Von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd v Nasr

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

VON DOUSSAS LEGAL PTY LTD v NASR

[2008] SASC 206

Judgment of The Honourable Justice White

25 July 2008

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE'S FINDINGS OF FACT - FUNCTIONS OF APPELLATE COURT - WHERE FINDINGS BASED ON CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES - NECESSITY FOR FINDING TO BE CLEARLY WRONG

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - DUTIES AND LIABILITIES - SOLICITOR AND CLIENT - RETAINER - EXTENT OF RETAINER

Appeal against judgment entered by a magistrate for part only of a solicitor's claim against a former client for legal fees in respect of a Supreme Court appeal - whether Magistrates Court had jurisdiction to hear and determine all issues concerning the liability for the claimed costs - whether magistrate erred in finding that respondent was not liable for costs of the appeal - whether magistrate erred by failing to make any award of interest.

Held:  Magistrates Court had jurisdiction to hear and determine all issues concerning the liability (but not the quantum) for legal fees - magistrate's finding that respondent was not liable for costs of the appeal was based on his assessment of the credibility of witnesses - magistrate's conclusion was not glaringly improbable or inconsistent with incontrovertible facts or uncontested testimony - magistrate did not overlook the issue of interest on the judgment sum but simply entered judgment for the amount agreed between the parties - appeal dismissed.

Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) s 34; De Facto Relationships Act 1996 (SA) s 9; Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) s 41, s 42, s 43; Legal Practitioners Act 1936-72 (SA) s 17; Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 40, referred to.
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118; Soulemezis v Dudley (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1987) 10 NSWLR 247; R v Keyte (2000) 78 SASR 68; Geister v Police [2008] SASC 177; Toll (FGCT) Pty Limited v Alphapharm Pty Limited (2004) 219 CLR 165, applied.
King William Law Chambers and Williamson & Co v Mobitel (International) Pty Ltd (1981) 29 SASR 316, distinguished.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"glaringly improbable", "contrary to compelling inferences", "inconsistent with incontrovertible facts or uncontested testimony"

VON DOUSSAS LEGAL PTY LTD v NASR
[2008] SASC 206

Magistrates Appeal

  1. WHITE J:             The appellant (von Doussas) and another firm of legal practitioners (J P Stevens Lawyers) sued the respondent in the Magistrates Court for the non-payment of legal fees.  Save in respects which were admitted by the respondent, the claims failed.  The magistrate accordingly entered judgment for the plaintiffs for $6,393.73, which represented part only of their claim. 

  2. The dispute determined by the magistrate concerned the liability of the respondent to von Doussas and to J P Stevens in respect of the costs of an appeal to this Court.[1]  That appeal was against an order by the District Court restraining von Doussas and, in particular, its consultant Mr Carabelas from acting for the respondent in certain District Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd v Nasr and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 206
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal, Von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd v Nasr, involved a dispute between a former client and his solicitor over legal fees incurred during a Supreme Court appeal. The matter was initially heard and decided by a magistrate in the Magistrates Court of South Australia. The client, Nasr, contested the solicitor's claim for costs, arguing that he had not agreed to pay for the costs of the appeal and that any such agreement was reached after the fact. The solicitor, Von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd, sought to appeal the magistrate's decision, arguing that the magistrate had erred in finding that Nasr was not liable for the costs of the appeal.

The court had to determine several key issues. Firstly, whether the Magistrates Court had jurisdiction to hear and determine all issues concerning the liability for the claimed costs. Secondly, whether the magistrate had erred in finding that Nasr was not liable for the costs of the appeal. Thirdly, whether the magistrate erred by failing to make any award of interest on the judgment sum. Fourthly, whether the magistrate erred by not making an order in respect of the costs of the proceedings, and fifthly, whether the magistrate had determined the claim of J P Stevens without having heard from it.

The Court held that the Magistrates Court had jurisdiction to hear and determine all issues concerning the liability for the legal fees, though not the quantum. The magistrate's finding that Nasr was not liable for the costs of the appeal was based on an assessment of the credibility of the witnesses. The Court found that the magistrate's conclusion was not clearly wrong and was consistent with the evidence presented. The Court also found that the magistrate did not overlook the issue of interest but rather entered judgment for the amount agreed upon by the parties. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

