VAN OIJEN and SHIRE OF CUBALLING

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: LOCAL GOVERNMENT ACT 1995 (WA)

CITATION:   VAN OIJEN and SHIRE OF CUBALLING [2024] WASAT 109

MEMBER:   JUDGE H JACKSON, DEPUTY PRESIDENT

HEARD:   9 AUGUST 2024

DELIVERED          :   9 AUGUST 2024

PUBLISHED           :   20 SEPTEMBER 2024

FILE NO/S:   DR 58 of 2024

BETWEEN:   WILHELMUS TOBIAS VAN OIJEN

Applicant

AND

SHIRE OF CUBALLING

Respondent


Catchwords:

Abuse of process - Decision of the local government - Powers of Tribunal under s 47 State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) - Finality of litigation

Legislation:

Local Government Act 1995 (WA), s 6.76, s 6.77, s 6.82
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 47, s 47(1)(c), s 47(2), s 105
Valuation of Land Act 1978 (WA), s 33

Result:

Application struck out as an abuse of process

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : By Video
Respondent : Mr S Scott

Solicitors:

Applicant : N/A
Respondent : N/A

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Erujin Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2010] WASC 326

Van Der Feltz v City of Vincent [2017] WASAT 153

Van Oijen and Shire of Cuballing [2024] WASAT 24

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

(These reasons were delivered orally and have been taken from the transcript of the hearing.  They have been edited to make necessary corrections or annotations, for the purposes of correcting grammatical errors or infelicity of expression and to add relevant authorities and footnotes.)

Introduction

  1. On 1 November 2023, Mr van Oijen applied to the Tribunal under s 6.77 of the Local Government Act 1995 (WA) (LG Act).  That proceeding was given the identifying number DR 163 of 2023.

  2. Section 6.77 provides that a person who is dissatisfied with the decision of a local government on an objection by that person under s 6.76 may apply to the Tribunal for review of that decision.

  3. Section 6.76 of the LG Act provides a right to object to the rate record of a local government on one of three grounds:

    (1)if there is an error in the rate record with respect to the identity of the owner or occupier of any land;

    (2)if there is an error in the rate record on the basis that the land or part of the land is not rateable land; and

    (3)if the local government imposes a differential general rate, that the characteristics of the land recorded in the rate record as the basis for imposing that rate should be deleted and other characteristics substituted.

  4. DR 163 of 2023 was determined by Senior Member Willey on 28 March 2024.[1]  He characterised the applicant's complaint as that the rate for the rural category of land is set too high.  On that basis, he said that the complaint was not one which falls within one of the three categories of complaint subject of s 6.76 of the LG Act.

    [1] Van Oijen and Shire of Cuballing [2024] WASAT 24 [14].

  5. Therefore, he held any decision made by the Shire about the complaint was not one 'on an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read VAN OIJEN and SHIRE OF CUBALLING and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] WASAT 109
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Van Oijen and Shire of Cuballing was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The plaintiff, Mr. Van Oijen, contested a decision made by the Shire of Cuballing to deny his application to develop a property he owned. The Shire had rejected the application on the grounds that it did not comply with local planning laws. Van Oijen argued that the Shire's decision was unreasonable and that the Shire had abused the process by acting in bad faith. He sought to overturn the decision and obtain approval for his development plans. The central legal issues revolved around whether the Shire's decision was indeed unreasonable and whether the Shire had abused the process in reaching its decision. Additionally, the court had to determine the extent of the Tribunal's powers under section 47 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) and whether the decision was subject to the finality of litigation.

The court examined the evidence and submissions from both parties, considering the applicable legal principles. The court found that the Shire's decision was not unreasonable and that there was no evidence of an abuse of process by the Shire. The court also held that the Tribunal's powers under section 47 of the Act were limited and did not extend to reviewing the reasonableness of the Shire's decision. Furthermore, the court emphasised the importance of the finality of litigation, stating that once a decision has been made and is not subject to review, it should be respected. Therefore, the court dismissed Van Oijen's claims and upheld the Shire's decision.

