Paterson v Calvary Healthcare Act Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Paterson v Calvary Healthcare ACT Ltd

Citation:

[2023] ACTSC 70

Hearing Date:

31 March 2023

DecisionDate:

31 March 2023

Before:

McWilliam AsJ

Decision:

See [17].

Catchwords:

NEGLIGENCE – medical treatment which resulted in death – compensation to relatives – where one child is a minor – settlement of proceedings – court approval required for settlement involving a minor

Legislation Cited:

Court Procedures Rules (2006) (ACT), r 282

Health and Other Services (Compensation) Act 1995

Public Trustee and Guardian 1985 (ACT), s 25

Cases Cited:

Duffell v Duffell [2015] ACTSC 123

Elliott (by his next friend) v Diener (1978) 21 ACTR 21
Fairhurst (bht NSW Trustee and Guardian) v Fairhurst [2012] NSWSC 388
Institoris by his next friend Maria Institoris v Falconer [2012] NSWCA 298
Royce (a pseudonym) v Australian Capital Territory [2023] ACTSC 69
Ryan v Larkham [2022] ACTSC 151
Singh (by her next friend Singh) v Calvary Hospital Incorporated [2008] ACTSC 118; 220 FLR 352

Veal (by his next friend Watson) v Hehir [2018] ACTSC 330

Parties:

Melissa Jane Paterson (First Plaintiff)

Ruben Paterson (by his Litigation Guardian Melissa Jane Paterson) (Second Plaintiff)

Calvary Healthcare ACT Ltd (Defendant)

Representation:

Counsel

A Muller ( Plaintiffs)

S Moore ( Defendant)

Solicitors

David Healey Solicitors (Plaintiffs)

ACT Government Solicitors (Defendant)

File Number:

SC 63 of 2023

McWilliam AsJ:

  1. The parties to the present litigation have been involved in a dispute arising out of a medical negligence claim.  A claim was brought against Calvary Healthcare ACT Limited by the wife and three children of Mr Jay Patterson, who died in September 2017 following treatment provided some time earlier by the Calvary Hospital.  

The Application before the Court

  1. A compromise has been reached between the defendant, the two plaintiffs and the other two children, being adult claimants. It is $450,000 in total, exclusive of costs. As one of the claimants (the second plaintiff) is a child, an application must be made for approval of the settlement insofar as it relates to the child pursuant to r 282 of the Court Procedures Rules (2006) (ACT).  An originating application was filed on 13 February 2023 for that purpose.

  1. One quarter of the total settlement sum (that is, $112,500) is the proposed share allocated to the second plaintiff.  Each of the adult claimants and their mother will receive the remaining three quarters in equal shares.  There are draft orders by consent to be forwarded to the Court for the finalisation of the proceedings subject to the approval of the settlement component in respect of the second plaintiff.

The Court’s jurisdiction and approach

  1. For consistency and convenience, the following largely replicates the authorities and principles referred to in Royce (a pseudonym) v Australian Capital Territory [2023] ACTSC 69, a matter that was heard and determined on the same day as the present application. In deciding whether to approve a settlement involving an infant, the Court is exercising the inherent parens patriae jurisdiction; that is, the protective…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paterson v Calvary Healthcare Act Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory involves a medical negligence claim brought by Melissa Jane Paterson and her three children against Calvary Healthcare ACT Ltd. The claim arose from the death of Mr Jay Patterson, who died in September 2017 following treatment provided by Calvary Hospital. A compromise of $450,000 has been reached between the parties, with $112,500 allocated to the second plaintiff, Ruben Paterson, who is a minor. As a result, an application for court approval of the settlement in respect of the minor is necessary pursuant to rule 282 of the Court Procedures Rules (2006) (ACT).

The legal issue before the court was whether the proposed settlement of $112,500 for the minor is in his best interests. The court exercised its inherent parens patriae jurisdiction to protect the interests of the minor, considering the applicable principles and authorities in cases such as Veal (by his next friend Watson) v Hehir [2018] ACTSC 330 and Ryan v Larkham [2022] ACTSC 151. The court focused on whether the settlement sum was beneficial to the minor, taking into account the risk that the minor would receive nothing if the matter went to hearing and the potential for a less favourable outcome. The court considered the expert advice, the opinion of the minor's tutor, and the recommendation of the solicitor on record for the plaintiffs.

The court was satisfied that the proposed settlement of $112,500 was in the best interests of the minor, Ruben Paterson. The court placed particular reliance on the confidential advice of experienced counsel, Mr Andrew Muller, who provided a comprehensive analysis of the case and the risks involved. The court also considered the opinion of the minor's tutor and the recommendation of the solicitor on record for the plaintiffs. The court approved the settlement and made orders for the payment of the settlement sum, investment of the funds on behalf of the minor, and deduction of any required amounts by law.

In conclusion, the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory approved the settlement of $112,500 for the minor, Ruben Paterson, in the medical negligence claim against Calvary Healthcare ACT Ltd. The court exercised its inherent jurisdiction to protect the interests of the minor and considered the applicable principles and authorities in reaching its decision. The settlement was approved as it was deemed to be in the best interests of the minor, taking into account the risk of receiving nothing if the matter went to hearing and the potential for a less favourable outcome.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established