Vincentia MC Pharmacy Pty Ltd v Australian Community Pharmacy Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Vincentia MC Pharmacy Pty Ltd v Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2020] FCA 438

Related to: Choice Pharmacy Vincentia Pty Ltd v Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (No 2) [2020] FCA 363
File number: NSD 348 of 2020
Judge: FLICK J
Date of judgment: 2 April 2020
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for a stay of orders pending appeal – arguable point of construction – stay granted

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for security of costs for appeal refused     

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act1976 (Cth) s 56

National Health Act 1953 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules2011 (Cth) rr 36.08 and 36.09

National Health (Australian Community Pharmacy Authority Rules) Determination 2011 (Cth) s 5   

Cases cited:

Chief of the Defence Force v Gaynor [2016] FCA 311

Choice Pharmacy Vincentia Pty Ltd v Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2020] FCA 93

Choice Pharmacy Vincentia Pty Ltd v Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (No 2) [2020] FCA 363

Commissioner of Taxation v Donoghue [2015] FCA 337

Fard v Secretary, Department of Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1224

Philip Morris Limited v Nixon [1999] FCA 1281

Stambe v Minister for Health (No 2) [2019] FCA 479

Tait v Bindal People [2002] FCA 322

Date of hearing: 1 and 2 April 2020
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 21
Counsel for the Appellant: Ms M Allars SC
Solicitor for the Appellant: Chong & Co Lawyers
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Mr D Blencowe of Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr T Flaherty
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Michael Flaherty Solicitor
Counsel for the Third Respondent: The Third Respondent filed a submitting notice save as to costs

ORDERS

NSD 348 of 2020
BETWEEN:

VINCENTIA MC PHARMACY PTY LTD (ACN 617 467 366)

Appellant

AND:

THE AUSTRALIAN COMMUNITY PHARMACY AUTHORITY

First Respondent

CHOICE PHARMACY VINCENTIA PTY LTD (ACN 605 545 462)

Second Respondent

THE SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

FLICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 APRIL 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Subject to the Appellant prosecuting the appeal with all due expedition, the orders made on 18 March 2020 be stayed until the hearing and resolution of the appeal.

2.The application by the Second Respondent for security for costs of the appeal be dismissed.

3.The costs of the present hearing be the Appellant’s costs in the appeal.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

FLICK J:

  1. In March 2017 the Appellant, Vincentia MC Pharmacy Pty Ltd (“Vincentia MC Pharmacy”) applied to the Third Respondent, the Secretary of the Department of Health (the “Secretary”), for approval pursuant to the National Health Act 1953 (Cth) to supply pharmaceutical benefits from premises at a Medical Centre in Vincentia.  Vincentia is a small town on the south coast of New South Wales.  In June 2017, the First Respondent, the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vincentia MC Pharmacy Pty Ltd v Australian Community Pharmac... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 438
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Vincentia MC Pharmacy Pty Ltd sought a stay of the orders of the Federal Court, which found that it did not meet the definition of a “large medical centre” in the National Health (Australian Community Pharmacy Authority Rules) Determination 2011, and therefore, it was not entitled to approval to dispense Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS) medicines. The decision followed a determination by the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority that Vincentia MC Pharmacy did not meet the criteria for approval because it did not operate for at least 70 hours each week. The primary issue for the Full Court was whether the phrase “operates at least 70 hours each week” in the definition of “large medical centre” required that a pharmacy operate for at least 70 hours each and every week, or whether it was sufficient if the pharmacy operated for at least 70 hours each week on average. The Full Court found that the phrase was capable of bearing more than one meaning but ultimately construed it as requiring that the pharmacy operate for at least 70 hours in each consecutive period of seven days. The Full Court considered that this interpretation served the purpose of creating a category for approvals related to “large medical centres” and met the demand for dispensing of PBS medicines that such centres generate.

The Full Court also considered whether it should grant a stay of the orders of the Federal Court pending the appeal. The Full Court noted that the granting of a stay was a matter of discretion and that the party seeking a stay must demonstrate a reason, or an appropriate case, to warrant the exercise of the discretion in their favour. The Full Court found that the grounds of appeal were reasonably arguable and that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of a stay. The Full Court also noted that the appellant had agreed to prosecute the appeal with all due expedition. Accordingly, the Full Court granted a stay of the orders of the Federal Court pending the hearing and resolution of the appeal. The Full Court also dismissed the application by the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority for security for costs of the appeal and ordered that the costs of the present hearing be the appellant’s costs in the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Subject to the Appellant prosecuting the appeal with all due expedition, the orders made on 18 March 2020 be stayed until the hearing and resolution of the appeal.

