Vantage Holdings Pty Ltd v Huang (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Vantage Holdings Pty Ltd v Huang (No 3) [2015] FCA 383

Citation: Vantage Holdings Pty Ltd v Huang (No 3) [2015] FCA 383
Parties: VANTAGE HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 097 178 240) v YONG HUANG (AKA PETER HUANG)
File number: QUD 127 of 2013
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 23 April 2015
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – interim application for freezing orders – rr 7.32, 7.34 and 7.35 Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – whether order for adjournment appropriate – principles in Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Vasiliades [2014] FCA 1250 discussed and applied – whether freezing orders appropriate against third parties – apparent dissipation of real property assets – whether undertakings as to damages by applicant has value – whether “carve outs” from freezing orders appropriate
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 588G(2), 588M
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 7.32, 7.34, 7.35
Cases cited: Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175
Cambridge Credit Corporation Limited (Receiver Appointed) v Surfers’ Paradise Forests Limited (1977) Qd R 261
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Hua Wang Bank Berhad (2010) 80 ATR 449
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Vasiliades [2014] FCA 1250
K.C. Park Safe (Brisbane) Pty Ltd v Cairns City Council [1997] 1 Qd R 497
SBA Music Pty Ltd v Hall [2014] FCA 1038
Vantage Holdings Pty Ltd v Huang [2015] FCA 155
Date of hearing: 22 April 2015
Place: Brisbane
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 25
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr MK Stunden
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mills Oakley Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr GD Beacham with Ms F Chen
Solicitor for the Respondent: Yong Legal and Immigration Services Pty Ltd

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 127 of 2013

BETWEEN:

VANTAGE HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 097 178 240)
Applicant

AND:

YONG HUANG (AKA PETER HUANG)
Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 APRIL 2015

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to rr 7.32, 7.34 and 7.35 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) a freezing order be made against the respondent, JHC Mum Pty Ltd ACN 132 838 316 as trustee for the JHC Mum Unit Trust, and DZY Pty Ltd ACN 167 517 973 as trustee for the DZY Family Trust in the terms specified in Annexure A to these Orders.

2.        There be liberty to apply.

3.        Costs be reserved.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


ANNEXURE A

PENAL NOTICE

TO:     YONG HUANG (AKA PETER HUANG)

JHC MUM PTY LTD ACN 132 838 316 as trustee for the JHC MUM UNIT TRUST

DZY PTY LTD ACN 167 517 973 as trustee for the DZY FAMILY TRUST

IF YOU:

(A)REFUSE OR NEGLECT TO DO ANY ACT WITHIN THE TIME SPECIFIED IN THIS ORDER FOR THE DOING OF THE ACT; OR

(B)DISOBEY THE ORDER BY DOING AN ACT WHICH THE ORDER REQUIRES…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vantage Holdings Pty Ltd v Huang (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 383
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Vantage Holdings Pty Ltd sought an interim application for freezing orders against Huang, JHC Mum Pty Ltd, and DZY Pty Ltd in the Federal Court of Australia. The applicant claimed that Huang had dissipated or transferred assets to defeat any potential success in the main proceedings, leading to concerns that any judgment would be unsatisfied due to the lack of assets. Vantage argued that it had a good arguable case on both the law and facts, that there was a real danger that the prospective judgment would be unsatisfied because of the disposition or diminution in value of assets, and that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of the freezing orders.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant could substantiate a case for freezing orders by reference to the provisions of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). Specifically, the court considered whether Vantage had a good arguable case on both the law and the facts, whether there was a danger that a prospective judgment would be wholly or partially unsatisfied because the assets of the prospective debtor would have been disposed of or their value diminished, and whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of the freezing orders. The court also considered whether the undertakings offered by Vantage had value and the appropriateness of the relief against third parties such as JHC Mum Pty Ltd and DZY Pty Ltd.

