Von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd v NASR

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

VON DOUSSAS LEGAL PTY LTD v NASR

[2009] SASC 246

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Bleby, The Honourable Justice Gray and The Honourable Justice Layton)

20 August 2009

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE'S FINDINGS OF FACT

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - REMUNERATION

MAGISTRATES - JURISDICTION AND PROCEDURE GENERALLY - JURISDICTION, POWERS AND DUTIES - SUBJECT MATTER - OTHER MATTERS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

Appeal by permission from dismissal by single Judge of appeal from decision of Magistrate - Magistrate held that appellant, a firm of solicitors, was not entitled to payment by respondent of costs of an appeal relating to alleged conflict of interest of appellant in acting for respondent - whether Magistrate erred in finding that parties agreed that appeal relating to conflict of interest would be conducted at no cost to respondent - whether Judge erred in finding that judgment in the Magistrates Court was entered by consent - whether Magistrate had jurisdiction to determine liability under retainer or whether determination of that issue is exclusively within the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court - whether Magistrate determined liability under retainer or under separate agreement.

Appeal dismissed - Magistrate's findings of fact not shown to be in error - Magistrate had jurisdiction to determine all issues.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) s 42; Legal Practitioners Act 1936-1978 (SA) s 17; De Facto Relationships Act 1996 (SA), referred to.
King William Law Chambers v Mobitel (International) Pty Ltd (1981) 29 SASR 316; Re Herbert (1887) 34 Ch D 504; Re Jones (1887) 36 Ch D 105; Von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd v Nasr [2008] SASC 206, discussed.
Nasr v Vihervaara (2005) 91 SASR 222; Burridge v Bellew (1975) 32 LTNS 807, considered.

VON DOUSSAS LEGAL PTY LTD v NASR
[2009] SASC 246

Full Court:      Bleby, Gray and Layton JJ

BLEBY J.

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal by permission from a decision of a judge of this Court dismissing an appeal from a decision of a magistrate. The Magistrate held that the appellant (“von Doussas”) was not entitled to payment from the respondent, Mr Nasr, for certain legal services provided by von Doussas.

  2. The appeal raises questions as to whether the work was done by a solicitor pursuant to a retainer and, if so, whether the Magistrates Court had jurisdiction to determine the extent of the retainer and the amount payable by the client under it, or whether such questions are within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under s 42 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA). Incidental questions concerning interest and the rights of a non-party to the appeal are also raised.

    Background

  3. In 2004 Mr Nasr retained von Doussas to act for him in a dispute with a Ms Vihervaara concerning a property settlement under the De Facto Relationships Act 1996 (SA). Mr Carabelas of von Doussas was the solicitor with the conduct of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd v NASR and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 246
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd v NASR, the appellant, a firm of solicitors, appealed against the decision of a single Judge who had dismissed their appeal from a decision of the Magistrate. The primary issue in this case was whether the Magistrate had erred in finding that the parties had agreed that the costs of an appeal relating to a conflict of interest would be borne by the respondent, and whether the Magistrate had jurisdiction to determine the liability under the retainer agreement. Additionally, the appeal raised questions about whether the Magistrate had jurisdiction to determine the extent of the retainer and the amount payable by the client under it, or whether such questions are within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under section 42 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA).

The reasoning of the court was that the Magistrate's findings of fact were not shown to be in error. The Magistrate had jurisdiction to determine all issues. The appeal was dismissed on the basis that the Magistrate's finding that the judgment in the Magistrates Court was entered by consent was accurate, as it reflected the material before the court. The court found that the Magistrate had not overlooked interest, given that the only information before him was that the solicitor in attendance for von Doussas neither applied for costs of the Magistrates Court action nor for interest on the judgment. Furthermore, the court held that the Magistrate had jurisdiction to determine the extent of the retainer and the amount payable by the client under it.

