Verge v Devere Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Verge v Devere Holdings Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 832

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – discovery and inspection – application for discovery and inspection of documents relating to settlement of a separate proceeding – without  prejudice privilege claimed – scope of privilege – public policy considerations – whether without prejudice negotiations ‘pleaded into relevance’ – whether privilege waived – whether ‘subject matter’ or parties the same

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 120, 120(1), 120(6), 120(7)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 131(1), 131(2)(g)

Accredited (Wholesale Tobacco) Distributors v Griffiths [2003] VSC 20
Alstom Power Ltd v Yokogawa Australia Pty Ltd (No 3) [2009] SASC 100
Austotel Management Pty Ltd v Jamieson (1995) 57 FCR 411
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v FFE Building Services Pty Ltd (2003) ATPR 41-967
Bloss Holdings Pty Ltd v Brackley Industries Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 756
Brown v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) (2001) 187 ALR 714
Field v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) (1957) 99 CLR 285
Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd v Andersen [2002] 1 Qd R 233
Hong Kong Bank of Australia Ltd v Murphy (1992) 28 NSWLR 512
Hongkong Bank of Australia Ltd v Murphy [1993] 2 VR 419
Mathieson v Booth [2000] VSC 89
Mercantile Mutual Custodians Pty Ltd v Village/Nine Network Restaurants & Bars Pty Ltd [2001] 1 Qd R 276
Pitts v Adney (1961) 78 WN (NSW) 886
Quad Consulting Pty Ltd v David R Bleakley & Associates Pty Ltd (1991) 27 FCR 86
Rush & Tompkins Ltd v Greater London Council [1989] AC 1280
State of Western Australia v Southern Equities Corporation Limited (1996) 69 FCR 245
Verge & Anor v Devere Holdings Pty Ltd & Ors (No 3) [2008] FMCA 1220
Verge & Anor v Devere Holdings Pty Ltd & Ors (No.2) [2008] FMCA 743
Verge & Anor v Devere Holdings Pty Ltd & Ors (No.4) [2008] FMCA 1421
Verge & Anor v Devere Holdings Pty Ltd & Ors [2008] FMCA 591

EVAN ROBERT VERGE and GEORGE AUBREY LOPEZ v DEVERE HOLDINGS PTY LTD, PACKHAM PTY LTD and CASTLEWORLD PTY LTD

WAD 238 of 2008

MCKERRACHER J
5 AUGUST 2009
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 238 of 2008

BETWEEN:

EVAN ROBERT VERGE
GEORGE AUBREY LOPEZ
Applicants

AND:

DEVERE HOLDINGS PTY LTD
First Respondent

PACKHAM PTY LTD
Second Respondent

CASTLEWORLD PTY LTD
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 AUGUST 2009

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Unless an alternative consent minute is filed within 10 days:

(a)Topfox Corporation Pty Ltd (‘Topfox’) do within 14 days of the date of this order produce for inspection the documents numbered 19 to 47 inclusive and described in Part 2 of the affidavit of discovery sworn by Giacomino Fazio on 18 September 2008 and filed in Federal Magistrate’s Court proceedings number PEG 64 of 2007 in compliance with an order made by Federal Magistrate Lucev on 29 August 2008.

(b)Topfox and the first and second respondents do, within 14…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Verge v Devere Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 832
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Verge v Devere Holdings Pty Ltd involves the Trustees in Bankruptcy for the bankrupt estates of Mr and Mrs Andony who seek to challenge the validity of certain transfers of property and transactions, claiming they were undervalued. The applicants argue that these transactions were void under section 120 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) as they occurred within five years of the bankruptcy without adequate consideration. The dispute includes a claim regarding the transfer of a one third share in the Dongara Land from the Andonys to Devere, which the applicants claim was undervalued. Devere and other respondents have raised objections to the discovery of certain documents, asserting 'without prejudice' privilege and claiming that any waiver by one party is insufficient to constitute a waiver for all parties involved.