The court found that while Vantage had a good arguable case, there was insufficient evidence to demonstrate that Huang had deliberately dissipated or transferred assets to defeat any potential success in the main proceedings. The court also found that there was no evidence of the properties being sold at undervalue and that the undertakings offered by Vantage did not have sufficient value. The court held that the balance of convenience did not favour the grant of the freezing orders against Huang, JHC Mum Pty Ltd, and DZY Pty Ltd. However, the court granted a freezing order against JHC Mum Pty Ltd and DZY Pty Ltd in the terms specified in Annexure A to the orders, with liberty to apply and costs reserved.

The court's decision demonstrates the high threshold for granting freezing orders in Australia, requiring a strong showing of a good arguable case, a real danger of unsatisfied judgment, and a favourable balance of convenience. The court also emphasised the importance of the value of undertakings and the appropriateness of relief against third parties. The outcome of this case highlights the need for applicants seeking freezing orders to provide compelling evidence to support their claims and to consider the potential consequences of such orders on third parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to rr 7.32, 7.34 and 7.35 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) a freezing order be made against the respondent, JHC Mum Pty Ltd ACN 132 838 316 as trustee for the JHC Mum Unit Trust, and DZY Pty Ltd ACN 167 517 973 as trustee for the DZY Family Trust in the terms specified in Annexure A to these Orders.

2. There be liberty to apply.

3. Costs be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Vantage Holdings Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, has initiated legal proceedings against Huang, the defendant, involving claims related to the alleged dissipation of real property assets. Vantage claims that Huang has deliberately dissipated or transferred assets in an effort to defeat any potential success Vantage may have at trial. The urgency of the application is based on the argument that if Vantage is successful at trial, such victory would be hollow without assets against which a judgment could be enforced. The plaintiff has also sought freezing orders against JHC Mum Pty Ltd and DZY Pty Ltd, two trustee companies in which Huang has an interest but which are not parties to the proceedings.

