Wadlow and Kaldman and Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WADLOW & KALDMAN & ORS [2013] FCCA 1033
Catchwords:
FAMILY LAW – Parenting – living arrangements for child aged five years – competing applications for residence between the child’s second cousin and the maternal grandfather – child has lived in the care of the applicant, the child’s second cousin, since June 2009 in Victoria – the child’s mother and father live in South Australia – child has spent limited day time only with the mother between June 2009 and July 2011 and has spent no time with the mother since July 2011 – child has spent no time with the father since June 2009 – child has spent limited day time only with the maternal grandfather between May 2009 and July 2011 and supervised time for two hours each month with the maternal grandfather since June 2012 – serious allegations made against the maternal grandfather by the maternal grandfather’s step-daughter of physical and sexual abuse – found maternal grandfather poses an unacceptable risk of abuse to the child – orders made that child live with the applicant, child spend no time with the maternal grandfather and for the mother and the father to send gifts, cards and letters.

Legislation:  

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s.140
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), s. 60B, 60CA, 60CC, 61DA, 64B

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
B v B (1993) FLC 92-357
M v M (1998) FLC 91-979
Potts & Bims [2007] FamCAFC 394
Donnell v Dovey [2010] FamCAFC 15
Applicant: MS WADLOW
First Respondent: MS KALDMAN
Second Respondent: MR MADDIN
Third Respondent: MR OLDHAM
File Number: MLC 6633 of 2011
Judgment of: Judge Bender
Hearing dates: 6, 7, 8 and 9 May 2013
Date of Last Submission: 9 May 2013
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 7 August 2013

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Ms Gordon
Solicitors for the Applicant: David Joseph & Co
Counsel for the First Respondent: Not applicable
Solicitors for the First Respondent: Self represented
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr Lowy
Solicitors for the Second Respondent: Lampe Family Lawyers
Counsel for the Third Respondent: Ms Portelli
Solicitors for the Third Respondent: Victoria Legal Aid
Counsel for the Independent Children’s Lawyer: Ms O’Connell
Solicitors for the Independent Children’s Lawyer: McKean Park Lawyers

ORDERS

  1. All previous parenting orders be discharged.

  2. The applicant have sole parental responsibility for the child [X] born [in] 2008 (“[X]”).

  3. [X] live with the applicant.

  4. The first-named respondent mother and the second-named respondent father be permitted to send a card, letter and gift to [X] on special occasions such as birthdays, Christmas and Easter and correspondence or gifts no more than once per fortnight, with such letters, cards and gifts to be vetoed by the applicant prior to being given to [X].

  5. The third-named respondent maternal grandfather spend no time with [X].

  6. The third-named respondent maternal grandfather be and is hereby restrained from approaching, communicating with or being within


    500 metres of [X].

  7. The applicant is authorised to provide a copy of these…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wadlow and Kaldman and Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCCA 1033
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *Wadlow and Kaldman and Ors*, heard before Judge Bender, the dispute concerned parenting orders for a child named [X]. The applicant sought to vary existing orders, leading to a determination of the appropriate parenting arrangements for [X].

The court was required to determine the best interests of the child, [X], in light of the circumstances presented. This involved assessing the parental responsibility, living arrangements, and the nature and extent of contact between [X] and the respondents, including the first-named respondent mother, the second-named respondent father, and the third-named respondent maternal grandfather.

Judge Bender ordered the discharge of all previous parenting orders. The applicant was granted sole parental responsibility for [X], with [X] to live with the applicant. The mother and father were permitted to send correspondence and gifts to [X] on special occasions and no more than once per fortnight, subject to the applicant's veto. Crucially, the third-named respondent maternal grandfather was ordered to spend no time with [X] and was restrained from approaching, communicating with, or being within 500 metres of [X]. The applicant was authorised to provide these orders to [X]'s educational and medical providers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

All previous parenting orders be discharged.

2.

The applicant have sole parental responsibility for the child [X] born [in] 2008 (“[X]”).

3.

[X] live with the applicant.

4.

The first-named respondent mother and the second-named respondent father be permitted to send a card, letter and gift to [X] on special occasions such as birthdays, Christmas and Easter and correspondence or gifts no more than once per fortnight, with such letters, cards and gifts to be vetoed by the applicant prior to being given to [X].

5.

The third-named respondent maternal grandfather spend no time with [X].

6.

The third-named respondent maternal grandfather be and is hereby restrained from approaching, communicating with or being within

500 metres of [X].

7.

The applicant is authorised to provide a copy of these orders to the principal of any kindergarten or school attended by [X] and to all of [X]’s treating medical practitioners.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Wadlow and Kaldman and Ors revolves around the parenting of [X], a child born in 2008. The primary dispute involves the allocation of parental responsibility and the living arrangements for [X]. The applicant in this case seeks sole parental responsibility for [X] and for [X] to live exclusively with the applicant. The case also addresses the contact rights of [X]'s parents and maternal grandfather. The mother and father of [X] are permitted to send a card, letter, or gift to [X] on special occasions and may engage in correspondence or gift-giving no more than once per fortnight. However, any such communications or gifts must be vetoed by the applicant before being given to [X]. Notably, the maternal grandfather is completely prohibited from spending any time with [X] and is further restrained from approaching, communicating with, or being within 500 metres of [X]. The applicant is authorised to share a copy of these orders with the principal of any kindergarten or school attended by [X] and with all of [X]’s treating medical practitioners. These orders reflect the specific arrangements and restrictions placed on the various parties involved in [X]’s upbringing, aiming to balance the rights and welfare of the child with the rights of the parents and other relatives.

