Von Stieglitz and Comcare (Compensation) [2015] AATA 1034 (11 November 2015)
Division
GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s)
2012/0675
Re
Katherine Von Stieglitz
APPLICANT
And
Comcare
RESPONDENT
INTERLOCUTORY DECISION
Tribunal Deputy President Gary Humphries
Date 11 November 2015 Date of written reasons 3 February 2016 Place Canberra Privilege has not been waived with respect to the two pieces of legal advice dated 10 January 2008 and 14 February 2008 and the advices are privileged from production on the grounds of legal professional privilege.
………………………[sgd]……………………………
Deputy President Gary Humphries
Catchwords
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – summons to produce documents – legal professional privilege claimed over certain documents – whether legal professional privilege waived by conduct of summonsed party.
Legislation
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 40A
Cases
Nine Films & Television Pty Ltd v Ninox Television Ltd (2005) 65 IPR 442
REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President Gary Humphries
3 February 2016
At an interlocutory hearing, the applicant, Katherine Von Stieglitz, has sought access to two legal advices prepared by the Australian Government Solicitor (the AGS) for its client, the High Court of Australia, dated 10 January 2008 and 14 February 2008 respectively. It was common ground at the hearing that these documents attract legal professional privilege but the applicant argued that the privilege had been waived by the conduct of the representatives of the High Court.
Background
The applicant was a Senior Court Reporter employed by the High Court until April 2008, when her employment was terminated. She subsequently brought two claims for workers compensation against Comcare in relation to her employment at the High Court. In relation to her second claim, the applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of a Comcare redetermination denying her compensation (2012/0675). In the course of those proceedings the applicant sought production of all communication between the High Court and AGS for the period 20 July 2007 to 9 February 2009. Citing legal professional privilege, the High Court objected to the production of those documents.
On 11 December 2013, the Tribunal (Cowdroy J) upheld the claim of privilege over all but one of the documents, a legal advice dated 19 June 2008. It found that privilege in that document had been waived because its substance had been included in a memorandum that was produced to the applicant by Comcare. The applicant appealed the Tribunal’s decision regarding access to the documents to the Full Federal Court.
In the course of that appeal the applicant sought an order that she be granted access to legal advices dated 10 January and 14 February 2008 respectively, prepared by AGS for the High Court (the 2008 advices). She argued that, as they were referred to in the advice of 19 June 2008, and privilege had been waived in that document, privilege in turn had been waived in the 2008 advices. The Full Court refused to make that order on the basis that the applicant should have sought that access at the Tribunal but had not done so.
The applicant now…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Von Stieglitz and Comcare (Compensation) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] AATA 1034
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case centred on whether the legal professional privilege claimed over the two advices had been waived by the conduct of the High Court’s representatives. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the reference to these advices in a later legal advice, which had already been produced to the applicant, amounted to a waiver of privilege. The applicant argued that the High Court’s representatives had disclosed the advices to gain a forensic advantage against her. The High Court, on the other hand, contended that the reference to the advices in the later document did not disclose their ‘gist substance or conclusion’ and did not amount to a waiver of privilege.
The court considered the starting point that communications between parties and their lawyers attract legal professional privilege and must be respected. The court found that the onus of proving a waiver of privilege falls on the party asserting it. The court examined the use of the advice of 19 June 2008 by the High Court’s representatives in the proceedings before the Federal Court and found that there was no evidence that the High Court was seeking or obtaining any tactical or forensic advantage by quoting from that advice. The court concluded that the reference to the 2008 advices in the advice of 19 June 2008 did not disclose their ‘gist substance or conclusion’ and did not amount to a waiver of privilege. The court dismissed the application for access to the two advices.
No final orders were made in this interlocutory hearing. The case continues to be before the court.
Background
Background to the litigation
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether legal professional privilege was waived by the conduct of the representatives of the High Court through the disclosure of certain documents.
2. Whether the references to the 2008 advices in the advice of 19 June 2008 disclose the 'gist substance or conclusion' of those advices.
3. Whether the High Court's representatives disclosed the 2008 advices to gain a forensic advantage against the Applicant.
Held
1. The court held that legal professional privilege was not waived by the conduct of the representatives of the High Court through the disclosure of certain documents.
2. The court held that the references to the 2008 advices in the advice of 19 June 2008 do not disclose the 'gist substance or conclusion' of those advices.
3. The court held that the High Court's representatives did not disclose the 2008 advices to gain a forensic advantage against the Applicant.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court contends that the references to the 2008 advices in the advice of 19 June 2008 does not disclose the ‘gist substance or conclusion’ of those advices. It submits that the reference to the 2008 advices merely contextualises the bald reference to the existence of advice without divulging its substance. It asserted, using the test of Tamberlin J in Nine Films & Television Pty Ltd v Ninox Television Ltd (2005) 65 IPR 442, that the substance or content of the advice is not disclosed with specificity or clarity. It denied seeking any forensic or other advantage from the reference.Consideration It is the starting point with consideration of matters of communication between parties and their lawyers that those communications attract privilege, specifically legal professional privilege. In that context it is important to respect the right (I think it was put in one of the cases – perhaps a little exaggerated – as a fundamental aspect of the conduct of humankind) that people have to communicate with their lawyers in a confidential fashion, and for those communications not to be generally disclosable in proceedings. So that is the starting point that the Tribunal takes with respect to this matter. I accept the contention put by the High Court, in considering whether waiver of that privilege has occurred, that the evidentiary onus with respect to showing that a waiver has occurred falls on the party asserting that there has been a waiver. It falls to Ms Von Stieglitz to demonstrate that the waiver has been effected by the conduct of the High Court’s representatives in these proceedings. Looking at the use of the advice of 19 June 2008, I struggle to understand what kind of tactical or forensic advantage was being obtained by the High Court in its representative’s use of that advice in the proceedings before the Federal Court. I accept that there were alternatives open to counsel for the High Court in citing paragraph 20 of that legal advice, which of course makes reference to the other advices of 10 January and 14 February 2008. As Ms von Stieglitz has suggested, it would have been possible to make other more oblique references to the 2008 advices. However, I do not see – by having actually quoted the paragraph – that the representative of the High Court was in fact seeking or actually obtaining some kind of forensic advantage in respect of the matter then before the Federal Court or otherwise. And given that, as was pointed out, this advice was produced under protest by the High Court, I find it difficult to follow the logic of arguing that this advice essentially placed the High Court in a stronger position with respect to litigation, such that its use of the advice, or more importantly the advices of 10 January and 14 February 2008, provided or offered the circumstances where the holder of the privilege might be said to have used the privileged or protected communication to create an inaccurate perception of the content of that communication.