In conclusion, the appeal was dismissed, and the Magistrate's findings of fact were upheld. The Magistrate had jurisdiction to determine all issues, including the liability under the retainer agreement and the amount payable by the client under it. The court did not find any error in the Magistrate's decision, and the appeal was accordingly dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal raises questions as to whether the work was done by a solicitor pursuant to a retainer and, if so, whether the Magistrates Court had jurisdiction to determine the extent of the retainer and the amount payable by the client under it, or whether such questions are within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under s 42 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA). Incidental questions concerning interest and the rights of a non-party to the appeal are also raised.Background In 2004 Mr Nasr retained von Doussas to act for him in a dispute with a Ms Vihervaara concerning a property settlement under the De Facto Relationships Act 1996 (SA). Mr Carabelas of von Doussas was the solicitor with the conduct of the matter. A letter of engagement dated 16 July 2004 was signed by Mr Nasr on 20 July 2004. It included the following provision:Before commencing work we will set out in this letter the general terms on which we accept instructions with a view to these applying not only in relation to this particular matter but any further matters in which you may kindly instruct us. This will make for certainty and should help you in planning and budgeting.1. The Work1.1 DescriptionAll matters and advice incidental to alleged de facto property settlement and children’s issues matter.The letter also explained the basis on which von Doussas was to charge Mr Nasr for the work done. On 2 November 2004, on the application of Ms Vihervaara, a District Court judge made an order restraining von Doussas and Mr Carabelas from acting for Mr Nasr in relation to the De Facto Relationships Act proceedings. This was on the ground that von Doussas and, in particular, Mr Carabelas, had previously acted for Ms Vihervaara. Notwithstanding the order, von Doussas instituted, in Mr Nasr’s name, an appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court against that order (“the conflict appeal”). One of the issues on this appeal is whether that was done on the instructions of Mr Nasr. When the conflict appeal was called on for hearing on 7 February 2005, the Full Court declined to hear the appeal while von Doussas continued to act for Mr Nasr. J P Stevens Lawyers were then engaged to represent Mr Nasr for the appeal, and the Full Court heard argument on the appeal on 8 February. Counsel for the appellant was Mr T L Stanley. Judgment was handed down on 15 March 2005.[1] The Full Court set aside the order made by the District Court Judge. The Court ordered that Ms Vihervaara pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, but that von Doussas and Mr Carabelas pay Ms Vihervaara’s costs thrown away for 7 February 2005. On 2 June 2005 von Doussas obtained an allocatur in respect of the costs of the appeal to which the appellant was entitled in the sum of $12,096.50. However, the costs order against Ms Vihervaara has never been enforced.[1] Nasr v Vihervaara [2005] SASC 83, (2005) 91 SASR 222. After the Full Court judgment was handed down, the relationship between Mr Nasr and von Doussas deteriorated, due principally to Mr Nasr’s refusal to pay the counsel fees and, subsequently, their own fees and those of J P Stevens Lawyers in respect of the conflict appeal. Von Doussas ceased to act for Mr Nasr at all on 7 October 2005.The proceedings in the Magistrates Court

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLEBY J GRAY J (dissent) LAYTON J (dissent)
In respect of the other grounds of appeal it is convenient to deal with them in reverse order.The entry of judgment in the Magistrates Court Von Doussas submitted on this appeal that the Judge, based on what was said to be erroneous submissions before him, had made a finding that the judgment entered in the Magistrates Court was a judgment entered by consent, when it was asserted that that was not so. Counsel sought to tender, on the hearing of this appeal, an affidavit of the solicitor who attended at the Magistrates Court hearing on the day judgment was entered. This was fresh evidence which was not before the Judge and which, if considered relevant, could have been placed before him. The Judge had received an affidavit sworn by Mr Nasr’s solicitor who attended on the relevant date before the Magistrate deposing to what then occurred. Von Doussas had adequate notice of the intention to rely on that affidavit before the Judge. No attempt was made to file an answering affidavit. For those reasons the tender of the affidavit of von Doussas’ solicitor was rejected. The affidavit of Mr Nasr’s solicitor included the following paragraphs:17.On the 14th of March 2008, the Judgment was entered in favour of the Appellant in the sum of $6,393.73 in the Magistrates Court action by His Honour Magistrate Gumpl (with the sum of $2,000.00 deducted from the amount agreed on the adjudication, as the Respondent had previously paid this sum to the Appellant).18.I was present at the Magistrates Court hearing on the 14th of March 2008 when the Judgment was entered. At the hearing, I specifically asked that His Honour Magistrate Gumpl note that the question of costs of the trial in the Magistrates Court action is yet to be determined (as indicated in the entry of the 14th of March 2008 in the Copy of Record in the Magistrates Court action). Furthermore, at the hearing, the solicitor in attendance for the Appellant neither applied for costs of the Magistrates Court action, nor for interest on the Judgment.It was not asserted in the affidavit that the judgment in the Magistrates Court was by consent. However, the solicitor elsewhere in the affidavit deposed to the circumstances of the application to tax von Doussas’ costs in the Supreme Court and that, following the rulings of the Master, on 11 February 2008, “the adjudication was finalised (without the need for a full taxation), when it was agreed that [von Doussas’] recoverable costs amounted to $8,393.73”. There was no dispute that such agreement had been reached. The copy of the Record of the Magistrates Court indicates that on 14 March 2008 judgment was entered in the sum of $6,393.73. It does not suggest that it was by consent. Contrary to the submission of von Doussas’ counsel in this appeal, the Judge did not make a finding that the judgment in the Magistrates Court was entered by consent. His Honour’s finding accurately reflected the material that was before him, namely that the Magistrate “had entered judgment for the amount upon which the parties had agreed”. That says nothing about the attitude of von Doussas as to whether a judgment should be entered at all. The Judge’s finding that the Magistrate had not overlooked interest was also accurate, given that the only information before him was that the solicitor in attendance for von Doussas neither applied for costs of the Magistrates Court action nor for interest on the judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLEBY J,