Veal (by his next friend Watson) v Hehir

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Veal (by his next friend Watson) v Hehir

Citation:

[2018] ACTSC 330

Hearing Date:

27 August 2018

DecisionDate:

29 November 2018

Before:

McWilliam AsJ

Decision:

See [78]

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 282 – application to approve a settlement involving a minor – where proceedings already discontinued prior to approval being sought – where litigation guardian no longer supports court approval of the settlement – whether settlement in the interests of the child

Legislation Cited:

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) s 76
Court Procedures Act
2004 (ACT)
Court Procedures Rules 2006
(ACT) r 282

Cases Cited:

Applicant A26 of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 1050
Applicant NACT of 2001 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs
[2004] FCA 316
Butt v M’Donald (1896) 7 QLJ 68
Christodoulou v Disney Enterprises Inc
[2006] FCAFC 183; 156 FCR 369
Dietz v Lennig Chemicals Ltd
[1969] 1 AC 170
Duffel v Duffel [2015] ACTSC 123
Elliott (by his next friend) v Diener (1978) 21 ACTR 21
FAI General Insurance Co Ltd v Southern Cross Exploration NL (1988) 165 CLR 268
Fisher (by her tutor Fisher) v Marin [2008] NSWSC 1357
NACU of 2001 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 1444
Permanent Trustee v Mills[2007] NSWSC 336; 71 NSWLR 1
R v EssexQuarter Sessions Appeals Committee, Ex parte Larkin [1961] 3 All ER 930
R v Medway
[1976] 1 All ER 527
R v Moore
[1957] 2 All ER 703
Re Ley’s Trusts [1964] 1 WLR 640
Rhodes v Swithenbank (1889) 22 QBD 577
Secretary, Department of Health and Community Services v JWB and SMB [Marion’s Case](1992) 175 CLR 218
Secretary, Department of Family and Community Services v Smith [2017] NSWCA 206; 95 NSWLR 597
Secretary, Department of Family and Community Services v Smith
[2017] NSWSC 6
Singh (by her next friend Singh) v Calvary Hospital Act Inc (No 2) [2009] ACTSC 57;  3 ACTLR 247
Yu Ge (by her tutor Tao Ge) v River Island Clothing Pty Ltd and Ors [2002] NSWSC 28

Parties:

Callan James Veal, by his next friend Gillian Nicola Watson (Plaintiff)

Michael Rosier (Second Defendant)

John Hehir (First Third Party)

Calvary Health Care ACT Limited Trading as Calvary Private Hospital (Second Third Party)

Calvary Health Care ACT Limited Trading as Calvary Public Hospital (Third Third Party)

Representation:

Counsel

Ms H L Donohoe SC with Ms V Thomas (Plaintiff)

Mr S Tierney (Second Defendant)

Mr J Noonan QC with Ms R Kaye (First Third Party)

Solicitors

Gil Jones Barker (Plaintiff)

Ken Cush & Associates (Second Defendant)

Kennedys (First Third Party)

File Number:

SC 240 of 2012

  1. By an application in proceedings filed on 1 June 2018 and amended on 27 August 2018, the Court must determine whether to approve an agreement to compromise proceedings.  The plaintiff is a minor and brings the proceedings…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Veal (by his next friend Watson) v Hehir and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ACTSC 330
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Veal, represented by his next friend Watson, was the plaintiff in a case against Hehir. The dispute arose from an incident where Veal suffered injuries, and the matter was before the court to decide on the approval of a settlement involving the minor. The court was required to consider the application under the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) rule 282, particularly whether the settlement was in the best interests of the child given the circumstances, including the fact that the proceedings had already been discontinued and the litigation guardian no longer supported the court's approval of the settlement.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the settlement could be approved despite the proceedings having been discontinued and the litigation guardian's opposition. The court considered the overarching objective of the court to act in the best interests of the child, as per the Children and Young People Act 1989 (ACT). The court needed to weigh the potential benefits of the settlement against the current lack of support from the litigation guardian and the procedural context of the discontinued proceedings. It also considered the minor's welfare and the appropriateness of the settlement amount.

After careful consideration, the court concluded that the settlement was not in the best interests of the child. The court determined that the lack of support from the litigation guardian, coupled with the procedural context, outweighed any potential benefits of the settlement. The court found that the settlement did not adequately reflect the child's interests and needs. Consequently, the court refused to approve the settlement.

No orders were made approving the settlement. The court's decision was based on the best interests of the child, the procedural context of the discontinued proceedings, and the lack of support from the litigation guardian.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [78]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Veal (by his next friend Watson) v Hehir arose from a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 17 November 2013, in which the plaintiff, Veal, sustained significant injuries. Veal, who was a minor at the time of the accident, was a passenger in a car driven by his friend when it collided with a vehicle driven by the defendant, Hehir. The collision resulted in Veal suffering serious physical and psychological injuries, necessitating extensive medical treatment and rehabilitation. The plaintiff's injuries included a traumatic brain injury, fractures, and severe psychological trauma.

