Vescio and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

Vescio and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) [2022] AATA 1353 (26 May 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/0487

Re:Norina VESCIO

APPLICANT

AndTelstra Corporation Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:The Hon. Dennis Cowdroy AO QC, Deputy President

Date:26 May 2022

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal decides that the decision under review be set aside and substituted with the decision that the respondent is liable to make payments of compensation to the applicant pursuant to sections 17 and 18 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth).

........................................[SGD]................................

The Hon. Dennis Cowdroy AO QC, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – asbestos-related pleural diseases – multiple comorbidities – whether deceased’s death caused by asbestos-related pleural diseases or other comorbidities – whether asbestos-related pleural diseases can be considered an injury under s 5A(a) or s 5A(b) – whether Applicant entitled to compensation under ss 17 and 18 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) – decision set aside and substituted.

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4, 5, 7, 14, 17, 18.

CASES

Comcare v Starkey [2017] FCAFC 151

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May [2016] HCA 19

Wuth v Comcare [2022] FCAFC 42

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Henry Gray FRS, Anatomy Descriptive and Surgical (Barnes & Noble Books New York, 15th ed, 1995) 954.

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. Dennis Cowdroy AO QC, Deputy President

26 May 2022

  1. Ms Norina Vescio (“the applicant”) initiated proceedings for recovery of compensation under Section 17 and 18 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (“the SRC Act”) arising out of the death of her husband, the late Giovanni Vescio (“the deceased”) who died on 12 January 2019 aged 85 years. The respondent rejected such application.

    By Application for Review of Decision made on 29th of January 2020, the applicant seeks review of the decision of the respondent made on 17 December 2019, which affirmed the original decision dated 5 August 2019. Each decision found that the deceased’s death did not result from benign asbestos-related pleural disease.

  2. As will become apparent, the principal issue in these proceedings is whether the deceased died as a result of pulmonary disease or from renal failure.

    APPLICANT’S CLAIMS

  3. The Applicant is the widow of the late Giovanni Vescio ("deceased"). The deceased was born on 14 June 1933 in Italy. The deceased was employed as a linesman by the Respondent (formerly Post Master General's Department, then Telcom Australia) from 23 August 1972 to 4 November 1992.

  4. Throughout the deceased's employment by the Respondent as a linesman, he was exposed to and inhaled asbestos dust and fibre. The deceased's exposure to and inhalation of asbestos dust and fibre during his employment by the Respondent occurred in the manner and circumstances set out in paragraphs 4.1.1 to 4.1.21 of the Form 1 Statement of Particulars executed by the deceased on 11 December 2014 during his claim for common law damages against the Respondent in the Dust Diseases Tribunal of NSW.

  5. As a result of the deceased's exposure…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vescio and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 1353
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a claim for compensation under the *Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) by an applicant in relation to the death of the deceased, Mr Vescio, who had been employed by Telstra Corporation Limited. The applicant sought compensation on the basis that the deceased's death was caused by, or significantly contributed to by, asbestos-related pleural diseases, including diffuse pleural thickening, rounded atelectasis, and asbestos-related pleural effusion, which arose from his employment with the respondent. The respondent had affirmed a previous decision denying the claim, asserting that the deceased's death was due to renal failure, infection, or pneumonia, rather than asbestos-related conditions.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the deceased's death was caused by, or significantly contributed to by, his asbestos-related pleural diseases and whether these conditions were caused by, or significantly contributed to by, his employment with the respondent. Central to this determination was the question of whether the deceased's death was primarily attributable to his asbestos-related respiratory conditions or to his pre-existing comorbidities, specifically severe Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD), emphysema, and renal failure.

The court considered conflicting expert medical opinions. Dr Johnson opined that the asbestos-related respiratory diseases, including diffuse pleural thickening and pleural effusion, significantly contributed to the deceased's death, exacerbated by a surgical procedure. Conversely, AP McKenzie suggested that the most likely cause of death was Type II respiratory failure due to severe COPD and emphysema, with analgesic and sedative medications as contributing factors, and that renal failure may have contributed but was not the prime cause. While some experts agreed that the surgical procedure hastened death, there was disagreement on the extent to which pre-existing asbestos-related pleural disease and renal failure contributed to the cause of death. The Tribunal noted that the deceased suffered from emphysema, renal failure, diffuse pleural thickening, and pleural effusions, and that the applicant's experts attributed his death to the pleural conditions and a surgical procedure, while the respondent's experts pointed to renal failure or infection.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

