Voysey v Chief Superintendent Glen Horton

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Voysey v Chief Superintendent Glen Horton [2025] QCAT 199

PARTIES:

CHRISTOPHER VOYSEY

(applicant)

v

CHIEF SUPERINTENDENT GLEN HORTON

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR229-21

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

22 May 2025

HEARING DATE:

9 December 2024

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Richard Oliver

ORDERS:

1.     Matter 1 although substantiated, did not constitute official misconduct and the respondent’s decision that it constituted official misconduct is set aside.

2.     Subject to any objection by either party the further hearing on the sanction imposed by the respondent will be determined on the papers without an oral hearing.

IT IS DIRECTED THAT:

3.     The applicant is to file and give to the respondent any written submissions (no more than six pages) on sanction by:

  4:00pm on 14 June 2025.

4.     The respondent is to file and give to the applicant any written submissions (no more than six pages) on sanction in reply by:

  4:00pm on 4 July 2025.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – POLICE – MISCONDUCT – review of a finding of misconduct by the applicant officer – nature of the review – where the applicant failed to follow management procedures in conducting and finalising an investigation – where applicant failed to refer the investigation to an office in charge before finalising the investigation – whether failure to have officer in charge sign off on the investigation constitutes misconduct – whether conduct carless, incompetent or inefficient – whether Matter 1 substantiated

Crime and Corruption Act 2001 (Qld), s 219Q(1)

Child Protection Act1999 (Qld)
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act2009 (Qld), s 20

Police Service Administration Act1990 (Qld), s 7.1, s 7.2, s 7.4, s 7.8, s 7.34, s 7.35, s 7.44

Assistant Commissioner Stephen Hollands v Tolsher [2016] QCATA 123

Assistant Commissioner Brian Wilkins & Anor v Gunter (No. 2) [2021] QCATA 42
Deputy Commissioner Stewart v Dark [2012] QCA 228
Gunter v Assistant Commissioner Wilkins [2021] QCA 274
Heuston v Horton [2024] QCAT 432
Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd v Kim Yen Tat [2018] QCA 182

Willmott v Carless [2024] QCA 115

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondent:

Mr Nicholson of counsel instructed by the Queensland Police Service Legal unit

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. On 12 July 2021 the applicant filed an application to review the respondent’s decision that he had engaged in misconduct, as defined in the Police Service Administration Act 1990 (“PSA Act), in the manner in which he had investigated and finalised information received from a female child’s school about a sexual incident. As a consequence of the finding of misconduct, a sanction was imposed that he be demoted from Senior Constable 2.10 to Constable 1.6 for three months, suspended after six weeks, subject to no further grounds for discipline being committed for a period of 12 months from the date of the sanction.

  2. The source of statutory right to review in the Tribunal is contained in s 219G of the Crime and Corruption Act 2001…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Voysey v Chief Superintendent Glen Horton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QCAT 199
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Voysey v Chief Superintendent Glen Horton, the applicant, a former police officer, sought a review of a disciplinary decision that his conduct constituted misconduct under the Police Service Administration Act 1990 (Qld). The central dispute revolves around the applicant's failure to follow specific management procedures in concluding an investigation, particularly not obtaining approval from the Officer in Charge (OIC) before finalising the investigation. The key issues before the court were whether the applicant's conduct, as admitted, constituted misconduct as defined, and whether the conduct was substantiated.

The court held that while the applicant's conduct was indeed improper, it did not meet the threshold of misconduct. The court emphasised that the onus was on the applicant to demonstrate some error of fact or law that would justify setting aside the respondent's finding. The applicant argued that his actions were based on his extensive experience and aimed at ensuring the child involved was comfortable during the interview process. Although the respondent criticised the applicant's methods, the evidence did not support a deliberate intent to bypass proper procedures, which is necessary for a finding of misconduct.

Consequently, the court set aside the respondent's decision that the applicant's conduct constituted misconduct. However, the conduct was substantiated under another provision of the Act. The court also noted that the imposed sanction, a demotion, needed to be reviewed as it was contingent on the finding of misconduct. The matter was to be further heard on the issue of sanction, with directions for both parties to submit written arguments.