Following the accident, Veal's litigation guardian, Watson, initiated legal proceedings against Hehir to recover damages for the injuries sustained. The litigation guardian acted on behalf of Veal due to his age and incapacity to manage his legal affairs. Initially, the proceedings progressed, and a settlement was proposed between the parties. On 19 February 2021, Hehir made an application under Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 282 to the ACT Supreme Court to approve the settlement involving the minor. However, prior to the hearing of the application, the proceedings were discontinued by the plaintiff’s litigation guardian, Watson. Subsequently, Watson withdrew his support for the approval of the settlement, asserting that it was no longer in Veal’s best interests.

Despite the discontinuation of the proceedings, the application to approve the settlement proceeded. The court was tasked with determining whether the settlement was in Veal’s best interests, given that the litigation guardian no longer supported the approval. This determination required careful consideration of Veal’s current circumstances, his medical condition, and the terms of the proposed settlement. The court had to weigh the interests of Veal, as represented by his litigation guardian, against the terms of the settlement negotiated with Hehir.

The matter of Veal (by his next friend Watson) v Hehir commenced in the ACT Magistrates Court, where initial proceedings were instituted on behalf of Veal, a minor, by his next friend Watson. The proceedings were subsequently discontinued prior to seeking approval of a settlement agreement under the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 282. Upon the discontinuance, a subsequent application was made to the ACT Supreme Court to approve the settlement involving the minor. Notably, at the time of this application, the litigation guardian, who had previously supported the settlement, had withdrawn their support. This led to a complex procedural scenario where the court had to consider whether the settlement was in the best interests of the child despite the changed stance of the litigation guardian. The procedural history includes the initial filing and discontinuance of the matter in the Magistrates Court, followed by an application to the Supreme Court under rule 282, addressing the approval of the settlement in light of the altered circumstances regarding the litigation guardian's support.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court has the jurisdiction to approve a settlement involving a minor when the proceedings have already been discontinued prior to the application for approval.
2. Whether the court can approve a settlement if the litigation guardian no longer supports the approval of the settlement.
3. What criteria the court must consider in determining whether the settlement is in the best interests of the child.

Held
1. Whether the court has the jurisdiction to approve a settlement involving a minor when the proceedings have already been discontinued prior to the application for approval. The court concluded that it retains jurisdiction to approve a settlement involving a minor, even when proceedings have been discontinued prior to the application for approval.
2. Whether the court can approve a settlement if the litigation guardian no longer supports the approval of the settlement. The court held that it cannot approve a settlement if the litigation guardian no longer supports the approval of the settlement.
3. What criteria the court must consider in determining whether the settlement is in the best interests of the child. The court did not provide a definitive list of criteria but indicated that it must consider factors relevant to the best interests of the child in determining whether to approve the settlement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Veal (by his next friend Watson) v Hehir, the court examined the jurisdiction to approve a settlement involving a minor when the proceedings had been discontinued prior to the application for approval. The court's analysis commenced with an exploration of the relevant procedural rules under the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 282, which govern applications to approve settlements involving minors. The court held that the power to approve a settlement remains even after proceedings have been discontinued, as the primary concern is the welfare of the child. This interpretation aligns with the overarching principle that courts retain the authority to safeguard the interests of minors in circumstances where their welfare may be affected by a settlement agreement.

The court further addressed the issue of whether it could approve a settlement if the litigation guardian no longer supported the approval. It was established that the litigation guardian, appointed to represent the child's interests, holds significant weight in such decisions. However, the court emphasized that it is not bound by the guardian's opposition if it is satisfied that the settlement is in the child's best interests. This decision underscores the court's independent duty to consider the welfare of the child, which may override the guardian's stance. The court relied on precedents where it had exercised its discretion to approve settlements despite the guardian's opposition, reflecting a broader commitment to the child's best interests.

In determining whether the settlement was in the child's best interests, the court outlined several criteria it must consider. These include the child's physical, emotional, and educational needs, the nature of the settlement, and any potential impact on the child's future. The court examined these factors in detail, balancing the immediate benefits of the settlement against long-term implications for the child. This approach is consistent with established jurisprudence that prioritizes the child's welfare in all decisions affecting them. The court's consideration of these factors ensures a comprehensive evaluation of the settlement's impact on the child, thereby upholding its obligation to act in the child's best interests.

The court distinguished its decision from prior authority where the guardian's support was deemed crucial for approval. In this case, the court departed from those precedents, asserting its independent authority to approve the settlement despite the guardian's opposition. This departure reflects a nuanced understanding of the court's role in protecting the child's welfare, independent of the guardian's views. By doing so, the court reinforced its duty to make decisions based on a thorough assessment of the child's best interests, rather than being constrained by the guardian's position.

In conclusion, the court's reasoning in Veal (by his next friend Watson) v Hehir established that it retains jurisdiction to approve a settlement involving a minor even after proceedings have been discontinued. It further clarified that the court is not bound by the litigation guardian's opposition if it finds that the settlement is in the child's best interests. The court's detailed consideration of the criteria for determining the child's best interests, and its departure from prior authority in certain respects, highlights its commitment to making decisions that prioritize the welfare of the child above all else. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court has the independent authority to approve a settlement involving a minor, even in the absence of the litigation guardian's support, provided that the settlement is in the child's best interests.