Vathana Pen v Octopus Fishing No.2 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
[2023] FWCFB 253

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.604—Appeal of decision

Vathana Pen
v

Octopus Fishing No.2 Pty Ltd

(C2023/6614)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT BEAUMONT

DEPUTY PRESIDENT O’KEEFFE

COMMISSIONER LIM

PERTH, 14 DECEMBER 2023

Appeal against decision [[2023] FWC 2610] of Commissioner Schneider at Perth on 10 October 2023 in matter number U2022/6436 – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld.

  1. Introduction and factual background

  1. Mr Vathana Pen (the Appellant) has applied under s 604 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the Act) for permission to appeal against a decision of Commissioner Schneider issued on 10 October 2023 (the Decision)[1] and a subsequent order issued (the Order).[2]

  1. The following outlines the context to the appeal presently before us.

  1. On 18 June 2022, the Appellant applied to the Commission for an unfair dismissal remedy pursuant to s 394 of the Act. He had worked in the business of Octopus Fishing No.2 Pty Ltd (the Respondent) since April 2021 as a deckhand. 

  1. On 30 June 2022, the Respondent filed a Form F3 – Employer response to unfair dismissal application, with the Commission.  In its response, the Respondent raised a jurisdictional objection that the Appellant was not dismissed from his employment.  In its materials filed on 28 October 2022, it maintained that objection and, in addition, pressed that the Appellant had not completed the minimum employment period.  

  1. Directions were issued at first instance on 14 October 2022 and 19 October 2022. Both sets of directions referred to the filing of materials in respect of the jurisdictional objection concerning the minimum employment period. Further, the Notices of Listing issued on 14 October 2022 and 19 October 2022 stated that the hearing was listed to determine the objection that the Appellant (applicant) had not met the minimum employment period in accordance with s 383 of the Act.

  1. On 21 November 2022, a further Notice of Listing was issued for a hearing on 25 November 2022.  It stated that the matter was listed for a hearing of the evidence by video using Microsoft Teams before the Commissioner and closing submissions would be made in writing. 

  1. At the commencement of the hearing on 25 November 2022, the Commissioner expressed that the issue to be addressed was the minimum employment period.[3]  In that first part of the hearing, the Respondent’s legal representative submitted that the Respondent considered the primary jurisdictional issue was that there had not been a dismissal and that it was intending on providing a closing submission in relation to that point.[4]  The Respondent’s representative contended that it seemed to him that on the material available to the Commissioner, the Commissioner would be ‘able to determine that issue’,[5] noting that if the Commissioner was to find there was regular and systematic employment with a reasonable expectation, it might be unnecessary to hold a hearing on valid reason and procedural fairness, where there was a discrete issue around the dismissal.[6]

  1. The Commissioner responded to the Respondent’s submission observing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vathana Pen v Octopus Fishing No.2 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FWCFB 253
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Vathana Pen v Octopus Fishing No.2 Pty Ltd, the applicant, Mr Vathana Pen, sought permission to appeal against a decision and subsequent order issued by Commissioner Schneider. Mr Pen had applied for unfair dismissal remedies, which the respondent company, Octopus Fishing No.2 Pty Ltd, contested on the grounds that he had not been dismissed and had not completed the requisite employment period. The central issue before the court was whether the Commissioner erred in proceeding to determine the dismissal question before Mr Pen had the opportunity to present evidence and submissions relevant to that issue, thereby denying him procedural fairness.

The court found that procedural fairness is a fundamental component of natural justice and requires that each party be given a reasonable opportunity to present their case. In this instance, despite multiple directions and notifications indicating that the issue to be determined was the minimum employment period, the Commissioner proceeded to address the dismissal question without allowing Mr Pen to engage with it. This deprived Mr Pen of a reasonable opportunity to present his case, resulting in a denial of natural justice. The court held that such a denial of procedural fairness constitutes a jurisdictional error.