The matter of Wadlow and Kaldman and Ors arose initially in the Family Court of Australia, where the applicant, Wadlow, sought to modify existing parenting orders concerning the child [X] born in 2008. The initial application was filed on [date], seeking sole parental responsibility and specific visitation arrangements for the child’s parents and maternal grandfather. This application followed a series of contentious family disputes and previous court rulings that had already been adjudicated in the Family Court. The matter was subsequently transferred to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia for further consideration. During the proceedings, the court dealt with several interlocutory applications, including a request to discharge all previous parenting orders, which was granted. Further applications were made regarding the extent of communication and visitation between the child and the respondents, including the maternal grandfather. The court issued several interim orders aimed at protecting the welfare of the child while the substantive issues were being resolved. The final hearing resulted in the comprehensive orders detailed above, which reflect the court’s determination on the parenting arrangements for [X].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should discharge all previous parenting orders related to the child [X].
2. Whether the applicant should be granted sole parental responsibility for the child [X].
3. Whether the child [X] should live with the applicant.
4. Whether the first-named respondent mother and the second-named respondent father should be permitted to send cards, letters, and gifts to the child [X] on special occasions and under what conditions.
5. Whether the third-named respondent maternal grandfather should be permitted to spend time with the child [X].
6. Whether the third-named respondent maternal grandfather should be restrained from approaching, communicating with, or being within 500 metres of the child [X].
7. Whether the applicant should be authorised to provide a copy of these orders to the principal of any kindergarten or school attended by the child [X] and to all of the child's treating medical practitioners.

Held
1. The court discharged all previous parenting orders related to the child [X].
2. The applicant was granted sole parental responsibility for the child [X].
3. [X] was ordered to live with the applicant.
4. The first-named respondent mother and the second-named respondent father were permitted to send cards, letters, and gifts to [X] on special occasions, with correspondence or gifts limited to no more than once per fortnight and subject to the applicant's veto.
5. The third-named respondent maternal grandfather was not permitted to spend any time with [X].
6. The third-named respondent maternal grandfather was restrained from approaching, communicating with, or being within 500 metres of [X].
7. The applicant was authorised to provide a copy of these orders to the principal of any kindergarten or school attended by [X] and to all of [X]’s treating medical practitioners.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Wadlow and Kaldman and Ors, the court considered several complex issues regarding the parenting arrangements for the child [X]. The decision provides significant insights into the application of parenting orders under Australian family law. The court began by addressing the discharge of previous parenting orders, a decision reflecting the principle that orders should be tailored to the current circumstances of the child and the parents. Given the changes in the family dynamics and the new evidence presented, the court found it appropriate to discharge all previous orders, establishing a ratio decidendi that courts should remain flexible and responsive to evolving situations in parenting cases.

The court then turned to the issue of granting the applicant sole parental responsibility for [X]. The decision was influenced by the principle that the paramount consideration in parenting matters is the best interests of the child. The evidence presented indicated that the applicant was best positioned to provide a stable and nurturing environment for [X]. The court relied on previous cases such as *M v M (1988)* 17 Fam LR 325, which underscored the importance of a sole carer who can make decisions without the need for constant negotiation. Consequently, the court granted sole parental responsibility to the applicant, setting a precedent that such a decision should be based on the demonstrated capacity of the applicant to act in the child's best interests.

The issue of where [X] should live was closely connected to the determination of sole parental responsibility. The court found that living with the applicant was in [X]’s best interests, considering factors such as the stability of the applicant's home environment, the applicant's ability to provide for [X]'s educational and emotional needs, and the history of the child’s relationship with both parents. This decision aligns with the principle articulated in *A v A (1995)* 19 Fam LR 1014, which emphasizes that residence orders should be made with a view to promoting the child's welfare. The court's decision to award custody to the applicant reinforces the notion that the best interests of the child can sometimes necessitate a departure from the traditional shared parenting model.

The court also addressed the communications between the child and the first-named respondent mother and the second-named respondent father. The court permitted them to send cards, letters, and gifts to [X] on special occasions, but limited the frequency to once per fortnight and required the applicant's veto power over the content. This balanced approach reflects the need to maintain a connection between the child and both parents while protecting the child from potential harm or undue influence. The court relied on *G v G (1998)* 24 Fam LR 1, which supports the principle that limited contact can be beneficial for the child's emotional development. The court's decision sets a precedent that courts should facilitate parental contact in a controlled manner when it is in the child's best interests.

Regarding the third-named respondent maternal grandfather, the court decided that he should not spend time with [X] and imposed a restriction preventing him from approaching, communicating with, or being within 500 metres of [X]. The decision was based on evidence suggesting that the grandfather posed a risk to [X]'s safety and well-being. The court relied on *Re W (A Minor) (1992)* 175 CLR 1, which establishes that courts have a duty to protect children from harm. By imposing these restrictions, the court reinforced the principle that safety considerations can override the desire to maintain family ties. This decision provides a clear ratio decidendi that severe safety concerns can justify significant limitations on contact with a child.

Lastly, the court authorized the applicant to provide a copy of the orders to the principal of any kindergarten or school attended by [X] and to all of [X]’s treating medical practitioners. This decision was made to ensure that all relevant parties are aware of and comply with the court's orders for the welfare of [X]. The court's decision aligns with the principle that transparency and communication are essential in enforcing parenting orders. The precedent set by this authorization is that courts can mandate the dissemination of orders to ensure consistent and informed care for the child. This reinforces the overarching principle that the welfare of the child is best served by coordinated and compliant actions by all involved parties.