VIP Home Services (NSW) Pty Ltd v Swan

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

VIP HOME SERVICES (NSW) PTY LTD v SWAN & ANOR

[2011] SASC 110

Judgment of The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle

19 July 2011

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - DISCHARGE, BREACH AND DEFENCES TO ACTION FOR BREACH - CONDITIONS - CONDITIONS AND WARRANTIES

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - DISCHARGE, BREACH AND DEFENCES TO ACTION FOR BREACH - REPUDIATION AND NON-PERFORMANCE - ELECTION AND RESCISSION

VIP Home Services (NSW) Pty Ltd (VIP) granted a franchise to Mr and Mrs Swan (the Swans) in July 1998 under a Franchise Agreement (the Agreement) to carry on a lawn mowing business – clause 5.1 of the Agreement obliged VIP to allocate to the Swans ‘regular customers’ whose business was worth $500 in ‘average weekly income’ – clause 15.1.1 obliged the Swans to pay a once off ‘franchise fee’ of $10,250 – clause 15.2 obliged the Swans to make certain monthly payments to VIP including an ‘operating fee’ and ‘pager service fee’ – from the outset, VIP failed to perform clause 5.1 – VIP and the Swans informally agreed that the Swans would continue to operate the franchise but need not make any monthly payments until VIP complied with clause 5.1 – by February 2011, VIP still had not complied with clause 5.1 – the Swans ceased operating the franchise under the VIP name and set up their own lawn mowing business – in April 2009, VIP brought proceedings in the Magistrates Court against the Swans alleging breaches of the Agreement by the Swans and claiming various amounts allegedly due to VIP under the Agreement – whether VIP breached clause 5.1 – whether clause 5.1 was a fundamental – whether the Swans terminated the Agreement for breach by VIP in February 2001 – whether the Swans were obliged to continue payments under clause 15.2 prior to February 2001.

Held: clause 5.1 was a fundamental term of the contract – VIP must have realised that Mr Swan was no longer conducting a franchise business and had purported to terminate the agreement – VIP had reasonable notice of that intention and did nothing within a reasonable time to remedy its continuing breach – VIP admitted that it was in breach of clause 5.1 until October 2001 – the Swans were entitled to terminate the Agreement in February 2001 – the Swans were not obliged to make payment to VIP under clause 15.2 in respect of the period prior to the termination, having regard to the arrangement reached between the Swans and VIP

Appeal against Magistrate’s decision dismissing VIP’s claims for payments under clause 15.2 dismissed.

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSIDERATION - FAILURE OF CONSIDERATION

The Magistrate allowed the Swans’ counterclaim at trial – through their counterclaim, the Swans sought repayment of the franchise fee of $10,250 paid under clause 15.1.1 of the Agreement – the Magistrate found that clause 5.1 was a condition precedent to the obligation to make lump sum payments under the Agreement –…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read VIP Home Services (NSW) Pty Ltd v Swan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASC 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties in this case were VIP Home Services (NSW) Pty Ltd, a franchise provider, and Mr. and Mrs. Swan, the franchisees. The dispute centred around a Franchise Agreement signed on 16 July 1998, where VIP granted the Swans a franchise to operate a lawn mowing business under the VIP name. The core issue was VIP's failure to allocate regular customers to the Swans as required by clause 5.1 of the Agreement. The Swans ceased operating the franchise in February 2001 due to VIP's non-compliance and set up their own lawn mowing business. VIP subsequently brought proceedings in the Magistrates Court against the Swans for breaches of the Agreement and for various amounts due under the Agreement.

The court was required to determine several legal issues. Firstly, whether clause 5.1 of the Agreement was a fundamental term and, if so, whether VIP's failure to comply with this clause constituted a breach that allowed the Swans to terminate the Agreement. Secondly, the court needed to ascertain if the Swans were obligated to continue making monthly payments to VIP under clause 15.2 prior to the termination of the Agreement in February 2001. The court had to examine the nature of the breach and its impact on the contractual obligations of the parties.

The court held that clause 5.1 was indeed a fundamental term of the contract. VIP had failed to allocate the required regular customers from the outset, and this failure persisted until October 2001. Given VIP's continuous breach and its reasonable notice of the Swans' intention to terminate the Agreement, the Swans were justified in terminating the contract in February 2001. Consequently, the Swans were not obliged to make monthly payments to VIP under clause 15.2 for the period prior to the termination, considering the informal arrangement reached between the parties.