No specific final orders were made beyond the dismissal of the appeal, as the Court found no basis to interfere with the magistrate's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The issues raised by the von Doussas’ notice of appeal are these:1.Did the Magistrates Court have jurisdiction to hear and determine all issues arising in the proceedings? This issue is raised by von Doussas despite it having itself invoked the jurisdiction of the Magistrates Court, and despite it having sought an order from the Magistrates Court that the respondent pay the sum of $20,318.17 to it.2.Did the magistrate err in failing to find that the respondent was liable to von Doussas in respect of the costs of the Conflict Appeal?3.Even if judgment was appropriately entered for the principal sum of $6,393.73, did the magistrate err by failing to make any award of interest under s 34 of the Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) (MCA)?4.Did the magistrate err by failing to make an order in respect of the costs of the proceedings?5.Has the magistrate determined the claim of J P Stevens without having heard from it?Background Circumstances On 21 October 2004, a Ms Vihervaara instituted proceedings against the respondent in the District Court (the De facto Action). She sought a division of property under s 9 of the De Facto Relationships Act 1996 (SA) in consequence of the termination of a relationship which she alleged had subsisted between her and the respondent for many years. The respondent retained von Doussas in relation to the dispute about her entitlements. Ms Vihervaara applied to the District Court for an order restraining von Doussas from acting for the respondent in those proceedings. She contended that von Doussas and, in particular, Mr Carabelas, had previously acted for her in relation to her claim; that confidential information given by her to von Doussas may be used to her detriment; and that von Doussas was in breach of fiduciary duties owed to her. On 2 November 2004, a District Court judge made an order restraining von Doussas and Mr Carabelas from acting for the respondent in relation to the De facto Action. On 10 November 2004 the judge declined to vary his order so as to permit von Doussas to prosecute an appeal by the respondent to this Court. An appeal against the order made on 2 November 2004 (the Conflict Appeal) was brought by the respondent to this Court. Despite the terms of the District Court order, that appeal was instituted on the respondent’s behalf by von Doussas. When the appeal was called on for hearing on 7 February 2005 the Full Court declined to hear it while von Doussas remained the solicitors on the record for the respondent. The hearing was adjourned to 8 February 2005. J P Stevens was then retained and filed a notice of change of address for service. The hearing of the appeal commenced on 8 February after counsel announced that he was now instructed by J P Stevens. The precise means by which J P Stevens was instructed was not disclosed in the papers on this appeal. The respondent succeeded on the Conflict Appeal.[2] On 15 March 2005 the Full Court ordered that the restraining order made by the District Court be set aside and that Ms Vihervaara’s application to restrain von Doussas and Mr Carabelas from acting be dismissed with costs. The Full Court ordered that Ms Vihervaara pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal, save that von Doussas and Mr Carabelas were ordered to pay Ms Vihervaara’s costs thrown away on 7 February 2008.[2] Nasr v Vihervaara [2005] SASC 83; (2005) 91 SASR 222.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In the present case, von Doussas submitted that the magistrate’s decision was inconsistent with the documentary evidence and involved a conclusion which was glaringly improbable.The Evidence of Mr Carabelas Mr Carabelas is an experienced solicitor. He said that he regarded the work on the Conflict Appeal as having been carried out under the Terms of Engagement signed by the respondent on 16 July 2004. Mr Carabelas said that he discussed with the respondent the prospect of an appeal from the District Court order restraining von Doussas from acting. The respondent was distressed and angered by the District Court order and considered that he was being disadvantaged by Ms Vihervaara. Mr Carabelas said that he also considered for a time instituting judicial review proceedings in this Court in which von Doussas would be the plaintiff and the District Court the defendant. A draft of these proposed judicial review proceedings dated 19 November 2004 was exhibited at the trial. Mr Carabelas also admitted that on 22 November 2004 he had written a letter to Ms Vihervaara’s solicitor in which, amongst other things, he had said:We advise that we are presently in the process of completing documentation intended to instigate an action pursuant to Rule 98 of the Supreme Court Rules and to seek Orders by way of Judicial Review in respect of the Orders made by [the District Court] in the above action on 2nd November 2004 and 10th November 2004.