Philip Mckay v Stuart Earl Greentree and Nadeen Maree Greentree

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Philip Mckay v Stuart Earl Greentree and Nadeen Maree Greentree [2014] NSWCATCD 69
Hearing dates:28 August 2013
Decision date: 07 May 2014
Before: P Boyce, Senior Member
Decision:

The application is dismissed

Catchwords: Sufficient Dividing fence, Retaining Wall
Legislation Cited: Dividing Fences Act 1991
Dividing Fences Act 1951
Crown Lands Act 1989
Civil And Administrative Tribunal Act 2013
Cases Cited: Alwiah v Watts And Anor [2004] NSWSC 948
Brown v Doyle [2012] NSWSC 1269
Larney v Johannson [2012] NSWSC 1297
Larney v Johannson [2013] NSWCA 409
Riggio v The Estate Of The Late Phyllis Annette Lockard [2011] NSWLEC 1292
Warringah Properties Pty Limited v Babij (Snr) And 1 Ors [2006] NSWSC 702
Kontikis & Anor v Schreiner & Ors (1989) 16 NSWLR 706
Riggio v The Estate Of The Late Phyllis Annette Lockard [2011] NSWLEC 1292
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Philip Mckay (applicant)
Stuart Earl Greentree and Nadeen Maree Greentree (respondents)
Representation: Applicant: In Person (Philip Mckay)
Respondents: Mr J David, Solicitor, Hansons Lawyers
Mr J David, Solicitor Hansons Lawyers (Stuart Earl Greentree Nadeen Maree Greentree (respondents)
File Number(s):COM 14/21132

reasons for decision

JURISDICTION

  1. This application was commenced by filing on 18 March 2013 in the registry of the Local Land Board.

  1. The application was heard by the Board on 28 August 2013.

  1. On 29 August 2013 the Chairperson conducted a view of the subject land without the presence of the parties, but with their consent.

  1. The time for making written submissions ceased on 25 October 2013.

  1. On 31 December 2013 the provision in the Crown Lands Act 1989 establishing and granting jurisdiction to the Local Land Borards were repealed.

  1. Division 3 of Schedule 1 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 contains savings and transitional provision for pending proceedings commenced before 1 January 2014 in an existing Tribunal that has been abolished.

  1. NCAT may determine such matters and exercise all functions that the relevant existing Tribunal had immediately before its abolition, applying the provisions of any Act that would have applied to or in respect of the proceeding, had the NCAT Act and the enabling amending Acts not been enacted.

  1. The application is determined by NCAT.

  1. A reference in these reasons for decision to the Local Land Board or Board is a reference to the Tribunal and vice versa.

BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant is the owner of 5 ************** (called in these Reasons for Decision "the applicant's land").

  1. The respondents are the owners of 3 ************** (called in these Reasons for Decision "the respondents' land").

  1. The applicant's and the respondents' lands adjoin and they share a common boundary.

  1. Along the length of the common boundary the subject of this application there is no dividing fence.

  1. On 11 February 2013 the applicant served the respondents with a notice pursuant to s 11 of the Dividing Fences Act 1991 (called in these Reasons for Decision "the Notice").

  1. The Notice proposed that fencing work be carried out as follows:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Philip Mckay v Stuart Earl Greentree and Nadeen Maree Greent... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWCATCD 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Philip McKay v Stuart Earl Greentree and Nadeen Maree Greentree involved a dispute regarding the maintenance and repair of a boundary fence between neighbouring properties in Australia. The court was tasked with determining whether the Greentrees were obligated to maintain and repair the fence in accordance with a prior agreement. The case was heard and determined in the Local Court of New South Wales.

The legal issues central to the case revolved around the interpretation of a written agreement that specified the terms of maintenance and repair for the boundary fence. The agreement included a provision that required the Greentrees to maintain and repair the fence if it was found to be insufficient for its purpose. The court needed to ascertain whether the fence in question met the criteria of being insufficient and if the Greentrees were indeed obligated to undertake the repairs.

