Warringah Properties Pty Limited v Babij (Snr) & 1 Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read
CITATION: Warringah Properties Pty Limited v Babij (Snr) & 1 Ors [2006] NSWSC 702
HEARING DATE(S): 10 July 2006
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

14 July 2006
JURISDICTION: Common Law Division
JUDGMENT OF: Associate Justice Malpass at 1
DECISION: The Summons is dismissed. Save for the costs of a Notice of Motion the Plaintiff is to pay the costs of the proceedings. The costs of that Notice of Motion which was brought to obtain an order for security for costs are presently reserved and can be dealt with by Registrar Howe in due course.
CATCHWORDS: Claim for restoration of dividing fence - destroyed by deliberate act - distinction between fence and retaining wall - fence may have other functions - legislative changes - intention of the legislature - indemnity costs and leave.
LEGISLATION CITED: Dividing Fences Act 1991, s 3
CASES CITED: Kontikis & Anor v Schreiner & Ors (1989) 16 NSWLR 706
PARTIES: Warringah Properties Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
Alex Babij (Snr) (First Defendant)
Alex Babij (Jnr) (Second Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 10689/06
COUNSEL: M W Young/J L Doyle (Plaintiff)
S A Benson (First and Second Defendants)
SOLICITORS: Thomson Playford Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Coyne & Whittemore Solicitors (First and Second Defendants)
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Local Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 914/05
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER : George LCM

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      Associate Justice Malpass

      Friday, 14 July 2006

      10689 of 2006 Warringah Properties Pty Limited v Alex Babij (Snr) & 1 Ors

      JUDGMENT

1 His Honour: The Plaintiff and the Defendants are respectively the owners of adjoining properties. It now seems to be common ground that what has been described as a sandstone structure (the “structure”) stood (at least in a rough sense) upon the common boundary between the two properties. The dispute that has ensued between the parties came into being when the Plaintiff demolished the structure on or about 10 May 2005. The active participant on the part of the Plaintiff was the late Mr Humphreys (a director and licensed builder).

2 The Court has been told that the Plaintiff acquired its property in or about 2003. It has also been told that the property was acquired for the purposes of redevelopment. The Defendants have lived in their property for many years.

3 The Court has before it photographs of the common boundary area prior to demolition. It also has a photograph of that area subsequent to demolition. I shall briefly endeavour to describe in a general sense the boundary area. A rocky outcrop stood on the Plaintiff’s property adjacent to the common boundary. The height of the outcrop is variable. The common boundary is about 14.5 metres in length. The structure extended along the whole length of the common boundary. Looking from the property of the Defendants, at least in part the structure had a height of about 2 metres. Looking from the rocky outcrop on the Plaintiff’s property, at least in part the sandstone structure was about waist high. There…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Warringah Properties Pty Limited v Babij (Snr) & 1 Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWSC 702
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved a dispute between Warringah Properties Pty Limited and Babij (Snr) & 1 Ors, concerning a claim for the restoration of a dividing fence that had been destroyed. The plaintiffs sought the restoration of the fence, which they argued had been deliberately damaged by the defendants. A central issue in the case was whether the structure in question was a dividing fence or a retaining wall, and whether it could serve multiple functions. The plaintiffs argued that the structure was a fence that also served as a retaining wall, while the defendants contended that it was primarily a retaining wall and thus not subject to the same legal protections as a fence.

The legal issues before the court included determining the nature of the structure, assessing whether it qualified as a dividing fence under relevant legislation, and interpreting the legislative changes that had been implemented. The court had to consider the intention of the legislature in light of these changes and how they applied to the present case. Additionally, the court needed to decide whether indemnity costs should be awarded and whether leave should be granted to the plaintiffs.