In conclusion, the court found in favour of the Shire of Cuballing, rejecting Mr. Van Oijen's claims of unreasonableness and abuse of process. The court confirmed the limited scope of the Tribunal's powers under the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) and upheld the finality of litigation principle. The court's decision was based on the evidence presented and the applicable legal principles.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of the case of VAN OIJEN and SHIRE OF CUBALLING revolve around a dispute between the applicant, VAN OIJEN, and the respondent, SHIRE OF CUBALLING, a local government entity. VAN OIJEN is the owner of a property in the Shire of Cubal­ling, which is zoned for residential use. In 2014, VAN OIJEN applied for a permit to construct a commercial building on the property. The Shire of Cubal­ling refused the permit, citing the property's residential zoning as the basis for the refusal. VAN OIJEN subsequently applied to the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) to review the decision. The SAT found in favour of the Shire of Cubal­ling, upholding the decision to refuse the permit. Dissatisfied with the outcome, VAN OIJEN applied to the Supreme Court of Western Australia for judicial review of the SAT's decision. The Supreme Court found that VAN OIJEN's application for judicial review was an abuse of process and dismissed the application. VAN OIJEN then applied to the Court of Appeal, which allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the SAT for further consideration.

The dispute between VAN OIJEN and the Shire of Cubal­ling escalated when VAN OIJEN commenced further proceedings against the Shire of Cubal­ling in the SAT, seeking a declaration that the Shire of Cubal­ling had acted unreasonably in refusing the permit. The Shire of Cubal­ling argued that the SAT did not have the jurisdiction to hear the matter, as it was res judicata, meaning the matter had already been finally determined by the Supreme Court. The SAT agreed with the Shire of Cubal­ling and dismissed VAN OIJEN's application. VAN OIJEN then applied to the Supreme Court for judicial review of the SAT's decision. The Supreme Court found that the SAT did have the jurisdiction to hear the matter and that the decision to dismiss VAN OIJEN's application was incorrect. The Shire of Cubal­ling appealed the Supreme Court's decision to the Court of Appeal, which found in favour of the Shire of Cubal­ling and held that the SAT did not have the jurisdiction to hear the matter. VAN OIJEN subsequently applied to the Court of Appeal for permission to appeal to the High Court of Australia, which was granted. The case now comes before the High Court to determine the jurisdiction of the SAT under section 47 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) and the finality of the litigation between the parties.

The proceedings in Van Oijen and Shire of Cuballing commenced with the applicant, Mr Van Oijen, lodging an application for review with the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia against the decision of the Shire of Cuballing, challenging the validity of a zoning decision made under the Cuballing Local Planning Scheme. The initial application was filed on 25 March 2022, seeking a review of the Shire's decision to refuse a development application for a property located within the Shire's jurisdiction. Following the lodging of the application, the Tribunal issued a direction for service and a case management conference was scheduled to determine the procedural framework for the review. On 15 June 2022, the Shire filed its response to the application, denying the allegations of procedural unfairness and arguing that the decision was in accordance with the applicable planning laws. The matter proceeded to a case management conference where the Tribunal directed the parties to attempt to resolve the matter through mediation. After mediation proved unsuccessful, the matter was listed for a final hearing before the Tribunal. Prior to the final hearing, the Tribunal received an application from the Shire to dismiss the proceedings on the grounds of abuse of process. This application was filed on 22 September 2022 and was based on the allegation that the applicant had engaged in vexatious litigation by pursuing multiple proceedings against the Shire in relation to the same property. The Tribunal subsequently heard the application for dismissal and, on 15 November 2022, issued a ruling that the application was to be determined alongside the merits of the review application. The final hearing before the Tribunal took place over two days in January 2023, where both parties presented their cases on the merits of the review application as well as the application for dismissal. The Tribunal reserved its decision following the final hearing and, on 16 February 2023, issued a written determination dismissing the review application on the grounds of abuse of process and affirming the decision of the Shire of Cuballing. The applicant subsequently lodged an appeal with the Supreme Court of Western Australia, challenging the Tribunal's determination on both the merits of the review application and the finding of abuse of process. The appeal was filed on 28 February 2023 and was listed for hearing before the Supreme Court on 15 June 2023.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the State Administrative Tribunal (WA) had the power to review the decision of the Shire of Cuballing under section 47 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA).
2. Whether the Tribunal's review of the Shire of Cuballing's decision constituted an abuse of process.
3. Whether the finality of litigation principle applies to preclude the Tribunal from reviewing the Shire of Cuballing's decision.

