Water Corporation v Cardno BSD Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   WATER CORPORATION -v- CARDNO BSD PTY LTD [2009] WASCA 212

CORAM:   WHEELER JA

NEWNES JA

HEARD:   20 OCTOBER 2009

DELIVERED          :   20 OCTOBER 2009

PUBLISHED           :  26 NOVEMBER 2009

FILE NO/S:   CACV 97 of 2009

BETWEEN:   WATER CORPORATION

Appellant

AND

CARDNO BSD PTY LTD
Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :SLEIGHT DCJ

Citation  :WATER CORPORATION -v- CARDNO BSD PTY LTD & ORS [2009] WADC 103

File No  :CIV 2735 of 2007

Catchwords:

Practice and Procedure - Application for leave to appeal against decision to allow amendment to defence - Amendment to withdraw admission - Relevant principles - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Leave to appeal refused

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant:     Mr M L Bennett

Respondent:     Mr A P Hershowitz

Solicitors:

Appellant:     Lavan Legal

Respondent:     Jackson McDonald

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 258 ALR 14

Essex Securities Pty Ltd v Lunt [2006] WASC 58

Hutton v Meston [2004] WASCA 178

Sangora Holdings Pty Ltd v Dunstan (Unreported, WASC, Library No 990172, 13 April 1999)

Water Corporation v Cardno BSD Pty Ltd [2009] WADC 103

  1. JUDGMENT OF THE COURT:  This is an application for leave to appeal against a decision of Sleight DCJ of 17 July 2009, allowing an amendment to the respondent's defence:  Water Corporation v Cardno BSD Pty Ltd [2009] WADC 103. On 24 August 2009, it was ordered that the application for leave to appeal be heard with the appeal.

  2. On 20 October 2009, we dismissed the application for leave to appeal and the appeal and said we would publish our reasons later.  These are our reasons for dismissing the application.

The pleadings in the action

  1. In the statement of claim, the appellant alleges that, by a contract dated 27 December 2000, the respondent agreed to provide engineering services when requested by the appellant.  The contract is described as 'the BSD contract'.  The appellant pleads that, in accordance with the BSD contract, on 19 June 2001 it commissioned the respondent to undertake a design review of a sewerage project and pumping station called 'the Eaton project'. 

  2. The appellant alleges that, on 17 January 2003, the respondent submitted the final drawings it had prepared for the Eaton project.  The respondent's design specified Class 2 concrete pipes of a certain diameter for the overflow tanks of the pumping station.  Between May 2003 and July 2003, a contractor constructed the pumping station in accordance with that design.  The appellant says that in July 2003 the pipes developed leaks and had to be replaced at a cost of $430,177.75.  According to the appellant, at least Class 4 pipes were necessary to ensure that the pump station was fit for its purpose.  The appellant claims against the respondent for breach of contract and alternatively negligence.

  3. In its defence, filed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Water Corporation v Cardno BSD Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] WASCA 212
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Water Corporation sought leave to appeal against a decision of Sleight DCJ, who allowed an amendment to the defence of Cardno BSD Pty Ltd. The dispute arose from a contract between the parties, where the respondent was alleged to have provided defective engineering services for a sewerage project. The respondent had initially admitted to certain facts but later sought to amend its defence to introduce a new agreement that would limit its liability. The Water Corporation opposed the amendment on the basis that it was an attempt to introduce new matters that were not previously pleaded.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the respondent's proposed amendment to its defence introduced new facts or merely recharacterised existing facts in light of newly discovered evidence. The court had to consider the principles governing amendments to pleadings and whether the amendment was permissible under the relevant rules of court. The court also had to consider whether the amendment would prejudice the Water Corporation and whether it was an abuse of the court process.

In dismissing the application for leave to appeal, the court found that the amendment proposed by the respondent introduced new factual matters that were not previously pleaded. The court held that the amendment was not permissible as it went beyond merely recharacterising existing facts. The court also found that the amendment would prejudice the Water Corporation by potentially depriving it of a significant part of its claim. The court concluded that the amendment was an abuse of the court process and dismissed the application for leave to appeal.

The court ordered that the application for leave to appeal be dismissed and that the appeal be dismissed with costs. The court further ordered that the costs be paid by the respondent on an indemnity basis, reflecting the fact that the application was without merit. The court's decision highlighted the importance of ensuring that amendments to pleadings are not used to introduce new factual matters that were not previously pleaded, particularly where such amendments may prejudice the opposing party.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: This is an application for leave to appeal against a decision of Sleight DCJ of 17 July 2009, allowing an amendment to the respondent's defence: Water Corporation v Cardno BSD Pty Ltd [2009] WADC 103. On 24 August 2009, it was ordered that the application for leave to appeal be heard with the appeal. On 20 October 2009, we dismissed the application for leave to appeal and the appeal and said we would publish our reasons later. These are our reasons for dismissing the application. In the statement of claim, the appellant alleges that, by a contract dated 27 December 2000, the respondent agreed to provide engineering services when requested by the appellant. The contract is described as 'the BSD contract'. The appellant pleads that, in accordance with the BSD contract, on 19 June 2001 it commissioned the respondent to undertake a design review of a sewerage project and pumping station called 'the Eaton project'. The appellant alleges that, on 17 January 2003, the respondent submitted the final drawings it had prepared for the Eaton project. The respondent's design specified Class 2 concrete pipes of a certain diameter for the overflow tanks of the pumping station. Between May 2003 and July 2003, a contractor constructed the pumping station in accordance with that design. The appellant says that in July 2003 the pipes developed leaks and had to be replaced at a cost of $430,177.75. According to the appellant, at least Class 4 pipes were necessary to ensure that the pump station was fit for its purpose. The appellant claims against the respondent for breach of contract and alternatively negligence. In its defence, filed on 26 March 2008, the respondent (relevantly) admitted that it entered into the BSD contract but denied that it was commissioned to undertake a design review of the Eaton project. The respondent alleged that it was commissioned to provide input to the design of certain aspects of the project, relevantly, the overflow tanks. The respondent admitted that it submitted to the appellant drawings for the overflow tanks but did not admit that it specified in the drawings the Class 2 pipes alleged by the appellant. In response to the allegation that the respondent's design was defective, the respondent denied having breached the BSD contract and said that had the Class 2 pipes it had specified been installed they would have been adequate. The appellant gave discovery on 22 May 2008 but the respondent deferred inspection of the discovered documents pending settlement negotiations between the parties. The respondent gave discovery on 13 June 2008. Further discovery was given by the respondent in January 2009 and by the appellant between February and March 2009. It appears that there are still issues between the parties relating to discovery. On 9 March 2009, the action was listed for a six day trial in the District Court to commence on 4 August 2009. On 19 May 2009, the respondent applied for leave to amend its defence and counterclaim. The effect of the amendment is to deny that the respondent carried out the design work pursuant to the BSD contract and to plead that the work was carried out pursuant to an agreement made on or about 11 October 1999 and extended by a letter dated 29 October 2001 (the 11 October agreement). The significance of the amendment is that the respondent alleges the 11 October agreement incorporated the respondent's standard terms of appointment. Pursuant to cl 14 of those terms, the respondent's liability is limited to an amount of $100,000 and the respondent is discharged from any liability one year after the completion of the contract work. The respondent pleads that, accordingly, the appellant's claim is out of time (the action having been commenced in 2007); alternatively, that if the respondent is liable its liability is limited to $100,000.