The final orders of the tribunal were that the substantiated conduct did not constitute official misconduct and the respondent's decision to that effect was set aside. The tribunal also directed that the further hearing on the sanction imposed would be determined on the papers without an oral hearing, unless objected by either party. Both parties were required to file and exchange written submissions on the sanction by specified deadlines.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Matter 1 although substantiated, did not constitute official misconduct and the respondent’s decision that it constituted official misconduct is set aside.

2. Subject to any objection by either party the further hearing on the sanction imposed by the respondent will be determined on the papers without an oral hearing.

IT IS DIRECTED THAT:

3. The applicant is to file and give to the respondent any written submissions (no more than six pages) on sanction by:

4:00pm on 14 June 2025.

4. The respondent is to file and give to the applicant any written submissions (no more than six pages) on sanction in reply by:

4:00pm on 4 July 2025.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issues in this review application are twofold. Firstly, whether the conduct to which the applicant admits, not having his OIC approve of him unfounding the occurrence, constitutes misconduct, as defined. Secondly, whether the applicant did in fact unfound the occurrence because, factually, he was unable to do so for the reasons stated in his submissions filed on 2 October 2024. It could only be finalised by a senior officer. This latter point may involve the reception of fresh evidence to be discussed below.Background On 21 September 2020 the applicant was invited to participate in an Abbreviated Discipline Proceeding (“ADP”), under s 7.10 of the Police Service Administration Act1990 (Qld) (“PSA Act”) as a result of his failure to follow the correct procedures in closing off an investigation (“occurrence”), when the officer was satisfied that no offence had occurred, and no further investigation was necessary. The terminology used for finalising an “occurrence” in these circumstances is “unfounded”. The particular failure of concern was that the applicant did not get the authority of the Officer in Charge, Sergeant Pickett, (“OIC”) to use her delegation “to unfound the occurrence”. Particulars of the applicant’s conduct in the investigation and his entries into the QPRIME computer system were set out in the ADP. The ADP included the particulars supporting the conduct referred to above. It also set out the allegation details and allegation type. It was alleged that the allegation type was misconduct.[3] The applicant was given a choice to accept the invitation to participate in the ADP process or decline. He elected to decline the ADP invitation, by signing it, on 8 December 2020.[3]S 21(2) documents page 4. As a consequence, an investigation into his conduct was instigated with him formally engaging in a directed interview on 31 July 2020. A statement was also provided by Sgt Pickett as to her concerns about the investigation by the applicant. Subsequently on 17 December 2020 the applicant was issued with a Disciplinary Proceeding Notice (updated on 27 January 2021) in relation to the matters referred to above in the ADP. It was alleged:Matter OneThat on or about the 7th day of February 202 at Brisbane your conduct was improper in that you:(a)Finalised an occurrence recorded on QPRIME as unfounded without prior consultation with your Officer in Charge; and(b)Inaccurately recorded on the QPRIME occurrence entry you had received prior approval from your Officer in Charge to finalise the matter as unfounded. The Notice then goes on to provide particulars for Matter 1(a) which is essentially a brief history of the applicant’s involvement in the investigation where information was received about a sexual incident between a young schoolgirl and her stepbrother. The particulars for Matter 1(b) related to the fact that the applicant had filed a supplementary report on QPRIME that the OIC (Sgt Pickett) had provided approval to finalise the occurrence as unfounded, when in fact this was not the case. The applicant was provided with all of the evidence obtained to support the Notice including a transcript of his directed interview and the statement of Sgt Pickett. These documents have been provided to the Tribunal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Another factor is, as the applicant submits, that from the very beginning, the conduct was not considered by the QPS to be misconduct. Otherwise, it is reasonable to assume, he would not have been offered the ADP before referral for disciplinary action. I do not place too much weight on this submission because it is the factual findings that determine the nature of the conduct. Conclusion on Substantiation This review application is not a rehearing of the disciplinary proceeding before the respondent. The onus is on the applicant to demonstrate some error of fact or law which would warrant an interference with the respondent’s finding that the applicant’s conduct constituted “misconduct” as defined in the PSA Act. Although the applicant says he followed the investigative procedures under the OPM, he