The court was required to determine whether the respondents could maintain the 'without prejudice' privilege in this litigation given that the subject matter and parties differed from those in the Kevill litigation, and whether the respondents had effectively 'pleaded into relevance' the documents to which the privilege attached. Additionally, the court had to consider whether a waiver by one party was sufficient to waive the privilege for all parties and whether the respondents could rely on a contractual obligation to maintain their caveat or interest in the land without allowing inspection of the documents.

The court found that the 'without prejudice' privilege could not be maintained in this litigation due to the differences in subject matter and parties from the Kevill litigation, and because the respondents had effectively 'pleaded into relevance' the documents. The court further concluded that since the privilege was not maintained, it was unnecessary to consider whether a waiver by one party was sufficient. The court also ruled that the respondents could not maintain a claim of 'without prejudice' privilege over certain documents if they intended to rely on them in their defence.

The court ordered that unless an alternative consent minute was filed within 10 days, Topfox must produce specific documents for inspection. Additionally, all respondents must provide discovery of various documents relating to the applicants' claims and discussions. The respondents were also required to pay the applicants' costs of the motion if not agreed upon within the specified timeframe.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Unless an alternative consent minute is filed within 10 days:

(a) Topfox Corporation Pty Ltd (‘Topfox’) do within 14 days of the date of this order produce for inspection the documents numbered 19 to 47 inclusive and described in Part 2 of the affidavit of discovery sworn by Giacomino Fazio on 18 September 2008 and filed in Federal Magistrate’s Court proceedings number PEG 64 of 2007 in compliance with an order made by Federal Magistrate Lucev on 29 August 2008.

(b) Topfox and the first and second respondents do, within 14 days of the date of this order, give discovery on oath of all documents including file notes of meetings and telephone calls, other memoranda, email messages and correspondence passing between Mr Alfred Naude and/or Project Planning, Management and Development Pty Ltd (‘PPM’) and Topfox, Devere Holdings Pty Ltd (‘Devere’) and/or Solomon Brothers or its representatives relating to the applicants’ claim against the first and second respondents or evidencing discussions regarding the claim.

(c) The first and second respondents do within 14 days of the date of this order give discovery of any and all documents created between the drafting of the conveyance agreement and settlement and around the time of settlement in May 2001, including those created by Solomon Brothers, relating to the provision contained in clause 3 of the 2001 Conveyance Agreement providing for the consideration to be paid by Packham to be reduced by amounts alleged to have been paid by Packham for Devere’s benefit.

2. Unless submissions (not exceeding 3 pages) are filed within 10 days, the respondents are to pay the applicants’ costs of the motion to be taxed if not agreed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Further, ‘without prejudice’ privilege is not an absolute concept. It is a privilege which attaches to admissions made, not to ‘every syllable uttered’ in the course of negotiations. Secondly, in circumstances where other public policy interests would be defeated by the privilege being maintained, the protection of privilege may be lifted. In the present circumstances, as I will explain, it is my view that the respondents have ‘pleaded into relevance’ (or perhaps pleaded out of privilege) the documents to which the privilege attached. BACKGROUND The applicants are the Trustees in Bankruptcy for the bankrupt estates of Mr and Mrs Andony. The Trustee applicants bring proceedings pursuant to s 120(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (BA) for declarations that transfers of land, shares and other transactions are void. Section 120 BA relevantly provides:120 Undervalued transactionsTransfers that are void against trustee(1)A transfer of property by a person who later becomes a bankrupt (the transferor) to another person (the transferee) is void against the trustee in the transferor’s bankruptcy if:(a)the transfer took place in the period beginning 5 years before the commencement of the bankruptcy and ending on the date of the bankruptcy; and(b)the transferee gave no consideration for the transfer or gave consideration of less value than the market value of the property.…Protection of successors in title(6)This section does not affect the rights of a person who acquired property from the transferee in good faith and by giving consideration that was at least as valuable as the market value of the property.Meaning of transfer of property and market value(7) For the purposes of this section:(a)transfer of property includes a payment of money; and(b)a person who does something that results in another person becoming the owner of property that did not previously exist is taken to have transferred the property to the other person; and(c)the market value of property transferred is its market value at the time of the transfer. The bankruptcies occurred in 2003 and 2004 respectively. The applicants were appointed in 2004. THE CONTENTIONS As there have been several earlier interlocutory decisions, it is not necessary to refer to the entirety of issues on the very complex pleadings. The outline below is only intended to address the issues which are pertinent to this discovery debate. The first aspect of the applicants’ claims concerns what has been described as the Dongara Land. The claim is that from 1997 until 2001, the Andonys were the registered proprietors as joint tenants of a one third share in the Dongara Land with the first respondent (Devere) holding the other two thirds. On 23 May 2001, Devere became the registered proprietor of the whole of the land. In 2007, the third respondent (Castleworld) later became the registered proprietor. The Andonys each owned one ordinary share in Devere. Mrs Andony was a director of Devere from 1987 to 2001. Mr Andony was a director from 1987 to 2003. The only substantial asset held by Devere was the interest in the Dongara Land. The 2001 transfer of the Andonys’ interest in the Dongara Land was, according to the claim, at a significant reduction from market value. The applicants’ claim is that Devere gave, at the most, $45,000 for the transfer of the Andonys’ one undivided third share of the Dongara Land to Devere when the value of that share was between $236,666 and $242,000.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MCKERRACHER J
The other point to be made is that without prejudice privilege goes to the question of admissions. The applicants in these proceedings are not interested in admissions as to liability in the Kevill litigation. It is of no interest to the applicants as to whether or not Topfox was liable in some way to Kevill or the other plaintiffs. What the applicants wish to understand is why it is said by Castleworld that its assumption of the responsibility in relation to resolution of the Kevill litigation had a particular value which was, in effect, to be added to what was actually paid for the Dongara Land. Conclusion on ‘without prejudice’ privilege Both on the ground that the subject matter and parties of this litigation differ from those of the Kevill litigation and on the basis that the respondents have ‘pleaded into relevance’ the documents concerned, in my view the privilege cannot be maintained in this litigation. A second ground of objection raised for Devere and Packham to the production of this documentation was that ‘without prejudice’ privilege is a joint privilege and a purported waiver by one party is insufficient: Quad 27 FCR 86 at 93 per Hill J. The submission is that as the conduct on which the applicants rely as constituting a waiver was conduct only of Topfox that conduct was insufficient to constitute a waiver. In light of my conclusion as to the unavailability of the privilege, it is unnecessary to consider this further argument. Finally, Devere and Packham and Topfox say that the documents over which privilege is said to be waived are those referred to in cl 1.4(a) of the sale agreement. That clause refers only to documents exchanged ‘in or about October 2006’ in relation to the vendor’s responsibilities. However the orders made by Lucev FM required discovery of a wider category of documents than this. Any waiver would not be of the privilege attaching to all documents over which it was claimed, only those referred to in cl 1.4(a). Those documents, it is said, have already been provided to the applicants as indicated in the affidavit of Mr Fletcher. As a consequence, it is asserted for the respondents that Topfox is entitled to maintain a claim of ‘without prejudice’ privilege over all of the documents listed (at items 19 to 47 of the discovery) except those with respect to which Topfox has chosen not to maintain a privilege claim, those being referred to in the affidavit of Mr Fletcher. On that basis, although the documents have been discovered in accordance with Lucev FM’s order, they should not be produced for inspection. The applicants, however, point to the fact that if Topfox and Devere are relying on cl 1.4(a) to create a caveat or interest in the land imposing a contractual obligation on Castleworld to assume Topfox’s responsibilities to settle the Kevill litigation in order to maintain its caveat or interest, it must at some point acknowledge that it is necessary for Topfox to demonstrate that Castleworld has performed and discharged the obligations or intends to perform and discharge them. The respondents, however, rely on the documents on the one hand but refuse to allow their inspection on the other. The argument of the applicants is correct. The proceeding has been set down for trial. The time has come to permit inspection if the respondents wish to rely on this defence.SECOND PARAGRAPH OF THE MOTION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MCKERRACHER J

Full text does not contain this section.