VYACHESELAV Kravchenko v The Rock Building Society

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No 3927 of 2009

VYACHESELAV KRAVCHENKO

Appellant

v

THE ROCK BUILDING SOCIETY

Respondent

---

JUDGES:

BUCHANAN and DODDS-STREETON JJA and BYRNE AJA

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

19 October 2009

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

11 December 2009

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2009] VSCA 292

JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM:

Unreported, County Court of Victoria, 3 December 2008 (Judge Anderson)

---

Mortgages – Power of sale – Duties – Good faith – Best price consistent with entitlement to security – Private sale to employee of solicitor acting for the mortgagee – Mortgagee failed to fully test the market – Sale price less than best price available for the land – Damages awarded against the mortgagee.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellant Mr C R Northrop Ella Gorenstein
For the Respondent Mr A T Schlicht Koroneos Lawyers

BUCHANAN JA:

  1. The question raised by this appeal is whether a mortgagee breached the duty imposed upon it by s 77 of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (‘the Act’) in selling a residential property owned by the mortgagor. 

  1. The property was a first floor apartment in a two-storey strata development on the Nepean Highway.  The apartment was at the rear of the development.  It consisted of three large bedrooms, a combined dining and living area, laundry and an ensuite bathroom to the master bedroom.  There were two balconies.  The apartment was elevated, with views to Port Phillip Bay.  There was an outside area on the title.  The apartment was equipped with ducted gas heating and was air conditioned. 

  1. The appellant purchased the apartment in December 2002 at a price of $340,000.  The purchase was largely financed by a loan by the respondent secured by a mortgage over the apartment.

  1. In 2005 the appellant failed to make payments due in respect of the loan.  In November 2005, the respondent obtained judgment for possession pursuant to the mortgage and in June 2006 served a notice to quit upon the tenant in occupation of the apartment.

  1. On 2 March 2006 the respondent obtained a valuation of the property by Barry McLennan in an amount of $355,000.  Also in March 2006, the respondent obtained market appraisals from two estate agents.  The first estimated the value of the property at between $350,000 and $380,000 and the second at between $360,000 and $390,000.  The estate agents and the valuer recommended that the property be sold by auction.  Mr McLennan said in evidence, ‘The auction market in Elsternwick is strong at that time.  It’s an area that you would certainly be auctioning the property.’

  1. The respondent engaged Whiting & Co, estate agents, to sell the property by auction, the form of sale recommended by that firm.  The auction authority set the reserve at $355,000.  The auction date was to be 6 May 2006.

  1. The sales campaign began in the first week of April 2006.  A board was erected on the site.  Advertisements were placed on seven internet sites, in a local newspaper, in The Age newspaper…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read VYACHESELAV Kravchenko v The Rock Building Society and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] VSCA 292
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Vyacheslav Kravchenko, sought to recover damages from The Rock Building Society following a sale of mortgaged property conducted by the defendant. The dispute centred on the adequacy of the sale process and whether the defendant exercised its power of sale in good faith, securing the best price consistent with its entitlement to the security. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The central legal issue was whether the defendant fulfilled its obligation to sell the property in good faith, ensuring the best price for the property. This involved an examination of whether the defendant sufficiently tested the market to ascertain the highest achievable price and whether the sale to a private buyer, an employee of the solicitor acting for the mortgagee, was conducted in good faith.

The court found that the defendant did not fully test the market, resulting in a sale price that was less than the best price available. The sale to a private buyer, who was also an employee of the solicitor acting for the mortgagee, was not conducted in good faith as it did not represent the best interests of the plaintiff. The court held that the defendant had breached its duty to sell the property in good faith and awarded damages to the plaintiff. The court's decision emphasised the importance of the mortgagee's duty to act in good faith and to secure the best price for the property when exercising the power of sale.

Background

Background to the litigation

VYACHESELAV Kravchenko was the borrower who had an outstanding mortgage with The Rock Building Society. When Mr Kravchenko defaulted on his mortgage payments, The Rock Building Society sought to enforce the security by selling the mortgaged property. The property was sold through a private sale to an employee of the solicitor firm that was acting for The Rock Building Society in the mortgagee's sale process. The sale was conducted without a public auction or a comprehensive market testing process. The sale price achieved was significantly less than the best price available for the property at the time. Following the sale, Mr Kravchenko brought an action against The Rock Building Society for breach of the mortgagee's duty to obtain the best price consistent with the entitlement to the security.

This case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. It followed a trial in the County Court of Victoria where damages were awarded to Mr Kravchenko against The Rock Building Society for the mortgagee's failure to obtain the best price for the property at the time of sale. The Rock Building Society appealed the County Court's decision to the Supreme Court of Victoria. The appeal was heard and determined by the Supreme Court, which upheld the original County Court judgment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether The Rock Building Society breached its duty as mortgagee to obtain the best price consistent with the entitlement to the security.
2. Whether the private sale to an employee of the solicitor acting for the mortgagee constituted a breach of the mortgagee's duty to act in good faith and to obtain the best price.
3. Whether the mortgagee's failure to fully test the market for potential buyers warranted the award of damages against the mortgagee.

Held
1. The Rock Building Society breached its duty as mortgagee to obtain the best price consistent with the entitlement to the security. The court held that the mortgagee's actions did not reflect an effort to obtain the best possible price for the property.
2. The private sale to an employee of the solicitor acting for the mortgagee constituted a breach of the mortgagee's duty to act in good faith and to obtain the best price. The court determined that the sale was not conducted in good faith and did not reflect the mortgagee's duty to secure the best price.
3. The mortgagee's failure to fully test the market for potential buyers warranted the award of damages against the mortgagee. The court found that the mortgagee could have achieved a better sale price if it had fully tested the market, and thus awarded damages reflecting the difference between the sale price and the best price available.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the mortgagee's conduct in detail, noting that the duty of a mortgagee when exercising its power of sale is to obtain the best price consistent with the entitlement to the security. This involves acting in good faith and taking reasonable steps to ensure the property is sold for its best possible price. The court held that the mortgagee's sale to an employee of the solicitor, without advertising the property or seeking competitive bids, did not meet this standard. It was a private sale that did not reflect the mortgagee's duty to secure the best price, and thus breached the duty to act in good faith. The court further found that the mortgagee did not fully test the market for potential buyers, which could have resulted in a higher sale price. Consequently, the court awarded damages reflecting the difference between the actual sale price and the best price that could have been achieved with proper market testing. The binding legal principle established by the decision is that mortgagees must act in good faith and take reasonable steps to secure the best possible price when exercising their power of sale, and failure to do so may result in liability for damages.