took it upon himself to proceed in a way which he considered best in the circumstance to ensure that child was not anxious about the interview process and so he could get her to open up about why she made the statement she did. In doing this he relied on his 14 years in the CPIU having investigated they types of complaints in the past. The criticisms of him doing the investigation this way by the respondent may well be justified in the operational setting, but there the evidence falls short of establishing the conduct was deliberate to shortcut the investigation, and thus misconduct. In coming to this conclusion, the respondent was in error. I therefore propose to set aside the respondent finding that the applicant engaged in misconduct as described in s 7.4(a) of the PSA Act. However, the conduct does fall within s 7.4(c).Sanction On 9 August 2021, the respondent imposed a sanction of demotion from Senior Constable 2.10 to Constable 1.6 for three months, suspended after six weeks, conditional upon no further ground for discipline being committed for 12 months. Because this sanction was based on a finding of misconduct, now set aside, the sanction must be reviewed. The parties have not provided submissions on sanction and therefore it is necessary to list the matter for further submissions on sanction. It may well be, given the applicant has retired from the QPS, the parties can come to some agreement about that. Subject to any objection by the parties I propose to determine the question of sanction on the papers with directions for filing written submissions. The orders of the Tribunal are:(a)Matter 1 although substantiated, did not constitute official misconduct and the respondent’s decision that it constituted official misconduct is set aside.(b)Subject to any objection by either party the further hearing on the sanction imposed by the respondent will be determined on the papers without an oral hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Having accepted the particulars of Matter 1(a) and 1(b) apart from the notebook recording, the applicant contended in his submission to the respondent that the conduct did not amount to misconduct. He referred to the definition in s 7.4 and some cases in support of this contention. He does accept that his conduct was “careless”. I will return to this submission later in these reasons.The respondent’s consideration. On 24 March 2021 the respondent delivered written reasons finding that both Matters 1(a) and 1(b) were substantiated and constituted misconduct. The respondent had regard to each of the particulars and the applicant’s response. In the section headed “Evidence and submissions discussion” he considered what he referred to as the “evidence” in support of Matter 1. This evidence was by reference to the particulars of Matter 1 which included making a decision not to exercise powers under s 17 of the Child Protection Act1999 (Qld), which permits an authorised officer to interview the child at school. Also, the other matters of complaint are that he did not have another officer with him when he conducted the interview, did not use a recording device or take notes during the interview and that he relied on his experience in conducting the interview the way he did. The respondent had regard to the applicant’s responses in the directed interview and concluded that he had a “sound understanding” of the processes to be followed in conducting an interview of this nature. He was also satisfied the applicant was aware of the requirements of concluding an investigation by requiring OIC review and recommendation. He concluded that there was no lack of understanding as asserted by the applicant, but he was an officer “happy to take shortcuts in order to finalise the matter”. With respect to the diary entry in the notebook of the interview, he found that the record was not of a recorded conversation with the female child but only that a conversation occurred. They did not meet the required standard for an experienced officer of the applicant’s rank in the CPIU. I would observe that the notes are certainly brief, but they do record the substance of the conversation relating to the incident. The Respondent found particular v substantiated. It seems that the respondent proceeded on the basis that the particulars themselves ought to be considered to determine whether the applicant engaged in improper conduct. The only relevance of this is to decide whether the applicant’s conduct was deliberate to shortcut the proper procedure. This approach was also contained in the submissions of the respondent in the appeal. However, although the respondent may be critical of the way the applicant carried out his duties, the improper conduct alleged is not that, it is the finalisation of the QPRIME occurrence as unfounded without OIC approval. All the particulars do is record the history of the conduct leading up to Matter 1. In other words, it is not alleged that the failure to have another officer with him in the interview, failure to engage s 17 of the Child Protection Act 1999 (Qld) and failure to record the interview electronically or in writing constituted improper conduct. They are not the substance of Matter 1. However, the respondent took all of that into account in coming to his decision.