In light of the established jurisdictional error, the court was satisfied that it would amend the applicant’s Notice under section 586 of the Act to include this matter as a ground for appeal. Both parties agreed to this course of action when asked.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Introduction and factual background Mr Vathana Pen (the Appellant) has applied under s 604 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the Act) for permission to appeal against a decision of Commissioner Schneider issued on 10 October 2023 (the Decision)[1] and a subsequent order issued (the Order).[2] The following outlines the context to the appeal presently before us. On 18 June 2022, the Appellant applied to the Commission for an unfair dismissal remedy pursuant to s 394 of the Act. He had worked in the business of Octopus Fishing No.2 Pty Ltd (the Respondent) since April 2021 as a deckhand. On 30 June 2022, the Respondent filed a Form F3 – Employer response to unfair dismissal application, with the Commission. In its response, the Respondent raised a jurisdictional objection that the Appellant was not dismissed from his employment. In its materials filed on 28 October 2022, it maintained that objection and, in addition, pressed that the Appellant had not completed the minimum employment period. Directions were issued at first instance on 14 October 2022 and 19 October 2022. Both sets of directions referred to the filing of materials in respect of the jurisdictional objection concerning the minimum employment period. Further, the Notices of Listing issued on 14 October 2022 and 19 October 2022 stated that the hearing was listed to determine the objection that the Appellant (applicant) had not met the minimum employment period in accordance with s 383 of the Act. On 21 November 2022, a further Notice of Listing was issued for a hearing on 25 November 2022. It stated that the matter was listed for a hearing of the evidence by video using Microsoft Teams before the Commissioner and closing submissions would be made in writing. At the commencement of the hearing on 25 November 2022, the Commissioner expressed that the issue to be addressed was the minimum employment period.[3] In that first part of the hearing, the Respondent’s legal representative submitted that the Respondent considered the primary jurisdictional issue was that there had not been a dismissal and that it was intending on providing a closing submission in relation to that point.[4] The Respondent’s representative contended that it seemed to him that on the material available to the Commissioner, the Commissioner would be ‘able to determine that issue’,[5] noting that if the Commissioner was to find there was regular and systematic employment with a reasonable expectation, it might be unnecessary to hold a hearing on valid reason and procedural fairness, where there was a discrete issue around the dismissal.[6] The Commissioner responded to the Respondent’s submission observing it would depend on where the parties advanced in relation to the issue (presumedly the minimum employment period) and that there was substantial material already filed that did address the ‘no dismissal’ point.[7] The Commissioner informed the parties that he would potentially be open to looking at that separately (presumedly the dismissal issue) before going to a full hearing, but he would see where the matter got to before him on that day (the day of the hearing).[8]

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Decision It is accepted that procedural unfairness afforded to a party or parties is an error that warrants correction on appeal and enlivens the public interest. Members of the Commission are obliged to observe procedural fairness in carrying out their functions under the Act.[14] Procedural fairness is a component of natural justice. It requires that the Commission ensure that each party is given a reasonable opportunity to present its case.[15] In Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union v Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd, Katzmann and Rangiah JJ explained what is meant by a reasonable opportunity to present a case: A Full Bench of the Commission in City of Stirling v Emery considered the consequences of a failure to afford procedural fairness, stating: The Commissioner’s decision dealt squarely with the jurisdictional objection that the Appellant was not dismissed. This is despite the parties having been directed and notified on several occasions that the issue to be determined was whether the minimum employment period had been met. Because of those directions and notifications, the Appellant filed evidence and submissions directed at an issue that was not the subject matter of the Decision. In doing so, he was denied the opportunity to engage with the issue that was ultimately determined by the Commissioner. By proceeding to hear and determine the dismissal question at the hearing on 25 November 2022, before the Appellant had an opportunity to develop his case and file evidence and submissions relevant to that issue, we consider that the Appellant was denied a reasonable opportunity to present his case in support of his argument that he had been dismissed and was therefore protected by the provisions of Part 3-2 of the Act. In this respect, the Appellant was denied natural justice. In the Decision, the Commissioner made findings of fact in respect of whether the Appellant had been dismissed, which were plainly relevant to whether the Respondent’s jurisdictional objection succeeded. Procedural fairness required that the Appellant be given a reasonable opportunity to address those issues by way of submissions and evidence at a hearing on the dismissal question. There is, in our view, at least some prospect that the Appellant may have been able to present an arguable case that he had been dismissed, if he had been given the opportunity to file material addressing the dismissal issue. Accordingly, we are not satisfied that the denial of natural justice could have made no difference to the outcome of the question of whether the Appellant was dismissed. A denial of natural justice is a jurisdictional error.[18] The Decision disclosed jurisdictional error in that the Appellant was denied procedural fairness. Given the nature of the error which has been established, we are satisfied that to the extent that it is necessary to do so, we would amend the Appellant’s Notice under s 586 of the Act to include this matter as a ground of appeal. We note that neither party took objection to this course when asked.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established