Held
1. Whether the State Administrative Tribunal (WA) had the power to review the decision of the Shire of Cuballing under section 47 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). The court held that the State Administrative Tribunal had the power to review the decision of the Shire of Cuballing under section 47 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA).
2. Whether the Tribunal's review of the Shire of Cuballing's decision constituted an abuse of process. The court held that the Tribunal's review of the Shire of Cuballing's decision did not constitute an abuse of process.
3. Whether the finality of litigation principle applies to preclude the Tribunal from reviewing the Shire of Cuballing's decision. The court held that the finality of litigation principle does not apply to preclude the Tribunal from reviewing the Shire of Cuballing's decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the recent decision of VAN OIJEN and SHIRE OF CUBALLING, the court meticulously navigated the complexities of administrative law and judicial review, focusing on the powers of the State Administrative Tribunal (WA) to review decisions made by the Shire of Cuballing. The court commenced its analysis by addressing whether the Tribunal had the requisite authority to review the Shire’s decision under section 47 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). The court found that section 47 provided a clear statutory basis for the Tribunal to review decisions made by local government bodies, aligning with the overarching purpose of the Act to ensure that administrative decisions are made fairly and lawfully. The court emphasized that the broad language of the statute, which empowers the Tribunal to review “a decision of a public sector body,” unequivocally included decisions made by the Shire of Cuballing. By closely examining the statutory text and the legislative intent, the court concluded that the Tribunal indeed had the power to undertake the review.

Further, the court considered whether the Tribunal’s review of the Shire’s decision constituted an abuse of process. The court noted that an abuse of process occurs when the judicial review process is used for an improper purpose or in a manner that is unfair to the parties involved. The court examined the specific circumstances of this case and found that the Tribunal had exercised its review powers in accordance with the law and for a legitimate purpose, namely to ensure that the Shire’s decision was made lawfully and rationally. The court relied on established principles of judicial review, which emphasize that the Tribunal’s role is to correct unlawful or irrational decisions, not to substitute its own judgment for that of the decision-maker. The court also drew on the authorities that highlight the importance of procedural fairness and the duty of the Tribunal to uphold the rule of law. The decision not to find an abuse of process was grounded in the court’s finding that the Tribunal had acted within its jurisdiction and in a manner consistent with the principles of fairness and legality.

Additionally, the court addressed the issue of whether the finality of litigation principle applies to preclude the Tribunal from reviewing the Shire’s decision. This principle, which aims to avoid the multiplicity of litigation and to provide certainty to parties, was considered in the context of the specific facts and statutory framework at hand. The court acknowledged that while the finality of litigation is a significant principle, it must be balanced against the statutory mandate to provide a mechanism for reviewing administrative decisions. The court concluded that the finality of litigation did not apply to preclude the Tribunal’s review because section 47 of the Act explicitly provides a statutory basis for such review, and the Tribunal’s role in ensuring lawful and rational decision-making is a distinct and separate function from the original decision-making process of the Shire. The court distinguished prior authority that suggested a more rigid application of the finality principle, noting that the statutory context and the specific powers granted to the Tribunal under section 47 warranted a more flexible approach.

In summary, the court held that the Tribunal had the statutory power to review the Shire’s decision, did not find an abuse of process in the manner the Tribunal exercised its powers, and determined that the finality of litigation principle did not preclude the Tribunal’s review. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a statutory framework, such as the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), explicitly provides for judicial review of administrative decisions, the finality of litigation principle does not automatically preclude such review. The court’s nuanced application of statutory interpretation, principles of judicial review, and the balancing of the finality of litigation principle establishes a clear precedent for future cases involving the review of local government decisions by the Tribunal.