settle, the court found that this did not alter the outcome on costs, as the plaintiff had not unreasonably delayed in pursuing its claim. The court emphasised the principle that indemnity costs are not automatically granted and must be justified by the circumstances of each case.
The court's decision in Hendon Homes Pty Ltd v. Centennial Group Holdings Pty Ltd underscores the importance of enforcing procedural rules while maintaining a balanced approach to the consequences of non-compliance. The court applied established legal principles regarding the enforcement of disclosure orders and the imposition of penalties for non-compliance, distinguishing between punitive measures and the merits of the case. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that while courts have the authority to enter judgment against defendants who fail to comply with disclosure orders, such judgments should be carefully considered and tailored to the specific circumstances of the case, with a preference for avoiding unduly harsh outcomes unless justified by the defendant's conduct.