…We confirm that we are not presently acting, nor purport to act for Mr Nasr in fear of contravention of the Orders but the proceedings intended will be issued on behalf of the writer and our firm of solicitors as plaintiffs with the District Court of South Australia as respondent. On 24 November 2004 Mr Carabelas obtained the respondent’s instructions to institute an appeal. He was very confident that the appeal would be successful. When taking instructions from the respondent on 24 November 2004 he did tell the respondent that “in all probability” von Doussas would not be able to charge him in the event that the appeal was unsuccessful. Mr Carabelas said that he said that because he considered that if the conflict of interest of von Doussas was confirmed it would mean that it was inappropriate for it to have acted in the first place. He believed that in those circumstances von Doussas would “probably” not be entitled to charge for its services. Mr Carabelas denied that he had told the respondent that if the appeal was unsuccessful von Doussas would forego its costs. When the Full Court said on 7 February 2005 that it was not prepared to hear the appeal while von Doussas remained the solicitors on the record, he arranged for J P Stevens to act for the respondent. The evidence does not disclose whether that was done with, or without, the respondent’s instructions. Mr Carabelas did not make any file note of his meeting with the respondent on 24 November 2004. He said that he often did not make notes in relation to his discussions with the respondent. Mr Carabelas did, however, produce a letter dated 10 December 2004 which he had sent to the respondent and which he said accurately reflected their discussion. The letter included the following:We wish to report that we have now completed your instructions with respect to the institution and service [of] a Notice of Appeal to the Full Bench of the Supreme Court of South Australia in respect of the Orders made by His Honour Judge Smith concerning the supposed conflict of interest issue.Firstly, we wish to confirm that the Appeal was instituted after lengthy discussions with you and, in particular, your firm request that we do proceed with the Appeal as concluded in the course of discussions on 24th November 2004.Specifically, we wish to confirm that the background to the matter includes your very firm and specific instructions to the effect that you were very unhappy with the decision of Judge Smith and that you wanted to have the matter Appealed.Also, we refer specifically to the very firm advice given to you following the orders of Judge Smith in which we informed you very specifically that in all the circumstances it is a decision for you whether you wish to continue to have us as your solicitors and the writer to have the conduct of the matter or whether you may be prepared to consider having other solicitors carry on with the conduct of the matter.It is in this context that we must make it very clear that we have always advised you of your rights to have other solicitors to act for you but you have specifically resisted any such alternative and have specifically requested that we continue to act for you.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The contention that the magistrate had determined the plaintiff’s claim in the Magistrates Court without hearing from J P Stevens was not pursued on appeal. In any event, J P Stevens has not appealed the magistrate’s order. The Court was informed that J P Stevens had notice of the appeal of von Doussas. It has not sought to intervene.Conclusion For the reasons given above, my conclusion is that the appeal should be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The magistrate concluded:I am satisfied that the plaintiff did, through its agent Mr Carabelas, agree to pursue the Supreme Court Appeal at its expense on the condition as outlined by the defendant and that the notion of charging for the Appeal was an afterthought. The plaintiff failed to advise the defendant in explicit and unequivocal terms concerning the matter of costs precisely because payment by the defendant was not contemplated at the relevant time. I prefer the defendant’s version of events, particularly when combined with [a] the lack of any written record of the meeting of 24th November; [b] the lack of a separate retainer or amendment to the one that existed, and [c] the documents already referred to.Consideration In the ordinary course, legal practitioners act for clients under a retainer which provides for the practitioner’s remuneration. However, there are many circumstances in which practitioners agree to act pro bono. Those circumstances include public spiritedness by practitioners, an acceptance of a professional responsibility to make legal representation available to those whose liberty is jeopardised and who are unable themselves to afford legal representation, and a willingness to assist the courts in the proper administration of justice. The circumstances also include cases in which practitioners accept some level of personal responsibility for the predicament in which the client finds himself/herself, or simply loyalty to the client. In other words, it is not unknown for practitioners to agree to act in a matter without an expectation of payment. The attitude attributed to von Doussas by the respondent in the present case has to be assessed against that general experience. Counsel submitted that the magistrate had erred by attaching significance to the lack of a separate retainer or an amendment to the Terms of Engagement dated 20 July 2004. I consider that the absence of a separate retainer or an amendment was really a neutral factor. On one view, it could be said that the Conflict Appeal to this Court was so different from the work for which von Doussas had been engaged originally that a separate retainer, or at least an amendment to the existing retainer, could have been expected. But on the other hand, the Terms of Engagement letter said expressly that it was setting out the general terms upon which von Doussas would act, not only in relation to the de facto property issues but on “any further matters in which you may kindly instruct us”. In my opinion, those Terms of Engagement were capable of encompassing the Conflict Appeal. That being so, the absence of a separate retainer or an amendment to the original, was not, in my opinion, particularly significant. However, I note that the magistrate’s reference to the absence of a separate retainer, or an amendment, appears not to have been a primary reason for his acceptance of the respondent’s evidence. Instead, it was a matter which he used by way of confirmation, having already decided that the respondent’s evidence was credible and reliable.