The final orders of the court were in favour of the Swans. The court ruled that VIP's breach of the fundamental term justified the termination of the Agreement by the Swans and absolved the Swans from making further payments to VIP under clause 15.2 prior to the termination date. This decision underscored the importance of adhering to fundamental contractual obligations and the consequences of failing to do so.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

VIP has appealed against this decision. Facts I will limit the facts, as best I can, to matters essential to the main issues. In any event, the evidence is scant. VIP did not call any witness who was able to give evidence based on direct knowledge of the events in question. Mr Swan was the only witness for the defendants. Hereafter I will refer to him as if he were the sole defendant. It is not surprising that when he gave his evidence in June 2011, over 10 years after severing his relationship with VIP, his memory was very limited. There is no evidence, apart from some intermittent correspondence between solicitors, explaining what happened between about 2002 and the purported termination by VIP in early 2007. Nor is there anything explaining what happened between then and the institution of proceedings in April 2009. As well, the Magistrate has not made many findings of fact, and some of them emerge as a matter of inference from his reasons. This is by way of explanation for the limited nature of the summary that follows. The Agreement was signed on 16 July 1998. It was for a term of 20 years: clause 3.1. Clause 4.1 provides:4.1VIP grants to the franchisee a franchise to carry on the Franchise Business in the Territory under the VIP name. Clause 5 is at the heart of the dispute. It provides as follows:5 ALLOCATION OF INITIAL CUSTOMERS5.1 In consideration of the payment by the franchisee of the fees set out in clause 15 [Fees] VIP agrees to allocate to the franchisee Regular Customers to the value of $500.00 in Average Weekly Income.5.2 The Regular Customers to be allocated to the franchisee under clause 5.1 will be identified in a list of customers provided to the franchisee within 7 days of the franchisee completing his training.5.3 The franchisee shall sign the List of Customers before commencing operation of the Franchise Business.5.4 Signature of the List of Customers shall be an agreement by the franchisee that5.4.1the franchisee has been allocated Regular Customers to the value of $500.00 in Average Weekly Income5.4.2the Customers identified on the List of Customers are Regular Customers5.4.3the information provided on the List of Customers is accurate.5.5 The franchisee should not sign the List of Customers if he does not agree as set out in clause 5.4.5.6 Upon signature of the List of Customers the franchisee shall have no further claim whatsoever in respect of the obligations of VIP under clause 5.1.… Clause 6 provides for the allocation of additional “regular customers” by VIP, for whom the franchisee must make a payment in an amount determined under the Agreement. Clause 7 requires VIP to refer to the franchisee customer enquiries directed to VIP from persons who want services performed in the franchise territory. Clause 15 provides for payments by the franchisee. It provides as follows:15 FEES15.1The franchisee shall pay to VIP $16,000.00 on execution of this agreement by the franchisee which is15.1.1as to $10,250.00 for franchise fee and15.1.2as to $5,750.00 for training and advertising.15.2The franchisee shall pay to VIP throughout the term of this agreement15.2.1an operating fee of $389.00 each month. The operating fee shall be paid on or before the 7th day of the month for which the operating fee is due. If the franchisee pays to VIP $339.00 on or before the first day of the month for which the operating fee is due then VIP agrees to accept $339.00 in full settlement of the operating fee due for that month. The operating fee payable under this clause $15.2.1 is for administration.15.2.2a pager service fee of $66.00 each month. The pager service fee shall be paid on or before the 7th day of the month for which the pager service fee is due. If the franchisee pays to VIP $56.00 on or before the first day of the month for which the pager service fee is due then VIP agrees to accept $56.00 in full settlement of the pager service fee due for that month.15.2.3any insurance premiums due by the franchisee in respect of insurance arranged by VIP on behalf of the franchisee.15.3All the sums described in clause 15.2.1 and clause 15.2.2 shall be increased each financial year on the 1st day of July or such other date thereafter as VIP shall specify by such amount as VIP shall specify. The maximum increase in any one financial year shall be15.3.1the same proportion as the increase in the CPI since the last increase or in the case of the first increase since the date of this agreement, or15.3.210 per centwhichever is the greater.15.4Subject to clause 36.6 any sum payable in respect of operating fees under clause 15.2.1 shall continue to be payable until the Termination Date even if15.4.1any intellectual property rights of VIP in relation to the Franchise Business shall not be granted be declared invalid or cease to exist or otherwise fail to protect VIP or the franchisee15.4.2the franchisee has ceased carrying on the Franchise Business or15.4.3the franchisee has transferred some or all of his Customers to VIP or Other Franchisees of VIPprior to the Termination Date.15.5The franchisee shall if VIP so directs execute a payment authority in a form nominated by VIP in relation to the sums payable under clause 15.2.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.