The matter is before the court on an interlocutory application by Vantage Holdings Pty Ltd for freezing orders under the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). This application is part of the ongoing litigation between Vantage and Huang. Prior to this application, there were no specific details provided about the history of the case or any other proceedings that have occurred. The current application focuses solely on the need for interim relief in the form of freezing orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, Vantage relies on r 7.35 which relevantly provides:7.35Order against judgment debtor or prospective judgment debtor or third party(1) This rule applies if:…(b)an applicant has a good arguable case on an accrued or prospective cause of action that is justiciable in:(i) the Court; or(ii)for a cause of action to which subrule (3) applies—another court.…(4)The Court may make a freezing order or an ancillary order or both against a judgment debtor or prospective judgment debtor if the Court is satisfied, having regard to all the circumstances, that there is a danger that a judgment or prospective judgment will be wholly or partly unsatisfied because any of the following might occur:…(b)the assets of the judgment debtor, prospective judgment debtor or another person are:(i)removed from Australia or from a place inside or outside Australia; or(ii) disposed of, dealt with or diminished in value.(5)The Court may make a freezing order or an ancillary order or both against a person other than a judgment debtor or prospective judgment debtor (a third party) if the Court is satisfied, having regard to all the circumstances, that:…(b)a process in the Court is or may ultimately be available to the applicant as a result of a judgment or prospective judgment, under which process the third party may be obliged to disgorge assets or contribute toward satisfying the judgment or prospective judgment.(6)Nothing in this rule affects the power of the Court to make a freezing order or ancillary order if the Court considers it is in the interests of justice to do so. The reason for the reliance by Vantage on both rules is that the interlocutory relief sought is against not only the respondent Mr Huang, but against JHC Mum Pty Ltd and DZY Pty Ltd, being two trustee companies in which Mr Huang has an interest but which are not parties to these proceedings.Submissions of Vantage Holdings The key reason for the urgency of the interlocutory application by Vantage Holdings is that, in summary, it claims that Mr Huang has deliberately dissipated or transferred assets to defeat any success Vantage may have at trial. The effect of this, it claims, is that if Vantage is successful at trial in June 2015, such victory would be hollow in the absence of assets against which a judgment could be enforced. In this respect, and relying on the decision in Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Vasiliades [2014] FCA 1250 at [35], Vantage claims that it can substantiate a case for freezing orders by reference to three limbs of r 7.35, namely:1.That the applicant has a good or reasonably arguable case on both the law and the facts.2.That there is a danger that a prospective judgment will be wholly or partially unsatisfied because the assets of the prospective debtor will have been disposed of or their value diminished. This limb has two parts:a. The identification of the relevant assets; andb.Establishing whether there is a real danger of the prospective judgment being unsatisfied.3. That the balance of convenience favours the grant of the freezing orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Huang strongly opposed the relief sought by Vantage pursuant to this interlocutory application. In summary Mr Beacham for Mr Huang submitted as follows:·A freezing order is an exceptional interlocutory remedy which involves a significant interference in the personal affairs of a person or entity: SBA Music Pty Ltd v Hall [2014] FCA 1038 at [15].·This urgent application for freezing orders has been brought at short notice notwithstanding that, according his own evidence, Mr O’Brien has been concerned at the possible dissipation of assets since 17 March 2015. The material before the Court suggests rather that the applicant has adopted a relatively leisurely pace in seeking this relief. Urgent interim relief is not warranted on these facts.·Although Mr Huang has sold a significant number of properties, the evidence of Mr Sun is that those properties were actually on the market for a long time.·Mr Huang is a property developer in the business of purchasing and selling real property.·The Court should require more compelling evidence than an alleged conversation between Mr Huang and Mr O’Brien to justify the intervention of freezing orders.·In any event, an innocent interpretation can be placed upon the comments of Mr Huang to Mr O’Brien on 17 March 2015. At the hearing Mr Beacham submitted as follows in respect of the conversation to which Mr O’Brien deposed at paragraph 4 of his affidavit:MR BEACHAM: Paragraph 4. So he says, allegedly, that he would not be affected business-wise or financially if he loses the case. Not a statement that he intends to go about dissipating assets in any untoward way; a statement of fact. Perhaps a statement that – well, we don’t know. Subparagraph (b) seems to be the one that they rely upon.HER HONOUR: I think (c) is also relied upon by the applicants.MR BEACHAM: Can I come to (c). He had no land in his name for the applicant to get from him. That does not suggest that – and it’s obviously incorrect for a start, because he does. He still does. But he doesn’t say he’s going to get rid of it, and ..., he will restructure his group so that he becomes a passive investor. The point about that, your Honour, is again he doesn’t say he’s going to dissipate assets. The point about that is, that the compelling inference about what he’s talking about there is that it doesn’t matter to Mr Huang, or that it’s not going to interfere with Mr Huang if he goes bankrupt, because he will become a passive person in his corporate group. So, in other words, he’s not talking about his assets; he’s talking about the role that he will play in his corporate group.·It is clear from Mr Smouha’s affidavit of 21 April 2015 that most of the properties sold by Mr Huang have been to unrelated persons or entities.·There is a serious issue as to whether the undertakings offered by Vantage are of real value. The onus lies with Vantage to establish that the undertakings offered have value: K.C. Park Safe (Brisbane) Pty Ltd v Cairns City Council [1997] 1 Qd R 497 at 506. The quality of an undertaking is an issue to be considered in determining the balance of convenience: Cambridge Credit Corporation Limited (Receiver Appointed) v Surfers’ Paradise Forests Limited (1977) Qd R 261 at 263-264.·There is no evidence before the Court that the sale of properties by Mr Huang to JHC Mum and DZY were at undervalue.·In any event, if the Court were minded to grant an interim injunction, the injunction should be limited to restraint of Mr Huang’s share of the proceeds of sale of properties. There is no justification for relief against JHC Mum or DZY.Consideration