2. The application by the Second Respondent for security for costs of the appeal be dismissed.

3. The costs of the present hearing be the Appellant’s costs in the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Rule 36.08 provides as follows: Stay of execution or proceedings under judgment appealed from (1) An appeal does not: (a)operate as a stay of execution or a stay of any proceedings under the judgment subject to the appeal; or (b)invalidate any proceedings already taken. (2)However, an appellant or interested person may apply to the Court for an order to stay the execution of the proceeding until the appeal is heard and determined. (3)An application may be made under subrule (2) even though the court from which the appeal is brought has previously refused an application of a similar kind.… Clearly enough, r 36.08 confers a discretion upon the Court when deciding whether or not to grant a stay. That discretion has been described as a “broad discretion”: e.g., Commissioner of Taxation v Donoghue [2015] FCA 337 at [18] per Edmonds J. The principles to be applied when exercising the discretion are not in doubt and have long been established: Philip Morris Limited v Nixon [1999] FCA 1281. Sackville, Hely and Gyles JJ there observed:[17]The general principles governing an application for a stay pending the determination of an appeal or application for leave to appeal are not in doubt. The party seeking a stay must demonstrate a reason, or an appropriate case, to warrant the exercise of a discretion in his or her favour. This requirement is not satisfied by the mere filing of an appeal or an application for leave to appeal: …The Court has a discretion whether or not to grant the stay, and if so, as to the terms that will be fair. In the exercise of the Court's discretion, it weighs consideration such as the balance of convenience and the competing rights of the parties, in particular whether prejudice will be caused by reason of the grant or withholding of a stay: ... Within this framework, the Court exercises a broad discretion, and the party seeking a stay does not have to establish “special” circumstances: … In general, a party which has succeeded at the trial is entitled to the benefit of a judgment and thus to commence with the presumption that the judgment is correct: …(citations omitted) One important factor is whether the grounds of appeal are reasonably arguable but neither that factor nor any other single factor is necessarily determinative: Chief of the Defence Force v Gaynor [2016] FCA 311 at [11] per Gleeson J (“Gaynor”). On the facts of the present case the central issue upon which the primary Judge resolved the case against the Vincentia MC Pharmacy was that it did not operate the pharmacy “for at least 70 hours each week”. That phrase was employed in the definition of a “large medical centre” in s 5(1) of the National Health (Australian Community Pharmacy Authority Rules) Determination 2011. The primary Judge set forth the facts of relevance to whether the Vincentia MC Pharmacy operated “for at least 70 hours each week” as follows:[11]At the partial hearing of Choice Pharmacy’s application …. counsel for MC Pharmacy conceded that, based on rosters provided to the Authority, the evidence before the Authority was that the Medical Centre was not open on public holidays between 30 January 2017 and the first week of June 2017 … Those public holidays were 14 to 17 April 2017 (inclusive) (Easter) and 25 April 2017 (Anzac Day). Accordingly, in the weeks on which those public holidays fell, fewer than 70 hours were worked at the Medical Centre. [12]Counsel for MC Pharmacy also conceded that, as a matter of fact, the Medical Centre was also not open on any of the public holidays which fell on 25 and 26 December 2016, 1, 2 and 26 January 2017 and the Queen’s Birthday on 12 June 2017, but that information was not before the Authority when it made its recommendation. That concession would only have relevance if the Court found that the requirement that a medical centre operate at least 70 hours each week is a jurisdictional fact.Part of the contention being advanced on behalf of the Choice Pharmacy was “that ‘each week’ goes beyond ‘a week’ to mean ‘each and every week’…”: [2020] FCA 93 at [16]. The primary Judge relevantly accepted that the phrase in issue was one “capable of bearing more than one meaning” but ultimately concluded that the phrase should be construed as requiring “a prescribing medical practitioner … be in attendance … at least 70 hours in each consecutive period of seven days”. These conclusions were expressed in part as follows: [63] The Court accepts the submissions that the term “operates at least 70 hours each week” used in s 5 (b) of the definition of “large medical centre” is capable of bearing more than one meaning and is, to some extent, evaluative. This is because there is nothing in Item 136 (or the 2011 Rules more broadly) which indicates for what period the medical centre must meet the test and the term “operates” is not defined. ……[67] In the Court’s view, the meaning to be derived from “at least 70 hours each week” in ss 5(a) and (b) is a requirement that the ordinary and habitual hours in which the medical centre operates and a prescribing medical practitioner will be in attendance are at least 70 hours in each consecutive period of seven days. This is what the evidence before the Authority should demonstrate, for whatever period the Authority elects to receive evidence. This interpretation serves the purpose of Item 136 by ensuring that in each week, the medical centre operates with the services of a prescribing medical practitioner during extended business hours. The purpose of creating a category for approvals related to “large medical centres” is to meet the demand for dispensing of PBS medicines that such centres generate. That purpose would be undermined if the “at least 70 hours each week” criterion is not strictly interpreted.[68] A stated intention to operate on some “selected” public holidays, when the usual hours are only 70.5 per week, has the result that on up to eight weeks in a year the medical centre will not operate at least 70 hours each week where (as here) there is no intention expressed to make up the lost hours at other times during the relevant weeks and no evidence that those lost hours were in fact made up in the weeks in which public holidays fell during the evidence period. It demonstrates that the Medical Centre’s operating hours are not ordinarily or habitually at least 70 hours each week or that its intended operation is to have at least one prescribing medical practitioner at the Medical Centre for that period each week, even though it may often do so. In the Court’s view, it would be necessary for there to be express words in the 2011 Rules addressing public holidays to produce the result contended for by MC Pharmacy.[69] The Court does not accept that this interpretation has the effect of reading the words “and every” into ss 5(b) and (c); it gives the words “at least 70 hours each week” their plain meaning in circumstances where there is nothing in the National Health Act or the 2011 Rules which suggests that some other meaning should be adopted. The Court also does not accept that that interpretation operates to frustrate the stated intention of Item 136 in which the definition of “large medical centre” has relevance. The stated intention is that there be a pharmacy available where a medical centre of a particular kind operates outside normal business hours consistent with the 70 hours each week requirement in ss 5(b) and (c) of the 2011 Rules.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established