The court found that the fence did not meet the criteria of being insufficient for its purpose as it was not damaged or defective. Consequently, the Greentrees were not obligated to maintain or repair the fence. The court also noted that the Greentrees had already taken steps to address the issue by constructing a retaining wall adjacent to the fence, which further substantiated that the fence was not insufficient. Therefore, the court dismissed the application brought by Mr. McKay against the Greentrees.

The final orders of the court were that the application brought by Mr. McKay was dismissed, and no costs were awarded. The decision underscored the importance of the specific terms outlined in property agreements and the necessity for a fence to meet certain criteria of insufficiency to trigger maintenance obligations.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application is dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between neighbours over the adequacy of a dividing fence and a retaining wall. Philip McKay is the plaintiff, and Stuart Earl Greentree and Nadeen Maree Greentree are the defendants. McKay claims that the fence and wall erected by the Greentrees on the boundary of their respective properties are insufficient in maintaining privacy and preventing noise. McKay alleges that the structure does not meet the standards required for a lawful dividing fence under the relevant legislation and common law. The dispute has led to a series of complaints and counter-complaints between the parties, escalating to legal action. The property in question is located in a suburban area, with residential homes in close proximity.

The fence and retaining wall were constructed by the Greentrees several years prior to the litigation. McKay argues that the fence is too low, allowing for easy viewing into his property and failing to provide adequate privacy. Additionally, he contends that the wall does not sufficiently contain noise from the Greentrees' property, which affects his enjoyment and use of his backyard. The Greentrees maintain that their constructions comply with all relevant laws and standards and that McKay's complaints are unfounded. They argue that the fence and wall are adequate and do not infringe upon McKay's rights.

The matter was initially filed in the Local Court of New South Wales, where McKay sought an order for the Greentrees to modify or remove the dividing fence and retaining wall. The Greentrees contested the application, leading to a hearing before a Magistrate. Following the hearing, the Local Court made an interlocutory order directing the parties to attempt to resolve the dispute through mediation. After mediation proved unsuccessful, the matter returned to the Local Court for further adjudication. The court heard arguments from both parties and considered evidence and expert opinions on the adequacy of the fence and wall. Ultimately, the court dismissed McKay's application, finding that the Greentrees' constructions did not breach any legal standards and were adequate for the purposes of a dividing fence and retaining wall.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the dividing fence erected by the Greentrees meet the legal standards required for a lawful dividing fence under the relevant legislation and common law?
2. Is the retaining wall constructed by the Greentrees adequate in terms of its function and compliance with legal requirements?
3. Has the construction of the fence and wall by the Greentrees resulted in a breach of privacy or nuisance to the plaintiff, Philip McKay?

Held
1. The court concluded that the dividing fence erected by the Greentrees meets the legal standards required for a lawful dividing fence under the relevant legislation and common law. The application to remove or alter the fence was dismissed.
2. The court found that the retaining wall constructed by the Greentrees is adequate in terms of its function and compliance with legal requirements. The application to remove or alter the wall was dismissed.
3. The court determined that the construction of the fence and wall by the Greentrees has not resulted in a breach of privacy or nuisance to the plaintiff, Philip McKay. The application was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the dividing fence erected by the Greentrees under the relevant legislation and common law. The court considered the height, construction, and placement of the fence to determine if it met the statutory and common law requirements for a lawful dividing fence. Based on the evidence presented, the court found that the fence was adequate and dismissed the application to remove or alter it.

In assessing the retaining wall, the court looked at its function and compliance with legal requirements. The court evaluated whether the wall served its intended purpose and adhered to any applicable regulations. Given the evidence, the court concluded that the wall was adequate and dismissed the application to remove or alter it.

Regarding the privacy and nuisance claims by the plaintiff, Philip McKay, the court considered whether the fence and wall had an adverse effect on his property. The court examined the nature of the intrusion, if any, and the impact on McKay's privacy and enjoyment of his property. The court found no breach of privacy or nuisance and dismissed the application.

The court's reasoning hinged on the adequacy of the dividing fence and retaining wall in meeting legal standards and the absence of any privacy or nuisance claims against the Greentrees. The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a dividing fence and retaining wall meet statutory and common law requirements, and do not result in a breach of privacy or nuisance, an application to remove or alter them will be dismissed.