Warner-Lambert Company v Cardinal Health, Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

ABSTRACTS OF DECISIONS

DECISION OF A DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No. 762692 in the name of Warner-Lambert Company

Title:          Modified Starch Film Compositions

Action:          Opposition by Cardinal Health, Inc under s.59 of the Act, and lawful excuse for not complying with a Notice requiring production of certain documents.

Decision:          Issued  20 April 2006.

Abstract

Lawful excuse for not complying with a Notice requiring production of certain documents including drafts of declarations considered. Lawful excuse not found in relation to all of the documents covered by the notice - ASIC v Southcorp Limited [2003] FCA 804 applied.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No. 762692 in the name of Warner-Lambert Company, Opposition by Cardinal Health, Inc under s.59 of the Act, and lawful excuse for not complying with a Notice requiring production of certain documents.           

BACKGROUND

  1. This matter arises in the context of opposition proceedings in relation to patent application 762692. The relevant particulars are apparent from the Delegate’s decision in Warner-Lambert Company v Cardinal Health, Inc [2005] APO 26 where an extension was granted for serving evidence in support of the opposition. This evidence when filed included statutory declarations made by two expert witnesses, Dr John Besida and Dr David Dunstan.

  1. On 20 September the applicant requested the Commissioner to issue a notice to produce certain documents pursuant to s.201 of the Act. The justification for the request was given in the following terms:

“We are currently reviewing the opponent's Evidence-in-Support and wish to establish whether the opponent's experts were properly instructed in the matter of evidence preparation. The applicant's Evidence-in-Reply is due for service on 22 October, 2005. As production of the requested documents may have a bearing on the case the applicant has to answer, we request that the date for delivery of the documents requested be set for two months from the date of the Notice, if possible. The time period of two months has been requested because some of the documents requested may be overseas. Specifically, we know from the opponent's extension of time applications relating to service of their Evidence-in-Support that some of the Experts' draft declarations were sent for review and comment to the opponent's overseas attorneys.”

  1. I then on 23 September issued the Notice to “ The Proper Officer CARDINAL HEALTH INC.” which required the following documents to be filed by 23 November 2005:

“1.All documents sent by the opponent or representatives of the opponent, including the opponent's attorneys, to Dr. David Dunstan regarding preparation of Evidence-in-Support including instructions to Dr. Dunstan in relation to his role.

2.All of Dr. David Dunstan's written responses to 1 above, including drafts of declarations.

3.All documents sent by the opponent or representatives of the opponent, including the opponent's attorneys, to Dr. John Besida regarding his utility experiments including all instructions to Dr. Besida on what experiments were considered or required.

4.All of Dr. John Besida's written responses to 3 above, including drafts…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Warner-Lambert Company v Cardinal Health, Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] APO 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Warner-Lambert Company, the patent applicant, brought an action against Cardinal Health, Inc, the opponent, in the context of opposition proceedings for patent application 762692. The dispute centered on the opponent's failure to comply with a Notice to produce certain documents, including drafts of expert declarations. The applicant sought a lawful excuse for non-compliance with the Notice, which the opponent contested on grounds of privilege.

The key legal issues revolved around the application of client legal privilege to the communications between the opponent's solicitors and their experts, and whether the opponent could maintain a claim of privilege while relying on the experts' declarations in the proceedings. The court also needed to determine whether a lawful excuse existed for the opponent's non-compliance with the Notice.

The court reasoned that the nature of expert evidence in proceedings before the Commissioner required transparency and objectivity, aligning with the guidelines for expert witnesses in Federal Court matters. The court categorized the documents into several groups, including instructions provided to experts, reports from experts, drafts of declarations, and miscellaneous communications. The court found that a lawful excuse did not exist for all the documents, particularly the drafts of declarations, as the opponent could not maintain privilege while relying on the experts' declarations. The court held that allowing production of these documents would not be inconsistent with maintaining the confidentiality of the privilege. The court also considered the Commissioner's discretion under section 210 of the Act, concluding that the Commissioner must apply the same considerations as the Court before refusing a request to issue a notice for production.

The court concluded that a lawful excuse did not exist for production of the documents in question and ordered the opponent to produce them within 14 days. The court awarded costs against the opponent, finding that the documents should be produced in accordance with the principle that costs follow the event.

The final orders were that Cardinal Health, Inc. had 14 days from the date of the decision to request the Commissioner to treat the documents as prescribed for the purpose of section 55 and to provide submissions on the conditions under which they should be made available to the applicant. Costs were awarded against Cardinal Health, Inc.