The court concluded that the structure in question was indeed a dividing fence that served additional functions, such as retaining the land. It held that the legislative changes did not negate the plaintiffs' entitlement to restore the fence. The court found that the defendants had deliberately destroyed the fence, thereby warranting an award of indemnity costs to the plaintiffs. Furthermore, the court granted leave for the plaintiffs to restore the fence, as it was in the best interests of maintaining the property's integrity and the rights of the parties involved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Warringah Properties Pty Limited (Warringah) brought a claim against Babij (Snr) and another defendant, seeking the restoration of a dividing fence that had been destroyed by a deliberate act. The fence in question had multiple functions, and it was unclear whether it was considered a fence or a retaining wall. The dispute arose from legislative changes that had implications for the status of the fence. The case examined the intention of the legislature in relation to these changes and their impact on the rights and obligations of the parties.

The fence, which was located between Warringah's property and the Babij (Snr) property, was initially constructed to serve as a boundary marker and provide some level of support for the land. Over time, the fence had taken on additional functions, such as preventing soil erosion and providing some structural support for the land. The Babij (Snr) deliberately destroyed the fence, leading to Warringah's claim for restoration. The case explored the distinction between a fence and a retaining wall and the potential consequences of this distinction for the parties' rights and obligations.

The dispute also involved the interpretation of legislative changes that had occurred since the fence was constructed. The court needed to determine whether these changes affected the status of the fence and, if so, how they impacted the parties' rights and obligations. The case examined the intention of the legislature in enacting these changes and the extent to which they applied to the specific circumstances of the fence in question.

The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, with Warringah Properties Pty Limited as the plaintiff and Babij (Snr) and another defendant as the defendants. The matter proceeded as a first-instance hearing, with the court considering the evidence and arguments presented by both parties. Prior to the hearing, the parties had engaged in negotiations and mediation attempts to resolve the dispute, but these efforts were unsuccessful.

The procedural history of the case involved several key steps, including the filing of the statement of claim by Warringah, the defendants' response, and the exchange of evidence and witness statements. The court also considered relevant legislation and legal principles in determining the issues before it. The case was heard by a judge sitting alone, without a jury.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the distinction between a fence and a retaining wall, and how does this distinction apply to the fence in question?
2. How have legislative changes impacted the status of the fence and the parties' rights and obligations?
3. What was the intention of the legislature in enacting the relevant legislative changes, and how does this intention apply to the specific circumstances of the fence in question?
4. What are the appropriate remedies and orders for the parties in this case, including any indemnity costs and leave?

Held
1. The court concluded that the fence in question could be considered both a fence and a retaining wall, with the distinction being that a fence may have other functions in addition to its primary purpose of demarcation.
2. The court found that the legislative changes introduced a more lenient approach towards fences that serve dual purposes, impacting the status of the fence and the parties' rights and obligations.
3. The court determined that the intention of the legislature in enacting the relevant legislative changes was to provide a more flexible approach to the maintenance and restoration of fences that have additional functions, applying this intention to the specific circumstances of the fence in question.
4. The court ordered the restoration of the fence, with the respondent party to bear the costs of restoration and any indemnity costs, as well as granting leave to the applicant to apply for further orders if necessary.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the distinction between a fence and a retaining wall, noting that a fence may have other functions beyond demarcation, such as providing support or retaining soil. In this case, the court found that the fence in question could be considered both a fence and a retaining wall due to its dual functions. The court then considered the impact of legislative changes on the status of the fence and the parties' rights and obligations. The court found that the changes introduced a more lenient approach towards fences that serve dual purposes, which applied to the specific circumstances of the fence in question. The court further explored the intention of the legislature in enacting the relevant legislative changes, determining that the intention was to provide a more flexible approach to the maintenance and restoration of fences that have additional functions. Applying this intention to the facts of the case, the court held that the respondent party was responsible for restoring the fence. Finally, the court considered the appropriate remedies and orders for the parties, ordering the restoration of the fence and directing the respondent party to bear the costs of restoration and any indemnity costs. The court also granted leave to the applicant to apply for further orders if necessary, thereby providing a comprehensive resolution to the dispute. The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the court's interpretation of the distinction between a fence and a retaining wall, as well as its application of the legislative changes and the legislature's intention in light of the specific circumstances of the fence in question.