Waller & Waller v Fmc & Burns (No 2) No. DCCIV-98-1796

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

WALLER v FLINDERS MEDICAL CENTRE and BURNS (NO 2)
[2004] SADC 67

Judge Lunn
Civil

Introduction

  1. The plaintiffs have sued the defendants for damages for the alleged medical negligence of the 2nd defendant.  In its defence the 1st defendant admits liability for the acts and omissions of the 2nd defendant after 1 July 1977.  The 2nd plaintiff’s claim is limited to one for losses of consortium and services arising out of the disabilities of the 1st plaintiff, his wife.  On 10 March 2004 I deemed that this action had been commenced by both plaintiffs against both defendants on 16 August 2001.[1]

    [1] Waller v Flinders Medical Centre (No 1) – Jud No [2004] SADC 45, 10/3/04, 232 LSJS 342.

    Overview[2]

    [2] The facts set out in this Overview were generally not in dispute but in any event I find them proved on the evidence.

  2. The 1st plaintiff (“the plaintiff”) was born on 1 April 1954 on Kangaroo Island where she continued to live until the end of 2003.  She left school at the age of fifteen to become an apprentice hairdresser at a hairdressing salon operated by her mother in Kingscote on Kangaroo Island.  Her mother died in November 1970 and shortly afterwards her hairdressing salon was closed down.  The plaintiff transferred her apprenticeship to another hairdresser in Kingscote, Richard Ley.

  3. On 12 April 1972 the plaintiff married the 2nd plaintiff who had been born on 22 March 1951.  The 2nd plaintiff’s father owned and operated a sheep and cereal farm of 1500 acres on Kangaroo Island.  The 2nd plaintiff worked for his father for minimal wages and supplemented his income with work as a wool classer.  After their marriage the plaintiffs lived in a fairly primitive old farmhouse close to the home of the 2nd plaintiff’s parents and about 25 kms from Kingscote.

  4. In the early years of her marriage the plaintiff enjoyed good health and led an active social and sporting life.  She played competitive netball and tennis.  Her first daughter, Nicole, was born on 25 December 1973.  Some weeks after the birth she resumed work as a hairdresser.  She completed her apprenticeship in 1974 and she then continued to work for Richard Ley.

  5. In early 1975 the plaintiff was pregnant with her second child.  On 1 April 1975 she consulted Doctor Alcorn, a general practitioner in Kingscote, complaining of back pain which prevented her from sleeping.  She was tender over T6-T8, but an xray of her thoracic spine did not reveal any damage.  On 17 April she complained to Dr Alcorn of numb legs and feet and continued back pain.  She had decreased sensation below her breast level and some ankle clonus.  Although he did not tell it to the plaintiff, Dr Alcorn feared she had Multiple Sclerosis (“MS”).

  1. In 1975 the 2nd defendant was a specialist medical physician practising in Adelaide as a neurologist.  Dr Alcorn referred the plaintiff to him.  On about 22…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Waller & Waller v Fmc & Burns (No 2) No. DCCIV-98-1796 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SADC 67
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, the Wallers, sued the defendants, Flinders Medical Centre and Dr Burns, for damages for the alleged medical negligence of Dr Burns. The Wallers' claim was limited to one for losses of consortium and services arising out of the disabilities of the 1st plaintiff, the wife, caused by Dr Burns' alleged negligence. The 1st defendant admitted liability for the acts and omissions of the 2nd defendant after 1 July 1977. The Wallers contended that Dr Burns was negligent in his diagnosis and treatment of the 1st plaintiff from 1975 to 1988. The Wallers' case was that the 1st plaintiff suffered from a spinal cord lesion caused by an epidermoid cyst and that Dr Burns failed to properly diagnose and treat the condition from 1975 to 1988. The Wallers' case was that had Dr Burns properly diagnosed and treated the 1st plaintiff's condition in about 1980, her disabilities would not have been as severe as they were and she would have been able to continue to work as a hairdresser until about the usual retiring age. The Wallers further contended that the defendants were liable for the 1st plaintiff's damages under the principle of vicarious liability. The Wallers' action was time barred by s36 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1936. The Wallers pleaded that their claims were not time barred because they had not discovered the defendants' negligence until 1997 and that the delay in bringing the action was excusable. The Wallers sought an extension of time pursuant to s48 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1936. The court found that the Wallers' claims were not time barred because they had not discovered the defendants' negligence until 1997 and that the delay in bringing the action was excusable. The Wallers' claims were deemed to have been commenced on 16 August 2001. The court found that Dr Burns was negligent in his diagnosis and treatment of the 1st plaintiff from 1975 to 1988. The court found that Dr Burns breached his duty of care to the 1st plaintiff by failing to properly diagnose and treat her condition in about 1980. The court found that had Dr Burns properly diagnosed and treated the 1st plaintiff's condition in about 1980, her disabilities would not have been as severe as they were and she would have been able to continue to work as a hairdresser until about the usual retiring age. The court assessed the 1st plaintiff's damages at $3,202,000 and the 2nd plaintiff's damages at $16,800. The court found in favour of the Wallers and awarded damages against the defendants.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established