VICARIO & VICARIO -v- GLENNON
[2002] SADC 151Judge Anderson
Civil
Giuseppe Vicario, the first named Plaintiff (“the Plaintiff”) and his wife, Rosina Vicario, issued proceedings on 22 October 2001 against the Defendant, Bernard John Glennon, seeking damages arising from a motor vehicle collision which occurred at about 10.00am on 8 July 2000 on the Sturt Highway at Gawler Belt.
The Defendant, in his defence, has denied responsibility in any form for the loss alleged by the Plaintiffs and has alleged, in the alternative, that the Plaintiff, who was the driver of his vehicle, was negligent and/or contributed to the Plaintiff’s loss.
At the outset counsel for the Plaintiffs, Mr McRae, with the consent of Mr Milazzo of counsel for the Defendant, indicated to me that this matter was proceeding on the issue of liability only.
The Plaintiff said in evidence that at the time of impact he was driving his Berlina motor vehicle north on the Sturt Highway towards the Barossa Valley. He had travelled from his home via that of his passengers’, Mr & Mrs Mercurio, and his stepson’s residence at Para Hills to the Gawler bypass and then onto the Sturt Highway.
The Plaintiff was towing a small two-wheeled single axle trailer in which was paraphernalia to be used for olive picking. It was the Plaintiff’s intention to travel to the Barossa Valley and for the party to pick olives.
I reject the suggestion implicit from the evidence of Mr West, that this impact occurred after the Plaintiff and his party had visited Mr West’s property and picked olives. I find that at the time of impact, the Plaintiff was travelling towards the Barossa Valley in order that the picking of olives may be undertaken.
The passengers in the Plaintiff’s vehicle were, as I have said, his cousin, Mr Mercurio and Mrs Mercurio. Mr Mercurio was seated behind the driver. His wife was next to him. The Plaintiff was the driver and his wife was occupying the front passenger seat.
Each of the witnesses in the car gave evidence that, at the time of impact, it was raining. This evidence was contrary to that given by the Defendant and by Mr Jones, who was working in an adjacent factory, and was at the scene, and the evidence of Mr & Mrs Turnbull who were driving on the bypass to the rear of the Defendant. I find that whilst it had been raining earlier on that day, and whilst the road may have still had some dampness at the time of impact, it was not then raining and the road was not wet in the sense of being covered with water and, therefore, dangerous. This point lost importance in the course of the trial as the suggestion that the Plaintiff had, in some way, lost control of his vehicle and aquaplaned was not supported by the evidence and was not pursued.
In evidence the Plaintiff said that he drove his vehicle towards the Barossa Valley from the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Vicario & Vicario v Glennon No. DCCIV-01-1606 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] SADC 151
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue in the case was whether the Defendant was negligent in his driving or whether the Plaintiff, as the driver of the vehicle, was negligent or contributed to his own loss. The court had to decide whether the Defendant failed to keep a proper lookout, or if the Plaintiff's actions contributed to the accident. The court also had to consider whether the Defendant's actions, or lack thereof, contributed to the collision and the subsequent loss of the Plaintiffs.
The court found that the collision occurred as described by the Defendant, where the Plaintiff had left the roadway and moved onto the gravel verge, before bringing his vehicle back onto the roadway ahead of the semi-trailer. The court rejected the Plaintiff's scenario as physically impossible, based on the evidence presented and the angle of impact between the two vehicles. The court found that the Plaintiff had failed to observe oncoming traffic and re-entered the carriageway without ensuring it was clear, which constituted negligence. The court concluded that the Defendant's actions did not contribute to the collision and the subsequent loss of either Plaintiff, and therefore, s27A of the Wrongs Act 1936 had no application in this case.
The final orders of the court will be determined after hearing counsel on the question of costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi