MIGRATION – visa refusal – application for partner visa – past and present general conduct – use of fraudulent identity – provision of false and misleading information to immigration authorities – failure to pass character test – discretion to refuse visa application enlivened – decision affirmed
AAT Guideline for Persons Giving Expert and Opinion Evidence dated 30 June 2015
Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Cth), Ministerial Direction No 65 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s 501CA dated 22 December 2014
REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member A. Nikolic AM CSC
11 August 2017
REASONS FOR DECISION
Mrs Fatmira Veliu seeks review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Minister), to refuse to grant her husband, Mr Adil Veliu, a Partner (Provisional) (Class UF) Visa (Partner Visa), under section 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act). The basis of the Minister’s decision was that Mr Veliu did not pass the character test as a result of his past and present general conduct.
For the reasons that follow, I have decided to affirm the decision under review.
BACKGROUND
Mr Adil Veliu was born in Albania on 2 May 1954 and is 63 years of age. He first visited Australia in 1991 under his real name and stayed for approximately nine months.[1] He returned to Australia in 1994 under a false passport in the name of Pellumb Tafek Haxhiu, date of birth 18 March 1952 (the fraudulent identity). Mr Veliu remained in Australia for almost 17 years until October 2011, before returning to Albania where he has since resided. His immigration history in Australia encompasses numerous visa requests, using both the…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Veliu and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Mi... and more:
This case concerned Mr Adil Veliu, who sought to remain in Australia. Mr Veliu first entered Australia in 1991, but returned in 1994 using a fraudulent identity and passport. He remained in Australia for almost 17 years, during which time he married an Australian citizen under the fraudulent identity, though his wife and children remained in Albania. His wife later arrived in Australia and eventually obtained permanent residency. Mr Veliu's own visa applications, made under both his real and fraudulent identities, faced numerous refusals and appeals. The Minister ultimately refused Mr Veliu's Partner Visa application on character grounds, leading to the review by the Tribunal.
The core legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Mr Veliu satisfied the character test under section 501(6) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). This involved determining if his past and present general conduct indicated that he was not of good character. The Tribunal was required to consider various factors, including his history of serious breaches of immigration law, such as entering Australia on a false passport and using a fraudulent identity for an extended period. The Tribunal also had to assess the weight to be given to character references provided by community members and his family, and consider whether these, along with his remorse, demonstrated enduring moral qualities and rehabilitation.
The Tribunal reasoned that while Mr Veliu had provided references from community members suggesting he was a hardworking and respected individual, and that his actions may have been born of desperation, these did not outweigh the seriousness of his conduct. The Tribunal noted that the decision to refuse his visa was based on his general conduct, not a criminal record, and that the references provided by Mayor Adem were given little weight due to concerns about the basis of his knowledge. The Tribunal applied the principles that the character test focuses on enduring moral qualities and that the protection of the Australian community and community expectations are primary considerations.
Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review. This meant that Mr Veliu's Partner Visa application was refused. The effect of this affirmation, due to section 501F(2) of the Act, was that any other pending visa applications for Mr Veliu, with limited exceptions, would also be refused by operation of law.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
For the reasons that follow, I have decided to affirm the decision under review.BACKGROUND Mr Adil Veliu was born in Albania on 2 May 1954 and is 63 years of age. He first visited Australia in 1991 under his real name and stayed for approximately nine months.[1] He returned to Australia in 1994 under a false passport in the name of Pellumb Tafek Haxhiu, date of birth 18 March 1952 (the fraudulent identity). Mr Veliu remained in Australia for almost 17 years until October 2011, before returning to Albania where he has since resided. His immigration history in Australia encompasses numerous visa requests, using both the fraudulent identity and his real identity. Key aspects of Mr and Mrs Veliu’s immigration and family history since 1994 are summarised from the G-documents and Supplementary G-documents as follows:[1] G-Documents (Exhibit R1), p.217.(a)19 November 1994: Mr Veliu arrives in Australia using a false passport and the fraudulent identity. He claims to have been separated from his wife at this time, who remained in Albania with their two children;(b)October-November 1995: Less than a year after arriving in Australia, Mr Veliu married Ms Elica Talevska on 21 October 1995 under the fraudulent identity.[2] As an Australian citizen, Ms Talevska sponsored Mr Veliu’s combined application for a Partner (Temporary) (Class UK) (Subclass 820) Visa and a Partner (Residence) (Class AS) (Subclass 801) Visa in November 1995. This application was refused by the Department and the decision was affirmed by the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT). Mr Veliu’s applications for judicial review and Ministerial intervention, both made under the fraudulent identity, were refused;[3][2] Supplementary G-documents (Exhibit R2), p.176.[3] Exhibit R1, pp.171-175.(c)February 1996. Mrs Fatmira Veliu and her two minor children (sons Fatjon and Erald) arrive in Australia on a Visitor Visa. (d)11 October 1997. Mrs Fatmira Veliu marries Mr Yusuf Balla, an Australian citizen. (e)3 October 2008. Mrs Fatmira Veliu is granted an Aged Parent Visa affording her permanent resident status.[4] The application was sponsored by her son Erald, an Australian citizen;[4] Exhibit R2, pp.216-217.(f)1 June 2009. Almost 15 years after arriving in Australia, Mr Veliu lodges a Bridging Visa application in his real name for the first time;[5][5] Exhibit R2, p.26.(g)21 May 2010. Mrs Fatmira Veliu’s marriage to Mr Balla ends in divorce;[6][6] Exhibit R2, p.177.(h)26 July 2011. Mr Veliu obtains a Divorce Order from the Federal Magistrates Court dissolving his marriage to Ms Talevska (under the fraudulent identity);[7][7] Exhibit R2, p.176.(i)1 September 2011. Mrs Fatmira Veliu re-marries Mr Veliu in Australia,[8] seven weeks before the expiration of Mr Veliu’s Bridging Visa on 22 October 2011. Mr Veliu had earlier requested Ministerial intervention to remain in Australia,[9] which was denied.[10] [8] Exhibit R2, p.178.[9] Exhibit R1, pp.171-172.[10] Exhibit R1, pp.173-175.(j)20 October 2011. Mr Veliu departs Australia for Albania.(k)21 October 2011: Mrs Fatmira Veliu lodges an application to sponsor Mr Veliu’s migration to Australia.[11] The application was refused by a delegate of the Minister on 19 June 2012;[12] [11] Exhibit R2, pp.167-175.[12] Exhibit R1, pp.176-182.(l)8 November 2011: Mr Veliu lodges a combined application (from Albania) for a Partner (Provisional) (Class UF) Visa and a Partner (Migrant) (Class BC) Visa based on his re-marriage to Mrs Fatmira Veliu, in which he lists the fraudulent identity under ‘other names.’[13] This application was refused by a delegate of the Minister on 19 June 2012;[14][13] Exhibit R2, pp.124-147.[14] ibid.(m)14 January 2013: Mr Veliu lodges another Partner Visa application from Albania using his real identity and with Mrs Veliu as his sponsor.[15] This was refused by a delegate of the Minister on 20 November 2013.[16] The Department contended that the couple were ‘… not in a spouse relationship with the emotional involvement and mutual support as would be expected from a couple in a genuine and ongoing relationship.’ This decision was overturned by the MRT on 24 March 2015.The MRT found that the marriage was valid for the purposes of the Act and remitted the visa application to the Minister ‘… to consider the remaining criteria for a Subclass 309 (Partner) (Provisional) Visa.’[17] The application was subsequently referred to the Visa Applicant Character Consideration Unit (VACCU) for consideration;[15] Exhibit R1, pp.65-87.[16] Exhibit R1, pp.183-190.[17] Exhibit R1, pp.191-196.(n)4 March 2014. Mr Erald Veliu sponsors an application for a Contributory Parent (Migrant) (Class CA) (Subclass 143) Visa for his father.[18] Should the decision under review in these proceedings be affirmed, the effect of section 501F(2) of the Act is that this application and any other pending visa applications for Mr Veliu (except a Protection Visa or other visa specified in the regulations), will be refused by operation of law;[18] Exhibit R2, pp.179-203.(o)23 February 2016. The Department sends Mr Veliu’s registered migration agent in Australia, Ms Merushe Asim, a Notice of Intention to Consider Refusal of Mr Veliu’s Partner (Provisional) (Class UF) visa application under section 501(1) of the Act.[19] The Department said it held information suggesting Mr Veliu may not pass the character test under section 501(6)(c)(ii) of the Act in that:[19] Exhibit R1, pp.119-166.(c) having regard to either or both of the following:(i) …;(ii) the person's past and present general conduct; the person is not of good character; or(d) … (p)22 March 2016. Mr Veliu responds to the Notice via Ms Asim;[20] (q)3 August 2016. After considering Mr Veliu’s response, the Minister refuses Mr Veliu’s visa application;[21] and (r)31 August 2016. Mr Veliu’s wife, as sponsor of his Partner Visa application, asks the Tribunal to review the Minister’s decision.[22]4.The hearing was held on 20 June 2017. Mr Veliu gave evidence by phone from Albania with the assistance of an Albanian interpreter and was cross-examined. Mrs Fatmira Veliu and her son Erald attended the hearing, gave evidence, and were cross-examined – in Mrs Veliu’s case, with the assistance of an Albanian interpreter. [20] Exhibit R1, pp.201-208.[21] Exhibit R1, pp.51-64.[22] Exhibit R1, pp.4-12.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Applicant’s Sumission: Precedent. I have considered the written submissions of Mr Veliu’s solicitor, that in other cases ‘… including drugs and murder…’ the Tribunal decided ‘... not to exercise the discretion to refuse their visa application.’[34] Cases relied upon as comparators are Li,[35] and Lam.[36] In the latter case, the applicant was convicted for possessing heroin and sentenced to nine years imprisonment. I do not accept the comparison that Mr Veliu’s solicitor seeks to make, however, because the decision to refuse Mr Veliu’s visa application was not based on his having a criminal record, but on his past and present general conduct.[34] Applicant’s Submissions in Reply dated 13 June 2017, paragraphs 15-17.[35] Re Li v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] AATA 147.[36] Re Lam and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] AATA 56.Witness Evidence References in support of a person whose character has been called into question, can help inform judgements by decision-makers. As Davies J noted in Irving v Minister of State for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 68 FCR 422 at 425: If the conviction was in the past, the decision-maker will turn his attention to whether or not the applicant has shown that he has reformed. If persons speak well of the applicant, the decision-maker will take that into account. I have had regard to the following statements in support of Mr Veliu, noting that none of the authors appeared at the hearing or were cross-examined:(a)Mayor Dinny Adem, Greater Shepparton City Council.[37] Mayor Adem submits that he has known Mr Veliu for several years and is aware that he used a false passport and fraudulent identity to enter Australia in 1994. He states that ‘I cannot defend, and do not condone Adil’s decision to illegally enter Australia on a false passport, suffice to say, it may have been a decision born out of desperation.’ Mayor Adem describes Mr Veliu as being of good character while in Australia, stating that he was well known in Shepparton under the fraudulent identity Pellumb Haxhiu and ‘… was well liked as he has a very social and interactive nature.’ On the basis of their interactions Mayor Adem describes him as ‘… respectful, honest, and ready to help others… . [A] hardworking family man, of good character, who has no close family remaining in Albania, and would suffer greatly if he was to be denied his family here in Australia.’ During the hearing, I asked Mr Veliu whether he knew Mayor Adem. Mr Veliu replied that he did not know him personally and had only waved to him in passing. I therefore have significant concerns as to whether the reference provided by Mayor Adem is based on his personal knowledge of and interactions with Mr Veliu. On that basis I give it little weight.(b)Mr Eljam Bardi, Albanian Moslem Society – Shepparton Inc.[38] Mr Bardi is the Imam in Shepparton, ministering to people of the Muslim faith. He attests to knowing Mr Veliu under his fraudulent identity of Pellumb Haxhiu, and to meeting him during attendances at the Mosque and during Albanian festivals in Shepparton and Melbourne each year. He submits that ‘… over the years…’ they have spoken about Mr Veliu’s problems in Albania ‘… and that he came to Australia to find a better life for himself and his family as there was no work, no future in Albania…’. Mr Bardi considers Mr Veliu to be ‘… a good man…’ who has been ‘… highly regarded…’ in the Albanian community and is an ‘… honest person and has never committed any crimes in Australia or overseas.’ He contends that Mr Veliu is ‘… totally dependent on his sons in Australia for financial support… [and] has no close relatives in Albania and cannot work.’ I note an additional Statutory Declaration from Mr Bardi along similar lines,[39] elaborating on Mr Veliu’s regular attendance at the Mosque and assistance with cleaning duties and ‘… administering the Quran to people who also attended.’(c)Mr Bill Gani, President Australian Albanian Community Association Dandenong.[40] Mr Gani attests to knowing Mr Veliu for over 15 years, describing him as a ‘… very active and trustworthy person with strong family values…’ who was a valued member of their Association. He says that he was sad to ‘… hear Adil is torn away from his family, his two sons, 3 grandchildren and another on the way, and is (sic) loving wife...’. He contends that Mr Veliu has ‘… no family in Albania, no income, and he is being financially looked after by his two boys...’.(d)Mr Vahid Goga, President Albanian Australian Islamic Society (AAIS).[41] Mr Goga states that he knew Mr Veliu during his 17 years in Australia, and that he was a ‘… registered member…’ of the AAIS, under the name Pellumb Haxhiu. He states that Mr Veliu provided ‘… support and voluntary work at religious and cultural events for the Albanian community…’. Mr Goga submits that Mr Veliu is remorseful for entering Australia on a false passport, but did so because of political upheaval in Albania that left people ‘… without work and income…’ causing him to take ‘… this drastic action.’ He describes the stress caused to Mr Veliu and his family as a result of his immigration problems, stating that despite doing ‘… the right thing…’ by leaving Australia to ‘… apply correctly for a spouse visa…’ it appears that ‘… he will be refused his visa on character grounds.’ He states that Mr Veliu’s sons, Erald and Fatjon, support ‘… their father financially on a daily basis…’ which is causing pressure given they also have to support their mother and own families. I note an additional Statutory Declaration from Mr Goga along similar lines, in which he further elaborates on Mr Veliu’s contribution to fundraising conducted by the AAIS.[42](e)Mr Besnik Kutleshi, President of North Sunshine Eagles Football Club.[43] Mr Kutleshi states that Mr Veliu is known to him as a volunteer member of the Club, assisting with cleaning and other activities for approximately three years, contributing approximately 10 hours per week.[37] Exhibit R1 p.204-5.[38] Exhibit R1 p.206.[39] Statutory Declaration of Mr Eljam Bardi dated 25 October 2016.[40] Exhibit R1 p.207.[41] Exhibit R1 p.208.[42] Statutory Declaration by Mr Vahid Goga dated 3 November 2016.[43] Statutory Declaration by Mr Besnik Kutleshi dated 9 December 2016.Evidence of Mr Veliu’s family members
Decision
Reasons for decision
The primary considerations of protecting the Australian community and the expectations of the Australian community, outweigh any other considerations in this matter. DECISION It therefore follows that the decision under review is affirmed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
A report by psychologist Mr Zac Stojcevski was also tendered into evidence.[48] Mr Stojcevski did not appear at the hearing. His report also did not conform to the AAT Guidelines. Contrary to the requirement to provide impartial assistance to the Tribunal and not be an advocate for a party to a proceeding, Mr Stojcevski’s report was written ‘… in support of Fatmira Veliu’s application for a visa review for her husband.’. After expressing my concerns about the nature of this expert evidence, Mr Levingston stated he would not be relying on the evidence of either Ms Clarris or Mr Stojcevski. I have therefore afforded their evidence little weight. [48] Exhibit A1, pp.43-49.Consideration – Does Mr Veliu Fail the Character Test? Lander J (Carr and Sundberg JJ concurring) of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia explained the nexus between the character test and Parliament’s intent, in Akpata:[49] The definition of a person passing the character test in s 501(6) shows that Parliament intended that persons who have been convicted of relatively serious crime; associate with criminals; have a history including an immediate history of criminal conduct or general conduct indicating bad character; are a significant risk of engaging in criminal conduct or undesirable conduct (s 501(6)(d)), should not be permitted to travel to or remain in Australia. Shortly put, persons who have committed or are likely to commit criminal or other like conduct should not be permitted to travel to or remain in Australia. Because the purpose is to exclude those persons, the matters that are relevant to the exercise of the Minister’s discretion will include any fact or circumstance which would suggest that a person of otherwise bad character (as it is defined in the Act) should be allowed to travel to or remain in Australia. [49] Akpata v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 65 at [105]. The Direction provides for a number of factors to be considered in this regard, such as ‘Whether the person has been involved in activities indicating contempt or disregard for the law… [including but not limited to a]… history of serious breaches of immigration law...’.[50][50] Direction No. 65, Annex A, Section 2, Clause 5.2(2)(a)(ii). The Direction provides further guidance based on Wong at [33]:[51]As a matter of construction it seems to us that conduct can now be both general and criminal at the same time so that the Minister may take into account both conduct which is criminal conduct and conduct which is general conduct… .The concepts of criminal conduct and general conduct referred to cannot, now, be considered to be mutually exclusive… .[51] The Direction, Annex A, Section 2, Clause 5(2), referring to Wong v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCAFC 440 (Wong). The Direction further explains the need to obtain a ‘complete picture’ of a person’s character based on Godley, requiring consideration of a person’s enduring moral qualities:[52]The words “of good character” mean enduring moral qualities reflected in soundness and reliability in moral judgement in the performance of day-to-day activities and in dealing with fellow citizens. It is not simply a matter of repute, fame or standing in the community but of continuing performance according to moral principle.[52] The Direction, Annex A, Section 2, Clause 5(3)-(4), referring to Godley v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 83 ALD 411 (Godley), per: Lee J at [51].