By letter dated 9 December 2019, the Applicant requested a review of the Original decision. On 17 December 2019, the Respondent affirmed the Original decision to deny the Applicant's claim ("Review decision").DECISION UNDER REVIEW The decisions under review is the reviewable decision of the Respondent made on 17 December 2019, which affirmed the original decision dated 5 August 2019. The Original decision and the Review decision determined that the Applicant was not entitled to compensation under ss 17 and 18 of the SRC Act in respect of the death of the Deceased.ISSUES BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL Whether the applicant is entitled to compensation pursuant to ss 14, 17 and 18 of the SRC Act, because:(a) The deceased's death was caused by, and/or resulted from, and/or was contributed to, to a significant degree by each, and/or all of, the following injuries and diseases: diffuse pleural thickening, rounded atelectasis, asbestos related pleural disease and asbestos related right sided pleural effusion.(b) The deceased's diffuse pleural thickening, rounded atelectasis, asbestos related pleural disease and asbestos related right sided pleural effusion were caused by, and/or were contributed to, to a significant degree, by the deceased's employment by the Respondent. As will be apparent from the medical reports referred to hereunder, the deceased, prior to his death, suffered from emphysema, renal failure, diffuse pleural thickening and right sided pleural effusions. The expert reports provided by the applicant found that the deceased’s death resulted from his pleural thickening, rounded atelectasis and the right sided pleural effusion and that his condition deteriorated due to a surgical procedure performed at Manly Hospital in December 2019. The applicant’s medical experts claim that the cause of death was not due to renal failure nor to emphysema. The expert report provided by the respondent assert that the cause of the deceased’s death was renal failure, or the effects of infection or pneumonia.CHRONOLOGICAL SUMMARY OF MEDICAL HISTORY The applicant’s medical history commences on 23 October 2003, when an x-ray revealed consolidation or scarring at the right base and in axillary segment of the right upper lobe of the lungs. A week later, a CT scan conducted at the Warringah Medical Centre revealed pleural thickening adjacent to a small rib deformity most likely due to an old fracture. A chest x-ray report made on 15 January 2009 recorded “The pleural shadowing with the associated minor pleural calcification is probably the result of previous asbestos exposure. The round opacity at the right base posterior/medially is non-specific but may represent rounded atelectasis or possibly a neoplastic process”. On 30 January 2009 Dr Frankel reviewed the deceased at the Peninsula Respiratory Group. He reported:“Mr Vescio is an elderly gentleman who has bilateral pleural changes. I think that there are features to suggest pleural plaques and previous asbestos exposure with the possibility of other asbestos related pleural disease. I think that the right basal shadowing is likely all rounded atelectasis …”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent also relies upon the evidence of AP McKenzie, particularly his statement to the effect that Stage 5 kidney disease causes fluid retention which can severely exacerbate the impaired respiratory function in patients with COPD and emphysema. Further reliance is placed upon AP McKenzie’s opinion that recurrent pleural effusion has many features which are not typical of asbestos-related pleural effusion and his concluded view that the deceased’s pre-existing emphysema, renal failure and anticoagulant treatment probably contributed to the severity of the effusion and blood standing.CONSIDERATION OF THE ISSUES Was respiratory failure the cause of the deceased’s death? Dr Johnson provided the following opinion:“… I am of the opinion that his asbestos related respiratory disease i.e. the diffuse pleural thickening, pleural effusion and rounded atelectasis significantly contributed to his death. This is my opinion as there was relatively extensive diffuse pleural thickening on his radiology and in my experience, this amount of diffuse pleural thickening would have significantly contributed to his respiratory impairment and failure. The asbestos related pleural effusion resulted in him having to a have pleural drain, thoracoscopy and pleurodesis which worsened his diffuse pleural thickening. Was this not to have happened, it is very likely he would have survived for a significantly longer period. Therefore, in my view Mr Vescio’s death was attributable to his benign asbestos related pleural disease.” AP McKenzie disagreed with the joint expert opinion contained in the report dated 25 August 2021 as follows:“Prof Fox, Prof Bryant, Dr Johnson and I agree that Mr Vescio died as result of respiratory disease and respiratory failure. Prof Bryant, Dr Johnson and I also agree that the thoracoscopic surgical procedure and post-operative issues hastened his death. Prof Bryant disagrees with the other experts on the severity of Mr Vescio’s COPD and its contribution to the cause of death. The experts disagree about the extent to which the pre-existing asbestos-related pleural disease and renal failure contributed to his death.” AP McKenzie provided his contrary opinion as follows:“In my opinion, the most likely cause of death was Type II respiratory failure on the basis of underlying severe COPD and emphysema with analgesic and sedative medications acting as contributing factors. The renal failure may have contributed, but in my opinion, was not the prime cause of death. The tachypnea and myoclonic jerks are consistent with this conclusion.” Dr Johnson agreed with the view expressed by AP McKenzie earlier that whatever the position was prior to 2017 regarding the relative contributions to impairment/disability from emphysema on the one hand and asbestos related pleural thickening on the other, “something changed in this man in 2018”. Dr Johnson described the nature of this change in Mr Vescio’s health in 2018, as follows:- “Well, I think it was a large pleural effusion and then subsequent worsening of his diffuse pleural thickening related to that effusion and also then to his drainage of it and the biopsy and the thoracoscopy, the surgical procedure. So I think he developed a large effusion around August [sic: October] which worsened things and as a result of that effusion, which I consider to be benign due to asbestos exposure, that caused worsening of his diffuse pleural thickening and then I think that made his respiratory failure much worse and led to his death.”